Anyone here (maybe hawza student) that know ALOT of maraji and their fatwas

[Obitotheshia]

I want to know if there are people here who are like encyclopedia's when it comes to maraji, people that know many many currently alive knowledgable maraji with a vast range of opinions, have receipts on which scholars have testified for certain scholars etc. 

bascially people with above average knowledge when it comes to this kind of thing 

[realizm]

Some people actually know every Marja`s opinion regarding mut`a with a virgin girl. 

Other than that, I am not sure...

[Obitotheshia]

On 5/3/2024 at 10:40 AM, realizm said:

Some people actually know every Marja`s opinion regarding mut`a with a virgin girl. 

Other than that, I am not sure...

LOOOL you mean muta with a virgin girl without walis permission?

yeah i do too, but most maraji who allowed it are now deceased iirc 

anyway

do you or anyone else know all the scholars who allow you to not follow the most knowlegable i.e. (تقليد غير الاعلم) if you speak arabic 

could you please tag someone you think might be able to help with this 

[Hameedeh]

@Obitotheshia If you are interested in other Ayatullahs, see this topic:

https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/71812-grand-ayatullahs-choose-your-marja/

[Rohani]

On 5/2/2024 at 10:05 AM, Obitotheshia said:

I want to know if there are people here who are like encyclopedia's when it comes to maraji, people that know many many currently alive knowledgable maraji with a vast range of opinions, have receipts on which scholars have testified for certain scholars etc. 

bascially people with above average knowledge when it comes to this kind of thing 

Salaam alaykom

In hawzah as we study more advanced topics we learn that there are diffrent views on issues. We start to look at arguments and proofs and evidences. We kind of leave the masael books.  It's possible some people are well versed though. 

Edited May 27 by Rohani