Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

Recommended Posts

  • Advanced Member
Posted

Salam alaikom

For those of you who haven't watched Sayed Ammar's latest majles and want to, here's the link: 

What did you guys think about it? It's a pretty controversial topic to tackle. I'm surprised the Sayed chose a topic so disuniting. But nevertheless, it was a good majles, the Sayed seemed pretty neutral about it, neither extreme one way nor the other. I like how he went into the history of Shi'ism in the UK and started off with the first majalis to be taking place. He went into a bit of detail about the Shirazis and the Iranian religious authorities such as Ayatollah Khomeini (r) and Ayatollah Khamenei (h). But he didn't show open support for one side or the other. And I'm surprised he didn't go into more detail about Sheikh Yasser Al-Habib and those at the Rafida+ channel. Nevertheless, it was a good majles.

What did you think?

  • Advanced Member
Posted

Salaam i will respond again after finishing viewing it, but i will say this, and this is simply an observation about British Islam in general. It's definitely a bit more provocative from Hiz-b-Tahir, to grooming gangs that were predominantly Muslim, to characters like Muhammad Hijab and Ali Dawah to Yasir Al-Habib on the other spectrum. I'm sure there more reserved voices that make up the majority of the notable figures in the UK, but all the characters from the UK that appear through my youtube algorithm all tend to have an extra bit of spice to them compared to the more conciliatory nature of the American Muslim leadership.

Is it something in the water there?

  • Advanced Member
Posted

I'm glad he responded to that comical video.

SAN has his fair share of mistakes (who among us doesn't?), but making a video to smear someone who doesn't agree with you on certain things, and is critical of certain opinions you hold is not the best of akhlaaq. It strikes me as funny that, for all the turbaned cast and crew that channel sports, they don't realize how poorly slandering a mu'min reflects on their record in akhirah. 

I've been noticing this disturbing trend among the camp that the makers of that 'British Shi'ism' video belong to; it's always 'my way or the highway' with their doctrinaires and their army of despicable cyber trolls. Judge their intellectual bankruptcy from this fact alone- a nasibi who rejects the esteemed position and merits of the Ahl al-Bayt (ams) (I'm not even bringing up the topic of their Wilayah) is dearer to them than their mu'min brother who doesn't see eye to eye with them politically (because muh unity) ; the geopolitical interests of their camp become the aims and objectives of Islam, and if you disagree, you are as good as Muhammad bin Salman or Bush all of a sudden. They have this strange Soviet-style mentality where they're some sort of Shiite USSR, and all other Shi'a communities the world over are like the former communist satellite- states of Eastern Europe who are supposed to obey Moscow's orders verbatim or face consequences. 

Some people just don't have it in them to understand that the world is not black and white, smh, and that there may be imperatives and realities beyond their campist interests and rhetoric. SAN's response was still quite moderate, tempered and held-back one; he's still seeing the interests of the larger Tashayyu beyond purely personal/political concerns (unlike those who slandered him). He could have made the whole thing about himself, but commendably, didn't. 

Wassalam. 

  • Advanced Member
Posted
Quote

Judge their intellectual bankruptcy from this fact alone- a nasibi who rejects the esteemed position and merits of the Ahl al-Bayt (ams) (I'm not even bringing up the topic of their Wilayah) is dearer to them than their mu'min brother who doesn't see eye to eye with them politically (because muh unity)

could you kindly bring a single example where they pay homage to a nasibi? 

All I've them do is to critisize, rightly so, takfiri wahabbis, so could you kindly provide evidence to back up your claim.

  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, VoidVortex said:

could you kindly bring a single example where they pay homage to a nasibi? 

All I've them do is to critisize, rightly so, takfiri wahabbis, so could you kindly provide evidence to back up your claim.

Lest this goes unanswered-

1. This guy (in the picture below) is the same sub human whom many would recognize as the one who notoriously shouted slogans like "your mom has been with so many men she doesn't know your dad" - apparently a mutah reference (mods please don't delete Or censor this, I want everyone to see this ugliness) during the Lady of Heaven protests. This guy is being promoted by the 5 Pillars channel, and later Arif Abdulhussein and Jafar Ladak both attended a program hosted by 5Pillars instead of boycotting that sectarian channel. He's too notorious to not be known, his face is all over the press. 

Sure, critique the movie all you want. I myself have no love lost for Yasser al Habib or his clique. But atleast see whom you are legitimizing in the public eye, and what message it's sending across. 

2. What do Ismail Haniya and Khaled Mishal think of Shias? What was their role when the nasibi scum were giving calls to raze the shrine of Sayyida Zaynab (sa), to rape, enslave and parade our womenfolk, and to slaughter our children? After a brief hiatus of silencewhen they fell out with Hezbollah, all of a sudden they're nice again after the rapprochement following the 2014 bombings? There photos are all over the place again? I have no problems with, and nothing but admiration for groups like the PIJ, but these villains? Seriously? That too at the expense of Shi'a militias in Palestine like the Sabireen who are all but absent from the narrative? 

3. Now that Turkey is warming up to Iran and Russia again following its marginalization by the Euro-American bloc, all sins of Erdogan seem to have been forgotten. All pro-govt outlets like the PressTV as well as individuals like Mohammad Marandi are celebrating the trilateral summit like some great achievement while it's at best an uncomfortable truce with an unreliable enemy. Just look around on Twitter. I get that you don't always have the luxury of perfect allies, but why celebrate this like some great diplomatic breakthrough? 

Don't trust me. Do your own research. I get why unity is important and all, but atleast look at whom you are pushing for unity with. 

Since I don't wish to derail this thread, I won't pursue the topic further. 

IMG_20220730_215000.jpg

Edited by AbdusSibtayn
  • Advanced Member
Posted

sorry brother I don't follow what you are saying. I asked for an example of the channel paying homage to nasibis, they have no affiliation to the individual in the picture and sheikh jaffer ladak and other sunni and shia scholars condemned the behaviour of the guy in the picture and those like him. You haven't brought an example of the channel making dearer a nasibi than a mumin. 

5pillars is a news organisation, they haven't had anti-shia sentiments and have directly indicated a pro-unity position. A picture of that guy does not mean they support him but it was just an example of a leader of one of those protests, especially because his protest was controversial.

we haven't forgotten the sins of erdogan or other taghuti states. The shia ulema in Iran have wisdom especially sayed khamenei. If we were to be aggressive at every country then we would have no friends and the shia would suffer immensely. In this case these deals ensure the shia are protected, whilst also protected from the influence of the US. I noticed I have not answered your question directly but the new ties being created are important for the world to turn from unipolar to bipolar in terms of power, meaning not one entity(Nato/US) has only power, but there are two main sides to the world. This is good because the US got away with doing a massive amount of meddling and butchering people. Yes the new allies are not good, but this is far better for the shia in the world. Iran being a key member of a new alliance will ensure shii interests and lives, and even muslim lives are protected which is important.

I can't answer your second point because I don't know about it. 
The problem is you are bringing extreme takfiris as an argument for why we shouldn't be fraternal with sunnis. That's quite unfair, its like non-muslims generalising muslims as terrorists or sunnis calling all shias ghulat. You have be just and give a proper reason why fraternalising with sunnis is something problematic other than the few bad apples in their communities. Forget their extreme factions, we are talking about fraternalising with the majority, not the minority who are the loudest but the emptiest in terms of substance. The maraja in general have endorsed islamic unity, and the maraja only try to act according to the teachings of the Imams and Quran. Therefore do you not agree that we should be fraternalising with sunnis. 

Prohibiting Takfir - Fatwas Of Shi‘i Scholars | Al-Islam.org

these are the opinions of the maraja on unity. its not something to be dismissed. In fact it can even be said that the fitna maker is an indirect murderer, because his tongue causes the death of shiis by extremists. 

  • Advanced Member
Posted
2 hours ago, Abu Hadi said:

I think he is being a little naive in thinking that the CIA / MI6 have not infiltrated the Shia community in the UK and they are not recruiting 'assets' within the community to do their bidding. They definitely are doing that and will continue to do that. This is their modus operandi, going back many decades. They are fully supported by the US / UK governments are given huge budgets to do this, and are most effective at doing this within their home countries, because they understand these countries better than anywhere else. So to say they have been 100% ineffective at doing this is a little on the naive side. 

 

Have you heard the claim that Ayatullah Khomeini only gained power by help of MI6?

I must admit, there are a lot of unanswered questions about that time period.

  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, VoidVortex said:

sorry brother I don't follow what you are saying. I asked for an example of the channel paying homage to nasibis, they have no affiliation to the individual in the picture and sheikh jaffer ladak and other sunni and shia scholars condemned the behaviour of the guy in the picture and those like him. You haven't brought an example of the channel making dearer a nasibi than a mumin. 

5pillars is a news organisation, they haven't had anti-shia sentiments and have directly indicated a pro-unity position. A picture of that guy does not mean they support him but it was just an example of a leader of one of those protests, especially because his protest was controversial.

we haven't forgotten the sins of erdogan or other taghuti states. The shia ulema in Iran have wisdom especially sayed khamenei. If we were to be aggressive at every country then we would have no friends and the shia would suffer immensely. In this case these deals ensure the shia are protected, whilst also protected from the influence of the US. I noticed I have not answered your question directly but the new ties being created are important for the world to turn from unipolar to bipolar in terms of power, meaning not one entity(Nato/US) has only power, but there are two main sides to the world. This is good because the US got away with doing a massive amount of meddling and butchering people. Yes the new allies are not good, but this is far better for the shia in the world. Iran being a key member of a new alliance will ensure shii interests and lives, and even muslim lives are protected which is important.

I can't answer your second point because I don't know about it. 
The problem is you are bringing extreme takfiris as an argument for why we shouldn't be fraternal with sunnis. That's quite unfair, its like non-muslims generalising muslims as terrorists or sunnis calling all shias ghulat. You have be just and give a proper reason why fraternalising with sunnis is something problematic other than the few bad apples in their communities. Forget their extreme factions, we are talking about fraternalising with the majority, not the minority who are the loudest but the emptiest in terms of substance. The maraja in general have endorsed islamic unity, and the maraja only try to act according to the teachings of the Imams and Quran. Therefore do you not agree that we should be fraternalising with sunnis. 

Prohibiting Takfir - Fatwas Of Shi‘i Scholars | Al-Islam.org

these are the opinions of the maraja on unity. its not something to be dismissed. In fact it can even be said that the fitna maker is an indirect murderer, because his tongue causes the death of shiis by extremists. 

Dear brother, there seems to be some misunderstanding here

1. My post wasn't directed at the channel specifically, but at the entire camp. I very well know 5 Pillars is a news organization, but watch their coverage of the entire protests, see what they were trying to do surreptitiously, who all they were interviewing and you'll know for yourself. They are double-faced, that's what I meant to say- on one hand giving platform to guys like him and on another hand hosting programs promoting unity. 

'Unity' is the official stated position of Saudi Arabia and Qatar as well. Even they posture to this effect at times. How 'pro-Unity' does it make them exactly? 

As for the channel championing nawasib at the expense of mu'mineen, unfortunately, since their old channel has been taken down, I can't furnish you proof so you'll have to take my word or leave it, but at one point they were literally simping for Hamas. There was absolutely no mention of their betrayal in Syria when they joined the ranks of those who wanted to demolish the qubbah of Ummul Masa'ib Thaniyyatuz Zahra (sa), and enslave, rape and parade in the marketplace our mothers and sisters. There was no mention either of how their hoodlums are harassing and target- killing Shi'a converts in the West Bank.There was stoic silence on the struggle of Shi'a militias like al-Sabireen (many of us don't even know that they exist), our brothers in iman. There was stoic silence on the struggle of the Saudi Shi'a under their leader,Sheikh Hassan al-Saffar, just because he's affiliated to the Shirazi marjaiyyah (his own stance is pro unity and pro conciliation) who are seen as political rivals. If promoting shayatin like the Hamas while completely sidelining our mu'min brothers like the Sabireen is not celebrating nawasib at the expense of the Shi'a, I don't know what else it is . 

2. Again, you completely missed my point. I am not against Iran, Sayyid Khamenei, the Iranian ulama, unity with Sunnis, or negotiating with enemies if and when the need be. My point is- why celebrate what is at best an uneasy truce with an enemy like this great and holy bond of friendship? Do you honestly think this will change Turkey or its priorities, or their attitudes towards us? Really? Has that ever happened? What sort of reasoning is this? Will a nasibi suddenly become tolerant towards the Shi'a in a multipolar setting? The same was said about Hamas and at the very first opportunity they got they were at our throats. The same was said about the Deobandis in Pakistan, and they continue to perpetrate Shi'a massacres and support the Taliban. If weaning them away from Shi'a hatred is the stated aim, that clearly doesn't seem to be working. You know, none of us are buying this line of reasoning anymore. At least those of us outside Iran. 

And if you don't feel Erdogan's crimes are not being whitewashed, I invite you to explore Twitter a bit. The coverage is nothing short of his canonization. 

3. Please, don't patronize me with those fatawa Or think that i am unaware of what the maraja say. I guess we differ in our understanding of 'unity'. My definition of 'unity' is to speak from a position of strength and not inferiority complex, as equals and not pleaders; unity for me is not unilateral death-embraces with those who are manifest enemies, nor  licking my own spit by canonizing and kowtowing before those who desire my death and humiliation. 

And I find that whole 'Shi'a curse Sunni sanctities so they get killed' line of reasoning preposterous, horribly horrid, and nothing short of genocide apologia. Sunnis routinely call our holy figures like the Prophet (SAWA) 's blessed parents (ams) and Abu Talib (عليه السلام) kuffar and jahannami. Most of them praise the likes of Muawiya (la), Amr ibn Aas (la), Abu Sufyan (la), Hind (la) and Mughira ibn Shu'ba (la). Some (and this number is increasing) even praise Yazeed and Marwan (may Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) damn these two). How many Sunnis have the Shi'a killed in Iran, Iraq, Lebanon or Azerbaijan on that account? If insulting holy figures is an excuse for getting killed, then why are the Sunnis not getting killed? 

You say the fitna mongers contribute to our killings. Fine. How about those who actually kill us? Shaking hands with them is all fine? 

Edited by AbdusSibtayn
  • Advanced Member
Posted

I'm sorry, I misunderstood your viewpoint dear brother.

 

Quote

How about those who actually kill us? Shaking hands with them is all fine? 

there is no doubt those who kill us are cursed. However we need to make a distinction, who is killing us mainly. Who is the entity that is targeting us en masse. Honestly the west has butchered us far more than the nasibis, not even that, the nasibis are the lapdogs of the west, and by nasibis I mean those terrorists that kill us and muslims and the innocent in the east and the west.

I would say at the moment the biggest threat to Islam is the west, namely the USA. In the past Britain was the major superpower, now its the USA although its influence and power are being reduced as time goes by. 

Its a game of choosing the lesser evil.

Having a bipolar world is useful because Iran is on one side of it and it will be a key player. We can't stop all killings, but we can reduce it and in fact we have a duty to reduce it. For example Iran can do damage control in Afghanistan. having allies in the east means that our lands can be protected better, America won't be able to merely attack without consequence. For example Russia helping in defeating ISIS in Syria, although this isn't related to my last point a lot, it still shows a moment where having an ally like Russia was useful. We can't say Russia or China are good but they are far better than the US at least in terms of foreign policy. We haven't entered a multipolar world completely, the shift is very recent so we can't be 100% sure of how things will change but only make predictions. The shift won't make a nasibi like us, but it may limit the nasibi's abililty to attack us. Sayed khamenei has pushed the dollar to not be the global currency, so there is a shift more towards a bipolar world, and if the power of the dollar is weakened its very advantageous in weakening the monopoly the US has over many other countries. After all, many countries are just puppets afraid of standing up to their master or scared to do so. Libya stood up to the dollar, it was destroyed because of it. Other countries shared the same fate. Its not like China hasn't been moving behind the scenes. I watched a video about them basically moving on to african countries, something like placing them in debt, but I don't remember all the details. Though China is a lesser evil we need to work with what we have. As long as the source of so much corruption, killing etc. is dealt with or at least its influence reduced this will have a positive effect throughout the world and reduce the oppression that is on the shiis. 

Also dear brother could you send me some sources about the things you said about Hamas, I'd like to check them out because my knowledge of them is weak.

  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, EiE said:

 

Have you heard the claim that Ayatullah Khomeini only gained power by help of MI6?

I must admit, there are a lot of unanswered questions about that time period.

Actually I haven't. It's a ridiculous claim. 

Almost every single action taken by Imam Khomeni went directly against the interests of MI6. Why would they support him. 

Makes no sense. 

MI6 / CIA have a single purpose vis a via the institution of Marjaa3at. They have been very consistent in this

The single purpose is to have marjaa' who are apparently alim and adl but behind the scenes take their orders from London or Washington. Imam Khomeni never took his orders from London or Washington. That is obvious to both his friends and enemies. If he gained power with the help of the MI6, then this was their most spectacular failure in all of history. 

Edited by Abu Hadi
  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)

Salam. The term British Shiism does not stand for Shia Muslims that happen to be from and/or live in Britain. It means the "shiites" working for the global agendas of the Biritish Regime. If a so-called "shiite" hates a sincere but misguided sunni over let's say their rejecting imamate. Yet that "shiite" loves and kisses the hand of the British Queen and claims she is one of the Ahlulbayt (reference to Yasir Habib guy). That surely is not the shia of Ali bin Abu Talib. Rather he is shia of MI6.

Same goes for sunnis. You know the term "Islam-e Amrikai" (American Islam or American Sunnism) also does not refer to the Sunni Muslim brethren living in the USA. Rather it stands for the so-called "sunnis" working for the agendas of USA and NATO.

I did not watch the video but having seen his old videos, I don't think the tattoo sheikh would know about the term and what it stands for and how the British Shiism (i.e. the "shiism" that MI6 is pleased with and propagates) is wrong.

Edited by islamicmusic
  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
31 minutes ago, islamicmusic said:

Salam. The term British Shiism does not stand for Shia Muslims that happen to be from and/or live in Britain. It means the "shiites" working for the global agendas of the Biritish Regime. If a so-called "shiite" hates a sincere but misguided sunni over let's say their rejecting imamate. Yet that "shiite" loves and kisses the hand of the British Queen and claims she is one of the Ahlulbayt (reference to Yasir Habib guy). That surely is not the shia of Ali bin Abu Talib. Rather he is shia of MI6.

Same goes for sunnis. You know the term "Islam-e Amrikai" (American Islam or American Sunnism) also does not refer to the Sunni Muslim brethren living in the USA. Rather it stands for the so-called "sunnis" working for the agendas of USA and NATO.

I did not watch the video but having seen his old videos, I don't think the tattoo sheikh would know about the term and what it stands for and how the British Shiism (i.e. the "shiism" that MI6 is pleased with and propagates) is wrong.

Is there any proof for his kissing and saying that she is one of Ahlulbayt? And if there is then how do you connect it to MI6? 

Edited by Abu Nur
  • Advanced Member
Posted
3 hours ago, Abu Hadi said:

Actually I haven't. It's a ridiculous claim. 

Almost every single action taken by Imam Khomeni went directly against the interests of MI6. Why would they support him. 

Makes no sense. 

MI6 / CIA have a single purpose vis a via the institution of Marjaa3at. They have been very consistent in this

The single purpose is to have marjaa' who are apparently alim and adl but behind the scenes take their orders from London or Washington. Imam Khomeni never took his orders from London or Washington. That is obvious to both his friends and enemies. If he gained power with the help of the MI6, then this was their most spectacular failure in all of history. 

Sorry, I think according to the rumours, the CIA, not the MI6, was involved.


Please take a look at this and let me know what you think.

 

  • Moderators
Posted
7 hours ago, islamicmusic said:

 

I did not watch the video but having seen his old videos, I don't think the tattoo sheikh would know about the term and what it stands for and how the British Shiism (i.e. the "shiism" that MI6 is pleased with and propagates) is wrong.

It's surprising you claim that he doesn't know what it is. I thought you guys claimed that he was part of the conspiracy. 

  • Advanced Member
Posted
On 7/30/2022 at 4:19 AM, -Rejector- said:

Salam alaikom

For those of you who haven't watched Sayed Ammar's latest majles and want to, here's the link: 

What did you guys think about it? It's a pretty controversial topic to tackle. I'm surprised the Sayed chose a topic so disuniting. But nevertheless, it was a good majles, the Sayed seemed pretty neutral about it, neither extreme one way nor the other. I like how he went into the history of Shi'ism in the UK and started off with the first majalis to be taking place. He went into a bit of detail about the Shirazis and the Iranian religious authorities such as Ayatollah Khomeini (r) and Ayatollah Khamenei (h). But he didn't show open support for one side or the other. And I'm surprised he didn't go into more detail about Sheikh Yasser Al-Habib and those at the Rafida+ channel. Nevertheless, it was a good majles.

What did you think?

It was a good majlis. Topic was controversial yet equitably explained.

  • Forum Administrators
Posted

I watched it all the way through.

  1. He gave a listing of the first majalis in the UK from the 1960s onwards, by location and organiser.
    1. The point was about how modest they were and how everyone was welcoming/welcomed. Must say he did go on a bit about inane details.
    2. He felt that the contributions of the organisers should be better acknowledged. He seemed to be suggesting that others are and these people are not.
  2. A fair bit of the speech was about Khomeini/Shirazi differences and the derogatory labels supporters may attach to each other
    1. He acknowledged the importance of the 1979 revolution and the leading role of Ayat Khomeini
    2. He identified some differences between Ayatollah Shirazi and Ayatollah Khomeini e.g. Wilayat al Faqih
    3. He said that Ayat. Khomeini had placed Ayat. Shirazi under house arrest
      1. Without any context, the above sounds a bit drastic. Looking back the 1979 revolution the leadership of Ayat. Khomeini is nowadays taken for granted. I am not sure that was entirely the case while the revolution was happening and Ayat. Khomeini was facing some challenges from a range of sources.
      2. I am attaching a newspaper clipping (Times of London) from the period, which illustrates this. (OK my scrap-booking skills were't great, but I was only 12).
      3. So I am not surprised Ayat. Khomeini placed people under house arrest.
    4. Nakshwani went on to say that followers may exaggerate differences of their leaders and how Sheikh Shomali of the Islamic Centre of England had tried to reconcile the two groups.
      1. A sub-thread was his involvement with Imam Hussain TV and people criticising him for auctioning khak-e-shifa. This was likely because Imam Hussain TV is linked to the Shirazi group.
      2. He felt it was noteworthy how quickly the online critical campaign had taken off.
      3. He also defended his actions in the sense that it was not really a sale, that people sell khak-e-shifa in Iraq and the mar'je don't complain.
    5. The conclusion was that people should be more accepting of what may be relatively small differences and anyway the mar'je are no infallible
  3. Another theme was about British Shia labelling Britain as 'Shaitan', this being a sign of 'ingratitude' and his call for them to go back to Pakistan or Iran (which would not take them in anyway).
    1. I feel this is a kind of racism.
      1. White Britons can be critical of the socio/economic/political direction the country is taking without having their patriotism questioned. White Britons can protest for changes to be made to the socio-economic-cultural environment without being questioned for challenging Britishness, so why can't Muslim Britons be critical as well?

IMG_0619.jpg

  • Advanced Member
Posted
1 hour ago, Haji 2003 said:
  • He identified some differences between Ayatollah Shirazi and Ayatollah Khomeini e.g. Wilayat al Faqih
  • He said that Ayat. Khomeini had placed Ayat. Shirazi under house arrest
    1. Without any context, the above sounds a bit drastic. Looking back the 1979 revolution the leadership of Ayat. Khomeini is nowadays taken for granted. I am not sure that was entirely the case while the revolution was happening and Ayat. Khomeini was facing some challenges from a range of sources.
    2. I am attaching a newspaper clipping (Times of London) from the period, which illustrates this. (OK my scrap-booking skills were't great, but I was only 12).
    3. So I am not surprised Ayat. Khomeini placed people under house arrest.

Salam this is forging of history by SAN because in opposite of his claim Wilayat al Faqih has been differnce between Ayatollah Khomein (رضي الله عنه)  & Ayatollah Kazem Shariat-Madari which his name clearly has been mentioned in Times o London which Ayatollah Shiraz has been supporter of Wilayat al Faqih although he has wanted it only for himself.

which "Ayat. Khomeini had placed Ayat. Shirazi under house arrest" for insulting to Wilayat al Faqih & martyrs of Iran revolution which also he has put Ayatollah Kazem Shariat-Madari under house arrest for supporting Nojeh coup plot & sadiq Qutbzadeh  for overthrowing revolution & founding terrorist cult of " Khalq e Musalman" by support of America which it has been mentioned by Times of London

https://www.rouydad24.ir/fa/news/193739/آیت-الله-شریعتمداری-مرجع-تقلیدی-که-در-حصر-خانگی-درگذشت

https://www.alef.ir/news/3960627153.html

http://www.socio-shia.com/index.php/sociology-of-shia-fields/shia-ulama/351-حبس-خانگی-مراجع

  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
12 hours ago, Abu Nur said:

Is there any proof for his kissing and saying that she is one of Ahlulbayt? And if there is then how do you connect it to MI6? 

https://www.shiatv.net/video/2051387797

There was a clip in this documentary. I don't know the exact minute but the whole thing is beneficial anyway.

Also:

https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235045387-al-arour-al-habib-served-us-better-than-anyone/?do=findComment&comment=3001854

Edited by islamicmusic
  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
14 hours ago, islamicmusic said:

Salam. The term British Shiism does not stand for Shia Muslims that happen to be from and/or live in Britain. It means the "shiites" working for the global agendas of the Biritish Regime. If a so-called "shiite" hates a sincere but misguided sunni over let's say their rejecting imamate. Yet that "shiite" loves and kisses the hand of the British Queen and claims she is one of the Ahlulbayt (reference to Yasir Habib guy). That surely is not the shia of Ali bin Abu Talib. Rather he is shia of MI6.

Same goes for sunnis. You know the term "Islam-e Amrikai" (American Islam or American Sunnism) also does not refer to the Sunni Muslim brethren living in the USA. Rather it stands for the so-called "sunnis" working for the agendas of USA and NATO.

I did not watch the video but having seen his old videos, I don't think the tattoo sheikh would know about the term and what it stands for and how the British Shiism (i.e. the "shiism" that MI6 is pleased with and propagates) is wrong.

OK. I was referring to the way Sayyid Ammar uses the term in the video, not the way it is used in the context you are talking about. He titles the video 'British Shiism' but what he actually talks about in the video, the vast majority of it (including the history, the original masjids, etc, which was my favorite part and something I learned from this video) was Shias who happen to live in Britain. Maybe a better title might have been 'British Shiism vs. Shias in Britain'. 

The 'American Islam' vs. Muslims who live in America is actually much more extensive and would probably require it's own topic. It is a truly vast topic and I think most of the brothers and sisters, if they heard it, would just get extremely sad and I don't know how much benefit it would be to talk about it. Allah Alim. The MI6 is the CIAs much smaller little brother. The only people here who could probably understand what the CIA does in the US is the Iranian brothers and sisters, and the older ones, 50s and up, because they did the same thing in Iran prior to the 1979 revolution. For everyone else, it just might be better for your mental health if you don't know. I studied this topic extensively for 5 years and stopped studying it because it was affecting my own mental health. 

Edited by Abu Hadi
  • Forum Administrators
Posted
22 hours ago, Abu Hadi said:

So when Sayyid Hassan or Imam Khameni accuses certain 'ulema' (notice the air quotes) who live in the UK of being agents of CIA / MI6, they have both a logical basis and evidentiary basis to do that.

Before I return my scrapbooks to the archive, this is from Robert Fisk, written at the time of the revolution:

IMG_0620.jpg

 

  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Abu Hadi said:

The 'American Islam' vs. Muslims who live in America is actually much more extensive and would probably require it's own topic. It is a truly vast topic and I think most of the brothers and sisters, if they heard it, would just get extremely sad and I don't know how much benefit it would be to talk about it. Allah Alim. The MI6 is the CIAs much smaller little brother. The only people here who could probably understand what the CIA does in the US is the Iranian brothers and sisters, and the older ones, 50s and up, because they did the same thing in Iran prior to the 1979 revolution. For everyone else, it just might be better for your mental health if you don't know. I studied this topic extensively for 5 years and stopped studying it because it was affecting my own mental health. 

There is this late muslim scholar in Turkey with sunni origins who wrote a comprehensive book in 1988-1989 on American Islam and its history, strategies, links and all else. I wish one day it is translated into English.

I don't know if google translate will work but here is the book: Interrogation of the American Islam

Edited by islamicmusic
  • Advanced Member
Posted

These people will throw around phrases like "British Shi'ism"/"American Sunnism" or "Marg bar America"/"Marg bar Engleez" and then get surprised when they receive pushback. It's clear only to those of us who have read into what you mean when you throw these phrases around. Can you blame the average American for questioning why all these people are calling for "Death to America?" Can you blame the layman Shi'i in the UK to question why they are being attacked for being a "British Shi'a?" 

If you have a problem with the Shirazi followers of London who are known for their anti-Sunni rhetoric then make it clear you are referring to them instead of lumping all "British Shi'as" together. If you mean death to the US's foreign policies then make it clear in a way it doesn't seem like you're calling for the destruction of an entire country. Sayed Ammar even mentioned at around the 55 minute mark to be clear exactly who you are referring to.

SAN is trying to point out that even if there are disagreements within the community, you shouldn't cause it to disunite you. If I have a problem with IRI's foreign policies will their supporters make takfir on me?

  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
12 hours ago, islamicmusic said:
12 hours ago, islamicmusic said:

https://www.shiatv.net/video/2051387797 klo

There was a clip in this documentary. I don't know the exact minute but the whole thing is beneficial anyway.

Also:

https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235045387-al-arour-al-habib-served-us-better-than-anyone/?do=findComment&comment=3001854

There was a clip in this documentary. I don't know the exact minute but the whole thing is beneficial anyway.

Also:

https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235045387-al-arour-al-habib-served-us-better-than-anyone/?do=findComment&comment=3001854

I still don't get how it is related to MI6. What he referred is usually to Asylum when he said about aisha. Happens many times in muslim lands. 

The only thing that I really don't like is the hatred and insult between the two groups and it seems it will never be resolved. 

Edited by Abu Nur
  • Advanced Member
Posted
On 7/31/2022 at 3:05 PM, Jaabir said:

If I have a problem with IRI's foreign policies will their supporters make takfir on me?

Salam certainly no anyway at end of day  IRI's foreign policies always have been in favor of all shia muslims around the world especially in Britain  which even Ahlulbayt Tv has made a documentary about black shia muslims in formm of series of dcumentaries in America which in one of them has shown that Iran revolution & it's foreign policyhas caused reviving of shia migrants in America to their roots which surely in similar fashion it also happened for shia migrants in Britain too although some of them in documentaries have not agreed with  IRI's foreign policies .

On 7/31/2022 at 3:25 AM, Haji 2003 said:

White Britons can be critical of the socio/economic/political direction the country is taking without having their patriotism questioned. White Britons can protest for changes to be made to the socio-economic-cultural environment without being questioned for challenging Britishness, so why can't Muslim Britons be critical as well?

this is totally wrong conclusion which it seems SAN lives in a Lalaland which anyway patriotism in Britain is lesser than America anyway for centuries residents of Ireland & wales & scotland forcefully have been called as Britons which they only could  reach to semi independant from Britain by bloody wars which it leads to weakening patriotism in Britain so therefore criticizing "socio/economic/political direction" in controlled areas by Britain has not been a peacful process which last patriots in Britain are mainly head skins & some white supremacist Britons .

Patriotism in Britain reduces with each generation

Quote

Britain may briefly have felt patriotic in 2012, when Jubilee parties and the London Olympics stirred a dormant pride, but even in the past decade there’s been a significant drop in patriotism, and when YouGov tested the nation on the 'Life in the UK' exam that all aspiring immigrants must pass to gain citizenship, 51% of young people failed.

 

Quote

British people may become more patriotic as they grow older, but 18-24 year-olds are so much less as likely than over-60s to be 'very' patriotic (15% compared to 49%) that even if a significant proportion of the younger generation turn proud in their old age, this cohort will still be considerably less patriotic than today's older generation.

 

Quote

But in comparison to Germany, where history has weakened the appeal of national pride and patriotism has become associated with the far-right (the Pegida movement stands for "Patriotic Europeans Against the Islamisation of the West"), Britain seems positively patriotic. In Germany, only 9% say they are very patriotic. 

 

Quote

The most patriotic nation surveyed is Thailand (58% say they are very patriotic), where the popular king is seen as a stabilising force in a politically fractured society.

 

Quote

Most of the countries surveyed have similar levels of mild patriotism – the proportions choosing 'slightly' patriotic fall within an 11 point range of the average (35%) – and most countries are unlikely to say they are not at all patriotic. Actual non-patriotism (choosing 'not very' or 'not at all' patriotic), however, is relatively high in other Asia-Pacific nations.

The surveys were carried out by YouGov UK, YouGov Germany, YouGov America and YouGov Asia Pacific. Asia-Pac surveys representative of online populations.

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2015/07/14/decline-british-patriotism

How Britain got its patriotism back

From the monarchy to fashion to old-fashioned food, British culture is brimming with pride. But is there a dark side to this new patriotism?
Quote

Where does the mood of inward-looking, self-contented British patriotism that Cameron has gratified come from? Is the collective emotion that Cameron's anti-European stance unleashed an atavistic throwback to Churchillian "bulldog spirit"? Is it home-counties pub-talk bigotry? The respectable equivalent of far-right thuggery? It is none of these things. Cameron spoke to a very modern mood, widely shared across traditional party allegiances, that is not backward-looking but self-consciously contemporary, not coarse but sophisticated. He is surfing the wave of the new British cultural nationalism.

 

Quote

But consider this. One of the spectacular growth areas in modern British culture is the rise of popular history. Television history has no more eloquent exponent than David Starkey. There might seem a terrible gulf between Starkey's brilliant insights into the politics and personalities of Henry VIII's reign and his remarks on the riots this summer. But his historical imagination bridges that gap: he apparently does see the Britain whose history he has studied and popularized as "monocultural". In the pleasures of patriotism lurk the demons of nationalism.

https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2011/dec/17/jonathan-jones-britain-new-patriotism

  • 1 month later...
  • Advanced Member
Posted

A. Nakshawani said, "The Emir of the Believers would be proud of countries like Canada." He says emphatic insistence by Westerners that Muslims accept LGBTQIA+ culture and gay marriage isn't a form of Islamophobia. He and Payam Mohseni belong to the Iran Project at Harvard Kennedy School's Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs. This is an American think tank that attempts to anatomize the inner-workings of Shi'i psychology, Shi'i political thought, Shi'i allegiances, MENA and Islamic culture etc. so as to realign regional policy in a way that bolsters US, Israeli and British foreign policy efforts. I recently read an online article where he was advising American policy makers on how to entice revivalist movements like Hezbollah, Houthis, Mahdi Army, Hamas etc. away from Tehran by giving them financial incentives and shifting alliances from Riyadh to Najaf (hence neutralizing Qom as a hub of Shi'i influence).

  • Advanced Member
Posted

Hot off the press / released about 13 hours ago "The Crimes of Nakshawani / MI6 Shi'ism Exposed" Islamic Pulse 3 Muzaffer Hyder (53 minutes) 

  • Advanced Member
Posted
7 minutes ago, Eddie Mecca said:

A. Nakshawani said, "The Emir of the Believers would be proud of countries like Canada."

Please provide proof that he said this. I highly doubt it.

12 minutes ago, Eddie Mecca said:

He says emphatic insistence by Westerners that Muslims accept LGBTQIA+ culture and gay marriage isn't a form of Islamophobia.

Provide proof for this too, please.

16 minutes ago, Eddie Mecca said:

He and Payam Mohseni belong to the Iran Project at Harvard Kennedy School's Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs. This is an American think tank that attempts to anatomize the inner-workings of Shi'i psychology, Shi'i political thought, Shi'i allegiances, MENA and Islamic culture etc. so as to realign regional policy in a way that bolsters US, Israeli and British foreign policy efforts. I recently read an online article where he was advising American policy makers on how to entice revivalist movements like Hezbollah, Houthis, Mahdi Army, Hamas etc. away from Tehran by giving them financial incentives and shifting alliances from Riyadh to Najaf (hence neutralizing Qom as a hub of Shi'i influence).

I don't know where you're getting your information from, but I think you should try reading sources from Sayed Ammar Nakshawani's side as well.

34 minutes ago, Eddie Mecca said:

Hot off the press / released about 13 hours ago "The Crimes of Nakshawani / MI6 Shi'ism Exposed" Islamic Pulse 3 Muzaffer Hyder (53 minutes) 

 

I got to admit, it was a very persuading video. But the speaker focused on some of Sayed Ammar's words and ignored others. Sayed Ammar does promote Sunni-Shia unity (whether or not he actually acts on that is another question, but he at least makes an effort to speak about things in an academic way, unlike Yasser Al-Habib). 

I personally do admit that there is a clear problem with 'British Shi'ism', but I'm not sure if Sayed Ammar is a big part of it. (He's not exactly helping his case, though). 

But, at the end of the day, Ayatollah Khamenei is the faqeeh, he is the wakeel. He is, in the words of Sayed Hasan Nasrallah, the Husayn of this age. 

  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, -Rejector- said:

I don't know where you're getting your information from, but I think you should try reading sources from Sayed Ammar Nakshawani's side as well.

His expressions are very sly and tricky. He's a craftsman and a wordsmith despite ending every third sentence with the signature "ISN'T IT??!!". He's basically reasoning with the Americans, British and Israelis to drop the Sunni Gulf client monarchies and begin wooing the Shi'a world with shiny tidbits and crumbs from the master's table. His contention is that the Shi'a are naturally more responsible, reliable, logical and trustworthy partners in crime (especially when compared to their Wahhabi Khaleeji counterparts). He's maintaining that if the Shi'a start getting Western support and favorable regional clout and this creates socioeconomic upliftment...the (Shia) masses' reliance and zeal for the fiery brand of Persian Shi'ism will naturally wane and the militant revivalist movements will dissolve quietly into the annals of history. The group dynamic then can be contained and placated with a neutered form of the religion. The Shi'a Crescent region won't have time for talk of  revolutionary fervor because they'll be too busy with the material distractions of life.  

Edited by Eddie Mecca
  • Veteran Member
Posted (edited)

:salam:

4 hours ago, Eddie Mecca said:

Hot off the press / released about 13 hours ago "The Crimes of Nakshawani / MI6 Shi'ism Exposed" Islamic Pulse 3 Muzaffer Hyder (53 minutes) 

 

Great job. SAN's lecture was so dishonest, it feels good to hear someone tackle each of his words and 'dissect' them.

Thank you brother Muzaffer. You spoke my mind literally. 

That Ennio Morricone remix soundtrack is nice too. 

Edited by realizm
Posted
5 hours ago, Eddie Mecca said:

Hot off the press / released about 13 hours ago "The Crimes of Nakshawani / MI6 Shi'ism Exposed" Islamic Pulse 3 Muzaffer Hyder (53 minutes) 

 

Huh. I’m honestly kind of surprised, just based on the admittedly small amount I’ve seen of your thoughts in general, to see you into this sort of content. 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...