Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله
313 Seeker

Marjas are Fallible

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

22 minutes ago, Mohammadi_follower said:

I was in fact sarcastic and talking about people coming from nowhere and saying in internet that they have probably more knowledges that some marjas who studed Islam all their lifes.

Well this can happen. For instant a wahabi scholar studying all his life could be wrong about things while a 7 year old girl on the internet could be right about it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, ali_fatheroforphans said:

They do have a book which explains the reasoning behind every rule, however the books are in Arabic.

That's what I've heard.

Interesting mystery book. In my opinion  their public opinions shouldn't be detached from immediate reasoning from Qur'an and hadiths. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, 313 Seeker said:

In my opinion  their public opinions shouldn't be detached from immediate reasoning from Qur'an and hadiths

I don't think it's possible to provide the entire reasoning for every rule. People generally aren't interested in how a ruling is derived. Neither do they have the knowledge needed to understand the derivation. For example, many people do not have an understanding of the system of grading of hadith or ilm al rijal, specially somewhat less relegious people. So it's going to be very complicated and beyond the understanding of a common man to understand how a ruling is derived. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, 313 Seeker said:

and change their opinions about things. 

Please elaborate what do you mean by "things" here? Are you talking about religious rulings here? For newly evolved things they do ijtihaad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
37 minutes ago, Mohammadi_follower said:

We are not talking about wahabis but about Shia marjas.

Scholars of Islam who all think they are right about everything, while they might be about some things and wrong about others. Shia like Muslim is just a name but no guarantee. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, ahlulbayt_72 said:

I don't think it's possible to provide the entire reasoning for every rule. People generally aren't interested in how a ruling is derived. Neither do they have the knowledge needed to understand the derivation. For example, many people do not have an understanding of the system of grading of hadith or ilm al rijal, specially somewhat less relegious people. So it's going to be very complicated and beyond the understanding of a common man to understand how a ruling is derived. 

People should be encouraged to think and reflect and understand. Reasoning should be given even if on a very simple level according to Qur'an and known hadiths. People who follow blindly are destined to failure. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
36 minutes ago, Urwatul Wuthqa said:

Please elaborate what do you mean by "things" here? Are you talking about religious rulings here? For newly evolved things they do ijtihaad.

Any religious opinion. If a person spends 50 years without realizing any mistakes in their beliefs, then they must be wrong. Every normal human must have epiphanies, revelations, etc.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, 313 Seeker said:

People should be encouraged to think and reflect and understand. Reasoning should be given even if on a very simple level according to Qur'an and known hadiths. People who follow blindly are destined to failure. 

People do not do Taqleed for aqeedah. It's only done for Fiqh matters. And it's not blind. You have the option of becoming Mujtahid yourself. If you can't then search for the person you think is the most knowledgeable. They present information in the most simplistic way possible, for the benefit of common man. Then if you wish to go into depth you have the option of inquiring 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, 313 Seeker said:

Interesting mystery book. In my opinion  their public opinions shouldn't be detached from immediate reasoning from Qur'an and hadiths. 

It’s not a mystery book but takes many years of study & need huge amount of money to be translated & published but it’s not mysterious & forbidden also even it publishes you must spend your lifetime like a marjato understand it but you befit it from its results on internet & think that you know everything better than a Marja.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, 313 Seeker said:

@OrthodoxTruth and @ali_fatheroforphans

Did you ever think about what the Marjas teaching you in a more critical sense? Most of the time they don’t share the Qur'an/ hadith reasoning behind their rulings.

In the written scholarly works, they usually do. You can always request a reasoning behind particular fatwa from the office. 

6 hours ago, 313 Seeker said:

Maybe they are wrong about more than 1%. Did you ever hear about a scholar who realized something that contradicts his past beliefs? 

Brother, as explained before, they don’t claim infallibility. From the past till present and event the future, they will issue a fatwa on fiqh related themes, and some may retract or change the previous ruling. It is a normal process. That’s because they aren’t infallible.. I will give you a simple example. Shortly after the Islamic Revolution, Ayatollah Khomeini (may Allah be pleased with him) ruled chess haram, this is a traditional position of our ulama, in 1988 he revised his view and ruled them halal as long as the game doesn’t involve betting and doesn’t constitute gambling. Other marājiʿ, for example Ayatollah Sistani (may Allah prolong his life), rule them to be haram under any conditions. They are mujtahids who interpret sharia laws and they don’t have to agree with each other, neither they ever claim to be sinless or incapable of making mistakes or revision of judgment. However, we follow them because they have enormous knowledge acquired over the period of their entire lifes and therefore serve as a bridge between us and the Imamah.

6 hours ago, Mohammadi_follower said:

The main problem of our time is the raising of ayatollah made in google.

This. Internet became some sort of a blessing and a curse at the same time. Many people can’t understand or even read the Qur'an in Classical Arabic, but they take on marājiʿ after reading few books or articles... written by ulama, or their self-derived understanding of things. 

7 hours ago, 313 Seeker said:

I think it is healthy to question our scholars because they are fallible. It is not like questioning God who is infallible. 

Nobody states that you can’t question the rulings of marājiʿ, that’s why you have nowadays over 70 to choose from. In this sense, we are blessed to live in this time and age because in the past the title of marja’ was reserved and unique only for  very few individuals living at the same time, and in majority of countries or regions even so confined only upon one worthy individual. You keep repeating like mantra that they are fallible... 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
36 minutes ago, realizm said:

:salam:

ما شاء الله

This was a controversial thing and some disagree with the election of Sayyid Khamenei for the position of the leader. They raise an argument that there were way more knowledgeable people of the ulama to take over after the demise of Ayatollah Khomeini (may Allah bless him). Sayyid Khamenei, at that time at least, was supposedly only a Hujjat al-Islam, so the election itself was de facto invalid because according to then constitution, shortly afterwards amended, the leader could only be a marja’ “or paramount in fiqh”. Hence why the Sayyid pointed out at that particular moment that he wasn’t knowledgeable enough. The rest is history.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...