Kurds Djinns?

[GermanShia]

Salam,

As i only need Hadiths instead of Fatawa and dont believe in Rijjal refuse like done mostly today, this is only adressed to the people who knows and Share Hadiths called Akhbaris:

I heard that Kurds are Djinns (Al kafi)

Can anyone explain?

Thank you!

[Ashvazdanghe]

7 hours ago, GermanShia said:

I heard that Kurds are Djinns (Al kafi)

Can anyone explain?

Salam it has been refuted in following threads which it's a too weak narration also it's a false interpretation of the too weak hadith by anti shia people .

 

 

[hawdini]

8 hours ago, GermanShia said:

Salam,

As i only need Hadiths instead of Fatawa and dont believe in Rijjal refuse like done mostly today, this is only adressed to the people who knows and Share Hadiths called Akhbaris:

I heard that Kurds are Djinns (Al kafi)

Can anyone explain?

Thank you!

Salam

Im a kurd and I can assure you that I in fact am a jinn. And my mum always calls me ifriet which means im one of the powerfull ones.

Hope this helps!

[Abu_Zahra]

11 hours ago, GermanShia said:

Salam,

As i only need Hadiths instead of Fatawa and dont believe in Rijjal refuse like done mostly today, this is only adressed to the people who knows and Share Hadiths called Akhbaris:

I heard that Kurds are Djinns (Al kafi)

Can anyone explain?

Thank you!

Wa alaikum as salam 

If you claim to be an akhbari (are you aware of the history and methodology of the akhbariyya?) then you would essentially need to accept the hadith since it's in al Kafi. 

As for an explanation,  it wouldn't hold weight because the akhbariyya reject rational deduction. 

So the akhbari answer is: yes they are jinns and no there is no explanation. 

Now you know why the akhbari methodology didn't stand the test of time.

[islamicmusic]

Wa alaikum salam. Akhbarism is a dead cult. I don't see any alive akhbari movement today except for a few online enthusiasts that only claim they are akhbaris in order to avoid the fatawa of ayatullahs regarding tatbir or cursing etc.

[JannahLM]

On 8/11/2024 at 3:06 PM, islamicmusic said:

Wa alaikum salam. Akhbarism is a dead cult. I don't see any alive akhbari movement today except for a few online enthusiasts that only claim they are akhbaris in order to avoid the fatawa of ayatullahs regarding tatbir or cursing etc.

Yes, I've noticed this too. Mostly young kids as well. I doubt anyone at that age even has that much of a well-rounded understanding of faith to make those types of decisions. Just for a scholar of hadith to be qualified takes years of study in a hawza so I don't know what makes Akhbaris think they're more qualified to make religious rulings for themselves.