The Qur'an has 102 errors in it, do you want to see them?

[Guest Michael Junior]

Quran has 102 errors in it.

I will show you the first one and then all of it.

Quran 41:7-12 says allah created earth first then heaven. surah 79:27-28 says heaven first and then earth. thats the first contradiction.

Ask your questions.

[Haji 2003]

Until someone knowledgeable comes along here is what chatgpt has to say:

The verses in question from the Qur'an—Quran 41:9-12 (often referred to as Surah Fussilat) and Quran 79:27-30 (Surah An-Nazi'at)—have been interpreted in various ways, leading to the discussion about whether they present a contradiction regarding the order of creation of the heavens and the earth. To address this query:

### Quran 41:9-12 (Surah Fussilat)
These verses describe the creation of the earth and then the heavens:

- Verse 9: Describes the creation of the earth in two periods.
- Verse 10: Mentions that mountains were set on the earth, it was blessed, and provisions were created.
- Verse 11: Refers to the turning towards the heavens, which were smoke, and their shaping into seven heavens.
- Verse 12: States that the seven heavens were created in two periods and the order was given to each heaven.

### Quran 79:27-30 (Surah An-Nazi'at)
These verses seem to indicate the creation of the heavens before the earth:

- Verse 27: Questions whether the creation of the heavens is more difficult than the creation of humans.
- Verse 28: Describes the construction of the heavens and their raising.
- Verse 29: Mentions the night and day cycle.
- Verse 30: States that the earth was spread out after that.

### Reconciling the Verses
To understand these verses, it's essential to consider the following points:

1. **Chronological vs. Functional Description**: The Qur'an often presents descriptions of events in a non-linear or thematic manner rather than strictly chronological. The purpose of these descriptions may be more about illustrating Allah's power and majesty in creation rather than providing a step-by-step timeline.

2. **Thematic Focus**: Surah Fussilat (41:9-12) focuses on the earth's creation, detailing its formation and the provisions made for life, while Surah An-Nazi'at (79:27-30) emphasizes the heavens' grandeur and their creation. The phrase "after that" in Surah An-Nazi'at can be interpreted as referring to the earth's completion in relation to the heavens, not necessarily implying that the earth was entirely non-existent before.

3. **Simultaneous Creation**: Some scholars suggest that the verses describe overlapping or simultaneous acts of creation rather than a sequential order. In this view, the creation of the earth and heavens happened concurrently, with certain aspects of each being completed at different times.

4. **Understanding “After That”**: The Arabic phrase used in Surah An-Nazi'at, "ba‘da dhalika," translated as "after that," can also mean "moreover" or "furthermore," which does not strictly denote a sequence but rather an additional action or focus.

### Conclusion
The apparent contradiction arises when the verses are read with a rigid expectation of a chronological order. However, when understood in the broader context of Qur'anic exegesis, these verses are seen as complementary rather than contradictory. The focus is on the majesty of creation rather than providing a sequential narrative, and the descriptions in different surahs serve to highlight different aspects of the same creative process.

Islamic scholars and commentators (Mufassirun) have long discussed these verses, generally concluding that there is no contradiction, but rather different emphases on the elements of creation.

[Borntowitnesstruth]

15 hours ago, Guest Michael Junior said:

Quran has 102 errors in it.

I will show you the first one and then all of it.

Quran 41:7-12 says allah created earth first then heaven. surah 79:27-28 says heaven first and then earth. thats the first contradiction.

Ask your questions.

Well, the verses which you mentioned don't tell the chronological order because there is verse 21:30 which tells that heaven and earth we joined until they were separated by Allah (عزّ وجلّ). So, you are wrong about it.

[JannahLM]

lol this guy was debunked in a single post.