Isnt this two istifta answer contradictory?

[Botak]

Question 1

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

 

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

Question 2

 

Is it permissible to draw a fictional character that are not muslim considering they will not wear hijab

 

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

If it is obscene and excites one's passion, it is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

???

[Borntowitnesstruth]

5 minutes ago, Botak said:

Question 1

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

 

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

Question 2

 

Is it permissible to draw a fictional character that are not muslim considering they will not wear hijab

 

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

If it is obscene and excites one's passion, it is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

???

Well, the answers are obvious you know. One answer is general and one refers to the particular instances. General one points out to the fact that when you are drawing a picture, it is obvious that it may affect a lot of people so it is said it is impermissible. The second instance refers to a particular instance such as you wanna draw that image for people who will not feel attracted to it such as woman themselves, it will be permissible for them but not for the other section of the society. So, both are answering two different answers.

[Botak]

24 minutes ago, Borntowitnesstruth said:

Well, the answers are obvious you know. One answer is general and one refers to the particular instances. General one points out to the fact that when you are drawing a picture, it is obvious that it may affect a lot of people so it is said it is impermissible. The second instance refers to a particular instance such as you wanna draw that image for people who will not feel attracted to it such as woman themselves, it will be permissible for them but not for the other section of the society. So, both are answering two different answers.

I... dont understand?

[Muslim2010]

4 hours ago, Botak said:

I... dont understand?

Question 1

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

Question 2

Is it permissible to draw a fictional character that are not muslim considering they will not wear hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

If it is obscene and excites one's passion, it is impermissible.

The above sentences with particular emphasis on red statement answer the question clearly.

[Botak]

18 hours ago, Muslim2010 said:

Question 1

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

Question 2

Is it permissible to draw a fictional character that are not muslim considering they will not wear hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

If it is obscene and excites one's passion, it is impermissible.

The above sentences with particular emphasis on red statement answer the question clearly.

So if i draw a person with aurat revealed that is not obscene and does not excite one passion its ok? Why didnt they mention it on the first question?

Edited February 6 by Botak
Clarification

[Botak]

18 hours ago, Muslim2010 said:

Question 1

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

With prayers for your success

 

Question 2

Is it permissible to draw a fictional character that are not muslim considering they will not wear hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

If it is obscene and excites one's passion, it is impermissible.

The above sentences with particular emphasis on red statement answer the question clearly.

So if i draw a person with aurat revealed that is not obscene and does not excite one passion its ok?

[Borntowitnesstruth]

23 hours ago, Botak said:

I... dont understand?

The first question's answer addressed to general audience, the second question's answer addressed to a particular audience. In the first question, the responder gave answer keeping in mind that picture may be available to general public where there is high chance of getting attracted to such picture and hence it was declared impermissible. In the second question, the responder gave answer keeping in mind that the picture may be available to particular group which might not get attracted to it such as the picture of female was in magazine for females wherein there would be no effect upon the females so, it will be allowed for that particular instance. 

[Botak]

33 minutes ago, Borntowitnesstruth said:

The first question's answer addressed to general audience, the second question's answer addressed to a particular audience. In the first question, the responder gave answer keeping in mind that picture may be available to general public where there is high chance of getting attracted to such picture and hence it was declared impermissible. In the second question, the responder gave answer keeping in mind that the picture may be available to particular group which might not get attracted to it such as the picture of female was in magazine for females wherein there would be no effect upon the females so, it will be allowed for that particular instance. 

I did not mention the audience in both case however? I assume in both case its for general public like a comic

[Muslim2010]

4 hours ago, Botak said:

So if i draw a person with aurat revealed that is not obscene and does not excite one passion its ok? Why didnt they mention it on the first question?

Is it permissible to draw a person with aurat revealed, like no hijab

Salamun `alaykum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu

It is impermissible.

The answer is clear for your ambiguity in the mind.  

Edited February 6 by Muslim2010

[Abu_Zahra]

In the first instance you are drawing an actual person who are revealing the parts that should be covered and this is always impermissible.

 

In the second you are drawing a fictional character,  and this would be impermissible depending on the nature of drawing. 

[Borntowitnesstruth]

15 hours ago, Botak said:

I did not mention the audience in both case however? I assume in both case its for general public like a comic

You may have asked without referring to audience but the answers show the limitations that whether it is for general or specific audience.