Jump to content
Questioner

Doing Hajj with a sunni group

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Hajj 2018

This is an enquiry on doing Hajj with a sunni group South East Asians (no shia group goes from where I reside)

Is there any advice on things like 

where to do sajdah can we join them n do on carpet if need be. basically how to get around the sajdah part? can we pull out tissue and use? What to do?

anything in particular to note about tawaaf or anything else as this is coming from someone who has never even done umrah or ziyarat etc n come from a mix of sunni shia family.

is it also alright to use borrowed white clothes from others to be used in state of ihram where I do not know the status of the khums payment on it.

any references to free pdf books on this or sharing your personal experience on this would be greatly appreciated. The QnA section of the sistani website in relation to hajj has very few QnAs.

Many thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Questioner said:

any references to free pdf books on this or sharing your personal experience on this would be greatly appreciated. The QnA section of the sistani website in relation to hajj has very few QnAs.

Many thanks.

Salam you can see useful articles on www.al-Islam.org

About sajdah tissue must be from materials that comes from earth not chemical or other sources .

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.al-islam.org/hajj-pilgrimage-dr-ali-shariati&ved=2ahUKEwizkLS2qZDbAhXLuo8KHXh_AMcQFjAAegQIBhAB&usg=AOvVaw0lkFP5cpdaJcdwiU-Fn1so

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for your reply.

I understand technically what can be used for sajdah but wanted to know what is practically done under the watchful eyes of Saudis.

I have more questions also e.g. about footwear do n donts during ihram. I heard you can't wear sport shoes for ladies as you are not allowed to cover whole feet. What's the ruling in this regard. What if those sports shoes have hole in them for air are such types ok?

 

Hope someone can also give their personal input. 

Many thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Questioner said:

what is practically done under the watchful eyes of Saudis.

I have more questions also e.g. about footwear do n donts during ihram. I heard you can't wear sport shoes for ladies as you are not allowed to cover whole feet. What's the ruling in this regard. What if those sports shoes have hole in them for air are such types ok?

if you see that you are in danger you can do Taqiya 

Q: Some caravans clerics have told Hajjis that they do not use the Turbah during Hajj's journey. Therefore, it has been widely seen that the Hajjis do not even use Turbah in hotels that are all Shiites and prostrate on the carpet. Does this work? Sharia law is correct or not?

Answer: Mistake, prostration on other than what is corret for prostaration is not permissible except in Taqiya

Question: What is the decree of prostrate on the carpet inside the Harmain and mosques? Given the fact that if you use Turbah or paper, or a mattress, you can get fingertips?

A: There is no obstacle to using a rug from leaf , and it is common for Sunnis to throw this in various ways.

Question: In the mosque of Al-Haram and the al-Nabi mosque and other mosques in Mecca and Medina, some places are built and some are not built with stone, is it necessary to go to a congregation or Furada prayer to prostrate on the stone or to Can you prostrate on the carpet?

Answer: If you do it alone and is not necessary,you should not prostrate  on the carpet. And if the congregation does it, its judgment is revealed from previous answers.

Question: Whether you can prostrate on the carpet when attending the congregation prayers of the Mosque of Al-Haram and the al-Nabi mosque or other mosques, and if it is necessary to restore it if it is prostrate on the carpet, do you need it?

Answer: The prostration on carpet in the cases that it is necessary for the sake of taqiya is not obstructed, and the judgment of necessity and unnecessary restoration passed in answer to 864.

 

http://portal.anhar.ir/node/3974/#gsc.tab=0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Questioner said:

have more questions also e.g. about footwear do n donts during ihram. I heard you can't wear sport shoes for ladies as you are not allowed to cover whole feet. What's the ruling in this regard. What if those sports shoes have hole in them for air are such types ok?

 

21- Wearing everything that's cover your up of foot
Twenty-one wearing shoes and socks and everything that's on the foot. [1]

 

[1] (5). Ayatollah Behjat: It is absolutely with verifying clothes & wearing  On the strings(Sheikh's Rites, p. 21).

Ayatollah Khamenei: Muhram's man should not wear a boot or socks, and the obligatory precaution is to avoid wearing anything that covers everything on the foot-such as shoes and Giwe and the like. However, it does not have any problems if throw Ihram cloth or blanket suits and the like on his foot.

Ayatollah Tabrizi: Do not wear anything that covers all the back of foot.

Ayatullah Safi, Ayatollah Golpayegani: And it is precisely to refrain from wearing something that covers a part of the foot, but there is no problem with the clairvoyant.

Note: from Taq'eedo Hormat , use a sanity scourge to wear a suit, which means that the fall of the ihram towel and the blanket on the foot during sleep and so on has no problem
 

503. This decree is devoted to men and does not preclude women.

 

Wearing a shabby shoe
 

504- wearing a shoe that does not fit all of the legs is not an obstacle to ihram.

Emergency wearing socks and the like
 

505. If a man needs to wear something that takes all the foot up, [1] the obligatory precaution [2] is to break it.

 

[1] (1). Ayatollah Sistani: if It would be emegency.
[2] (2). The great Marjas: Behjat: Khoyy, Fadil, Myharam: The recommended precaution is this (Arabic Rites, Issue 248).

 

505/2. What are the duties of those who, when using artificial ankles, are forced to use socks or sewn belts, and it is very difficult for them to perform without artifically impaired legs? [1]

 

[1] (3). Ayatollah Behjat: If the norm is not true, it is not worthless. Otherwise, though it is an excuse to wear it, it is as much as necessary and excusable.

Ayatollah Khamenei: If you have to wear it, it is not forbidden to wear it, but if it will as a cloth , you have to pay Kaffarah it.

Ayatollah Fazil: If the socks are not sewn, it does not hurt, although it is sewn, but if the socks are stitched, you should give Kaffarah.

Ayatullah Makaram: If they are obliged, they you will pay Kaffarh, and Ihram will not have any problems.

506- It is not unnecessary to wear what is on the foot. [1]

 

[1] (4). Grand Ayatollah Tabrizi, Khoyi, Fadhil: This is the proof of Kaffarah is the Shepherd's infanticide. Ayatollah Noori: A sheep is obligatory.

Ayatollah Sistani: It is not obligatory to wear a boot and the like, but it is precausion  to wear sock and the like with intention must pay a sheep as Kaffarah. (Rite, 248).

Ayatollah Khamenei: The recommended precaution for a sock is to sacrifice a sheep as a casualty.

Source: Hedana website based on Rajah Hajj with Havashi and in accordance with the Fatawa of twelve great references and the main text of the thesis of Imam Khomeini and the Holy Ayatollahs: Khamenei, Sistani, Safi Golpayegani, Makarem Shirazi, Nouri Hamedani, Vahid Khorasani, Bahjat Fazel, Khoyi, Golpaygani, Tabrizi.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for your reply

The answer seem a bit confusing for me though. I basically am looking for the rulings of Ayatoallah Sistani and I have emailed them twice but have not got any response.

 

So confused. :(

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×