Imam Hussain's daughters

[YaSiN51214 1]

(salam) ,

I have read in many books and what not, that Imam Hussain (as) longed for a daughter. He even prayed to his mother, Bibi Fatima (as) to bless him with a daughter that would bring peace [sukoon] in to his life. And hence after that prayer, Bibi Sakina (as) was born. Now what i dont get is....before Bibi Sakina, Imam Hussain (as) had another daughter named Sughra. Sughra was his first daughter...so why didnt Imam Hussain (as) name this first daughter 'sakina'? and actually didnt he have another daughter named Ruqaya?...or is that just another name for Sakina?...well anyways, my main question is...if Imam Hussain (as) had a daughter first [i.e.Bibi Sughra], then why didnt he just name her "Sakina"?, or why was he praying for another daughter when he already had one?

[Perfectionist 97]

Good Question !

[rahat 25]

Perhaps he performed these prayers before the birth of his first daughter.

-

rahat

[~RuQaYaH~ 198]

Even if he did, how would it make a difference?

wasalam

[Fatimaa 4]

(bismillah) (salam)

^ I think there should be lot difference between both daughters and as the brother said Why he didn't named her SAKINA?

Can we ahve any reference brother rahat. :)

Wassalam.

[~RuQaYaH~ 198]

No, I meant, even if he prayed for a daughter before the birth of fatima sughra, why wouldn't he have named HER sakina?

[Fatimaa 4]

No, I meant, even if he prayed for a daughter before the birth of fatima sughra, why wouldn't he have named HER sakina?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

[hehe] i was refering to Brother rahat's post....

And yes my question is same if he was praying for daughter and he got why he named her Fatima sughra?hmm May be coz she resembled Bibi Fatima Zehra (as) so he named her this and then asked for another daughter who could bring peace [sukoon] in to his life...

Strickly My opinion....sorry if i m wrong anywhere.

Wassalam.

[xDSL 0]

(salam)

(bismillah)

good questions!.

Rugayah is another name for Sakinah. So, Sakinah = Rugayah.

1st daughter named Fatimah. as you know, Imam hussein a.s. mother is Bibi Fatimah. So...? This is what we called as LOVED. same as his sons. Ali, Ali, Ali.... where he get? :)

[A true Sunni 1,673]

salaam,

Ruqayya was also the daughter of Hz Ali(as) via Umul Baneen

[Il Nino 0]

I have read in many books and what not, that Imam Hussain as.gif longed for a daughter. He even prayed to his mother, Bibi Fatima as.gif to bless him with a daughter that would bring peace [sukoon] in to his life. And hence after that prayer, Bibi Sakina as.gif was born. Now what i dont get is....before Bibi Sakina, Imam Hussain as.gif had another daughter named Sughra. Sughra was his first daughter...so why didnt Imam Hussain as.gif name this first daughter 'sakina'? and actually didnt he have another daughter named Ruqaya?...or is that just another name for Sakina?...well anyways, my main question is...if Imam Hussain as.gif had a daughter first [i.e.Bibi Sughra], then why didnt he just name her "Sakina"?, or why was he praying for another daughter when he already had one?

they were both twins, 6 yr old each at 61 h , ya dig? :D

[YaSiN51214 1]

^^ um no, not really :unsure:

[Fatimaa 4]

they were both twins, 6 yr old each at 61 h , ya dig? :D

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Bibi Sakina was 4 year old at kerbala(according to many rivayaat nad majalis we hear)...I never heard about they being twins...are u sure :huh:

Same what i ask to everyone Can we have the source..not the statements only please brother. :)

Wassalam.

[Laleh 0]

Bibi Sakina was 4 year old at kerbala(according to many rivayaat nad majalis we hear)...I never heard about they being twins...are u sure :huh:

Same what i ask to everyone Can we have the source..not the statements only please brother. :)

Wassalam.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Its amazing how there is always something new to be learnt about the Infallibles (as) I never knew he prayed for teh birth of bibi sakina (as) or that bibi zainab (as) used to tell her so in zindaan e shaam

I generally read this ziaraat of the masooma (as) I wondered if other people know about it as well.

u can find it at

www.ziarrat.com under section damascus.

Not that i`ve been there but apparently,also in damscus are buried janab e Fiza,janab e sughra,bibi zainab and i think umme kulsum (as)

correct me if i am wrong.

[Devout 3]

(bismillah)

(salam)

I know I'm about to revive a thread from 2006 but there is something I really need a straight answer to and it was related to this thread so I figured it's better to revive an old one than open a new one.

Anyway, how many daughters did Imam Hussain (as) have? A straight answer, sources would be great.

I've heard soo many different answers to this. Some say he had 4 daughters( and that roqaya was the 4th), some day he had one daughter (sakina & roqaya being the same), some say he had 3 (and that fatima sughra didn't accompany him to karbala because she was ill) etc etc and sayed mahdi al-Modaressi says in his 9th night of muharram 2010 lecture that he had 5 daughters.. and that roqaya was the 3 yearold and youngest one

I've tried to do research on the matter but with no luck, I suppose my keywords & search engines aren't meant for this.. :unsure:

Pleaseeee help

[Rohani 643]

(salam)

^there are only two daughters listed in Al Irshad By: Shaykh Al Mufeed.

Sukayna (May Peace and Mercy from Allah be Upon)

And Fatima (May Peace and Mercy from Allah be Upon)

(wasalam)

Edited May 25, 2010 by AlMuttaqi

[Sehnsucht 27]

(salam)

Based on the ahadith stating that the son of Imam Hasan (as), Hasan Muthanna (as), asked for the hand of one of his uncle's daughters in marriage, it appears that Imam Hussain (as) had at least two daughters... Fatima (sa) and Sakina (sa); it is likely that the proper name of both was Fatima, but the younger one was referred to as Sakina. A daughter named Fatima was undoubtedly present in Karbala, who had her ankle rings looted (as-Saduq, Amali, p. 99, majlis 31. al-Thahbi, Siyar A’lam al-Nubala', Vol. 3, p. 204.)

As for Sakina (sa):

According to p. 163, Vol. 1, of al-Nawawi's Tahthib al-Asma', p. 58, Vol. 1, of al-Manawi's book Al-Kawakib al-Durriyya, p. 160 of al-Shiblinji's Nur al-Absar, and Ibn Khallikan's Wafiyyat al-A’yan, where the author details her biography, Sukayna daughter of al-Husain (‘a) died on a Thursday, Rabi’ I 5, 117 A.H./April 8, 735 A.D. According to Abul-Hasan al-’Amri's book Al-Mujdi and to al-Tabarsi's book I’lam al-Wara, p. 127, where the biographies of the offspring of Imam al-Hasan (‘a) are discussed. According to p. 163, Vol. 12, of Abul-Faraj al-Ishfahani's book Al-Aghani, she married her cousin, ‘Abdullah Ibn al-Hasan Ibn ‘Ali Ibn Abu Talib (‘a), who was killed during the Battle of al-Taff. She did not bear any children by him. But the author of I’lam al-Wara says that he was killed before her marriage, that during the Battle of al-Taff, she was a little more than ten years old, and that she was born before the death [martyrdom] of her uncle Imam al-Hasan (‘a). The statement in her honour made by the Master of Martyrs (‘a), “Sukayna is overcome by deep contemplation upon Allah,” as is recorded by al-Sabban in his book Is’af al-Raghibin, clearly outlines for us the status his daughter occupied in the sacred canons of Islam's Shari’a.

source: Maqtal al Husayn by Syed Muqarram

^ If she is recorded to have married the son of Imam Hasan (as), the daughter mentioned here would presumably be the elder Fatima, as the ahadith about Hasan Muthanna (as)'s marriage indicate that Imam Hussain (as) told him to marry her because his younger daughter, Sakina, was devoted to worship as the last line mentions (couldn't find the direct source of the hadith about the marriage, but it's supposed to be in Nafasul Mahmum). Given the probable ages of Fatima (sa) and Sakina (sa), and that Sakina bintal Hussain (sa) has been recorded in some places as having lived a long life or become a transmitter of ahadith, it seems that Ruqayyah (sa)- the child who died in the prison of Damascus and is saluted by our Imam (atf) in ziyarah, was a different daughter altogether; some cite her as being the daughter of Hadhrat Muslim ibne Aqil (as). Also, Sukaina is a dimunitive of Sakina... so it's possible that Fatima (sa) and Sakina (sa) were the elder daughters, while Ruqayyah was a younger daughter known as Sukaina. This also somewhat makes sense alongside reports that mention a Fatima al-Kubra and Fatima al-Sughra, the latter of whom is listed in some places by name as being the wife of Hasan Muthanna (as).

Here are a few ambiguous but interesting sites:

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:6sj5ecIGoicJ:www.hujjat-workshop.org/docs/Sakina_bintal_Husayn.pdf+sakina+bintal+hussain&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESgd5bTAd62v4rMTHbscKnNNfHo2H_obCiQEYPjxefqiUpl3BGgxjqMmEaW_T18J2wdjR9kmmsrI14mvan9V8PAasPLNDsgSTPlplTv0eofzIsdMd_8n7I2lng8sl2BeSXm2cceJ&sig=AHIEtbSTGCFPym-ydVGPlwYZaQjzUL6LeA

http://www.alimoula110.com/woman2.php

http://en.rafed.net/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=249:lady-sakina-engrossed-by-divine-prepetual-beauty&catid=84:seerah&Itemid=849

[Basim Ali 1,111]

(salam),

You might find this useful:

http://www.al-islam.org/nafasul-mahmum/45.htm#1

wa (salam)

[3UINE KARBALAIE 5]

(salam) ,

I have read in many books and what not, that Imam Hussain (as) longed for a daughter. He even prayed to his mother, Bibi Fatima (as) to bless him with a daughter that would bring peace [sukoon] in to his life. And hence after that prayer, Bibi Sakina (as) was born. Now what i dont get is....before Bibi Sakina, Imam Hussain (as) had another daughter named Sughra. Sughra was his first daughter...so why didnt Imam Hussain (as) name this first daughter 'sakina'? and actually didnt he have another daughter named Ruqaya?...or is that just another name for Sakina?...well anyways, my main question is...if Imam Hussain (as) had a daughter first [i.e.Bibi Sughra], then why didnt he just name her "Sakina"?, or why was he praying for another daughter when he already had one?

Are you talking about Fatima al Aleela or Fatima al Saghyra?

As far as I know its

Sakayna

Fatima al Aleela

Rugaya

[Panzerwaffe 993]

sukayna is the right way to pronounce it not sakina

[Ali_Hussain 5,524]

The story sounds a bit dodgy to me, why would someone as pure as Imam Hussain (as) need "pray to his mother (as)". At least rephrase that bit, is He also to sinfull to ask Allah (swt) directly, good to know it doesn't just apply to us.

Also some say all his (as) sons where called Ali, all his daughters where called Fatima, they where defined by being called akbar asghar kobra etc. How ever the issue of why He (as) was called aba abdallah is also debatable some say His (as) youngest son was known as abdallah

[Haydar Husayn 9,677]

I have read in many books and what not, that Imam Hussain (as) longed for a daughter. He even prayed to his mother, Bibi Fatima (as) to bless him with a daughter that would bring peace [sukoon] in to his life. And hence after that prayer, Bibi Sakina (as) was born.

Did you really mean to write that?

[MOHIB E AHLAYBAIT 216]

Imam Ali already had Imam Hassan and Imam Hussain as sons. Why did he ask for Hazrat Abbas?? Same logic also applies to this Hz Sakina issue.

[Haydar Husayn 9,677]

I still can't believe there were so many replies before anyone even touched on the issue of Imam Hussain (as) praying to his mother to bless him with a daughter. Do none of you really see a problem with this, or you don't think it's even worth pointing out? I mean, from my point of view this is accusing Imam Hussain (as) of committing shirk, even if that is not what the original poster meant to do. Meanwhile, the rest of you don't even bat an eyelid.

What made it worse was it was phrased as 'he even prayed to his mother', as if praying to Allah (swt) wasn't working, so out of desperation he prayed to his mother instead. I think what this shows is that for some people the line between seeking intersession from someone and praying to them has become hopelessly blurred.

[rabbfatima 0]

imam hussain j.j had 3 daughters

fatima kubra s.a

fatima sughra s.a

sakina = sukain= ruqaiya a.s

there is no logic of asking this question ,

why did he pray for a daughter , if he already had [ 2 daughters?]?

there is no HARM or PROBLEM or any ISSUE , if he asks to have a daughter , who could bring peace to him

and this hadis is MEANT TO SHOW THE FAZEELAT OF hazrat ruqaiya a.s

hope that answers it

[xstatik2 64]

imam hussain j.j

What does j.j. stand for here ? Your reply is most anxiously awaited.

[Nader Zaveri 1,365]

(salam)

(bismillah)

What does j.j. stand for here ?

Please do not tell me he means (Ìá ÌáÇáå) = (Glorified be His Majesty/Greatness)!

(salam)

[doobybrother 352]

(salam)

(bismillah)

Please do not tell me he means (Ìá ÌáÇáå) = (Glorified be His Majesty/Greatness)!

(salam)

I hope not

[rabbfatima 0]

I hope not

YES- I mean it as you have rightly got it

however, i do not TAKE ahle bayt j.j to be Allah

let me make it very clear , before any FATWA is hurled upon me :)

[Nader Zaveri 1,365]

(salam)

(bismillah)

YES- I mean it as you have rightly got it

however, i do not TAKE ahle bayt j.j to be Allah

let me make it very clear , before any FATWA is hurled upon me :)

Then why are you using praises of Allaah for the Imaams? The phrase "جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ" has been used for Allaah, what you have done is basically like putting (عَزَّ وَ جَلَّ) by the Imaams names.

Al-Kaafi:

References that the phrase "جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ" has been used: (NOTICE who it is talking about)

إِنَّ اللَّهَ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1. pg. 86, hadeeth # 3

وَ اللَّهُ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1, pg. 119, hadeeth # 1

مِنْ تَعْظِيمِ اللَّهِ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1, pg. 141, hadeeth # 7

سَأَلْتُ أَبَا عَبْدِ اللَّهِ ع عَنْ قَوْلِ اللَّهِ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1, pg. 194, hadeeth # 3

Chapter title: بَابٌ فِيمَنْ دَانَ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَ جَلَّ بِغَيْرِ إِمَامٍ مِنَ اللَّهِ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 6, pg. 15

Al-Faqeeh:

فَأَوْحَى اللَّهُ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1, pg. 28, hadeeth # 58

فِيهَا رَبِّي جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1, pg. 212, hadeeth # 643

إِعْظَاماً لِلَّهِ جَلَّ جَلَالُهُ -> vol. 1. pg. 214, hadeeth # 645

....(And the list goes on).....

I advise you to ponder over this narration.

عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنِ ابْنِ أَبِي عُمَيْرٍ عَنْ هِشَامِ بْنِ سَالِمٍ عَنْ أَبِي عَبْدِ اللَّهِ ع قَالَ أَتَى قَوْمٌ أَمِيرَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ ع فَقَالُوا السَّلَامُ عَلَيْكَ يَا رَبَّنَا فَاسْتَتَابَهُمْ فَلَمْ يَتُوبُوا فَحَفَرَ لَهُمْ حَفِيرَةً وَ أَوْقَدَ فِيهَا نَاراً وَ حَفَرَ حَفِيرَةً أُخْرَى إِلَى جَانِبِهَا وَ أَفْضَى مَا بَيْنَهُمَا فَلَمَّا لَمْ يَتُوبُوا أَلْقَاهُمْ فِي الْحَفِيرَةِ وَ أَوْقَدَ فِي الْحَفِيرَةِ الْأُخْرَى [نَاراً] حَتَّى مَاتُوا

A group came to Ameer Al-Mu’mineen (عليه السلام), and they said: “Assalaamu `Alayka (Peace be upon you), O our Lord (rabbanaa)! So he asked for their repentance, but they did not repent. So he dug a ditch for them and lit a fire in it and dug a ditch to its other side and conveyed between them. So when they did not repent he threw them in the ditch and lit in the other ditch until they died.

Source:

1. Al-Kulayni, Al-Kaafi, vol. 7, pg. 258-259, hadeeth # 18

Grading:

1. Al-Majlisi said this hadeeth is Hasan (Good)

-> Mir’aat Al-`Uqool, vol. 23, pg. 401

Source: http://www.revivingalislam.com/2011/01/punishment-for-apostate-in-islam.html

The worse thing is, I have even heard people on Shiachat try to challenge and show why it is perfectly fine to call the Imaams "rabb".

P.S. - I seriously hope your username (rabbfatima) isn't supposed to mean "LordFatima", and you actually mean "rabb OF fatima". If you meant the former, then please take head to the narration above.

(salam)

Edited February 19, 2011 by Nader Zaveri

[rabbfatima 0]

(salam)

(bismillah)

Then why are you using praises of Allaah for the Imaams? The phrase "Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ" has been used for Allaah, what you have done is basically like putting (ÚóÒóø æó Ìóáóø) by the Imaams names.

Al-Kaafi:

References that the phrase "Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ" has been used: (NOTICE who it is talking about)

Åöäóø Çááóøåó Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1. pg. 86, hadeeth # 3

æó Çááóøåõ Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1, pg. 119, hadeeth # 1

ãöäú ÊóÚúÙöíãö Çááóøåö Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1, pg. 141, hadeeth # 7

ÓóÃóáúÊõ ÃóÈóÇ ÚóÈúÏö Çááóøåö Ú Úóäú Þóæúáö Çááóøåö Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1, pg. 194, hadeeth # 3

Chapter title: ÈóÇÈñ Ýöíãóäú ÏóÇäó Çááóøåó ÚóÒóø æó Ìóáóø ÈöÛóíúÑö ÅöãóÇãò ãöäó Çááóøåö Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 6, pg. 15

Al-Faqeeh:

ÝóÃóæúÍóì Çááóøåõ Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1, pg. 28, hadeeth # 58

ÝöíåóÇ ÑóÈöøí Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1, pg. 212, hadeeth # 643

ÅöÚúÙóÇãÇð áöáóøåö Ìóáóø ÌóáóÇáõåõ -> vol. 1. pg. 214, hadeeth # 645

....(And the list goes on).....

I advise you to ponder over this narration.

The worse thing is, I have even heard people on Shiachat try to challenge and show why it is perfectly fine to call the Imaams "rabb".

P.S. - I seriously hope your username (rabbfatima) isn't supposed to mean "LordFatima", and you actually mean "rabb OF fatima". If you meant the former, then please take head to the narration above.

(salam)

nice posts , but i still stick to my position and yes Lord Fatima is the intended meaning also ... and j.j goes with it too

[doobybrother 352]

nice posts , but i still stick to my position and yes Lord Fatima is the intended meaning also ... and j.j goes with it too

Even after the hadith quoted by Nader?!

[Nader Zaveri 1,365]

(salam)

(bismillah)

nice posts , but i still stick to my position and yes Lord Fatima is the intended meaning also ... and j.j goes with it too

I don't see why you are laughing, this isn't a funny matter. An authentic explicit hadeeth from our Imaams (as) about an incident that happened with Imaam `Alee (as) and you don't want to take a step back and think about what you are saying / believing?

(salam)

[rabbfatima 0]

(salam)

(bismillah)

I don't see why you are laughing, this isn't a funny matter. An authentic explicit hadeeth from our Imaams (as) about an incident that happened with Imaam `Alee (as) and you don't want to take a step back and think about what you are saying / believing?

(salam) as

apologies , if u both took offence of my "funny" comments.. i dont have to blind myself only what the ahadees text says... even some saheeh ahaadess i read say that umar was married to umm kulsum and some saheeh ahadees also say that quran is corrupted. and scholars have tried to argue very lamely to prove the otherwise in these cases .. both these saheeh ahadees makes no sense to me .. there is something called common sense which dictates to me something.

and as i have mentioned i do not take ahle bayt j.j to be God...

in the hadees quoted , people took ali maula as Allah ,which is not the case with me..

maula says...in hadees e tariq

“O” Ammaar, with My name was brought into being al-alameen,(the Worlds) and all things.

And with my name have supplicated all the Prophets.

And I am the Tablet (Wa Anall Lawh)

And I am the Pen (Wa Anal Qalam) .

And I am The Throne (Wa Anal Arsh)

And I am The Chair (Wa Ana-al-Kursi)

And I am The Seven Heavens (Wa Anass Samaawaatiss Sab’a).

And I am The Excellent Names and The Most High Words (Wa ana-al-asmaaullahil Husna wal kalimaatil Ulya)

when he is the most excellent names of Allah ,most high words , his name is Ali = the most high , i chose to call him and all ahlebayt as j.j , , which thatswhat my mind and heart says is ok...

and you ppl are responsible for your own faith and i am for my own..

somewhere maula ali says in a khotba that glorifying him (doing tasbeeh of his name) is worship of angels in eyes of Allah.,..

so i dont need any HADEES to start calling him or believing in him... verily there are many things beyond the TEXTs ..

maula waris...

[Bhooka_Bhairiya 16]

apologies , if u both took offence of my "funny" comments.. i dont have to blind myself only what the ahadees text says... even some saheeh ahaadess i read say that umar was married to umm kulsum and some saheeh ahadees also say that quran is corrupted. and scholars have tried to argue very lamely to prove the otherwise in these cases .. both these saheeh ahadees makes no sense to me .. there is something called common sense which dictates to me something.

and as i have mentioned i do not take ahle bayt j.j to be God...

in the hadees quoted , people took ali maula as Allah ,which is not the case with me..

maula says...in hadees e tariq

“O” Ammaar, with My name was brought into being al-alameen,(the Worlds) and all things.

And with my name have supplicated all the Prophets.

And I am the Tablet (Wa Anall Lawh)

And I am the Pen (Wa Anal Qalam) .

And I am The Throne (Wa Anal Arsh)

And I am The Chair (Wa Ana-al-Kursi)

And I am The Seven Heavens (Wa Anass Samaawaatiss Sab’a).

And I am The Excellent Names and The Most High Words (Wa ana-al-asmaaullahil Husna wal kalimaatil Ulya)

when he is the most excellent names of Allah ,most high words , his name is Ali = the most high , i chose to call him and all ahlebayt as j.j , , which thatswhat my mind and heart says is ok...

and you ppl are responsible for your own faith and i am for my own..

somewhere maula ali says in a khotba that glorifying him (doing tasbeeh of his name) is worship of angels in eyes of Allah.,..

so i dont need any HADEES to start calling him or believing in him... verily there are many things beyond the TEXTs ..

maula waris...

(salam)

So why are you then quoting "hadith e tariq", which doesn't even exist in our books but is from deviant heretic sufi Hafidh Rajab al Bursi's Mashariq anwar ul yaqeen.

[rabbfatima 0]

(salam)

So why are you then quoting "hadith e tariq", which doesn't even exist in our books but is from deviant heretic sufi Hafidh Rajab al Bursi's Mashariq anwar ul yaqeen.

hadees a tariq doesn't contain both the words i use for maula Ali

it was just quoted to bring attention to afzal manzelat of maula J.j

and i don't need a SANAD from an AKKHUND to know the fazail of Maula Ali or to call him j.j whatever i wish

i believe in hadees e tariq and no one can deter me from it ..

Maula waris

and yes you all shall not worry about me calling Maula Ali as Rabb and j.j

verily , none of you and or akhund is going to accompany me into my grave

we all have to face our hisaab individually