Robert Spencer rebuttal/exposed (part 1)

[AmirioTheMuzzy]

Error Count: 2

[AmirioTheMuzzy]

Discussion

Crosspost:

OP:

Let's discuss it here on Shiachat as well.

[baqar]

The guy rebutting Spencer makes a good point in regard to the word "terror" in that effectively it is a mis-translation of the Arabic text. 

But by the way, has he issued more videos on the subject?

[AmirioTheMuzzy]

19 hours ago, baqar said:

The guy rebutting Spencer makes a good point in regard to the word "terror" in that effectively it is a mis-translation of the Arabic text. 

But by the way, has he issued more videos on the subject?

Yes and no... he has made great rebuttals to other Islamaphobes in the past with his "iJihad" series. Those videos are much more entertaining. This new series with Robert Spencer is going to be like a million parts long, because he is going through the entire book and deconstructing it.

He makes other educational videos as well. He made a video where he proved that terrorists are motivated by vengeance, not Islam. Actually, this may have been part of his iJihad series, but I can't remember.

He went through the autobiographies of terrorists, and all of them consistently admitted that they are aware that what they're doing is Haram, but they just don't care. They don't want to follow Islamic war ethics because the West that bombs them doesn't follow Islamic war ethics. (It doesn't make it acceptable, but it shows that they aren't being inspired by their religion)

He also presented many statistics showing that Muslims as a whole compared to people of other belief systems had much higher moral/ethical standards for warfare.

E.g. Muslims, compared to all other groups, disagreed most with the statement: "collateral damage is sometimes justified in war".

Edited March 27, 2019 by AmirioTheMuzzy

[Abu Hadi]

I applaud the brother who is doing this rebuttal, but In my humble opinion the only people who would actually read a book of Richard Spencer and believe his nonsense are those who probably wouldn't listen to the facts in this rebuttal

This guy Spencer and his ilk are trying to talk about Islam while knowing absolutely nothing about the Arabic language and nothing about Islamic History, in a comprehensive sense. It is like someone who doesn't know how to add and subtract trying to teach calculus. It's just nonsense. How do you respond to utter nonsense. I don't know. This guy is trying, I'll give him that. Anyone with a few brain cells would reject it off hand. 

[baqar]

4 hours ago, Abu Hadi said:

This guy Spencer and his ilk are trying to talk about Islam while knowing absolutely nothing about the Arabic language and nothing about Islamic history.

Even so, some of his books have made it to the best seller list.

Even though they are all full of lies and distortions.

Unalterable hatred for Islam is Spencer's life-long obsession.

4 hours ago, Abu Hadi said:

 the only people who would actually read a book of Richard Spencer and believe his nonsense are those who probably wouldn't listen to the facts in this rebuttal

Most may not but some might.

There would be some who would use their brains while judging Spencer and a good rebuttal will be a great help at that point in time.

Edited March 28, 2019 by baqar

[baqar]

5 hours ago, AmirioTheMuzzy said:

He makes other educational videos as well. 

What is his name?

[AmirioTheMuzzy]

1 hour ago, baqar said:

What is his name?

His channel is "Andalusian Project"

His name is: Asadullah Ali

[Akbar673]

On 3/26/2019 at 4:05 PM, AmirioTheMuzzy said:

Error Count: 2

Robert Spencer is one of the vilest, most loathsome Anti-Islamic monsters on the Planet.

We should block his videos on here, so as to not allow his lies to pollute and corrupt the minds of lesser educated Shi'a. He speaks with the silver tongue of Satan.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_critics_of_Islam#Muslims

We need to avoid spreading the lies and falsehoods of people like this. Its like repeating the lies of Satan, no good ever comes of it regardless of the intention.

May Allah deprive Robert Spencer of any blessings.

 

[baqar]

8 hours ago, Akbar673 said:

May Allah deprive Robert Spencer of any blessings.

Ameen