Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 16 Advanced Member Report Posted October 16 (edited) Salam alaykum. I want to open a thread about a question I have thought about for a long time, and I want to ask it in a fair way. We agree that the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is binding. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, leave it (59:7). And He says the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) explains to the people what was sent down to them (16:44). So the question is not if we follow the Sunna. The question is how we know that a report really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Our way is easy to explain. A report needs a connected chain up to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and every man in it must be known as truthful and precise. Ibn Sirin (رضي الله عنه) said that when the fitna came, people started to say: name us your men. Ibn al Mubarak (رضي الله عنه) said the isnad is part of the religion, and without it everybody would say what he wants. Both is in the introduction of Sahih Muslim. And the main question is truthfulness. Al Dhahabi (رضي الله عنه) writes about Aban ibn Taghlib, a strong Shia, that he is truthful, so we take his truthfulness and his bid'a is on him. He says if we rejected such narrators, a big part of the Prophetic reports would be lost (Mizan al I'tidal 1/5). Now your side. In your books the chains usually stop at an Imam, mostly al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) or Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). I know your answer: the word of the Imam is like the word of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), because of the report "my hadith is the hadith of my father" (al Kafi, Kitab Fadl al Ilm). But in the same chapter of al Kafi there is a report that Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: when you narrate a hadith, give it back to the one who told it to you. And in Sahih Muslim 1218, Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) narrates from his father al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) that they went to Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) and asked him about the Hajj of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). So the Imams themselves named their source. So my first question: If the word of the Imam is enough without a chain, why does al Kafi itself tell us to name the one we heard a hadith from, and why did al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) name Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source? And how do you know that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam? I will come to your rijal in the next posts, but I would like to hear your answer to this first. Edited October 17 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 17 Advanced Member Report Posted October 17 23 hours ago, Maulana said: Salam alaykum. I want to open a thread about a question I have thought about for a long time, and I want to ask it in a fair way. We agree that the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is binding. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, leave it (59:7). And He says the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) explains to the people what was sent down to them (16:44). So the question is not if we follow the Sunna. The question is how we know that a report really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Our way is easy to explain. A report needs a connected chain up to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and every man in it must be known as truthful and precise. Ibn Sirin (رضي الله عنه) said that when the fitna came, people started to say: name us your men. Ibn al Mubarak (رضي الله عنه) said the isnad is part of the religion, and without it everybody would say what he wants. Both is in the introduction of Sahih Muslim. And the main question is truthfulness. Al Dhahabi (رضي الله عنه) writes about Aban ibn Taghlib, a strong Shia, that he is truthful, so we take his truthfulness and his bid'a is on him. He says if we rejected such narrators, a big part of the Prophetic reports would be lost (Mizan al I'tidal 1/5). Now your side. In your books the chains usually stop at an Imam, mostly al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) or Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). I know your answer: the word of the Imam is like the word of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), because of the report "my hadith is the hadith of my father" (al Kafi, Kitab Fadl al Ilm). But in the same chapter of al Kafi there is a report that Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: when you narrate a hadith, give it back to the one who told it to you. And in Sahih Muslim 1218, Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) narrates from his father al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) that they went to Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) and asked him about the Hajj of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). So the Imams themselves named their source. So my first question: If the word of the Imam is enough without a chain, why does al Kafi itself tell us to name the one we heard a hadith from, and why did al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) name Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source? And how do you know that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam? I will come to your rijal in the next posts, but I would like to hear your answer to this first. Salam I don’t know how many people you’re gonna find hero actually qualified enough to discuss Ilm ul Rijal and the differences among its methodologies between scholars and schools of thought Gonna get bogged down, I will simply simplify the topic A narration only has to reach infallible because infallible themselves knowledge all goes back to the holy prophet, peace and blessings be upon him So if a narration reaches an Imam as then it has reached the prophet sawa Imam Jafar as Sadiq as narrates my words of the words of my father, his words of the words of my grandfather, his words of the words of Hussayn as his words of the words ofHassan as his words of the words of the commander of the faithful, his words of the words of the holy prophet, his words of the words of Allah We also have the narration of Imam Muhammad Al Baqir as you want to quote something from one of us, but you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names for we all say the same thing We also have as you know, numerous narrations from the holy prophet, peace and blessings be upon them commanding to follow the holy family after him If you want to go on the specific narration and rules that may or may not apply from it, you’d have to post that narration with the chain. I’m taking my son to the dentist. I didn’t have time to do a deep dive. wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe and ServantOfMahdi 2 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 17 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 17 (edited) 1 hour ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam I don’t know how many people you’re gonna find hero actually qualified enough to discuss Ilm ul Rijal and the differences among its methodologies between scholars and schools of thought Gonna get bogged down, I will simply simplify the topic A narration only has to reach infallible because infallible themselves knowledge all goes back to the holy prophet, peace and blessings be upon him So if a narration reaches an Imam as then it has reached the prophet sawa Imam Jafar as Sadiq as narrates my words of the words of my father, his words of the words of my grandfather, his words of the words of Hussayn as his words of the words ofHassan as his words of the words of the commander of the faithful, his words of the words of the holy prophet, his words of the words of Allah We also have the narration of Imam Muhammad Al Baqir as you want to quote something from one of us, but you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names for we all say the same thing We also have as you know, numerous narrations from the holy prophet, peace, and blessings be a bottom commanding to follow the holy family after him If you want to go on the specific narration and rules that may or may not apply from it, you’d have to post that narration with the chain. I’m taking my son to the dentist. I didn’t have time to do a deep dive. wallahu Alam Salam brother Abu Hassanain, I hope all went good with your son at the dentist. You say not many people here are qualified to discuss rijal. I agree and this is actually my point. If a normal Shia needs a rijal expert, to know if a report really reached the Imam, then "it only has to reach the Imam" does not solve the problem. You still need a chain up to the Imam and people, who check the men in it. You asked for the chain. The report of Ali (رضي الله عنه) is in al Kafi, vol. 1, Kitab Fadl al Ilm, Bab riwayat al kutub wa al hadith, hadith 7: Ali ibn Ibrahim from his father, and from Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid, from al Nawfali, from al Sakuni, from Abu Abdillah (رضي الله عنه), from Amir al Muminin (ra): when you narrate a hadith, give its chain back to the one who told it to you. To be fair, your scholar al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (Mir'at al Uqul 1/179). But the two reports, which you used, are in the same chapter and they are not better. "My hadith is the hadith of my father" (hadith 14) has Sahl ibn Ziyad in the chain, and al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (1/182). "It is the same" (hadith 4) is from al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه), not from al Baqir (رضي الله عنه), it goes through Ali ibn Abi Hamza al Bata'ini, and al Majlisi calls it da'if (1/176). Al Behbudi did not take any of these three in his Sahih al Kafi. So the rule, that a report only has to reach the Imam, is your claim, and the reports you use for it are weak by your own scholars. If you have an authentic report for this rule please bring it. Until then the sahih example we have shows an Imam, who named his source: Jafar ibn Muhammad (رضي الله عنه) from his father (رضي الله عنه), who said: we entered upon Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) (Sahih Muslim 1218). You did not explain yet, why al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) did this. And even if the word of the Imam is enough, it still had to reach al Kulayni through normal men. Your own books say, that there were liars among them. In Rijal al Kashshi no. 401 al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says al Mughira ibn Said put hadith into the books of the companions of his father, and al Rida (رضي الله عنه) says the followers of Abu al Khattab were still putting lies into the books of the companions of Abu Abdillah. This question is not only for you. If any brother or sister here knows rijal good, I would like to hear the answer: with which standard do you make sure, that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam, when your own Imams said that liars put reports into the books of their companions? Edited October 17 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 17 Advanced Member Report Posted October 17 8 hours ago, Maulana said: Salam brother Abu Hassanain, I hope all went good with your son at the dentist. You say not many people here are qualified to discuss rijal. I agree and this is actually my point. If a normal Shia needs a rijal expert, to know if a report really reached the Imam, then "it only has to reach the Imam" does not solve the problem. You still need a chain up to the Imam and people, who check the men in it. You asked for the chain. The report of Ali (رضي الله عنه) is in al Kafi, vol. 1, Kitab Fadl al Ilm, Bab riwayat al kutub wa al hadith, hadith 7: Ali ibn Ibrahim from his father, and from Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid, from al Nawfali, from al Sakuni, from Abu Abdillah (رضي الله عنه), from Amir al Muminin (ra): when you narrate a hadith, give its chain back to the one who told it to you. To be fair, your scholar al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (Mir'at al Uqul 1/179). But the two reports, which you used, are in the same chapter and they are not better. "My hadith is the hadith of my father" (hadith 14) has Sahl ibn Ziyad in the chain, and al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (1/182). "It is the same" (hadith 4) is from al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه), not from al Baqir (رضي الله عنه), it goes through Ali ibn Abi Hamza al Bata'ini, and al Majlisi calls it da'if (1/176). Al Behbudi did not take any of these three in his Sahih al Kafi. So the rule, that a report only has to reach the Imam, is your claim, and the reports you use for it are weak by your own scholars. If you have an authentic report for this rule please bring it. Until then the sahih example we have shows an Imam, who named his source: Jafar ibn Muhammad (رضي الله عنه) from his father (رضي الله عنه), who said: we entered upon Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) (Sahih Muslim 1218). You did not explain yet, why al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) did this. And even if the word of the Imam is enough, it still had to reach al Kulayni through normal men. Your own books say, that there were liars among them. In Rijal al Kashshi no. 401 al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says al Mughira ibn Said put hadith into the books of the companions of his father, and al Rida (رضي الله عنه) says the followers of Abu al Khattab were still putting lies into the books of the companions of Abu Abdillah. This question is not only for you. If any brother or sister here knows rijal good, I would like to hear the answer: with which standard do you make sure, that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam, when your own Imams said that liars put reports into the books of their companions? Salam as for Sahih Muslim we generally do not take from it, except to argue with our opponents from other schools of thought Now there’s a rule from our mentor and master the late Sayyid Khoy Ra (qadwin Usul Fiqh/ foundational rules of methodology of jurisprudence) that the famous narrations meaning narrations that are famous among the people of waliyah and are well known and abundantly narrated may be relied upon, even if they’re apparently weak My opinion is that Sahl Ibn Ziyad reliable, and neither strong nor weak I also take from Abdallah Ibn Sinan and Muhammad Ibn Sinaan and found most of the reports against them to be unsustained or exaggerated As for the 14th narration, there are many such narrations and many books As for Ali Ibn Abi Hamza Batani is reliable during the lifetime of the sixth and seventh guide, but after the death of the seventh guide he became unreliable For many of the people you have to look at what year they were narrating the narrations No, I can make the statements because I spent 13 years in seminary and continued studying and teaching after that You promise I think is the net is that they’re late people cannot understand their religion because they do not have the qualifications to analyze the sources of the religion yes ? This is where the system of imitation of a living scholar comes in People who cannot become a jurist and are not learned enough to exercise precaution, according to the narrations precaution, according to the possibilities or precaution, according to the opinions of the scholars, then they must follow a qualified jurist That juris will have anywhere from 2500 to 3800 rulings on all the issues that affect the daily life he has analyzed ordinations and all the verses of the Quran and come to an authentic conclusion which is sufficient for the lay people to follow Now is for theology most of the people are not able to dedicate themselves to studying theology full-time but one must obtain his beliefs according to what he is able The holy Quran is very clear, but no soul she’ll be placed a burden more they can bear in the narrations narrate. People are only responsible for what they can understand beyond that nothing is upon them. So there are general books of the allergies that layout the opinions in the proofs and again those suffice for the lay people The higher issues of Islamic science are the domain of scholars and most of the people to be honest aren’t interested in under understand those things even if they have the capacity they don’t have the time they’re busy working traveling, raising a family. It’s a handful of specialist who can spend their life understanding those things. So through the grand, Eye told us the late people go around the science of the narrations in the narrators and are able to obtain their religion It was the same thing with traditional Sunnis before the rise of the Salafiyah which basically created a do it yourself religion under the guys of literalism and following the narration, but didn’t take count conflicting narration difference among scholars and I’m speaking of the movement as it occurred in America, not necessarily in the golf or places or people speak Arabic and have access to books Their movement destroyed Islam in this country Taqlid of a Marja is necessary in the people who are interested in capable of studying the sciences should and perhaps they would reach a level of precaution and very if you would reach a level of independent knowledge wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 17 Advanced Member Report Posted October 17 22 hours ago, Maulana said: Salam alaykum. I want to open a thread about a question I have thought about for a long time, and I want to ask it in a fair way. We agree that the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is binding. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, leave it (59:7). And He says the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) explains to the people what was sent down to them (16:44). So the question is not if we follow the Sunna. The question is how we know that a report really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Our way is easy to explain. A report needs a connected chain up to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and every man in it must be known as truthful and precise. Ibn Sirin (رضي الله عنه) said that when the fitna came, people started to say: name us your men. Ibn al Mubarak (رضي الله عنه) said the isnad is part of the religion, and without it everybody would say what he wants. Both is in the introduction of Sahih Muslim. And the main question is truthfulness. Al Dhahabi (رضي الله عنه) writes about Aban ibn Taghlib, a strong Shia, that he is truthful, so we take his truthfulness and his bid'a is on him. He says if we rejected such narrators, a big part of the Prophetic reports would be lost (Mizan al I'tidal 1/5). Now your side. In your books the chains usually stop at an Imam, mostly al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) or Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). I know your answer: the word of the Imam is like the word of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), because of the report "my hadith is the hadith of my father" (al Kafi, Kitab Fadl al Ilm). But in the same chapter of al Kafi there is a report that Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: when you narrate a hadith, give it back to the one who told it to you. And in Sahih Muslim 1218, Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) narrates from his father al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) that they went to Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) and asked him about the Hajj of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). So the Imams themselves named their source. So my first question: If the word of the Imam is enough without a chain, why does al Kafi itself tell us to name the one we heard a hadith from, and why did al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) name Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source? And how do you know that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam? I will come to your rijal in the next posts, but I would like to hear your answer to this first. Salam out of curiosity, which school of thought of Sunni or otherwise, are you affiliated with and how many years did you spend in an Islamic seminary or university? I’m assuming by your name you’re a member of the clergy. wallahu alam Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 18 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 (edited) 1 hour ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam as for Sahih Muslim we generally do not take from it, except to argue with our opponents from other schools of thought Now there’s a rule from our mentor and master the late Sayyid Khoy Ra (qadwin Usul Fiqh/ foundational rules of methodology of jurisprudence) that the famous narrations meaning narrations that are famous among the people of waliyah and are well known and abundantly narrated may be relied upon, even if they’re apparently weak My opinion is that Sahl Ibn Ziyad reliable, and neither strong nor weak I also take from Abdallah Ibn Sinan and Muhammad Ibn Sinaan and found most of the reports against them to be unsustained or exaggerated As for the 14th narration, there are many such narrations and many books As for Ali Ibn Abi Hamza Batani is reliable during the lifetime of the sixth and seventh guide, but after the death of the seventh guide he became unreliable For many of the people you have to look at what year they were narrating the narrations No, I can make the statements because I spent 13 years in seminary and continued studying and teaching after that You promise I think is the net is that they’re late people cannot understand their religion because they do not have the qualifications to analyze the sources of the religion yes ? This is where the system of imitation of a living scholar comes in People who cannot become a jurist and are not learned enough to exercise precaution, according to the narrations precaution, according to the possibilities or precaution, according to the opinions of the scholars, then they must follow a qualified jurist That juris will have anywhere from 2500 to 3800 rulings on all the issues that affect the daily life he has analyzed ordinations and all the verses of the Quran and come to an authentic conclusion which is sufficient for the lay people to follow Now is for theology most of the people are not able to dedicate themselves to studying theology full-time but one must obtain his beliefs according to what he is able The holy Quran is very clear, but no soul she’ll be placed a burden more they can bear in the narrations narrate. People are only responsible for what they can understand beyond that nothing is upon them. So there are general books of the allergies that layout the opinions in the proofs and again those suffice for the lay people The higher issues of Islamic science are the domain of scholars and most of the people to be honest aren’t interested in under understand those things even if they have the capacity they don’t have the time they’re busy working traveling, raising a family. It’s a handful of specialist who can spend their life understanding those things. So through the grand, Eye told us the late people go around the science of the narrations in the narrators and are able to obtain their religion It was the same thing with traditional Sunnis before the rise of the Salafiyah which basically created a do it yourself religion under the guys of literalism and following the narration, but didn’t take count conflicting narration difference among scholars and I’m speaking of the movement as it occurred in America, not necessarily in the golf or places or people speak Arabic and have access to books Their movement destroyed Islam in this country Taqlid of a Marja is necessary in the people who are interested in capable of studying the sciences should and perhaps they would reach a level of precaution and very if you would reach a level of independent knowledge wallahu Alam Salam brother, You say you don't take from Sahih Muslim. Ok, then from al Kafi. Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) says: Jabir (رضي الله عنه) told me from the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and Jabir (رضي الله عنه) did not lie (al Kafi vol. 7, Kitab al Mawarith, Bab ibn akh wa jadd, hadith 3). Al Majlisi grades it hasan (Mir'at al Uqul 23/168) and al Khoei says the chain is sahih (Mu'jam Rijal al Hadith, entry Jabir ibn Abdullah (ra)). So the Imam named his source and even said that he is truthful. Why should he do this, if the word of the Imam alone is enough? About the rule from al Khoei, can you give me the book and page? Because in Misbah al Usul, in the chapter about hujjiyyat al shuhra, al Khoei says the opposite. When the majority act on a report, this does not fix a weak chain the measure is that the chain itself is complete. And he even says that a report which is narrated a lot is not for this reason preferred over another report. If you mean tawatur, then please bring the many chains for "it only has to reach the Imam". You say there are many, so one sahih should not be hard to bring. About Sahl ibn Ziyad, you call al Khoei your master, but he says Sahl is weak for sure, or at least his reliability is not proven (Mu'jam Rijal al Hadith, no. 5639). About al Bata'ini you say he was reliable before the death of al Kazim (رضي الله عنه). In hadith 4 the man who narrates from him is al Qasim ibn Muhammad al Jawhari, and al Tusi says about him that he was a Waqifi himself (Rijal al Tusi, companions of al Kazim (ra)). Muhammad Rida al Sistani, the son of Ali al Sistani, says the reports of Waqifis like al Jawhari from al Bata'ini can not be counted as taken before the waqf (Qabasat min Ilm al Rijal 1/340 to 358). And al Kafi gives no year for any report. About taqlid, I agree that a normal person asks the scholars, Allah says ask the people of knowledge if you do not know (16:43).But then the normal Shia does not get "the word of the Imam" directly, he gets the opinion of his marja about the chain. For you Sahl is reliable, for al Khoei he is weak. So you also need chains and men who check them, same like us. And in the end the Imam himself gave his chain back to the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) through Jabir (رضي الله عنه). This is my point in this thread. The measure for our religion is what really comes from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), Allah says whatever the Messenger gives you, take it (59:7). And to know that it really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), we need a connected chain back to him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), not a chain that stops before him. Edited October 18 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 18 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 1 hour ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam out of curiosity, which school of thought of Sunni or otherwise, are you affiliated with and how many years did you spend in an Islamic seminary or university? I’m assuming by your name you’re a member of the clergy. wallahu alam About me, I am a Sunni and I follow the way of Ahl al Hadith. I am a seeker of knowledge, and I have discussed these topics with Shia in forums for some years. But who I am doesn't matter much here, the sources are from your books and so everybody can check them. Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 18 Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 On 10/17/2026 at 7:01 PM, Maulana said: Salam brother, You say you don't take from Sahih Muslim. Ok, then from al Kafi. Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) says: Jabir (رضي الله عنه) told me from the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and Jabir (رضي الله عنه) did not lie (al Kafi vol. 7, Kitab al Mawarith, Bab ibn akh wa jadd, hadith 3). Al Majlisi grades it hasan (Mir'at al Uqul 23/168) and al Khoei says the chain is sahih (Mu'jam Rijal al Hadith, entry Jabir ibn Abdullah (ra)). So the Imam named his source and even said that he is truthful. Why should he do this, if the word of the Imam alone is enough? About the rule from al Khoei, can you give me the book and page? Because in Misbah al Usul, in the chapter about hujjiyyat al shuhra, al Khoei says the opposite. When the majority act on a report, this does not fix a weak chain the measure is that the chain itself is complete. And he even says that a report which is narrated a lot is not for this reason preferred over another report. If you mean tawatur, then please bring the many chains for "it only has to reach the Imam". You say there are many, so one sahih should not be hard to bring. About Sahl ibn Ziyad, you call al Khoei your master, but he says Sahl is weak for sure, or at least his reliability is not proven (Mu'jam Rijal al Hadith, no. 5639). About al Bata'ini you say he was reliable before the death of al Kazim (رضي الله عنه). In hadith 4 the man who narrates from him is al Qasim ibn Muhammad al Jawhari, and al Tusi says about him that he was a Waqifi himself (Rijal al Tusi, companions of al Kazim (ra)). Muhammad Rida al Sistani, the son of Ali al Sistani, says the reports of Waqifis like al Jawhari from al Bata'ini can not be counted as taken before the waqf (Qabasat min Ilm al Rijal 1/340 to 358). And al Kafi gives no year for any report. About taqlid, I agree that a normal person asks the scholars, Allah says ask the people of knowledge if you do not know (16:43).But then the normal Shia does not get "the word of the Imam" directly, he gets the opinion of his marja about the chain. For you Sahl is reliable, for al Khoei he is weak. So you also need chains and men who check them, same like us. And in the end the Imam himself gave his chain back to the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) through Jabir (رضي الله عنه). This is my point in this thread. The measure for our religion is what really comes from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), Allah says whatever the Messenger gives you, take it (59:7). And to know that it really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), we need a connected chain back to him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), not a chain that stops before him. Salam I heard the opinion of our late mentor on the matter of the famous narration directly from two of his students It’s also worth mentioning the different scholars how different opinions at different times and often times their students who were students of them when they died are aware of their final opinions more than what is written in their books An example of this for instance, is that when I was studying in the seminary Shaikh Nasr Makarim considered all disbeliever is ritually impure whereas now his opinion is that no human being is ritually impure in the physical sense Many times versus research evidence and how to apply narrations and rulings for particular situations and times the ruling our opinion may change As for the difference of opinion with our late mentor on Sahl Ibn Ziyad those were studied up until the third level and those have completed. It have differences among each other and it’s not a big deal. As for Sayyid Muhammad Ridha Sistani dds I have great respect for him and his father, but I differ with him and his father in terms of science of the narrations science of the narrators the evidence for the methodology of repairing the week narrations what can be used to repair the weak narrations, and the number of scholars have completed the third level and what constitutes who can teach the third level etc he has a number of more strict in precaution views on the number of these topics for instance himself and said there’s no one qualified to teach the third level in North America, South America, Europe, Australia, and the vast majority of Asia or Africa he doubts the jury status of many scholars in India, Pakistan and Syria because he has a structure criteria etc I think your hope here is to weaken our books of narrations and cast out and to make people renounce the true faith and adopt a false faith I don’t think you’re here for sincere dialogue I’m aware that they don’t have years when reports were narrated but when you look at all the narrators in a chain, you can kind of deduce a rough timeline. That’s generally how we reduce deduce whether a report from a person who became a Waqfi later on can be relied upon Your own school of thought accepts narrations that are much more ridiculous than the narrations of ours. You seem to have a problem with. What about those narrations that accuse the holy prophet peace and blessings be upon him had unclean substance on the front of his sleeping pants and was leading the prayers like that, and then someone had to tell him so that he could go bathe in that person led the prayer prayers These according to your scholars have solid chains of narration We can all go back-and-forth on these type of issues The fundamental of our religion is monotheism, but your school of fraud claims the Lord has a physical body that he sits upon the throne that he puts his foot into hell to cool it off that he bends over and one of the masters of your school of father who I don’t want to name out of respect was asked if because he’s on the throne he’s limited by the sixth directions being backwards forwards, right left up and down and he said yes This understanding of the Lord violates chapter 112 verse four in the name of the Allah the gracious the merciful and there’s nothing from amongst his creation that resembles him So your School thought has a fundamental issue with anamorphosis the creator negating monotheism which leads and the polytheism and disbelief This is a much more important issue, which should be resolved first wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 18 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 7 hours ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam I heard the opinion of our late mentor on the matter of the famous narration directly from two of his students It’s also worth mentioning the different scholars how different opinions at different times and often times their students who were students of them when they died are aware of their final opinions more than what is written in their books An example of this for instance, is that when I was studying in the seminary Shaikh Nasr Makarim considered all disbeliever is ritually impure whereas now his opinion is that no human being is ritually impure in the physical sense Many times versus research evidence and how to apply narrations and rulings for particular situations and times the ruling our opinion may change As for the difference of opinion with our late mentor on Sahl Ibn Ziyad those were studied up until the third level and those have completed. It have differences among each other and it’s not a big deal. As for Sayyid Muhammad Ridha Sistani dds I have great respect for him and his father, but I differ with him and his father in terms of science of the narrations science of the narrators the evidence for the methodology of repairing the week narrations what can be used to repair the weak narrations, and the number of scholars have completed the third level and what constitutes who can teach the third level etc he has a number of more strict in precaution views on the number of these topics for instance himself and said there’s no one qualified to teach the third level in North America, South America, Europe, Australia, and the vast majority of Asia or Africa he doubts the jury status of many scholars in India, Pakistan and Syria because he has a structure criteria etc I think your hope here is to weaken our books of narrations and cast out and to make people renounce the true faith and adopt a false faith I don’t think you’re here for sincere dialogue I’m aware that they don’t have years when reports were narrated but when you look at all the narrators in a chain, you can kind of deduce a rough timeline. That’s generally how we reduce deduce whether a report from a person who became a Waqfi later on can be relied upon Your own school of thought accepts narrations that are much more ridiculous than the narrations of ours. You seem to have a problem with. What about those narrations that accuse the holy profit peace and blessings be upon him had unclean substance on the front of his sleeping pants and was leading the prayers like that, and then someone had to tell him so that he could go bathe in that person led the prayer prayers These according to your scholars have solid chains of narration We can all go back-and-forth on these type of issues The fundamental of our religion is monotheism, but your school of fraud claims the Lord has a physical body that he sits upon the throne that he puts his foot into hell to cool it off that he bends over and one of the masters of your school of father who I don’t want to name out of respect was asked if because he’s on the throne he’s limited by the sixth directions being backwards forwards, right left up and down and he said yes This understanding of the Lord violates chapter 112 verse four in the name of the Allah the gracious the merciful and there’s nothing from amongst his creation that resembles him So your School thought has a fundamental issue with anamorphosis the creator negating monotheism which leads and the polytheism and disbelief This is a much more important issue, which should be resolved first wallahu Alam Salam Two points you did not answer yet. Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) named Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source in al Kafi, and al Khoei says the chain is sahih. Why, if the word of the Imam alone is enough? And you still did not bring one sahih report for the rule "it only has to reach the Imam". About al Khoei, now you say you heard his opinion from two of his students. I don't doubt you, but this is exactly my point. A word from two people without names can not be checked, his book Misbah al Usul can be checked by everybody. This is why we need chains with known men. About Sahl and Muhammad Rida al Sistani, you differ with al Khoei, and you differ with al Sistani and his son in the method. You say this is not a big deal. But it means the same report is the word of the Imam for one scholar and not for the other. So in the end it does not only have to reach the Imam, it also has to pass the opinion of your marja. About the timeline, ok, then please apply it to hadith 4. Al Jawhari, who narrates it from al Bata'ini, was a Waqifi himself (al Tusi). How does the timeline show that he took it before the waqf? Al Majlisi did not see it like this, he graded it weak. About tawhid, this is another topic. If you want, open a thread for it and I will answer there in sha Allah. About the hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) and janaba, it does not say what you wrote. Nobody had to tell him, he (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) remembered it by himself (Bukhari 275, Muslim 605). Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 18 Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 Salam narrations are graded differently by different scholars Each grand scholar and student scholars who have reached the third level of free to grade narrators and narrations, according to their understanding for example, our master and mentor the teacher of my teachers Sayyid Khoy Ra graded one narrator in the sermon of Mina by Imam Hussayn as weak whereas Sayyid Khumanyi Ra didn’t And me, differing with scholars of the pastor present on the grading of a particular person, and thus the grading of an narration is not shocking or strange This is not limited to the school of thought of the 14th but is found among your own school of thought as well Their narrations in your six books that contradict each other other different scholars took different greetings and narration among your six books and others If you put different Sunni in a room mutant to differ in your methodologies grades of the chain and grades of the narrative in the chain in grades of narrations So to put it bluntly, I consider the chain that it only has to go back to an infallible as great as Hassan or sound, but not perfect Where is other scholars did not Going around in circles, saying that it only has to go through the grand scholars and their students from the third level and this is not approved and thus our whole religion is based on hearsay is an argument that’s not going to go very far As I said, you’re talking with someone who’s actually qualified to talk about Rijal the majority box on the topic that I were reading at 10:20 and 30 volumes and mostly in Arabic or Persian So again, there’s not really much of a debate to be had here as I said they’re numerous examples to support the students were quite right because Skylars changed their views on a number of topic and sometimes they had one view and one book, but not another Shaikh Saduq Ra view, and the number of the inflatables that were murdered is an example of this in his early book. He mentions 3 to 5 and a leader book he says about half at the end of his life he didn’t fear being assassinated. He mentioned all of them. You are so negate various recent scholars have several different ways to repair and utilize weak narrations There are the weak narrations that can be repaired on the weak narrations that can’t be repaired As for model theism in your own books, I am getting ready for the pre-month of Ramadan season, which we try to host some programs nightly a couple months ahead of time to get the people clean and at a spiritual level before that blessed month Have time I will post a topic about it As the narration of the impurity, I have seen it ridden a number of ways in later historical books, but I went back and read the narration. The only difference is that he realized that no one told him But him becoming in pure in this way, violates the holy Quran and is a serious problem and theology it violates chapter 33 verse 33 because he has become impure when the verse says that rijas which indicates both physical and spiritual impurity is impossible for him, and his four family members were under the cloak wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 18 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 1 hour ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam narrations are graded differently by different scholars Each grand scholar and student scholars who have reached the third level of free to grade narrators and narrations, according to their understanding for example, our master and mentor the teacher of my teachers Sayyid Khoy Ra graded one narrator in the sermon of Mina by Imam Hussayn as weak whereas Sayyid Khumanyi Ra didn’t And me, differing with scholars of the pastor present on the grading of a particular person, and thus the grading of an narration is not shocking or strange This is not limited to the school of thought of the 14th but is found among your own school of thought as well Their narrations in your six books that contradict each other other different scholars took different greetings and narration among your six books and others If you put different Sunni in a room mutant to differ in your methodologies grades of the chain and grades of the narrative in the chain in grades of narrations So to put it bluntly, I consider the chain that it only has to go back to an infallible as great as Hassan or sound, but not perfect Where is other scholars did not Going around in circles, saying that it only has to go through the grand scholars and their students from the third level and this is not approved and thus our whole religion is based on hearsay is an argument that’s not going to go very far As I said, you’re talking with someone who’s actually qualified to talk about Rijal the majority box on the topic that I were reading at 10:20 and 30 volumes and mostly in Arabic or Persian So again, there’s not really much of a debate to be had here as I said they’re numerous examples to support the students were quite right because Skylars changed their views on a number of topic and sometimes they had one view and one book, but not another Shaikh Saduq Ra view, and the number of the inflatables that were murdered is an example of this in his early book. He mentions 3 to 5 and a leader book he says about half at the end of his life he didn’t fear being assassinated. He mentioned all of them. You are so negate various recent scholars have several different ways to repair and utilize weak narrations There are the weak narrations that can be repaired on the weak narrations that can’t be repaired As for model theism in your own books, I am getting ready for the pre-month of Ramadan season, which we try to host some programs nightly a couple months ahead of time to get the people clean and at a spiritual level before that blessed month Have time I will post a topic about it As the narration of the impurity, I have seen it ridden a number of ways in later historical books, but I went back and read the narration. The only difference is that he realized that no one told him But him becoming in pure in this way, violates the holy Quran and is a serious problem and theology it violates chapter 33 verse 33 because he has become impure when the verse says that rijas which indicates both physical and spiritual impurity is impossible for him, and his four family members were under the cloak wallahu Alam Salam I never said your religion is hearsay. I only asked how you check that a report really reached the Imam. You wrote: "I consider the chain that it only has to go back to an infallible as hasan or sound, but not perfect", and that other scholars did not. Thank you, this is honest. So the rule "it only has to reach the Imam" is not agreed even among your scholars, al Majlisi grades the reports for it weak, and al Behbudi did not take them. And al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) naming Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source, sahih by al Khoei, is still not answered. You say we Sunnis also differ in gradings! Yes, our scholars differ about some narrators and some reports, I never said something else. But for all of them a hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is only sahih when its chain is connected all the way back to him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). If it stops at a companion, it is the word of the companion, not a hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). About 33:33, you say rijs means physical and spiritual impurity, so the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) can not become junub. But your Imam explained this verse himself. Al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says: "al rijs huwa al shakk, wallahi la nashukku fi rabbina abadan", rijs is doubt, by Allah we never doubt in our Lord (al Kafi vol. 1, Kitab al Hujja, Bab ma nassa Allah wa rasuluhu ala al a'imma wahidan fa wahidan, hadith 1). Al Majlisi grades it sahih by both chains (Mir'at al Uqul 3/213), and al Behbudi took it in Sahih al Kafi. Janaba is not doubt. And your Imams also tell that the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) made ghusl from janaba!! Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) say that he and his wife made ghusl together from one vessel with five mudd, and he started by washing his private parts (Tahdhib al Ahkam 1/370, no. 1130, sahih by al Behbudi). So your own Imams do not read 33:33 like you do, and the hadith in Bukhari does not go against the Quran. I understand you are busy now with your preparations before Ramadan. When you have time, open a thread about tawhid or other topics, and we can talk there in detail, inshallah. Then this thread can stay with its real question! Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 18 Advanced Member Report Posted October 18 3 hours ago, Maulana said: Salam I never said your religion is hearsay. I only asked how you check that a report really reached the Imam. You wrote: "I consider the chain that it only has to go back to an infallible as hasan or sound, but not perfect", and that other scholars did not. Thank you, this is honest. So the rule "it only has to reach the Imam" is not agreed even among your scholars, al Majlisi grades the reports for it weak, and al Behbudi did not take them. And al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) naming Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source, sahih by al Khoei, is still not answered. You say we Sunnis also differ in gradings! Yes, our scholars differ about some narrators and some reports, I never said something else. But for all of them a hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is only sahih when its chain is connected all the way back to him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). If it stops at a companion, it is the word of the companion, not a hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). About 33:33, you say rijs means physical and spiritual impurity, so the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) can not become junub. But your Imam explained this verse himself. Al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says: "al rijs huwa al shakk, wallahi la nashukku fi rabbina abadan", rijs is doubt, by Allah we never doubt in our Lord (al Kafi vol. 1, Kitab al Hujja, Bab ma nassa Allah wa rasuluhu ala al a'imma wahidan fa wahidan, hadith 1). Al Majlisi grades it sahih by both chains (Mir'at al Uqul 3/213), and al Behbudi took it in Sahih al Kafi. Janaba is not doubt. And your Imams also tell that the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) made ghusl from janaba!! Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) say that he and his wife made ghusl together from one vessel with five mudd, and he started by washing his private parts (Tahdhib al Ahkam 1/370, no. 1130, sahih by al Behbudi). So your own Imams do not read 33:33 like you do, and the hadith in Bukhari does not go against the Quran. I understand you are busy now with your preparations before Ramadan. When you have time, open a thread about tawhid or other topics, and we can talk there in detail, inshallah. Then this thread can stay with its real question! Salam some scholars consider these washings to be recommended or they consider those narrations to be borrowed from other school or a pest dissimulation, etc. if something came out for them, it’s different than what comes out for us. It’s like it’s very clear that Lady Fatima peace be upon her does not have a period. and Shane is different than theological beliefs See what Jala Ayyun says see Najhlul Israr And Rijis veterinarian meaning doubt is one thing it’s not the only thing Imam Sadiq as said in the sound chain for instance We the family of the prophet remain in the womb of her mother for six months, not a day less than a day more we emerge from the right side with a full head of hair and a full set of teeth, a light shining brighter than sun, moon and star we fall into prostration recite the two testimonies we are wrapped with a cloth where our lines would have been we sneeze and praise the Lord the angels respond to us and the Lord senses greeting we take milk from the finger of the previous deputy Their station is far above us into accuse them of ritual and purity is quite disturbing And you don’t know the nature of what occurred between him and his wife, some scholars have written and lengthy books, and all he would have to do is look at the women or touch their shoulder and they would become completely satisfied and he did recommended things so even though he does not become impure, he would take a ritual bath with them as a recommended act. I’ve seen a whole lecture series in like 15 lectures on this in Urdu with a discussion with a colleague. But this is not the point you can’t move the goal post or dance around different scholars have different opinion The companions are not infallible immaculate in air free, but the holy prophet, peace and blessing upon him family is the chain from Jabir isn’t the problem and it simply means an interpreted I mean that obviously it’s better to show going back through the infallible to the profit to produce a golden chain, but it’s not a hard role We have a clear narration from imam Sadiq as we are the proof on the people and our mother Fatima is the proof on us Do you find anyone says that every Hadi must go through Fatima peace upon her to be accepted Differences among the various scholars and criteria and narrations is fine. I would go back in along with studying our method of methodologies and analyzing the narrations study. What people are actually believing. wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 19 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 19 (edited) 21 hours ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam some scholars consider these washings to be recommended or they consider those narrations to be borrowed from other school or a pest dissimulation, etc. if something came out for them, it’s different than what comes out for us. It’s like it’s very clear that Lady Fatima peace be upon her does not have a period. and Shane is different than theological beliefs See what Jala Ayyun says see Najhlul Israr And Rijis veterinarian meaning doubt is one thing it’s not the only thing Imam Sadiq as said in the sound chain for instance We the family of the prophet remain in the womb of her mother for six months, not a day less than a day more we emerge from the right side with a full head of hair and a full set of teeth, a light shining brighter than sun, moon and star we fall into prostration recite the two testimonies we are wrapped with a cloth where our lines would have been we sneeze and praise the Lord the angels respond to us and the Lord senses greeting we take milk from the finger of the previous deputy Their station is far above us into accuse them of ritual and purity is quite disturbing And you don’t know the nature of what occurred between him and his wife, some scholars have written and lengthy books, and all he would have to do is look at the women or touch their shoulder and they would become completely satisfied and he did recommended things so even though he does not become impure, he would take a ritual bath with them as a recommended act. I’ve seen a whole lecture series in like 15 lectures on this in Urdu with a discussion with a colleague. But this is not the point you can’t move the goal post or dance around different scholars have different opinion The companions are not infallible immaculate in air free, but the holy prophet, peace and blessing upon him family is the chain from Jabir isn’t the problem and it simply means an interpreted I mean that obviously it’s better to show going back through the infallible to the profit to produce a golden chain, but it’s not a hard role We have a clear narration from imam Sadiq as we are the proof on the people and our mother Fatima is the proof on us Do you find anyone says that every Hadi must go through Fatima peace upon her to be accepted Differences among the various scholars and criteria and narrations is fine. I would go back in along with studying our method of methodologies and analyzing the narrations study. What people are actually believing. wallahu Alam Salam, You say some scholars see these washings as only recommended, or as borrowed from another school, or as taqiyya. Look at who narrates it: Zurara, Muhammad ibn Muslim and Abu Basir together, from al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) (Tahdhib al Ahkam 1/370, no. 1130, https://thaqalayn.com/hadith/41/1/17/23). All three are from the first group of the Ashab al Ijma, about whom al Kashshi says that your scholars agreed on their truthfulness (Ikhtiyar Ma'rifat al Rijal 2/507, quoted here: https://ar.wikishia.net/view/أصحاب_الإجماع). From which other school did these three take it? And al Hurr al Amili put this report in the chapters of janaba and took rulings from it: that husband and wife may make ghusl from one vessel, that the man should start, and how much water is used (Wasa'il al Shia, Abwab al Janaba, bab 32). So your fiqh uses it. Which scholar says it is only recommended or taqiyya, and in which book? And if it was not a ghusl from janaba, why does the Imam say that he started by washing his private parts? You say he only had to look at his wives or touch their shoulder. Please give the report and its chain. A lecture series in Urdu is not a source. You say "rijs is not only doubt". Which Imam says that it also means janaba? Then you bring the report about the birth of the Imams, six months in the womb, born from the right side, sneezing and so on, and say it has a sound chain. In which book is it, and who graded it sound? In al Kafi the chapter on the birth of the Imams has eight reports. Al Majlisi grades them weak, majhul or mursal, the only sahih one is not about the birth at all (Mir'at al Uqul 4/259 to 268,), and al Behbudi did not take any of them in his Sahih al Kafi !!!! And "we are the proof on the people and Fatima (رضي الله عنه) is the proof on us" is not from al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). Your own sites give it from al Askari (رضي الله عنه), and the only source they name is Atyab al Bayan (13/225), a Persian tafsir whose author died in 1990, without any chain. You say a chain through the Imams back to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is the better one, a golden chain, but not a rule. If it is the better way to know that something really comes from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), why is it not the rule? Edited October 19 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 19 Advanced Member Report Posted October 19 27 minutes ago, Maulana said: Salam, You say some scholars see these washings as only recommended, or as borrowed from another school, or as taqiyya. Look at who narrates it: Zurara, Muhammad ibn Muslim and Abu Basir together, from al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) (Tahdhib al Ahkam 1/370, no. 1130, https://thaqalayn.com/hadith/41/1/17/23). All three are from the first group of the Ashab al Ijma, about whom al Kashshi says that your scholars agreed on their truthfulness (Ikhtiyar Ma'rifat al Rijal 2/507, quoted here: https://ar.wikishia.net/view/أصحاب_الإجماع). From which other school did these three take it? And al Hurr al Amili put this report in the chapters of janaba and took rulings from it: that husband and wife may make ghusl from one vessel, that the man should start, and how much water is used (Wasa'il al Shia, Abwab al Janaba, bab 32). So your fiqh uses it. Which scholar says it is only recommended or taqiyya, and in which book? And if it was not a ghusl from janaba, why does the Imam say that he started by washing his private parts? You say he only had to look at his wives or touch their shoulder. Please give the report and its chain. A lecture series in Urdu is not a source. You say "rijs is not only doubt". Which Imam says that it also means janaba? Then you bring the report about the birth of the Imams, six months in the womb, born from the right side, sneezing and so on, and say it has a sound chain. In which book is it, and who graded it sound? In al Kafi the chapter on the birth of the Imams has eight reports. Al Majlisi grades them weak, majhul or mursal, the only sahih one is not about the birth at all (Mir'at al Uqul 4/259 to 268,), and al Behbudi did not take any of them in his Sahih al Kafi !!!! And "we are the proof on the people and Fatima (رضي الله عنه) is the proof on us" is not from al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). Your own sites give it from al Askari (رضي الله عنه), and the only source they name is Atyab al Bayan (13/225), a Persian tafsir whose author died in 1990, without any chain. You say a chain through the Imams back to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is the better one, a golden chain, but not a rule. If it is the better way to know that something really comes from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), why is it not the rule? Salam The narration just indicates he washed where the private area would be And it’s clear to anyone who speaks Arabic that rijis is a general word for something impure so since it’s general, it means both in khabath and Hadath And the three who are mentioned, there are known in reliable narratives, but I don’t interpret those narrations the way you do nor did many of the scholars you keep mentioning Al Majalisi did you look at his book Jala Uyun and what’s recorded in it ? Also, your school is known for having horrible narrators were known liars like Abu Huriah Amr Ibn As muwiyah etc This discussion is going around in circles and has moved away from the central issue Many of the narrators in your two most sacred books such as the father of cats knew the holy prophet, peace and blessings upon I’m only 18 to 35 months yet narrated over 20,000 narrations from him Many of the narrators were extremely weak or questionable people You’re looking at the literal meaning of these notations and not the app applied or commentary narration meaning That is more an ankhabari approach than an Usuli approach which most of us here are Again, there’s nothing in the narrations. It says he took the bath for ritual impurity or he taught how it was done or that’s how he did it. It doesn’t imply that he himself became impure Theological interpretation is different than legal interpretation And it misses the central issue the different scholars have graded different narrations different and had a completely different method of grading and analyzing narrations, and thus come to different conclusions so one says it must go back to the holy prophet, peace, and blessings upon him by name and said it can stop at an infallible. There is no problem there it doesn’t affect the school of thought, and to be honest our school of thought despite these differences is still 1000 times stronger than that of our opponents who will rely on people who disbelieved until the conquest of Makkah and whoever the 14 hypocrites who tried to scare the camel and assassinate the holy profit, peace and lessons be upon him wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 19 Advanced Member Report Posted October 19 Salam thanks for the statement about our mother Fatima peace upon her I see the statement from the 11th guide written in a few books. I’ve also seen it in a few other secondary books from the sixth guide peace upon them all. Again, it goes back to the statements that it’s fine if one offer narrows it from one and one book and another from another if you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names we all say the same thing Also, just to point out it’s interesting you brought up Zurrah Abu Basir Muhammad ibn Muslim who are reliable for horoscope, but not reliable for your school wallahu Alam Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 19 Advanced Member Report Posted October 19 Salam thanks for the statement about our mother Fatima peace upon her I see the statement from the 11th guide written in a few books. I’ve also seen it in a few other secondary books from the sixth guide peace upon them all. Again, it goes back to the statements that it’s fine if one offer narrows it from one and one book and another from another if you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names we all say the same thing Also, just to point out it’s interesting you brought up Zurrah Abu Basir Muhammad ibn Muslim who are reliable for horoscope, but not reliable for your school wallahu Alam Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 20 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 (edited) 20 hours ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam thanks for the statement about our mother Fatima peace upon her I see the statement from the 11th guide written in a few books. I’ve also seen it in a few other secondary books from the sixth guide peace upon them all. Again, it goes back to the statements that it’s fine if one offer narrows it from one and one book and another from another if you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names we all say the same thing Also, just to point out it’s interesting you brought up Zurrah Abu Basir Muhammad ibn Muslim who are reliable for horoscope, but not reliable for your school wallahu Alam 19 hours ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam thanks for the statement about our mother Fatima peace upon her I see the statement from the 11th guide written in a few books. I’ve also seen it in a few other secondary books from the sixth guide peace upon them all. Again, it goes back to the statements that it’s fine if one offer narrows it from one and one book and another from another if you can’t remember which one of us said it take any of our names we all say the same thing Also, just to point out it’s interesting you brought up Zurrah Abu Basir Muhammad ibn Muslim who are reliable for horoscope, but not reliable for your school wallahu Alam Salam, Let me bring the thread back to its question, and this time on the level of method, not single reports. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it (59:7). So the question is not what one scholar or another thinks, but how we know what really reached us from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). For this every school needs men who checked the narrators in their own time or close to it. Your rijal books are al Kashshi, al Najashi (d. 450), al Tusi (d. 460) and Ibn al Ghada'iri. The book of al Kashshi is lost, you only have the selection of al Tusi. About the book of Ibn al Ghada'iri your scholars still argue if it is really his. So the companions of al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) were graded 200 to 300 years after them. Which critic among you graded them in their own time, and where is his book? Then the method. Your sahih, hasan, muwaththaq and da'if came only with Ibn Tawus and al Allama al Hilli in the 7th century. Your own al Hurr al Amili called these new terms and gave 22 reasons against them (Wasa'il al Shia, at the end of the book). So for six centuries there was no fixed method, and until today your Akhbaris and Usulis do not agree if the Four Books need to be checked at all. Which of these two ways did the Imams teach? And you ask about Jala al Uyun. It is a Persian book of al Majlisi about the lives of the Imams, and there he mostly gives the reports without their chains. If there is a report in it you want to use, please bring its original source with the chain, then we can check it like any other report. And when the method is used, al Shahid al Thani counts 9,485 of the 16,121 reports in al Kafi as weak. And when a report is sahih but does not fit the belief, it becomes taqiyya, like the ghusl report of Zurara, Muhammad ibn Muslim and Abu Basir, where the Imam says he cleaned his private part (anqa farjahu), not only the place where it would be. What is the rule to know taqiyya, other than the belief itself? And if rijs includes hadath, as you say, then sleep and the toilet are hadath too. So the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) and the Imams never needed wudu? Now to your rule "take any of our names, we all say the same thing". It rests on two reports in al Kafi. "My hadith is the hadith of my father" has Sahl in the chain, al Majlisi grades it weak according to the majority (Mir'at al Uqul 1/182), and al Khoei, your teacher of teachers, says Sahl is weak for sure (Mu'jam Rijal al Hadith, no.5639). "It is the same" goes through al Qasim al Jawhari from al Bata'ini, and al Majlisi grades it weak (Mir'at al Uqul 1/176). Behbudi did not take either of them in his Sahih al Kafi. So my question stays. Allah ordered us to take from the Messenger (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Which sahih report, by your own grading, gives the rule that a report only has to reach the Imam? Abu Hurayra (رضي الله عنه), Mu'awiya (رضي الله عنه) are not the topic here! This thread is about your rijal system. Open a thread for them if you want, inshallah. Edited October 20 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 20 Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 Salam 59:7 is mainly revealed about the successorship that the people are commanded to take the successorship of Imam Ali as that the profit was going to be commanded to give them at Ghadir Khum If we take it generally to mean his command commands that is not a basis for this argument You’re very scholars have not agreed about various narrators or their authenticity in your earliest books of history on Sirah for example were written by men who are kicked out of Medina for lying There is no authentic book of the science of the narrators or on the science of the narrations from among the so-called companions of the prophet or the holy family or their immediate students that exist, or if it exist has reached us Sulaym Qays book which is disputed it said to be directly from the commander of the faithful peace be upon him The libraries of Egypt and many places were burned during the Umayyad period During the Mongol siege of the dead, the mangoes burned between 400,000 and 4 million books 300 books of Shaikh Saduq we’re lost or destroyed Shaikh Ghazzali on your side they have lost 400 of his books, including a 40 Volume commentary in the Quran You see the companions of the fifth and sixth guide from whom most of the narrations go back to the holy prophet be upon him be upon him we’re not graded too much later But by the same token Sahih Bukhari wasn’t written down till the life time of Imam Hadi as 10 10 generations and over 200 years after the holy prophet Musanad Ahamad wasn’t compiled until the Abbasid era either and has chains but not grades shubah ibn Hajjaj was one of the earliest figures in your school of the author to discuss the science, and he died in in 160 ah The oldest book you have on the matter is Taqabat Al Khabir which was writen 230 years after the migration Khous, that you were bringing the arguments you’re bringing the same problem arises in your own school of thought And you cannot use liars like Omar who is the basis for your narration the best people after the profit were three and he mentions Abu Bakr Umar Uthman to grade their other corrupt contemporary when 14 of these people literally tried to murder the proohet sawa We had differences of opinions among our scholars and we were being murdered by your school of fought for 1200 years really to be honest we’re being murdered all the time until the Iranian revolution and the golf Arab countries in North Africa became afraid of Iran’s military might and power to just randomly murder us anymore So with respect will never know how many books were lost or what early works didn’t reach us But we have scholars who are the masters of the third level and the students who have reached the third level such as myself we have dedicated our lives and who each have come to different conclusions about different narrators, but there is a framework in an every generation it is renewed as for no Hadath I am in the minority opinion, but yes, that is my theological view. I take the narration that something resembling food came out his backside or you could interpret it back and the Earth swallowed it up and it left a fragrance so wonderful it could be smelled for three days meaning they eat the food it absorbs the nutrients and it comes out used up looking like it is that their bodies are completely different that their level is completely different that they are below the Lord, but above a human being, etc. that really doesn’t have much to do with this topic. I only brought it up over the issue of purity. My answer is clear we have a system. We have a basis. It has been evaluated. There are differences, but the same argument I have shown and can be used against your own school of thought in your own books Fatima curses or Omar you rely on Omar for your religion That’s just one example there are many other examples of the companions, not liking each other and denouncing each other They fought wars against each other yet their own opinion about each other can be trusted when that opinion has not reached us in book form till 230 years after the prophet migration ? Wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 20 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 1 hour ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam 59:7 is mainly revealed about the successorship that the people are commanded to take the successorship of Imam Ali as that the profit was going to be commanded to give them at Ghadir Khum If we take it generally to mean his command commands that is not a basis for this argument Salam, You say 59:7 is mainly about the successorship at Ghadir!! Your own Imams use it for the commands of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) in the religion in general! In al Kafi, in the chapter on tafwid to the Messenger of Allah, al Baqir and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) say that Allah gave His Prophet the matter of His creation, to see how they obey, and then recite 59:7 (hadith 3, al Majlisi: sahih Mir'at al Uqul 3/150). In the next report Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says Allah gave him the matter of the religion and the umma, recites 59:7, and gives examples: the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) added rak'at to the prayer, made the sunna prayers and fasts, and forbade every intoxicant (hadith 4, al Majlisi: hasan, Mir'at al Uqul 3/150). Which Imam says, in a sahih report, that it is about Ghadir? And if the verse is general, as your Imams use it, then it is exactly the basis of this thread: we must know what the Messenger (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) gave us, and we only know it by a chain to him. The rest of your points I will answer tomorrow, inshallah. Quote
Advanced Member Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi Posted October 20 Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 On 10/17/2026 at 4:58 AM, Maulana said: Salam alaykum. I want to open a thread about a question I have thought about for a long time, and I want to ask it in a fair way. We agree that the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is binding. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, leave it (59:7). And He says the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) explains to the people what was sent down to them (16:44). So the question is not if we follow the Sunna. The question is how we know that a report really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Our way is easy to explain. A report needs a connected chain up to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and every man in it must be known as truthful and precise. Ibn Sirin (رضي الله عنه) said that when the fitna came, people started to say: name us your men. Ibn al Mubarak (رضي الله عنه) said the isnad is part of the religion, and without it everybody would say what he wants. Both is in the introduction of Sahih Muslim. And the main question is truthfulness. Al Dhahabi (رضي الله عنه) writes about Aban ibn Taghlib, a strong Shia, that he is truthful, so we take his truthfulness and his bid'a is on him. He says if we rejected such narrators, a big part of the Prophetic reports would be lost (Mizan al I'tidal 1/5). Now your side. In your books the chains usually stop at an Imam, mostly al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) or Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). I know your answer: the word of the Imam is like the word of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), because of the report "my hadith is the hadith of my father" (al Kafi, Kitab Fadl al Ilm). But in the same chapter of al Kafi there is a report that Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: when you narrate a hadith, give it back to the one who told it to you. And in Sahih Muslim 1218, Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) narrates from his father al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) that they went to Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) and asked him about the Hajj of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). So the Imams themselves named their source. So my first question: If the word of the Imam is enough without a chain, why does al Kafi itself tell us to name the one we heard a hadith from, and why did al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) name Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source? And how do you know that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam? I will come to your rijal in the next posts, but I would like to hear your answer to this first. salam. True that's a very interesting topic & i believe we can raise alot of questions on Rijal (just for sake of learning how it exactly works). Not an expert here but always trying to learn more. As for the point raised, i fail to understand the objection on Imam Baqir (عليه السلام) narrating from / quoting Jabir (رضي الله عنه) (especially living among majority who take Sahaba as authority to assert his point). Like, as per shia, since when an Infallible (Masoom) imam can't quote someone non-masoom? Like what's the issue with that? If an infallible said something about someone, we take it we accept it. I fail to understand the issue here. On 10/17/2026 at 6:38 PM, Maulana said: Salam brother Abu Hassanain, I hope all went good with your son at the dentist. You say not many people here are qualified to discuss rijal. I agree and this is actually my point. If a normal Shia needs a rijal expert, to know if a report really reached the Imam, then "it only has to reach the Imam" does not solve the problem. You still need a chain up to the Imam and people, who check the men in it. You asked for the chain. The report of Ali (رضي الله عنه) is in al Kafi, vol. 1, Kitab Fadl al Ilm, Bab riwayat al kutub wa al hadith, hadith 7: Ali ibn Ibrahim from his father, and from Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid, from al Nawfali, from al Sakuni, from Abu Abdillah (رضي الله عنه), from Amir al Muminin (ra): when you narrate a hadith, give its chain back to the one who told it to you. To be fair, your scholar al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (Mir'at al Uqul 1/179). But the two reports, which you used, are in the same chapter and they are not better. "My hadith is the hadith of my father" (hadith 14) has Sahl ibn Ziyad in the chain, and al Majlisi grades it da'if 'ala al mashhur (1/182). "It is the same" (hadith 4) is from al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه), not from al Baqir (رضي الله عنه), it goes through Ali ibn Abi Hamza al Bata'ini, and al Majlisi calls it da'if (1/176). Al Behbudi did not take any of these three in his Sahih al Kafi. So the rule, that a report only has to reach the Imam, is your claim, and the reports you use for it are weak by your own scholars. If you have an authentic report for this rule please bring it. Until then the sahih example we have shows an Imam, who named his source: Jafar ibn Muhammad (رضي الله عنه) from his father (رضي الله عنه), who said: we entered upon Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) (Sahih Muslim 1218). You did not explain yet, why al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) did this. And even if the word of the Imam is enough, it still had to reach al Kulayni through normal men. Your own books say, that there were liars among them. In Rijal al Kashshi no. 401 al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says al Mughira ibn Said put hadith into the books of the companions of his father, and al Rida (رضي الله عنه) says the followers of Abu al Khattab were still putting lies into the books of the companions of Abu Abdillah. This question is not only for you. If any brother or sister here knows rijal good, I would like to hear the answer: with which standard do you make sure, that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam, when your own Imams said that liars put reports into the books of their companions? So brother here's the thing, these gradings & manhaj came way later & it's not classical shia methodology. I'm not dismissing or discarding gradings of Majlisi or Khoei here however, I've personally heard from scholars like rarely do ever these things are followed exactly (like khoei's methods). Even Majlisi never discarded weak labled narrations as non-Hujjah. Honestly its been very long & you've right to say without references, i can't really be helpful but what i'd like to point out is the hadiths that you've called weak, have plenty of other narrations (graded authentic) giving the same meaning. So when you stumble upon one hadith, see it's weak, you decided shia use weak hadith. All i can say is brother it's an ocean of soo much more, that we can't fathom simply scholars dedicate their lives & still cannot claim they've learned everything. I'm for sake of example, going to quote some hadiths which are authentic as per shia standards you mentioned (atleast some) that convey same meaning that hadith of infallible is always connected. There's a chapter in Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/32 Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 32 The Imams عليه السلام are the Heirs of Knowledge to Inherit it one from the other Given imam's inherit knowledge from one another, proves they are connected. I'll quote a few hadiths rest can be checked from chapter. 1ـ عِدَّةٌ مِنْ أَصْحَابِنَا عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْحُسَيْنِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ بُرَيْدِ بْنِ مُعَاوِيَةَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ عَنْ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ عَلِيّاً (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) كَانَ عَالِماً وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلَنْ يَهْلِكَ عَالِمٌ إِلا بَقِيَ مِنْ بَعْدِهِ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ عِلْمَهُ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 1. A number of our people has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Husayn ibn Sa‘id from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from Burayd ibn Mu‘awiya from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام who has said the following. “Ali عليه السلام was a man of knowledge and knowledge is inherited. Whenever a man of knowledge dies he leave another man of knowledge behind who possess his knowledge or whatever Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/11) صحيح 2ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ حَمَّادِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنْ حَرِيزٍ عَنْ زُرَارَةَ وَالْفُضَيْلِ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ الَّذِي نَزَلَ مَعَ آدَمَ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) لَمْ يُرْفَعْ وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَكَانَ علي (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) عَالِمَ هَذِهِ الامَّةِ وَإِنَّهُ لَمْ يَهْلِكْ مِنَّا عَالِمٌ قَطُّ إِلا خَلَفَهُ مِنْ أَهْلِهِ مَنْ عَلِمَ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 2. Ali ibn Ibrahim has narrated from his father from Hammad ibn ’Isa from Hariz from Zurarah and al-Fudayl from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “The knowledge that came with Adam was not taken away. Knowledge is inherited. Ali عليه السلام was the knowledgeable person of this nation (Muslims). No one from us have ever left this world without leaving behind one like him in knowledge or what Allah wanted.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/12) حسن 3ـ مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْبَرْقِيِّ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْحَمِيدِ الطَّائِيِّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ قَالَ قَالَ أَبُو جَعْفَرٍ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلا يَمُوتُ عَالِمٌ إِلا وَتَرَكَ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 3. Muhammad ibn Yahya has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Barqi from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from ‘Abd al-Hamid al-Ta’i from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Knowledge is inherited. No man of knowledge dies without leaving behind one who is as knowledgeable as his predecessor or what Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (12/3) صحيح Then we see another chapter in Al-Kafi here: Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 33 The Imams عليه السلام inherited the knowledge of the Holy prophet صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم and all the prophets and their successors before them If Imams (عليه السلام) inherited all knowledge one after another from Ambiyaa (عليه السلام), then does that prove they are connected? Does quoting one hadith, saying it has a weak chain so can't be accepted. Does it seem fair? Let's see if this chapter has any authentic graded hadith 1ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْعَزِيزِ بْنِ الْمُهْتَدِي عَنْ عَبْدِ الله بْنِ جُنْدَبٍ أَنَّهُ كَتَبَ إِلَيْهِ الرِّضَا (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) أَمَّا بَعْدُ فَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كَانَ أَمِينَ الله فِي خَلْقِهِ فَلَمَّا قُبِضَ (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كُنَّا أَهْلَ الْبَيْتِ وَرَثَتَهُ فَنَحْنُ أُمَنَاءُ الله فِي أَرْضِهِ عِنْدَنَا عِلْمُ الْبَلايَا وَالْمَنَايَا وَأَنْسَابُ الْعَرَبِ وَمَوْلِدُ الاسْلامِ وَإِنَّا لَنَعْرِفُ الرَّجُلَ إِذَا رَأَيْنَاهُ بِحَقِيقَةِ الايمَانِ وَحَقِيقَةِ النِّفَاقِ وَإِنَّ شِيعَتَنَا لَمَكْتُوبُونَ بِأَسْمَائِهِمْ وَأَسْمَاءِ آبَائِهِمْ أَخَذَ الله عَلَيْنَا وَعَلَيْهِمُ الْمِيثَاقَ يَرِدُونَ مَوْرِدَنَا وَيَدْخُلُونَ مَدْخَلَنَا لَيْسَ عَلَى مِلَّةِ الاسْلامِ غَيْرُنَا وَغَيْرُهُمْ نَحْنُ النُّجَبَاءُ النُّجَاةُ وَنَحْنُ أَفْرَاطُ الانْبِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ أَبْنَاءُ الاوْصِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ الْمَخْصُوصُونَ فِي كِتَابِ الله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِكِتَابِ الله وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِرَسُولِ الله (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَنَحْنُ الَّذِينَ شَرَعَ الله لَنَا دِينَهُ فَقَالَ فِي كِتَابِهِ شَرَعَ لَكُمْ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ مِنَ الدِّينِ ما وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً قَدْ وَصَّانَا بِمَا وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً وَالَّذِي أَوْحَيْنا إِلَيْكَ يَا مُحَمَّدُ وَما وَصَّيْنا بِهِ إِبْراهِيمَ وَمُوسى وَعِيسى فَقَدْ عَلَّمَنَا وَبَلَّغَنَا عِلْمَ مَا عَلِمْنَا وَاسْتَوْدَعَنَا عِلْمَهُمْ نَحْنُ وَرَثَةُ أُولِي الْعَزْمِ مِنَ الرُّسُلِ أَنْ أَقِيمُوا الدِّينَ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ وَلا تَتَفَرَّقُوا فِيهِ وَكُونُوا عَلَى جَمَاعَةٍ كَبُرَ عَلَى الْمُشْرِكِينَ مَنْ أَشْرَكَ بِوَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ ما تَدْعُوهُمْ إِلَيْهِ مِنْ وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ إِنَّ الله يَا مُحَمَّدُ يَهْدِي إِلَيْهِ مَنْ يُنِيبُ مَنْ يُجِيبُكَ إِلَى وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) 1. Ali ibn Ibrahim, from his father, from Abdul Aziz ibn al-Muhtadi, from Abdullah ibn Jundab, that Imam al-Ridha عليه السلام wrote to him: "As for what follows: Verily, Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم was God’s trustee among His creation. When he passed away, we, the Ahl al-Bayt, inherited him, and thus we are the trustees of God on His earth. With us is the knowledge of calamities and deaths, the genealogies of the Arabs, and the origin of Islam. We recognize a person, upon seeing him, by the true essence of faith and the true essence of hypocrisy. Our followers (Shi'a) are recorded by their names and the names of their fathers. God has taken a covenant from us and from them, they shall return to our source and enter where we enter. None are truly upon the religion of Islam except us and them. We are the chosen ones, the saved, the vanguard of the prophets, the sons of their successors. We are the ones specifically mentioned in the Book of God, the Almighty and Exalted. We are the most worthy of the Book of God and the most worthy of the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. God has legislated His religion for us, as He said in His Book: 'He has ordained for you, O family of Muhammad, of the religion what He enjoined upon Noah.' He enjoined upon us what He enjoined upon Noah, and what He revealed to you, O Muhammad, and what He enjoined upon Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. He has taught us and conveyed to us what He taught them, and entrusted us with their knowledge. We are the heirs of the messengers of firm resolve (ulu al-‘azm). 'Establish the religion, O Family of Muhammad, and do not be divided therein. Be united.' It has become heavy upon the polytheists—those who associate others in the guardianship (wilayah) of Ali—what you call them to, of Ali’s wilayah عليه السلام. Indeed, God, O Muhammad, guides to it whomever turns to Him, and whoever responds to you regarding the wilayah of Ali عليه السلام." Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/14) حسن 4ـ أَحْمَدُ بْنُ إِدْرِيسَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ صَفْوَانَ بْنِ يَحْيَى عَنْ شُعَيْبٍ الْحَدَّادِ عَنْ ضُرَيْسٍ الْكُنَاسِيِّ قَالَ كُنْتُ عِنْدَ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) وَعِنْدَهُ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ فَقَالَ أَبُو عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ دَاوُدَ وَرِثَ عِلْمَ الانْبِيَاءِ وَإِنَّ سُلَيْمَانَ وَرِثَ دَاوُدَ وَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَرِثَ سُلَيْمَانَ وَإِنَّا وَرِثْنَا مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَإِنَّ عِنْدَنَا صُحُفَ إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَأَلْوَاحَ مُوسَى فَقَالَ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ إِنَّ هَذَا لَهُوَ الْعِلْمُ فَقَالَ يَا أَبَا مُحَمَّدٍ لَيْسَ هَذَا هُوَ الْعِلْمَ إِنَّمَا الْعِلْمُ مَا يَحْدُثُ بِاللَّيْلِ وَالنَّهَارِ يَوْماً بِيَوْمٍ وَسَاعَةً بِسَاعَةٍ. 4. Ahmad ibn Idris has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabbar from Safwan ibn Yahya from Shu‘ayb al-Haddad from Durays al-Kunasi who has said the following. “I was in the presence of abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام and abu Basir also was there. The Imams عليه السلام said, “David inherited the knowledge of the prophets. Solomon inherited David. Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم inherited Solomon and we inherited Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. With us are the pages of Abraham and the tablets of Moses.” Abu Basir then said, “This is the knowledge.” The Imams عليه السلام said, “O abu Muhammad, this is not the knowledge. The knowledge is what happens in the nights and in the days, day after day and hour after hour.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (20/3) صحيح على الظاهر The in another chapter from Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/44 4ـ أَبُو عَلِيٍّ الاشْعَرِيُّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ إِسْمَاعِيلَ عَنْ عَلِيِّ بْنِ النُّعْمَانِ عَنْ سُوَيْدٍ الْقَلاءِ عَنْ أَبِي أَيُّوبَ عَنْ أَبِي بَصِيرٍ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ لله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ عِلْمَيْنِ عِلْمٌ لا يَعْلَمُهُ إِلا هُوَ وَعِلْمٌ عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ فَمَا عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) فَنَحْنُ نَعْلَمُهُ. 4. Abu Ali al-Ash‘ari has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabber from Muhammad ibn Isma‘il from Ali ibn al-Nu‘man from Suwayd al-Qalla from abu Ayyub from abu Basir from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Allah, the Most Holy, the Most High, has two kinds of knowledge. One kind of knowledge is that which no one knows except He. The other kind is that which He has taught to the His angels and His messengers. Whatever His angels and Messengers have learned we know it.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/109) صحيح Shaykh Baqir al-Behbudi Ṣaḥīḥ al-Kāfī, vol. 1, p. 30 صحيح So I'd suggest, instead of weakning hadiths, focus on Science of hadith. Let's not assume our belief has no basis as per our own standards from our own books. that narrative won't move much further & will also change the topic. ServantOfMahdi and Ashvazdanghe 2 Quote
Advanced Member Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi Posted October 20 Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 On 10/17/2026 at 6:38 PM, Maulana said: And even if the word of the Imam is enough, it still had to reach al Kulayni through normal men. Your own books say, that there were liars among them. In Rijal al Kashshi no. 401 al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) says al Mughira ibn Said put hadith into the books of the companions of his father, and al Rida (رضي الله عنه) says the followers of Abu al Khattab were still putting lies into the books of the companions of Abu Abdillah. I think this narration clearly shows shias didn't blindly compile hadiths am I right? They were cross checking & liars/fabricators got caught messing with books. So what's the point? If they were careless, such narration wouldn't exist in first place. Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 20 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 (edited) 3 hours ago, Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi said: salam. True that's a very interesting topic & i believe we can raise alot of questions on Rijal (just for sake of learning how it exactly works). Not an expert here but always trying to learn more. As for the point raised, i fail to understand the objection on Imam Baqir (عليه السلام) narrating from / quoting Jabir (رضي الله عنه) (especially living among majority who take Sahaba as authority to assert his point). Like, as per shia, since when an Infallible (Masoom) imam can't quote someone non-masoom? Like what's the issue with that? If an infallible said something about someone, we take it we accept it. I fail to understand the issue here. So brother here's the thing, these gradings & manhaj came way later & it's not classical shia methodology. I'm not dismissing or discarding gradings of Majlisi or Khoei here however, I've personally heard from scholars like rarely do ever these things are followed exactly (like khoei's methods). Even Majlisi never discarded weak labled narrations as non-Hujjah. Honestly its been very long & you've right to say without references, i can't really be helpful but what i'd like to point out is the hadiths that you've called weak, have plenty of other narrations (graded authentic) giving the same meaning. So when you stumble upon one hadith, see it's weak, you decided shia use weak hadith. All i can say is brother it's an ocean of soo much more, that we can't fathom simply scholars dedicate their lives & still cannot claim they've learned everything. I'm for sake of example, going to quote some hadiths which are authentic as per shia standards you mentioned (atleast some) that convey same meaning that hadith of infallible is always connected. There's a chapter in Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/32 Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 32 The Imams عليه السلام are the Heirs of Knowledge to Inherit it one from the other Given imam's inherit knowledge from one another, proves they are connected. I'll quote a few hadiths rest can be checked from chapter. 1ـ عِدَّةٌ مِنْ أَصْحَابِنَا عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْحُسَيْنِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ بُرَيْدِ بْنِ مُعَاوِيَةَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ عَنْ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ عَلِيّاً (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) كَانَ عَالِماً وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلَنْ يَهْلِكَ عَالِمٌ إِلا بَقِيَ مِنْ بَعْدِهِ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ عِلْمَهُ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 1. A number of our people has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Husayn ibn Sa‘id from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from Burayd ibn Mu‘awiya from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام who has said the following. “Ali عليه السلام was a man of knowledge and knowledge is inherited. Whenever a man of knowledge dies he leave another man of knowledge behind who possess his knowledge or whatever Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/11) صحيح 2ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ حَمَّادِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنْ حَرِيزٍ عَنْ زُرَارَةَ وَالْفُضَيْلِ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ الَّذِي نَزَلَ مَعَ آدَمَ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) لَمْ يُرْفَعْ وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَكَانَ علي (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) عَالِمَ هَذِهِ الامَّةِ وَإِنَّهُ لَمْ يَهْلِكْ مِنَّا عَالِمٌ قَطُّ إِلا خَلَفَهُ مِنْ أَهْلِهِ مَنْ عَلِمَ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 2. Ali ibn Ibrahim has narrated from his father from Hammad ibn ’Isa from Hariz from Zurarah and al-Fudayl from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “The knowledge that came with Adam was not taken away. Knowledge is inherited. Ali عليه السلام was the knowledgeable person of this nation (Muslims). No one from us have ever left this world without leaving behind one like him in knowledge or what Allah wanted.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/12) حسن 3ـ مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْبَرْقِيِّ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْحَمِيدِ الطَّائِيِّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ قَالَ قَالَ أَبُو جَعْفَرٍ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلا يَمُوتُ عَالِمٌ إِلا وَتَرَكَ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 3. Muhammad ibn Yahya has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Barqi from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from ‘Abd al-Hamid al-Ta’i from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Knowledge is inherited. No man of knowledge dies without leaving behind one who is as knowledgeable as his predecessor or what Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (12/3) صحيح Then we see another chapter in Al-Kafi here: Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 33 The Imams عليه السلام inherited the knowledge of the Holy prophet صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم and all the prophets and their successors before them If Imams (عليه السلام) inherited all knowledge one after another from Ambiyaa (عليه السلام), then does that prove they are connected? Does quoting one hadith, saying it has a weak chain so can't be accepted. Does it seem fair? Let's see if this chapter has any authentic graded hadith 1ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْعَزِيزِ بْنِ الْمُهْتَدِي عَنْ عَبْدِ الله بْنِ جُنْدَبٍ أَنَّهُ كَتَبَ إِلَيْهِ الرِّضَا (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) أَمَّا بَعْدُ فَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كَانَ أَمِينَ الله فِي خَلْقِهِ فَلَمَّا قُبِضَ (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كُنَّا أَهْلَ الْبَيْتِ وَرَثَتَهُ فَنَحْنُ أُمَنَاءُ الله فِي أَرْضِهِ عِنْدَنَا عِلْمُ الْبَلايَا وَالْمَنَايَا وَأَنْسَابُ الْعَرَبِ وَمَوْلِدُ الاسْلامِ وَإِنَّا لَنَعْرِفُ الرَّجُلَ إِذَا رَأَيْنَاهُ بِحَقِيقَةِ الايمَانِ وَحَقِيقَةِ النِّفَاقِ وَإِنَّ شِيعَتَنَا لَمَكْتُوبُونَ بِأَسْمَائِهِمْ وَأَسْمَاءِ آبَائِهِمْ أَخَذَ الله عَلَيْنَا وَعَلَيْهِمُ الْمِيثَاقَ يَرِدُونَ مَوْرِدَنَا وَيَدْخُلُونَ مَدْخَلَنَا لَيْسَ عَلَى مِلَّةِ الاسْلامِ غَيْرُنَا وَغَيْرُهُمْ نَحْنُ النُّجَبَاءُ النُّجَاةُ وَنَحْنُ أَفْرَاطُ الانْبِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ أَبْنَاءُ الاوْصِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ الْمَخْصُوصُونَ فِي كِتَابِ الله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِكِتَابِ الله وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِرَسُولِ الله (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَنَحْنُ الَّذِينَ شَرَعَ الله لَنَا دِينَهُ فَقَالَ فِي كِتَابِهِ شَرَعَ لَكُمْ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ مِنَ الدِّينِ ما وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً قَدْ وَصَّانَا بِمَا وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً وَالَّذِي أَوْحَيْنا إِلَيْكَ يَا مُحَمَّدُ وَما وَصَّيْنا بِهِ إِبْراهِيمَ وَمُوسى وَعِيسى فَقَدْ عَلَّمَنَا وَبَلَّغَنَا عِلْمَ مَا عَلِمْنَا وَاسْتَوْدَعَنَا عِلْمَهُمْ نَحْنُ وَرَثَةُ أُولِي الْعَزْمِ مِنَ الرُّسُلِ أَنْ أَقِيمُوا الدِّينَ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ وَلا تَتَفَرَّقُوا فِيهِ وَكُونُوا عَلَى جَمَاعَةٍ كَبُرَ عَلَى الْمُشْرِكِينَ مَنْ أَشْرَكَ بِوَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ ما تَدْعُوهُمْ إِلَيْهِ مِنْ وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ إِنَّ الله يَا مُحَمَّدُ يَهْدِي إِلَيْهِ مَنْ يُنِيبُ مَنْ يُجِيبُكَ إِلَى وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) 1. Ali ibn Ibrahim, from his father, from Abdul Aziz ibn al-Muhtadi, from Abdullah ibn Jundab, that Imam al-Ridha عليه السلام wrote to him: "As for what follows: Verily, Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم was God’s trustee among His creation. When he passed away, we, the Ahl al-Bayt, inherited him, and thus we are the trustees of God on His earth. With us is the knowledge of calamities and deaths, the genealogies of the Arabs, and the origin of Islam. We recognize a person, upon seeing him, by the true essence of faith and the true essence of hypocrisy. Our followers (Shi'a) are recorded by their names and the names of their fathers. God has taken a covenant from us and from them, they shall return to our source and enter where we enter. None are truly upon the religion of Islam except us and them. We are the chosen ones, the saved, the vanguard of the prophets, the sons of their successors. We are the ones specifically mentioned in the Book of God, the Almighty and Exalted. We are the most worthy of the Book of God and the most worthy of the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. God has legislated His religion for us, as He said in His Book: 'He has ordained for you, O family of Muhammad, of the religion what He enjoined upon Noah.' He enjoined upon us what He enjoined upon Noah, and what He revealed to you, O Muhammad, and what He enjoined upon Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. He has taught us and conveyed to us what He taught them, and entrusted us with their knowledge. We are the heirs of the messengers of firm resolve (ulu al-‘azm). 'Establish the religion, O Family of Muhammad, and do not be divided therein. Be united.' It has become heavy upon the polytheists—those who associate others in the guardianship (wilayah) of Ali—what you call them to, of Ali’s wilayah عليه السلام. Indeed, God, O Muhammad, guides to it whomever turns to Him, and whoever responds to you regarding the wilayah of Ali عليه السلام." Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/14) حسن 4ـ أَحْمَدُ بْنُ إِدْرِيسَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ صَفْوَانَ بْنِ يَحْيَى عَنْ شُعَيْبٍ الْحَدَّادِ عَنْ ضُرَيْسٍ الْكُنَاسِيِّ قَالَ كُنْتُ عِنْدَ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) وَعِنْدَهُ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ فَقَالَ أَبُو عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ دَاوُدَ وَرِثَ عِلْمَ الانْبِيَاءِ وَإِنَّ سُلَيْمَانَ وَرِثَ دَاوُدَ وَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَرِثَ سُلَيْمَانَ وَإِنَّا وَرِثْنَا مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَإِنَّ عِنْدَنَا صُحُفَ إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَأَلْوَاحَ مُوسَى فَقَالَ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ إِنَّ هَذَا لَهُوَ الْعِلْمُ فَقَالَ يَا أَبَا مُحَمَّدٍ لَيْسَ هَذَا هُوَ الْعِلْمَ إِنَّمَا الْعِلْمُ مَا يَحْدُثُ بِاللَّيْلِ وَالنَّهَارِ يَوْماً بِيَوْمٍ وَسَاعَةً بِسَاعَةٍ. 4. Ahmad ibn Idris has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabbar from Safwan ibn Yahya from Shu‘ayb al-Haddad from Durays al-Kunasi who has said the following. “I was in the presence of abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام and abu Basir also was there. The Imams عليه السلام said, “David inherited the knowledge of the prophets. Solomon inherited David. Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم inherited Solomon and we inherited Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. With us are the pages of Abraham and the tablets of Moses.” Abu Basir then said, “This is the knowledge.” The Imams عليه السلام said, “O abu Muhammad, this is not the knowledge. The knowledge is what happens in the nights and in the days, day after day and hour after hour.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (20/3) صحيح على الظاهر The in another chapter from Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/44 4ـ أَبُو عَلِيٍّ الاشْعَرِيُّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ إِسْمَاعِيلَ عَنْ عَلِيِّ بْنِ النُّعْمَانِ عَنْ سُوَيْدٍ الْقَلاءِ عَنْ أَبِي أَيُّوبَ عَنْ أَبِي بَصِيرٍ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ لله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ عِلْمَيْنِ عِلْمٌ لا يَعْلَمُهُ إِلا هُوَ وَعِلْمٌ عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ فَمَا عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) فَنَحْنُ نَعْلَمُهُ. 4. Abu Ali al-Ash‘ari has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabber from Muhammad ibn Isma‘il from Ali ibn al-Nu‘man from Suwayd al-Qalla from abu Ayyub from abu Basir from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Allah, the Most Holy, the Most High, has two kinds of knowledge. One kind of knowledge is that which no one knows except He. The other kind is that which He has taught to the His angels and His messengers. Whatever His angels and Messengers have learned we know it.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/109) صحيح Shaykh Baqir al-Behbudi Ṣaḥīḥ al-Kāfī, vol. 1, p. 30 صحيح So I'd suggest, instead of weakning hadiths, focus on Science of hadith. Let's not assume our belief has no basis as per our own standards from our own books. that narrative won't move much further & will also change the topic. 3 hours ago, Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi said: I think this narration clearly shows shias didn't blindly compile hadiths am I right? They were cross checking & liars/fabricators got caught messing with books. So what's the point? If they were careless, such narration wouldn't exist in first place. Salam, I have read your two posts. Good that you bring your sources and the gradings, that is how this topic should be discussed. Right now I am preparing my second answer to Abu Hassanain on his open points, as I told him. After I finish it, I will answer your posts one by one, inshallah. To all who follow the thread: Please be patient with me. I check every report in the original, with its chain and the gradings of your scholars, and that takes time. Some points come up again and again, there I can answer faster. New points need more time, because I want to answer them properly. Edited October 20 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 20 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 20 (edited) 7 hours ago, Abu Hassanain said: Salam You’re very scholars have not agreed about various narrators or their authenticity in your earliest books of history on Sirah for example were written by men who are kicked out of Medina for lying There is no authentic book of the science of the narrators or on the science of the narrations from among the so-called companions of the prophet or the holy family or their immediate students that exist, or if it exist has reached us Sulaym Qays book which is disputed it said to be directly from the commander of the faithful peace be upon him The libraries of Egypt and many places were burned during the Umayyad period During the Mongol siege of the dead, the mangoes burned between 400,000 and 4 million books 300 books of Shaikh Saduq we’re lost or destroyed Shaikh Ghazzali on your side they have lost 400 of his books, including a 40 Volume commentary in the Quran You see the companions of the fifth and sixth guide from whom most of the narrations go back to the holy prophet be upon him be upon him we’re not graded too much later But by the same token Sahih Bukhari wasn’t written down till the life time of Imam Hadi as 10 10 generations and over 200 years after the holy prophet Musanad Ahamad wasn’t compiled until the Abbasid era either and has chains but not grades shubah ibn Hajjaj was one of the earliest figures in your school of the author to discuss the science, and he died in in 160 ah The oldest book you have on the matter is Taqabat Al Khabir which was writen 230 years after the migration Khous, that you were bringing the arguments you’re bringing the same problem arises in your own school of thought And you cannot use liars like Omar who is the basis for your narration the best people after the profit were three and he mentions Abu Bakr Umar Uthman to grade their other corrupt contemporary when 14 of these people literally tried to murder the proohet sawa We had differences of opinions among our scholars and we were being murdered by your school of fought for 1200 years really to be honest we’re being murdered all the time until the Iranian revolution and the golf Arab countries in North Africa became afraid of Iran’s military might and power to just randomly murder us anymore So with respect will never know how many books were lost or what early works didn’t reach us But we have scholars who are the masters of the third level and the students who have reached the third level such as myself we have dedicated our lives and who each have come to different conclusions about different narrators, but there is a framework in an every generation it is renewed as for no Hadath I am in the minority opinion, but yes, that is my theological view. I take the narration that something resembling food came out his backside or you could interpret it back and the Earth swallowed it up and it left a fragrance so wonderful it could be smelled for three days meaning they eat the food it absorbs the nutrients and it comes out used up looking like it is that their bodies are completely different that their level is completely different that they are below the Lord, but above a human being, etc. that really doesn’t have much to do with this topic. I only brought it up over the issue of purity. My answer is clear we have a system. We have a basis. It has been evaluated. There are differences, but the same argument I have shown and can be used against your own school of thought in your own books Fatima curses or Omar you rely on Omar for your religion That’s just one example there are many other examples of the companions, not liking each other and denouncing each other They fought wars against each other yet their own opinion about each other can be trusted when that opinion has not reached us in book form till 230 years after the prophet migration ? Wallahu Alam Salam, Now to the rest of your points. You say that most of the narrations of the companions of al Baqir and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) go back to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). In al Kafi it is the other way. Of its 16,199 reports only about 2,400 even tell us something the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) said or did, and of these al Majlisi grades less than 300 as sahih, and most of them stop at the Imam. So less than two percent of your main book is a sahih report about the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). How does a Muslim follow 59:7 with this??? You say Bukhari was written more than 200 years after the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). But as you know, the hadith were written already in his time. Abdullah ibn Amr (رضي الله عنه) wrote down what he heard, and the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) told him to keep writing, because nothing comes out of his mouth except the truth (Abu Dawud 3646). The sahifa of Hamam ibn Munabbih from Abu Hurayra (رضي الله عنه) is from the first century and is still with us!! Umar ibn Abd al Aziz (d. 101) ordered the hadith to be written down and said: accept nothing except the hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) (Bukhari, Kitab al Ilm). And al Bukhari (d. 256) died more than 70 years before al Kulayni (d. 329). You say yourself that Shu'ba died in 160. Al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) died in 148. But the checking of narrators did not start with Shu'ba, it started with the companions. Umar (رضي الله عنه) asked Abu Musa (رضي الله عنه) for a witness before he accepted his hadith. Ali (رضي الله عنه) made the companion who narrated to him swear, and only then he believed him (Abu Dawud 1521). Ibn Abbas (رضي الله عنه) said that when people began to narrate the good and the bad, they stopped taking hadith from them (Muqaddima of Sahih Muslim). Then Ibn Sirin (d. 110) said: when the fitna came, people said, name us your men. After them came al Zuhri, Shu'ba, Malik, Ibn al Mubarak, Yahya al Qattan, Ibn Mahdi, Ibn Ma'in, Ibn al Madini and Ahmad (رضي الله عنه), all before al Bukhari. Ibn Hibban says Shu'ba was the first in Iraq who examined the narrators and kept away from the weak ones. And you say our oldest book on the narrators is from 230. Your al Najashi died in 450, 300 years after al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه), and the book of al Kashshi did not even reach you. You did not name one critic of your side from the time of the Imams whose words reached you. That was my question. You say we will never know how many books were lost, and that your Imams and scholars were persecuted. Persecution can explain why a book is lost, but it can not give a chain to a report that has none. A religion can not be built on books that nobody has. About Umar (ra): the order Abu Bakr, then Umar, is not only from him. Ali (رضي الله عنه) himself said it to his son Muhammad ibn al Hanafiyya (Bukhari 3671). Fatima (رضي الله عنه), the companions and their wars are another topic for another thread, inshallah. That I do not answer it here does not mean I accept it. Edited October 20 by Maulana Quote
Advanced Member Abu Hassanain Posted October 21 Advanced Member Report Posted October 21 27 minutes ago, Maulana said: Salam, Now to the rest of your points. You say that most of the narrations of the companions of al Baqir and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) go back to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). In al Kafi it is the other way. Of its 16,199 reports only about 2,400 even tell us something the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) said or did, and of these al Majlisi grades less than 300 as sahih, and most of them stop at the Imam. So less than two percent of your main book is a sahih report about the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). How does a Muslim follow 59:7 with this??? You say Bukhari was written more than 200 years after the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). But as you know, the hadith were written already in his time. Abdullah ibn Amr (رضي الله عنه) wrote down what he heard, and the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) told him to keep writing, because nothing comes out of his mouth except the truth (Abu Dawud 3646). The sahifa of Hamam ibn Munabbih from Abu Hurayra (رضي الله عنه) is from the first century and is still with us!! Umar ibn Abd al Aziz (d. 101) ordered the hadith to be written down and said: accept nothing except the hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) (Bukhari, Kitab al Ilm). And al Bukhari (d. 256) died more than 70 years before al Kulayni (d. 329). You say yourself that Shu'ba died in 160. Al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) died in 148. But the checking of narrators did not start with Shu'ba, it started with the companions. Umar (رضي الله عنه) asked Abu Musa (رضي الله عنه) for a witness before he accepted his hadith. Ali (رضي الله عنه) made the companion who narrated to him swear, and only then he believed him (Abu Dawud 1521). Ibn Abbas (رضي الله عنه) said that when people began to narrate the good and the bad, they stopped taking hadith from them (Muqaddima of Sahih Muslim). Then Ibn Sirin (d. 110) said: when the fitna came, people said, name us your men. After them came al Zuhri, Shu'ba, Malik, Ibn al Mubarak, Yahya al Qattan, Ibn Mahdi, Ibn Ma'in, Ibn al Madini and Ahmad (رضي الله عنه), all before al Bukhari. Ibn Hibban says Shu'ba was the first in Iraq who examined the narrators and kept away from the weak ones. And you say our oldest book on the narrators is from 230. Your al Najashi died in 450, 300 years after al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه), and the book of al Kashshi did not even reach you. You did not name one critic of your side from the time of the Imams whose words reached you. That was my question. You say we will never know how many books were lost, and that your Imams and scholars were persecuted. Persecution can explain why a book is lost, but it can not give a chain to a report that has none. A religion can not be built on books that nobody has. About Umar (ra): the order Abu Bakr, then Umar, is not only from him. Ali (رضي الله عنه) himself said it to his son Muhammad ibn al Hanafiyya (Bukhari 3671). Fatima (رضي الله عنه), the companions and their wars are another topic for another thread, inshallah. That I do not answer it here does not mean I accept it. Salalam see the third sermon of the peak of eloquence that is opinion of the commander of the faithful about the three There were no written narrations and no proof of chains until the time of Umar ibn Abdul Aziz because the son of Khattab prevented people from writing the narrations, so unreliable people were narrating, and none of these reached in trust time could be trusted, unless they were narrated from an infallible How are ever even the four books in the secondary books must be reviewed by every scholar who reaches the third level and the great scholars who finish it and the grand scholars who have reached the highest level And many of the general statements of the scholars about 57 seven or four, our opponents will the true deeper meaning is hidden because they would’ve been murdered if they said what the verses actually meant For example, your own Shaikh Ahmad mentioned there are 300 verses revealed about Imam Ali as he did not mention those verses or give reference due to fear Many commentators mentioned it is actually 1000 verses revealed about him and 300 verses revealed about Fatimah as and Imam Hussayn as In the greetings of our mentor and teacher Sayyid Khoy on Kafi differ from other scholars as each scholar is reviewing the narrations, and according to his own method and knowledge Shaikh Hurr Amali had a different view of grading a as Al Malajisi although he graded narrations, then would tell people to act on the narrations he can piled in his books and when narrations conflicted to take the stronger of the narrations So again, I don’t see that you’re having your victory lap here. I think we’re looking at the information according to a completely different way in methodology. I think you’re kind of cherry picking this or have to form an opinion that our religion hasn’t reached us from reliable chains, and therefore we should become followers of the companions. If this is a wrong accusation, then forgive me, but this is the appearance I see And just so you know, I don’t disregard or have a very liberal method of analyzing the chain. I am currently teaching. Al Faqih of Saduq narration narration And the four volumes of prayer excruciatingly, long small chapter by chapter of Wasail Shia Where analyze the shorten chains that are found For theology right now I’m teaching Al khisal and analyzing the complete chain for each narration and when I thought Usul Kafi and Furu Kafi I analyze the complete chain give the opinion of various scholars of the narrator than my own opinion Same thing when I teach Islamic law with books like Tahrir wasail minhaj Shari nihayah eyc I generally quote the relevant narratives with grading and sometimes chain sometimes not wallahu Alam Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 21 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 21 15 hours ago, Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi said: salam. True that's a very interesting topic & i believe we can raise alot of questions on Rijal (just for sake of learning how it exactly works). Not an expert here but always trying to learn more. As for the point raised, i fail to understand the objection on Imam Baqir (عليه السلام) narrating from / quoting Jabir (رضي الله عنه) (especially living among majority who take Sahaba as authority to assert his point). Like, as per shia, since when an Infallible (Masoom) imam can't quote someone non-masoom? Like what's the issue with that? If an infallible said something about someone, we take it we accept it. I fail to understand the issue here. So brother here's the thing, these gradings & manhaj came way later & it's not classical shia methodology. I'm not dismissing or discarding gradings of Majlisi or Khoei here however, I've personally heard from scholars like rarely do ever these things are followed exactly (like khoei's methods). Even Majlisi never discarded weak labled narrations as non-Hujjah. Honestly its been very long & you've right to say without references, i can't really be helpful but what i'd like to point out is the hadiths that you've called weak, have plenty of other narrations (graded authentic) giving the same meaning. So when you stumble upon one hadith, see it's weak, you decided shia use weak hadith. All i can say is brother it's an ocean of soo much more, that we can't fathom simply scholars dedicate their lives & still cannot claim they've learned everything. I'm for sake of example, going to quote some hadiths which are authentic as per shia standards you mentioned (atleast some) that convey same meaning that hadith of infallible is always connected. There's a chapter in Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/32 Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 32 The Imams عليه السلام are the Heirs of Knowledge to Inherit it one from the other Given imam's inherit knowledge from one another, proves they are connected. I'll quote a few hadiths rest can be checked from chapter. 1ـ عِدَّةٌ مِنْ أَصْحَابِنَا عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْحُسَيْنِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ بُرَيْدِ بْنِ مُعَاوِيَةَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ عَنْ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ عَلِيّاً (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) كَانَ عَالِماً وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلَنْ يَهْلِكَ عَالِمٌ إِلا بَقِيَ مِنْ بَعْدِهِ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ عِلْمَهُ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 1. A number of our people has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Husayn ibn Sa‘id from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from Burayd ibn Mu‘awiya from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام who has said the following. “Ali عليه السلام was a man of knowledge and knowledge is inherited. Whenever a man of knowledge dies he leave another man of knowledge behind who possess his knowledge or whatever Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/11) صحيح 2ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ حَمَّادِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنْ حَرِيزٍ عَنْ زُرَارَةَ وَالْفُضَيْلِ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ الَّذِي نَزَلَ مَعَ آدَمَ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) لَمْ يُرْفَعْ وَالْعِلْمُ يُتَوَارَثُ وَكَانَ علي (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) عَالِمَ هَذِهِ الامَّةِ وَإِنَّهُ لَمْ يَهْلِكْ مِنَّا عَالِمٌ قَطُّ إِلا خَلَفَهُ مِنْ أَهْلِهِ مَنْ عَلِمَ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 2. Ali ibn Ibrahim has narrated from his father from Hammad ibn ’Isa from Hariz from Zurarah and al-Fudayl from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “The knowledge that came with Adam was not taken away. Knowledge is inherited. Ali عليه السلام was the knowledgeable person of this nation (Muslims). No one from us have ever left this world without leaving behind one like him in knowledge or what Allah wanted.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/12) حسن 3ـ مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى عَنْ أَحْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَمَّدٍ عَنِ الْبَرْقِيِّ عَنِ النَّضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ يَحْيَى الْحَلَبِيِّ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْحَمِيدِ الطَّائِيِّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ مُسْلِمٍ قَالَ قَالَ أَبُو جَعْفَرٍ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ الْعِلْمَ يُتَوَارَثُ وَلا يَمُوتُ عَالِمٌ إِلا وَتَرَكَ مَنْ يَعْلَمُ مِثْلَ عِلْمِهِ أَوْ مَا شَاءَ الله. 3. Muhammad ibn Yahya has narrated from Ahmad ibn Muhammad from al-Barqi from al-Nadr ibn Suwayd from Yahya al-Halabi from ‘Abd al-Hamid al-Ta’i from Muhammad ibn Muslim from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Knowledge is inherited. No man of knowledge dies without leaving behind one who is as knowledgeable as his predecessor or what Allah wants.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (12/3) صحيح Then we see another chapter in Al-Kafi here: Al-Kāfi Book 4, Chapter 33 The Imams عليه السلام inherited the knowledge of the Holy prophet صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم and all the prophets and their successors before them If Imams (عليه السلام) inherited all knowledge one after another from Ambiyaa (عليه السلام), then does that prove they are connected? Does quoting one hadith, saying it has a weak chain so can't be accepted. Does it seem fair? Let's see if this chapter has any authentic graded hadith 1ـ عَلِيُّ بْنُ إِبْرَاهِيمَ عَنْ أَبِيهِ عَنْ عَبْدِ الْعَزِيزِ بْنِ الْمُهْتَدِي عَنْ عَبْدِ الله بْنِ جُنْدَبٍ أَنَّهُ كَتَبَ إِلَيْهِ الرِّضَا (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) أَمَّا بَعْدُ فَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كَانَ أَمِينَ الله فِي خَلْقِهِ فَلَمَّا قُبِضَ (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) كُنَّا أَهْلَ الْبَيْتِ وَرَثَتَهُ فَنَحْنُ أُمَنَاءُ الله فِي أَرْضِهِ عِنْدَنَا عِلْمُ الْبَلايَا وَالْمَنَايَا وَأَنْسَابُ الْعَرَبِ وَمَوْلِدُ الاسْلامِ وَإِنَّا لَنَعْرِفُ الرَّجُلَ إِذَا رَأَيْنَاهُ بِحَقِيقَةِ الايمَانِ وَحَقِيقَةِ النِّفَاقِ وَإِنَّ شِيعَتَنَا لَمَكْتُوبُونَ بِأَسْمَائِهِمْ وَأَسْمَاءِ آبَائِهِمْ أَخَذَ الله عَلَيْنَا وَعَلَيْهِمُ الْمِيثَاقَ يَرِدُونَ مَوْرِدَنَا وَيَدْخُلُونَ مَدْخَلَنَا لَيْسَ عَلَى مِلَّةِ الاسْلامِ غَيْرُنَا وَغَيْرُهُمْ نَحْنُ النُّجَبَاءُ النُّجَاةُ وَنَحْنُ أَفْرَاطُ الانْبِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ أَبْنَاءُ الاوْصِيَاءِ وَنَحْنُ الْمَخْصُوصُونَ فِي كِتَابِ الله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِكِتَابِ الله وَنَحْنُ أَوْلَى النَّاسِ بِرَسُولِ الله (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَنَحْنُ الَّذِينَ شَرَعَ الله لَنَا دِينَهُ فَقَالَ فِي كِتَابِهِ شَرَعَ لَكُمْ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ مِنَ الدِّينِ ما وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً قَدْ وَصَّانَا بِمَا وَصَّى بِهِ نُوحاً وَالَّذِي أَوْحَيْنا إِلَيْكَ يَا مُحَمَّدُ وَما وَصَّيْنا بِهِ إِبْراهِيمَ وَمُوسى وَعِيسى فَقَدْ عَلَّمَنَا وَبَلَّغَنَا عِلْمَ مَا عَلِمْنَا وَاسْتَوْدَعَنَا عِلْمَهُمْ نَحْنُ وَرَثَةُ أُولِي الْعَزْمِ مِنَ الرُّسُلِ أَنْ أَقِيمُوا الدِّينَ يَا آلَ مُحَمَّدٍ وَلا تَتَفَرَّقُوا فِيهِ وَكُونُوا عَلَى جَمَاعَةٍ كَبُرَ عَلَى الْمُشْرِكِينَ مَنْ أَشْرَكَ بِوَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ ما تَدْعُوهُمْ إِلَيْهِ مِنْ وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ إِنَّ الله يَا مُحَمَّدُ يَهْدِي إِلَيْهِ مَنْ يُنِيبُ مَنْ يُجِيبُكَ إِلَى وَلايَةِ عَلِيٍّ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) 1. Ali ibn Ibrahim, from his father, from Abdul Aziz ibn al-Muhtadi, from Abdullah ibn Jundab, that Imam al-Ridha عليه السلام wrote to him: "As for what follows: Verily, Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم was God’s trustee among His creation. When he passed away, we, the Ahl al-Bayt, inherited him, and thus we are the trustees of God on His earth. With us is the knowledge of calamities and deaths, the genealogies of the Arabs, and the origin of Islam. We recognize a person, upon seeing him, by the true essence of faith and the true essence of hypocrisy. Our followers (Shi'a) are recorded by their names and the names of their fathers. God has taken a covenant from us and from them, they shall return to our source and enter where we enter. None are truly upon the religion of Islam except us and them. We are the chosen ones, the saved, the vanguard of the prophets, the sons of their successors. We are the ones specifically mentioned in the Book of God, the Almighty and Exalted. We are the most worthy of the Book of God and the most worthy of the Messenger of God صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. God has legislated His religion for us, as He said in His Book: 'He has ordained for you, O family of Muhammad, of the religion what He enjoined upon Noah.' He enjoined upon us what He enjoined upon Noah, and what He revealed to you, O Muhammad, and what He enjoined upon Abraham, Moses, and Jesus. He has taught us and conveyed to us what He taught them, and entrusted us with their knowledge. We are the heirs of the messengers of firm resolve (ulu al-‘azm). 'Establish the religion, O Family of Muhammad, and do not be divided therein. Be united.' It has become heavy upon the polytheists—those who associate others in the guardianship (wilayah) of Ali—what you call them to, of Ali’s wilayah عليه السلام. Indeed, God, O Muhammad, guides to it whomever turns to Him, and whoever responds to you regarding the wilayah of Ali عليه السلام." Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/14) حسن 4ـ أَحْمَدُ بْنُ إِدْرِيسَ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ صَفْوَانَ بْنِ يَحْيَى عَنْ شُعَيْبٍ الْحَدَّادِ عَنْ ضُرَيْسٍ الْكُنَاسِيِّ قَالَ كُنْتُ عِنْدَ أَبِي عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) وَعِنْدَهُ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ فَقَالَ أَبُو عَبْدِ الله (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) إِنَّ دَاوُدَ وَرِثَ عِلْمَ الانْبِيَاءِ وَإِنَّ سُلَيْمَانَ وَرِثَ دَاوُدَ وَإِنَّ مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَرِثَ سُلَيْمَانَ وَإِنَّا وَرِثْنَا مُحَمَّداً (صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَآلِه) وَإِنَّ عِنْدَنَا صُحُفَ إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَأَلْوَاحَ مُوسَى فَقَالَ أَبُو بَصِيرٍ إِنَّ هَذَا لَهُوَ الْعِلْمُ فَقَالَ يَا أَبَا مُحَمَّدٍ لَيْسَ هَذَا هُوَ الْعِلْمَ إِنَّمَا الْعِلْمُ مَا يَحْدُثُ بِاللَّيْلِ وَالنَّهَارِ يَوْماً بِيَوْمٍ وَسَاعَةً بِسَاعَةٍ. 4. Ahmad ibn Idris has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabbar from Safwan ibn Yahya from Shu‘ayb al-Haddad from Durays al-Kunasi who has said the following. “I was in the presence of abu ‘Abdallah عليه السلام and abu Basir also was there. The Imams عليه السلام said, “David inherited the knowledge of the prophets. Solomon inherited David. Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم inherited Solomon and we inherited Muhammad صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم. With us are the pages of Abraham and the tablets of Moses.” Abu Basir then said, “This is the knowledge.” The Imams عليه السلام said, “O abu Muhammad, this is not the knowledge. The knowledge is what happens in the nights and in the days, day after day and hour after hour.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (20/3) صحيح على الظاهر The in another chapter from Al-Kafi here: https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/44 4ـ أَبُو عَلِيٍّ الاشْعَرِيُّ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ عَبْدِ الْجَبَّارِ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ إِسْمَاعِيلَ عَنْ عَلِيِّ بْنِ النُّعْمَانِ عَنْ سُوَيْدٍ الْقَلاءِ عَنْ أَبِي أَيُّوبَ عَنْ أَبِي بَصِيرٍ عَنْ ابي جعفر (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) قَالَ إِنَّ لله عَزَّ وَجَلَّ عِلْمَيْنِ عِلْمٌ لا يَعْلَمُهُ إِلا هُوَ وَعِلْمٌ عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ فَمَا عَلَّمَهُ مَلائِكَتَهُ وَرُسُلَهُ (عَلَيْهِ السَّلام) فَنَحْنُ نَعْلَمُهُ. 4. Abu Ali al-Ash‘ari has narrated from Muhammad ibn ‘Abd al-Jabber from Muhammad ibn Isma‘il from Ali ibn al-Nu‘man from Suwayd al-Qalla from abu Ayyub from abu Basir from abu Ja‘far عليه السلام who has said the following. “Allah, the Most Holy, the Most High, has two kinds of knowledge. One kind of knowledge is that which no one knows except He. The other kind is that which He has taught to the His angels and His messengers. Whatever His angels and Messengers have learned we know it.” Allamah Baqir al-Majlisi Mirʾāt al-ʿUqūl fī Sharḥ Akhbār Āl al-Rasūl (3/109) صحيح Shaykh Baqir al-Behbudi Ṣaḥīḥ al-Kāfī, vol. 1, p. 30 صحيح So I'd suggest, instead of weakning hadiths, focus on Science of hadith. Let's not assume our belief has no basis as per our own standards from our own books. that narrative won't move much further & will also change the topic. Salam, About Jabir (ra): I did not object to it. I said the opposite. Al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) named his source, so in this report even the Imam narrated from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) through a named narrator. That is why I brought it. You say the gradings came later, they are not the classical method, and even weak reports were taken as hujja. Then which method do you use instead, and how does it show that a report in al Kafi really came from the Imam?? That is exactly the question of this thread. You also say you do not throw away the gradings of al Majlisi and al Khoei. Then they count for the two reports behind your rule too, "my hadith is the hadith of my father" and "it is the same", and al Majlisi grades both of them weak (Mir'at al Uqul 1/182 and 1/176, al Kafi, hadith 14 and 4) https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/2/17 . And you ask me to focus on the science of hadith instead of weakening hadith, but checking the chains is the science of hadith. You say the reports I called weak have sahih reports with the same meaning, and you brought these to show that the hadith of the infallible is always connected. Now look at what they say. The Imams inherit knowledge one from the other, back to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and a scholar does not die without leaving one who knows like him. None of them says that every word of the Imam is a hadith of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), or that a report needs no chain beyond the Imam. So they do not have the same meaning! And the report of Durays that you quoted says even more. Abu Basir says the pages of Abraham and the tablets of Moses are the knowledge, and al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) answers: this is not the knowledge, the knowledge is what happens in the nights and in the days, day after day and hour after hour. Al Majlisi explains: Abu Basir meant the best knowledge, and the Imam denied that this is their noblest and greatest knowledge (Mir'at al Uqul 3/20) https://books.rafed.net/view/1011/page/20 . And in the next chapters al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) says: if we did not get more, our knowledge would run out. Zurara asks him: do you get something that the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) did not know? He answers: when that happens, it is shown to the Messenger of Allah (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), then to the Imams, until it reaches us (al Kafi, Book 4, Chapter 43, hadith 3, al Majlisi: sahih, Mir'at al Uqul 3/107) https://thaqalayn.com/chapter/1/4/43 . Al Majlisi explains this in more than one way: either it is about what they knew only in general, so they can draw out the details, or it is a special knowledge other than the halal and haram, which the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) and the earlier Imams did not get before! (Mir'atalUqul3/106) https://books.rafed.net/view/1011/page/106 . So by your own sahih reports and your own scholar, the knowledge of the Imam is not only what he inherited from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and some of it comes after his death. What is shown to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) after his death is not something he gave to the umma, and Allah says: what the Messenger gives you, take it (59:7). And if you say the halal and haram comes only from the inherited part, then show me for a ruling of the Imam how you know it was inherited from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). The two reports that say so are the weak ones above. So when an Imam speaks without naming the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), how do you know it is the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم)? And if you say the word of the Imam counts by itself, even when it is not from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), then it is not the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) but a second source next to it, and that needs its own proof. And all these reports are Imams speaking about the Imams, so they can not prove this by themselves. Nobody can prove his own authority with his own word, and these reports reach you through the same chains we are asking about. For the rule that the word of the Imam needs no chain to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), you need a proof from outside them, from the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) himself, in a sahih report. I do not say your belief has no basis in your books. I ask by which method a report is shown to be from the Imam, and on what basis it counts as the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). That is the topic of this thread, not a change of it. Your question about al Kashshi I answer in my next post, inshallah. Ashvazdanghe 1 Quote
Advanced Member Maulana Posted October 21 Author Advanced Member Report Posted October 21 16 hours ago, Syed Ali Mehdi Shah Naqvi said: I think this narration clearly shows shias didn't blindly compile hadiths am I right? They were cross checking & liars/fabricators got caught messing with books. So what's the point? If they were careless, such narration wouldn't exist in first place. I did not say they were careless. My point is what this report means for us today. Read the whole report. Yunus ibn Abd al Rahman took the books of the companions of al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) and showed them to al Rida (رضي الله عنه). He rejected many hadith in them and said that the followers of Abu al Khattab put these hadith in until this day (Rijal al Kashshi no.401) https://rejal.masaha.org/12587 . So the lies were inside the books of the companions themselves. If the companion was trusted, such a hadith has a good chain, so checking the narrators alone can not find it. Which hadith were rejected, the report does not say. And al Kulayni wrote more than 100 years later. For this al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) gives a rule in the same report: accept from us only what agrees with the Quran and the Sunna, or what has a witness in our earlier hadith. Now look at it. How many rak'at, the times of prayer, how much zakat, the details of fasting and hajj, most of this is not in the Quran. The Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) you mostly have only through reports that stop at the Imam, so you test the hadith of the Imam with the hadith of the Imam. And a witness from their earlier hadith is a witness from the same books in which the liars put their hadith. So how do you know today which hadith in these books is true? That is the question of this thread. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.