Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

'Inshallah': Biden praised by Muslim Americans but accused of cultural appropriation for using Arabic phrase

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

  • Advanced Member (With Brothers Forum Membership)

'Inshallah': Biden praised by Muslim Americans but accused of cultural appropriation for using Arabic phrase

 
 
Graig Graziosi
Thu, October 1, 2020, 6:41 AM CDT
 
 
Joe Biden stirred up both praise and criticism on social media after using the Arabic and Farsi phrase
Joe Biden stirred up both praise and criticism on social media after using the Arabic and Farsi phrase

One of Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden's most well-known character traits is his colourful way of speaking; sometimes he's telling stories about being a teenager at a swimming pool, sometimes he's reminiscing about how his dad used to drive cars, sometimes he's putting his foot in his mouth, and sometimes he's resurrecting decades old words like "malarkey" and plastering them across buses.

During Tuesday night's debates, he added a new phrase to his ever shifting lexicon - "Inshallah."

Mr Biden deployed the phrase in a testy exchange with Donald Trump regarding his still-unreleased tax returns.

"Millions of dollars, and you'll get to see it," Mr Trump said, when asked how much he paid in taxes.

 

"When?" Mr Biden replied. "Inshallah?"

The invocation of the Arabic phrase by the 77-year-old, white, Roman Catholic man from Pennsylvania, did not go unnoticed on social media.

Mr Biden's campaign confirmed later on Tuesday that yes, he did use inshallah to respond to Mr Trump about his tax returns.

The phrase means "God willing" in Arabic and Farsi, but is used more colloquially as a non-committal response, akin to "not going to happen", "if it ever happens," or as writer Wajahat Ali put it, the "Arabic version of fuggedaboudit."

Reaction to his use of the phrase was mixed. Some found it endearing that a political candidate was using Arab American colloquialisms on the national stage, while others criticised his use, likening it to transparent and insulting pandering, or, worse, as disrespectful to Mulsims.

Sahid Hamid, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institute and a contributing writer at The Atlantic, was pleased with Mr Biden's use of the phrase.

"If my parents had told me when I was growing up that a major presidential candidate would one day say the words 'inshallah' in a nationally televised debate, I would have assumed they were crazy. But anything is possible in 2020," he wrote.

Bas, a rapper in Queens, New York who is French with Sudanese heritage, praised Mr Biden as well.

“Did Biden just hit him with a ‘inshallah’? That's all I needed to hear!!" he wrote.

On the other side, some users were already imagining the meandering op-eds explaining how an elderly white man using an Arabic phrase counts as representation.

“Whoever’s writing that op-ed about feeling seen because Biden said ‘inshallah,’ I urge you to spare your community the embarrassment please,” Asad Dandia, a Columbia University graduate student, tweeted.

Meriam Masmoudi, a political activist, likened the phrase to table scraps being tossed to the American Muslim community at a time when violence against them has been increasing throughout the country.

"It's so disheartening that the best thing the Biden campaign seems to be able to offer Muslim Americans in the midst of an uptick in islamophobic violence is an offhand, completely inappropriately applied 'inshallah' in the debate," she wrote.

Though the US Muslim population is relatively small - only about 1 per cent of the US electorate - they account for large populations in swing states like Michigan, Ohio and Florida.

Over the summer, Mr Biden held a virtual meeting with more than 3,000 Muslim leaders through the Emgage Action advocacy group.

During the meeting, he said he wished public schools did more to educate students on the Islamic faith.

"One of the things that I think is important: I wish, I wish we taught more in our schools about the Islamic faith," Mr Biden said. "What people don't realise is ... we all come from the same root here, in terms of our fundamental basic beliefs."

He has also pledged to end Mr Trump's controversial "Muslim ban" on the first day of his presidency.

Read more

The Latest: Biden says he would represent all Americans

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting.
 
 
 
 
 
5f74bacb6f94b955feeb163a_o_U_v2.jpg
 

NATO allies spar over Nagorno-Karabakh fighting

Intensifying conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan this week is dividing NATO allies. On Wednesday (September 30), France and Turkey sparred over the fighting in the region of Nagorno-Karabakh, deepening concerns outside powers could be drawn into it. Nagorno-Karabakh is a breakaway region in Azerbaijan run by ethnic Armenians. The two sides are waging their fiercest battles over it since the mid-1990s. Dozens have been reported killed and hundreds wounded, and fighting -- using heavy artillery -- has spread beyond the enclave's borders. Threatening to spill into all-out war between Azerbaijan and Armenia. These young Azeri men are queuing up to enlist. Both countries have declared martial law and mobilised their male populations. Turkey's foreign minister, Mevlut Cavusoglu, said Wednesday Ankara would 'do what is necessary', when asked if it would give military support to its ally, Azerbaijan, if requested. French President Emmanuel Macron, whose country is home to many people of Armenian ancestry, hit back at Turkey's, quote, "warlike" rhetoric. Armenia has another powerful ally in Moscow. Meanwhile, Armenia's unified information centre, an online governmental platform, posted pictures of the wreckage of what it said was a SU-25 warplane shot down by a Turkish fighter jet on Tuesday. Turkey denied downing the plane. A senior Azeri official accused Armenia of lying, saying two of its SU-25s had in fact crashed into a mountain

 
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Veteran Member
2 hours ago, Lion of Shia said:

Though the US Muslim population is relatively small - only about 1 per cent of the US electorate - they account for large populations in swing states like Michigan, Ohio and Florida.

THlS is the part that makes me suspicious.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, Lion of Shia said:

'Inshallah': Biden praised by Muslim Americans but accused of cultural appropriation for using Arabic phrase

 
 
Graig Graziosi
Thu, October 1, 2020, 6:41 AM CDT
 
 
Joe Biden stirred up both praise and criticism on social media after using the Arabic and Farsi phrase
Joe Biden stirred up both praise and criticism on social media after using the Arabic and Farsi phrase

One of Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden's most well-known character traits is his colourful way of speaking; sometimes he's telling stories about being a teenager at a swimming pool, sometimes he's reminiscing about how his dad used to drive cars, sometimes he's putting his foot in his mouth, and sometimes he's resurrecting decades old words like "malarkey" and plastering them across buses.

During Tuesday night's debates, he added a new phrase to his ever shifting lexicon - "Inshallah."

Mr Biden deployed the phrase in a testy exchange with Donald Trump regarding his still-unreleased tax returns.

"Millions of dollars, and you'll get to see it," Mr Trump said, when asked how much he paid in taxes.

 

"When?" Mr Biden replied. "Inshallah?"

The invocation of the Arabic phrase by the 77-year-old, white, Roman Catholic man from Pennsylvania, did not go unnoticed on social media.

Mr Biden's campaign confirmed later on Tuesday that yes, he did use inshallah to respond to Mr Trump about his tax returns.

The phrase means "God willing" in Arabic and Farsi, but is used more colloquially as a non-committal response, akin to "not going to happen", "if it ever happens," or as writer Wajahat Ali put it, the "Arabic version of fuggedaboudit."

Reaction to his use of the phrase was mixed. Some found it endearing that a political candidate was using Arab American colloquialisms on the national stage, while others criticised his use, likening it to transparent and insulting pandering, or, worse, as disrespectful to Mulsims.

Sahid Hamid, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institute and a contributing writer at The Atlantic, was pleased with Mr Biden's use of the phrase.

"If my parents had told me when I was growing up that a major presidential candidate would one day say the words 'inshallah' in a nationally televised debate, I would have assumed they were crazy. But anything is possible in 2020," he wrote.

Bas, a rapper in Queens, New York who is French with Sudanese heritage, praised Mr Biden as well.

“Did Biden just hit him with a ‘inshallah’? That's all I needed to hear!!" he wrote.

On the other side, some users were already imagining the meandering op-eds explaining how an elderly white man using an Arabic phrase counts as representation.

“Whoever’s writing that op-ed about feeling seen because Biden said ‘inshallah,’ I urge you to spare your community the embarrassment please,” Asad Dandia, a Columbia University graduate student, tweeted.

Meriam Masmoudi, a political activist, likened the phrase to table scraps being tossed to the American Muslim community at a time when violence against them has been increasing throughout the country.

"It's so disheartening that the best thing the Biden campaign seems to be able to offer Muslim Americans in the midst of an uptick in islamophobic violence is an offhand, completely inappropriately applied 'inshallah' in the debate," she wrote.

Though the US Muslim population is relatively small - only about 1 per cent of the US electorate - they account for large populations in swing states like Michigan, Ohio and Florida.

Over the summer, Mr Biden held a virtual meeting with more than 3,000 Muslim leaders through the Emgage Action advocacy group.

During the meeting, he said he wished public schools did more to educate students on the Islamic faith.

"One of the things that I think is important: I wish, I wish we taught more in our schools about the Islamic faith," Mr Biden said. "What people don't realise is ... we all come from the same root here, in terms of our fundamental basic beliefs."

He has also pledged to end Mr Trump's controversial "Muslim ban" on the first day of his presidency.

Read more

The Latest: Biden says he would represent all Americans

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting.
 
 
 
 
 
5f74bacb6f94b955feeb163a_o_U_v2.jpg
 

NATO allies spar over Nagorno-Karabakh fighting

Intensifying conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan this week is dividing NATO allies. On Wednesday (September 30), France and Turkey sparred over the fighting in the region of Nagorno-Karabakh, deepening concerns outside powers could be drawn into it. Nagorno-Karabakh is a breakaway region in Azerbaijan run by ethnic Armenians. The two sides are waging their fiercest battles over it since the mid-1990s. Dozens have been reported killed and hundreds wounded, and fighting -- using heavy artillery -- has spread beyond the enclave's borders. Threatening to spill into all-out war between Azerbaijan and Armenia. These young Azeri men are queuing up to enlist. Both countries have declared martial law and mobilised their male populations. Turkey's foreign minister, Mevlut Cavusoglu, said Wednesday Ankara would 'do what is necessary', when asked if it would give military support to its ally, Azerbaijan, if requested. French President Emmanuel Macron, whose country is home to many people of Armenian ancestry, hit back at Turkey's, quote, "warlike" rhetoric. Armenia has another powerful ally in Moscow. Meanwhile, Armenia's unified information centre, an online governmental platform, posted pictures of the wreckage of what it said was a SU-25 warplane shot down by a Turkish fighter jet on Tuesday. Turkey denied downing the plane. A senior Azeri official accused Armenia of lying, saying two of its SU-25s had in fact crashed into a mountain

 

This "cultural appropriation" thing annoys the hell out of me.

White person does anything resembling another culture or anything Non-White.

Twitter Gestapo: White Supremacy! Hate Crime! Cancel! Cultural appropriation!

Like Damn, where did these mentally ill people even come from. I don't remember them 10 years ago.

Edited by El Cid
Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, El Cid said:

This "cultural appropriation" thing annoys the hell out of me.

White person does anything resembling another culture or anything Non-White.

Twitter Gestapo: White Supremacy! Hate Crime! Cancel! Cultural appropriation!

Like Damn, where did these mentally ill people even come from. I don't remember them 10 years ago.

For once we agree. Tragically I can’t “like” your post, as the mods took away my rating ability months ago.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Haji 2003 changed the title to 'Inshallah': Biden praised by Muslim Americans but accused of cultural appropriation for using Arabic phrase
  • Forum Administrators

Bear in mind that the notion that matters may not be completely within our control is an important one, there no equivalent word in English and it's better than people ascribing a positive outcome to luck.

So I am quite happy when colleagues at work use it in front of me.

Cultural appropriation criticisms are perhaps understandable where someone starts to claim something is theirs culturally, when it isn't.

But Inshallah can only ever have one origin.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Advanced Member

Very dangerous when liberals speak for us. I'm more offended by them saying my religion is a "culture", and that some people need to back off of what we do. Is it cultural appropriation when non Muslims fast on Ramadan to understand us better?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...