Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله
Sign in to follow this  
reasoner

is Mahdi a Half-Roman?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Assalamalaikum  Brothers n sisters, 

Is  imam  mahdi  a  Roman  ?  

Mahdi  s  mother   is  Nargis 

Nargis  is  a  Roman  Princess 

Nargis  used  to  eat  pigs , alcohol, non-Halal, non-Kosher  meat  

Nargis  is  Unpure 

Why  would  Allah  make  Nargis  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi   ? 

Check  Quran  about  Romans. 

There hasnt  been  any  Prophet   who  is  a  Roman 

Why  would  Allah  suddenly  that  too  in  climax   make  Roman  woman  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi  ? 

P. S:   Mahdi  will  again  invade  Persia    from  Afghanistan 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
44 minutes ago, reasoner said:

Assalamalaikum  Brothers n sisters, 

Is  imam  mahdi  a  Roman  ?  

Mahdi  s  mother   is  Nargis 

Nargis  is  a  Roman  Princess 

Nargis  used  to  eat  pigs , alcohol, non-Halal, non-Kosher  meat  

Nargis  is  Unpure 

Why  would  Allah  make  Nargis  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi   ? 

Check  Quran  about  Romans. 

There hasnt  been  any  Prophet   who  is  a  Roman 

Why  would  Allah  suddenly  that  too  in  climax   make  Roman  woman  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi  ? 

P. S:   Mahdi  will  again  invade  Persia    from  Afghanistan 

 

Salam Alykom

I suggest you read this article:

http://www.revivingalislam.com/2010/06/narjis-mother-of-12th-imaam-story-is_20.html

@Islamic Salvation @Qa'im What do our authentic hadiths say about Imam Mahdi's A.J mother?

Edited by The Straight Path

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
46 minutes ago, reasoner said:

Assalamalaikum  Brothers n sisters, 

Is  imam  mahdi  a  Roman  ?  

Mahdi  s  mother   is  Nargis 

Nargis  is  a  Roman  Princess 

Nargis  used  to  eat  pigs , alcohol, non-Halal, non-Kosher  meat  

Nargis  is  Unpure 

Why  would  Allah  make  Nargis  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi   ? 

Check  Quran  about  Romans. 

There hasnt  been  any  Prophet   who  is  a  Roman 

Why  would  Allah  suddenly  that  too  in  climax   make  Roman  woman  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi  ? 

P. S:   Mahdi  will  again  invade  Persia    from  Afghanistan 

Where was Moses raised ? Firoun right ? Was Firoun a Muslim if not who saved Moses from Haram acts there ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can  you please  explain  it  with  your  own  words   

So  that  everyone  can  see 

6 minutes ago, The Straight Path said:

 

Salam Alykom

I suggest you read this article:

http://www.revivingalislam.com/2010/06/narjis-mother-of-12th-imaam-story-is_20.html

@Islamic Salvation @Qa'im What do our authentic hadiths say about Imam Mahdi's A.J mother?

No   links  or  redirect 

May  Allah  be  pleased 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, Sindbad05 said:

Where was Moses raised ? Firoun right ? Was Firoun a Muslim if not who saved Moses from Haram acts there ? 

She  was  not  Roman 

Check  Quran  about   Romans 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, reasoner said:

Allah  hates  Romans 

Check   in   Quran   about  Romans 

When Allah says Romans, he says those who are oppressors. Like Allah says human are unthankful but He says only to those who are unthankful.

Hazrat Abu Dhar Ghafari was a Roman and He was a Sahabi so what do you say about him ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nay!

Hast the arch of our beloved,

Built by the beloved,

His power unpredictable,

The arch of He,

Floating near His Throne,

Hurling the disbelievers from the Treasures,

Hast His noble words,

Not been reached to you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Kazemi said:

Nay!

Hast the arch of our beloved,

Built by the beloved,

His power unpredictable,

The arch of He,

Floating near His Throne,

Hurling the disbelievers from the Treasures,

Hast His noble words,

Not been reached to you?

What 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2016-05-27 at 4:16 PM, Qa'im said:

You can find the Roman princess narration you describe in Kitab al-Ghayba, hadith #178, and in Kamal ad-Deen Volume 2 Chapter 41. It is a detailed account of the story of the Emperor's granddaughter. I haven't seen any other narration in the early books that mentions the Roman princess story, and this narration itself is not strong in chain. Some say there were no Arab-Byzantine wars at this time for the princess to get herself captured, but there were actually three skirmishes in the 860s CE which is when this hadith would have taken place - probably the 863-866 Battle of Lalakaon, which took place in northern Turkey before Emperor Bardas dies in 866. There are other hadiths that account the story of Narjis' pregnancy and birth, sometimes under different names, but without mentioning Rome - only saying she was Imam al-Hadi's maidservant. 

There is a hadith in Nu`mani's Kitab al-Ghayba and Saduq's Kamal ad-Deen from Imam al-Baqir [a] which says that the Mahdi would have a black mother. The one in Nu`mani has a strong chain. However, there are hadiths that say the Mahdi would be abyad, but granted this is not a strong indicator to anything. I don't think Kulayni mentions either tradition (black or Roman), and his book was the earliest source with detailed accounts on the Mahdi's birth and early life. 

The existence of differing accounts on the Mahdi's mother, sometimes in the same book (Kamal al-Deen), demonstrates that the early scholars did not have a solid opinion on this issue. The Roman princess story would have some significance, because it is textually rich in symbolism, as it unites the Prophet's family with the family and apostles of Jesus through one lineage in the Mahdi. It is possible too that the Romans would want to align with the Shia to create a challenger to the Abbasids, as there was some collaboration between the ghulat and the Byzantines near that time. But we can't be too sure about this story. Allah knows best.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dajjal  loves  Romans 

Dajjal   followers    are  mostly  Romans 

But  Allah   wanted   Mahdi  s  mother  to   be   Roman  Princess ? 

Why? 

Check  Romans   Barbarism  in  Quran 

Maryam  came  to  Nargis   in  dream  ? 

Who  tried    to  kill  Jesus  ? 

Its  Romans 

But  Maryam  wanted  Nargis(Roman)    the  mother  of   Mahdi  ? 

Nargis   is  spirituality   Unpure  women 

Even  Fatima  and  Prophet  Muhammad   came  in  Nargis  dream   ? 

Right  ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, reasoner said:

Mahdi  s  mother   is  Nargis 

Nargis  is  a  Roman  Princess 

Nargis  used  to  eat  pigs , alcohol, non-Halal, non-Kosher  meat  

Nargis  is  Unpure 

Why  would  Allah  make  Nargis  the  mother  of  imam  Mahdi   ? 

You come to a Shia forum and insult our 12th Imam (AS) and his pure Mother?

What type of filth are you ?

You'll be banned shortly anyway...so Bye

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh you who believe!

Your tone is no melody,

Nay!

Thou cursed,

An evil melody!

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Mohammad Khan,

Why would you disrespect Sayyida Narjis?  What has she done to you?  

What about Hind? Are you a d3ish sympathizer?  Do you wish shias to be exterminated?  What are your intentions?

Back to back threads about topics you do not understand.  You are here to get a reaction.  Why don't you go play somewhere else, to people who are in your level.  We are not of your type.

The only time when gateway 501 is useful to such users.

Edited by Laayla
http://www.facebook.com/imthias.khan.786

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i  hate  ISIS  or  isil  or  daesh  ... 

Whatever   their  name   is 

--------

is  there   any  Shia   Like  Dr. Zakir Naik ? 

Zakir  Naik  is  going  all  over the  world   inviting   non-Muslims      to  islam   risking   his  Life..... 

If   you   shias   believe  your  sect  is  the  truth   go   n    give  Dawah  all  over the world 

There  is  no  Shia  like  Dr. Zakir Naik. 

Pros  of  Dr. Zakir Naik  is   very  high 

Cons    is  very  less 

But  you   guys  fixate   on   cons   only  and ignore, dismiss     him 

Do  you   know  how  many  people  zakir naik  has  been   able  to  persuade  with  discussions  and  make  them  realize   that  islam   is  truth   

What  have  shias  done  ? 

Only  cursing   sahaba 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Laayla said:

Yazid, may Allah be pleased with him?  Your moral compass is jacked up.

 

i  said  he  has  few  cons 

Read  my  posts  properly 

Dont  reply   for  the  sake of replying 

Think     Think    Think 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Zakir  naik  is  praising  Yazid  to   please  Saudi  rulers.... 

If   zakir  doesnt   lie  , then  Saudi s   wont  allow   him  to  give  Dawah   all  over the world.... 

The  world  is  not  Black  or  white 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Zakir forgot about whats happening in Yemen..........

main-qimg-d4a3185a1d41f64d329c297aa317284d-c.jpg.d47e2f725d9cab42675def3b996793fb.jpg

7 hours ago, reasoner said:

  Nargis  is  Unpure 

What about Abu Bakr? Umar? Uthman? Aisha? Hafsa? Technically all the Sahaba were impure before yet they became good. The difference is, Narjis became pious and left behind her life of Jahiliyyah, while the Prophet (saw) was afraid that the Arabs would return to Jahiliyyah and restart the tradition of idol worship *cough cough* Umar *cough*

3 hours ago, reasoner said:

  What  have  shias  done  ? 

Only  cursing   sahaba 

That and supporting your "brothers" in Palestine. Whats Saudi doing again?

2 hours ago, reasoner said:

Zakir  naik  is  praising  Yazid  to   please  Saudi  rulers.... 

If   zakir  doesnt   lie  , then  Saudi s   wont  allow   him  to  give  Dawah   all  over the world.... 

The  world  is  not  Black  or  white 

Do you feel that's the sunnah of the Prophet (saw)? Would he have relaxed some rules to please the Jahil Arabs?

3 hours ago, reasoner said:

If   you   shias   believe  your  sect  is  the  truth   go   n    give  Dawah  all  over the world 

Thats what we do every year for Muharram. You probably think all non muslims get scared away from our Taybir and chest-beating. You have no idea how many have been coming to the truth.

And why do you criticize us for cursing when you've just called the mother of our Imam impure? As long as your post is there slandering the mother of our Imam, I will refer to your Ummul Momineen to Ummul Kafireen. 

7 hours ago, reasoner said:

P. S:   Mahdi  will  again  invade  Persia    from  Afghanistan 

Tell me what he'll do to the Saudis. Congratulate them for giving so much dawah?

5 hours ago, reasoner said:

Dajjal   followers    are  mostly  Romans 

I mean, the Romans didn't go to war with Imam Ali 

3 hours ago, reasoner said:

Pros  of  Dr. Zakir Naik  is   very  high 

Is this one of them?

[Mod Note: Inappropriate image removed.]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do  you have  videos  in  which  non-Muslims   say   shahada   ? 

Plz   post   it   here 

You   are  saying    that   Shia s   are  giving   Dawah   all    around   the world 

Ok 

Post   the  videos   here 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Do  you have  videos  in  which  non-Muslims   say   shahada   ? 

Plz   post   it   here 

You   are  saying    that   Shia s   are  giving   Dawah   all    around   the world 

Ok 

Post   the  videos   here 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This should be enough proof for person like you that Dr. Taijani and many others after studying and coming in contact with Shia became Shia rather remaining with wrong notions of Sunna'h. In reality Shia are real Sunni if it means following the path of Prophet saww. 

If you means Sunnah wal jamat which came into existence by Muawiya lanatullah and currently followed by Wahabi/Salafi, we are sorry as we don't follow people who were deviant from the path of truth. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
45 minutes ago, haidermpr said:

This should be enough proof for person like you that Dr. Taijani and many others after studying and coming in contact with Shia became Shia rather remaining with wrong notions of Sunna'h. In reality Shia are real Sunni if it means following the path of Prophet saww. 

If you means Sunnah wal jamat which came into existence by Muawiya lanatullah and currently followed by Wahabi/Salafi, we are sorry as we don't follow people who were deviant from the path of truth. 

 

Im  talking  about  non-Muslims not  some  sunni  scholars.... 

Post  the  videos  here 

then 

i ll  shut  up 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you were talking about conversion not about non-muslim to muslim as i understood. It doesn't matter whether someone is converting from one religion or one sect to other. 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibrahim_Zakzaky

Here is a man who converted many people though before 1979 there were negligible shia in Nigeria but Ibrahim Zakzaky changed the scenario. He is inspired by Great Iranian Revolution of Khomeini and Nigerian government is afraid of him. 

Dr. Taijani of Tunisia another well known person who changed the path of falsehood and ignorance after coming in contact with Baqir al Sadr and Khoei.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_al-Tijani

Conversion doesn't mean only converting others to your religion. It means showing the right path and right way of thinking of Islam.

Zakir Naik is a deviant who believe in righteousness of Yazid lanatullah. He also said wrong things about our Prophet saww. In India, Shia as well as Sunni abhor this stupid man called Zakir Naik though salafi support him as he was preaching the lessons of Ale Abdul wahab and Ale Saud i.e. oppressors of our time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, haidermpr said:

you were talking about conversion not about non-muslim to muslim as i understood. It doesn't matter whether someone is converting from one religion or one sect to other. 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibrahim_Zakzaky

Here is a man who converted many people though before 1979 there were negligible shia in Nigeria but Ibrahim Zakzaky changed the scenario. He is inspired by Great Iranian Revolution of Khomeini and Nigerian government is afraid of him. 

Dr. Taijani of Tunisia another well known person who changed the path of falsehood and ignorance after coming in contact with Baqir al Sadr and Khoei.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_al-Tijani

Conversion doesn't mean only converting others to your religion. It means showing the right path and right way of thinking of Islam.

Zakir Naik is a deviant who believe in righteousness of Yazid lanatullah. He also said wrong things about our Prophet saww. In India, Shia as well as Sunni abhor this stupid man called Zakir Naik though salafi support him as he was preaching the lessons of Ale Abdul wahab and Ale Saud i.e. oppressors of our time.

Do you have videos   ? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dr. Zakir Naik  doesnt   really  care  about  Yazid, Yazid 1,Yazid 2,Yazid  3    etc........ 

Zakir  is  praising  Yazids   to  please   Saudi   rulers 

Dr, Zakir  Naik  loves  Hussain, Hassan, Ali, Fatima 

Skype   Zakir   and  ask  him 

Contact   him 

Edited by reasoner

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Iran  must  pay  some  guy   a Trillion  dollars   so  that   he  gives   Dawah    all  over the world... 

 

P. S:    still   no    videos ........ Why  ? 

Edited by reasoner

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
30 minutes ago, reasoner said:

Iran  must  pay  some  guy   a Trillion  dollars   so  that   he  gives   Dawah    all  over the world... 

Iran does not need propaganda only sauds / Whbi needs it yet they have to deduct one out of 50 countries who accepted their propaganda  just  few days meeting in Riyadh with their americn boss. 

so licking of feet does not work by Saudi,  

Edited by skyweb1987

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...