Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

Recommended Posts

  • Advanced Member
Posted
Quote

Dear brothers and sisters I m freshly converted to shiah from sunni. I want to ask you 1 question that who is the responsible of imam hassan and Hussain death shiah or someone other group like yazeed...

Assalaamulayekum,

For Poisoning of Imam Hassan(as) his wife is responsible under the Influence of Muawiyah.

And for Imam Hussain (as), Yazid (la) is responsible for his Killing. If our sunni brother say Shia are only responsible, let them remind that our prophet has prophesied that his nation will slay his son (ie Imam Hussain(as)). It would simply mean that Shia are the only part of his Ummah and sunni doesn't come under his nation. If they include themselves also, it means then shia and sunni shares equal responsibility in killing of Imam Hussain(as), as prophet said his nation would kill him. Basically they are trapped.

Nevertheless both person are condemned by our Aimmah (as) in our authentic hadeeth :

: ابن محبوب، عن عبد الله بن سنان قال: سمعت أبا عبد الله (عليه السلام) يقول
 
ثلاث هن فخر المؤمن وزينه في الدنيا والآخرة: الصلاة في آخر الليل ويأسه مما في أيدي الناس وولايته الامام من آل محمد (صلى الله عليه وآله) قال: وثلاثة هم شرار الخلق ابتلى بهم خيار الخلق: أبو سفيان أحدهم قاتل رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وآله) وعاداه ومعاوية قاتل عليا (عليه السلام) وعاداه ويزيد بن معاوية لعنه الله قاتل الحسين بن علي (عليهما السلام) وعاداه حتى قتله
 
Ibn Mahboob from Abdullah bin Sanan who said that I heard Imam Abu Abdullah  (عليه السلام) saying:
 
There are there things of pride for momin, and (they are) beautification for him in this world and the world here after, Salat in last part of night; Disappointment which he gets at the hands of people; Wilayat of Imam from Aal-e-Mohammad. He said: and there are three amongst the worst of creation who hurt the best of creation, Abu Sufian, who fought Holy Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله) and was his enemy; Muawiyah who fought Imam Ali  (عليه السلام) and was his enemy; Yazid curse of Allah be on him, who fought Imam Hussein  (عليه السلام) and was his enemy till he killed him. 
 
Grading:
  1. Allamah Majlisi:"Hasan" (Mirat ul Uqool 26/178)
  2. Sheikh Hadi al-Najafi: "Saheeh Sanad"  (Mausu'ah Ahadith Ahlulbayt 5/306)

 

Wa aleykumsalaam

  • Veteran Member
Posted (edited)

The killers of Imam Hussain as were nasibis / hypocrites. The detail on the subject may be found at the given links:

http://www.shiapen.com/comprehensive/who-killed-imam-hussain/uthmani-nawasib-killed-hussain.html

http://www.almuntazar.com/204/killers-of-imam-husain-as-a-historical-perspective/

Imam Hassan as was poisoned by his wife Juda binte Ashath for Muawiya.

The detail can be seen at the given link below:

http://www.sibtayn.com/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=5941:mu-awiya-s-plot-to-poison-imam-hasan-as&catid=576&Itemid=671

http://www.aldhiaa.com/english/book/book/history_library/various_books/muawiya/007.html

Wassalam
. 

Edited by skamran110
  • Advanced Member
Posted

A group of researchers worked on this question for a long time and the answer was astonishing in each of our Imam's deaths the Jews were the real planners, and they did their work by working on world seeker Muslims such as Muawiya and ... .

I have to say that if you search for Muawiya's ancestors you will find Jews in his bloodline.

  • Veteran Member
Posted
55 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

A group of researchers worked on this question for a long time and the answer was astonishing in each of our Imam's deaths the Jews were the real planners, and they did their work by working on world seeker Muslims such as Muawiya and ... .

I have to say that if you search for Muawiya's ancestors you will find Jews in his bloodline.

A group of researchers? Sounds like a bunch of bigots with no knowledge who hate Jews more than they hate the nawasib, you should avoid listening to such people.

  • Advanced Member
Posted
5 minutes ago, Ali_Hussain said:

A group of researchers? Sounds like a bunch of bigots with no knowledge who hate Jews more than they hate the nawasib, you should avoid listening to such people.

I listen to my mind and religion and I see their evidences and then i choose to accept or refuse them.

It is proven to me that jews where behind them all. 

One Question that is really lightening is why the jews forsake the beautiful and green land of Jerusalem and reside in the harsh desert of Hijaz? they wanted the last prophet be one of them and when they didn't sucess in it they start to do what they have done to christianity by killing the best of muslims and misguiding people by guys such as Ka'bolahbar and abu horaire. 

  • Moderators
Posted
3 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

One Question that is really lightening is why the jews forsake the beautiful and green land of Jerusalem and reside in the harsh desert of Hijaz? they wanted the last prophet be one of them and when they didn't sucess in it they start to do what they have done to christianity by killing the best of muslims and misguiding people by guys such as Ka'bolahbar and abu horaire. 

Even if some of them have hatred toward the Prophet, it still does not mean that they were behind the killings of the Imams. Can you refer the articles or works of these group of research?

  • Veteran Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

I listen to my mind and religion and I see their evidences and then i choose to accept or refuse them.

It is proven to me that jews where behind them all. 

One Question that is really lightening is why the jews forsake the beautiful and green land of Jerusalem and reside in the harsh desert of Hijaz? they wanted the last prophet be one of them and when they didn't sucess in it they start to do what they have done to christianity by killing the best of muslims and misguiding people by guys such as Ka'bolahbar and abu horaire. 

Exactly, at least you admit that you listen to you desires (mind) before your religion, or else you would stick to what has reached us in your texts and no start making things up as you go along to feed your prejudices. 

  • Advanced Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, Ali_Hussain said:

Exactly, at least you admit that you listen to you desires (mind) before your religion, or else you would stick to what has reached us in your texts and no start making things up as you go along to feed your prejudices. 

Allah advise us in Quran to thing and using our brain more than anything.

I am a shia not only because I was born in a shia family, I am a shia because I searched for the truth once and I found that my religion is the best by using my brain and thinking.

Posted
2 hours ago, Hidaren said:

A group of researchers worked on this question for a long time and the answer was astonishing in each of our Imam's deaths the Jews were the real planners, and they did their work by working on world seeker Muslims such as Muawiya and ... .

I have to say that if you search for Muawiya's ancestors you will find Jews in his bloodline.

bismillah.gif.63cd5ca0ef0c9502d70113ab7d

You are but not 100 %! Zionist Jews are not only atheist but Satan worshipers, only dressed as Jews, just as their brethren Wahabis/Salafis are Satan worshipers dressed as Muslims. Jews are people of the Book and small in numbers, that's why the Satan worshipers are using Judaism....Zionist Jews are different from Torah Jews, (not all Jews are Zionists)specially Hasidic Jews, Hasidic Jews are just like Muslims, except that they do not believe in Jesus a.s and Mohammad s.a.w. In my opinion, Hasidic Jews are like Shia Muslims, they dress more Islamic than most Muslims including our Shias, from head to toe. Here is another mind boggling thing, Othman(Osman), the 3rd Caliph,  was a Jew who converted to Islam, and think why would a Jew convert to Islam and then gets divided as soon as the Prophet s.a.w died.... infiltration,  infiltration! So not all Jews are bad, not all Muslims are good! I personally would not trade the dirty shoes of a good Jew for 100 million of so called Muslims.

  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
17 minutes ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

bismillah.gif.63cd5ca0ef0c9502d70113ab7d

You are but not 100 %! Zionist Jews are not only atheist but Satan worshipers, only dressed as Jews, just as their brethren Wahabis/Salafis are Satan worshipers dressed as Muslims. Jews are people of the Book and small in numbers, that's why the Satan worshipers are using Judaism....Zionist Jews are different from Torah Jews, (not all Jews are Zionists)specially Hasidic Jews, Hasidic Jews are just like Muslims, except that they do not believe in Jesus a.s and Mohammad s.a.w. In my opinion, Hasidic Jews are like Shia Muslims, they dress more Islamic than most Muslims including our Shias, from head to toe. Here is another mind boggling thing, Othman(Osman), the 3rd Caliph,  was a Jew who converted to Islam, and think why would a Jew convert to Islam and then gets divided as soon as the Prophet s.a.w died.... infiltration,  infiltration! So not all Jews are bad, not all Muslims are good! I personally would not trade the dirty shoes of a good Jew for 100 million of so called Muslims.

Zionism were not at time of Prophet or Imams. Uthman ibn Affan who is from Quraish tribe was an Jew? Please come on.

Edited by Dhulfikar
Posted
4 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

Zionism were not at time of Prophet or Imams.

Really? What does Zionism mean to you? Read Prophet Solomon's kingdom, he said that they Shaitons will come in a human forms way before Mohammad s.a.w.

  • Advanced Member
Posted
7 minutes ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

bismillah.gif.63cd5ca0ef0c9502d70113ab7d

You are but not 100 %! Zionist Jews are not only atheist but Satan worshipers, only dressed as Jews, just as their brethren Wahabis/Salafis are Satan worshipers dressed as Muslims. Jews are people of the Book and small in numbers, that's why the Satan worshipers are using Judaism....Zionist Jews are different from Torah Jews, (not all Jews are Zionists)specially Hasidic Jews, Hasidic Jews are just like Muslims, except that they do not believe in Jesus a.s and Mohammad s.a.w. In my opinion, Hasidic Jews are like Shia Muslims, they dress more Islamic than most Muslims including our Shias, from head to toe. Here is another mind boggling thing, Othman(Osman), the 3rd Caliph,  was a Jew who converted to Islam, and think why would a Jew convert to Islam and then gets divided as soon as the Prophet s.a.w died.... infiltration,  infiltration! So not all Jews are bad, not all Muslims are good! I personally would not trade the dirty shoes of a good Jew for 100 million of so called Muslims.

At least one person understand what I said.

I know these things u said, the moment I wrote that text I was in hurry and i had no time to explain and now u explained it here and I have to add this too that from every religion only one group will have redemption, from Islam Shias, from Judaism and Christianity small groups and they are too few like Lev Tahor Jews.

  • Moderators
Posted
3 minutes ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

Really? What does Zionism mean to you? Read Prophet Solomon's kingdom, he said that they Shaitons will come in a human forms way before Mohammad s.a.w.

Yes really. Doesn't matter what it does means to me, the definition is what matters. Zionism is a movement that came late 19th century. If you think Zionism was at the time of Prophet, we could say exactly Salafism movement was at time of Prophet too.

  • Advanced Member
Posted
7 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

Zionism were not at time of Prophet or Imams. Uthman ibn Affan who is from Quraish tribe was an Jew? Please come on.

The Zionism first came to be when Samiri made the Golden cow. Everyone know the story.

Posted
1 hour ago, Hidaren said:

Allah advise us in Quran to thing and using our brain more than anything.

I am a shia not only because I was born in a shia family, I am a shia because I searched for the truth once and I found that my religion is the best by using my brain and thinking.

Exactly brother, and this is why the Zionist Jews (Satan worshipers) have declared war on Shias to hide the truth. They also know that there is a God, but chose the devil.

Posted
Quote

Dear brothers and sisters I m freshly converted to shiah from sunni. I want to ask you 1 question that who is the responsible of imam hassan and Hussain death shiah or someone other group like yazeed...

bismillah.gif.04abbe3a1b39fbc74ced6f7827

This is the start, keep on researching, here is a good book by an ex Sunni, its free online. "And then I was guided"

  • Advanced Member
Posted

 

4 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

No it did not.

The base of Zionism is Kabbalah and Kabbalah existed long before Moses, the Egyptians were Kabbalah experts. When Samiri made that cow the Jews started practicing kabbalah and thus Zionism came to be.

Posted
7 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

Yes really. Doesn't matter what it does means to me, the definition is what matters. Zionism is a movement that came late 19th century. If you think Zionism was at the time of Prophet, we could say exactly Salafism movement was at time of Prophet too.

You have to study Shaiton to understand Zionism, salafism, and atheist Jews.

Posted
10 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

 

The base of Zionism is Kabbalah and Kabbalah existed long before Moses, the Egyptians were Kabbalah experts. When Samiri made that cow the Jews started practicing kabbalah and thus Zionism came to be.

They still practice Kaballah till present day, Yet still will fail plots after plots! God is the BEST PLANNER.

Posted
2 hours ago, Hidaren said:

I listen to my mind and religion and I see their evidences and then i choose to accept or refuse them.

It is proven to me that jews where behind them all. 

One Question that is really lightening is why the jews forsake the beautiful and green land of Jerusalem and reside in the harsh desert of Hijaz? they wanted the last prophet be one of them and when they didn't sucess in it they start to do what they have done to christianity by killing the best of muslims and misguiding people by guys such as Ka'bolahbar and abu horaire. 

bismillah.gif.a5466ad37896ed3e9b3fd04c79

people always talk about God/Allah but forgets to mention Shayton and his duties and responsibilities and his promise to Allah. If we get to know AShaiton, we will know who his followers are and will not be deceived by them. Shaytons come in all shapes forms, even as Shias believe it or not, even on this site believe it or not! Those who believe in Allah, have no reason to be scared or worried as Allah is our protector, the Best Protector Alhamdulillah.

  • Moderators
Posted
20 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

 

The base of Zionism is Kabbalah and Kabbalah existed long before Moses, the Egyptians were Kabbalah experts. When Samiri made that cow the Jews started practicing kabbalah and thus Zionism came to be.

And again false logic conclusion. With this same logic you can say Salafism was at time of prophet too.

Posted
2 hours ago, Hidaren said:

I listen to my mind and religion and I see their evidences and then i choose to accept or refuse them.

It is proven to me that jews where behind them all. 

One Question that is really lightening is why the jews forsake the beautiful and green land of Jerusalem and reside in the harsh desert of Hijaz? they wanted the last prophet be one of them and when they didn't sucess in it they start to do what they have done to christianity by killing the best of muslims and misguiding people by guys such as Ka'bolahbar and abu horaire. 

Don't waste your time on the ignorant people brother, Shayton comes in all forms.

  • Advanced Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

And again false logic conclusion. With this same logic you can say Salafism was at time of prophet too.

Salafism are just acting like Khavarij at the time of Imam Ali(as).

In Nahrawan 3 of Khawarij survived. one Killed Imam ali(as) and the two other remained alive.their way remained until now.

 

  • Moderators
Posted (edited)
24 minutes ago, Hidaren said:

Salafism are just acting like Khavarij at the time of Imam Ali(as).

In Nahrawan 3 of Khawarij survived. one Killed Imam ali(as) and the two other remained alive.their way remained until now.

 

Salafism was practiced mostly after Ibn Taiymiah, it was created because at that time Sufis had big influence toward the Sunnis and Ibn Taiymiah realized that these Sufis have gone way off from the real Islam. After him came muslims who followed the teaching of Ibn Taiymiah. It was in 19th century when Salafism as an group came in public. We don't say Khawarij = Salafism. Because they are not. Nor We say Zionism = The belief of bad jews at the time of X. Because they have different concepts and Ideology. Of course they may have similarities, but almost all sect have similarities.

Edited by Dhulfikar
  • Advanced Member
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Dhulfikar said:

Salafism was practiced mostly after Ibn Taiymiah, it was created because at that time Sufis had big influence toward the Sunnis and Ibn Taiymiah realized that these Sufis have gone way off from the real Islam. After him came muslims who followed the teaching of Ibn Taiymiah. It was in 19th century when Salafism as an group came in public. We don't say Khawarij = Salafism. Because they are not. Nor We say Zionism = The belief of bad jews at the time of X. Because they have different concepts and Ideology. Of course they may have similarities, but almost all sect have similarities.

Sufism is not a sect it is an science or methodology for emulating compassion:

"Similarly ilm al-tasawwuf, "the science of Sufism" came into being to preserve and transmit a particular aspect of the shari'a, that of ikhlas or sincerity. It was recognized that the sunna of the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) was not only words and actions, but also states of being: that a Muslim must not only say certain things and do certain things, but must also be something. "

Link/source: http://sunnah.org/tasawwuf/sufisnk.htm

Edited by Enlightened Follower
  • Moderators
Posted
1 hour ago, Enlightened Follower said:

Sufism is not a sect it is an science or methodology for emulating compassion:

"Similarly ilm al-tasawwuf, "the science of Sufism" came into being to preserve and transmit a particular aspect of the shari'a, that of ikhlas or sincerity. It was recognized that the sunna of the Prophet (Allah bless him and give him peace) was not only words and actions, but also states of being: that a Muslim must not only say certain things and do certain things, but must also be something. "

Link/source: http://sunnah.org/tasawwuf/sufisnk.htm

When you have an group that represent ideologies, concepts, methodologies, you can identify such a group by an name that represent it. When we say Sufi, we know very well what such a person beliefs on, in what hadith books he believes on and what concepts he believes on. This itself is an sect and it also can have sub-sects. If you say that there exist a Shi'a Sufis, and such a Shia is using methodology (or Science?) of Sufism, then such a personal is utterly nut, just believing in different sect. The Imams itself did warn about Sufism, so how can we have Shi'a Sufism?

Posted
13 hours ago, Dhulfikar said:

Zionism were not at time of Prophet or Imams. Uthman ibn Affan who is from Quraish tribe was an Jew? Please come on.

bismillah.gif.08d471c4443b319e1ec80124d2

Yes, Othman Bin Affan was a Jew before converting to Islam. And yes, Wahabis were present during the time of Mohammad s.a.w. but under a different name, Abu Sufyani/Yazidi! The names may have been changed but the enemy has not changed! Here is a perfect example: Were not the Yazidi/Abu Sufyani fighting our Imams and killing Shias after the death of our Prophet s.a.w. and are they not still killing us Shias till present day around the world?

  • Moderators
Posted
12 hours ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

bismillah.gif.08d471c4443b319e1ec80124d2

Yes, Othman Bin Affan was a Jew before converting to Islam. And yes, Wahabis were present during the time of Mohammad s.a.w. but under a different name, Abu Sufyani/Yazidi! The names may have been changed but the enemy has not changed! Here is a perfect example: Were not the Yazidi/Abu Sufyani fighting our Imams and killing Shias after the death of our Prophet s.a.w. and are they not still killing us Shias till present day around the world?

You need to give proof of your claim that he was a Jew. 

Quote

Wahabis were present during the time of Mohammad s.a.w. but under a different name, Abu Sufyani/Yazidi! The names may have been changed but the enemy has not changed! Here is a perfect example: Were not the Yazidi/Abu Sufyani fighting our Imams and killing Shias after the death of our Prophet s.a.w. and are they not still killing us Shias till present day around the world?

I'm not even trying to even say here that we don't have common enemies, Wahhabis and Khawarij is our enemies and they are nasibis, but we can't say they are exactly same in beliefs. Wahhabism is different movement with different ideology, but they are in same category of our enemies and of what our Prophet have warned about such a people. Salafism, Wahhabism, Khawarij...they are all different sect of Islam.

Posted
14 minutes ago, Dhulfikar said:

You need to give proof of your claim that he was a Jew. 

I'm not even trying to even say here that we don't have common enemies, Wahhabis and Khawarij is our enemies and they are nasibis, but we can't say they are exactly same in beliefs. Wahhabism is different movement with different ideology, but they are in same category of our enemies and of what our Prophet have warned about such a people. Salafism, Wahhabism, Khawarij...they are all different sect of Islam.

bismillah.gif.dd4062569b4747691cab900461

Let me dummy proof you here! Whats the difference between SIS and AL Qaeda? Their ideology is the same pretty much, their goal (anti Islam/Muslim) are the same, they get paid from the same government or governments(their creators)  but with two different names. One more evil than the other one. This is how Salafis and Wahabis are. The devils are more advanced than us human beings, but in order to defeat them, OUR ONLY WAY IS TO BE CLOSE TO GOD, like SHIA ISLAM, otherwise nobody can defeat them.

  • Moderators
Posted
3 minutes ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

bismillah.gif.dd4062569b4747691cab900461

Let me dummy proof you here! Whats the difference between SIS and AL Qaeda? Their ideology is the same pretty much, their goal (anti Islam/Muslim) are the same, they get paid from the same government or governments(their creators)  but with two different names. One more evil than the other one. This is how Salafis and Wahabis are. The devils are more advanced than us human beings, but in order to defeat them, OUR ONLY WAY IS TO BE CLOSE TO GOD, like SHIA ISLAM, otherwise nobody can defeat them.

Isis = Alqaida. Isis do claim that they are salafis but they actually are not them, they follow them only by name, but actually have no idea what their belief is about. For example the Salafis do not believe in killing of layman Shias to be Halal, because they don't consider such a muslims as kafir, but as Muslim. But ISIS kills everyone who is against them, even if the person is Sunni. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Dhulfikar said:

Isis = Alqaida. Isis do claim that they are salafis but they actually are not them, they follow them only by name, but actually have no idea what their belief is about. For example the Salafis do not believe in killing of layman Shias to be Halal, because they don't consider such a muslims as kafir, but as Muslim. But ISIS kills everyone who is against them, even if the person is Sunni. 

Dude, go preach to someone else, in short, Salafi/Wahabi are pretty much the same! The end!

  • Moderators
Posted
3 minutes ago, 12reasons4truth. said:

Dude, go preach to someone else, in short, Salafi/Wahabi are pretty much the same! The end!

I don't know what part of my text is hard to understand for you, because it seems you don't get it. Anyway I'm not interested to talk to you, since I feel you have no respect.

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...