Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله
Sign in to follow this  
Adeel-Raza

A hadeeth book agreed upon by both Shia and Sunni

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, Adeel-Raza said:

I need quotes of Prophet, Hazrat Ali and companions of Prophet. But I would like to read it from a book which is mutually accepted by both Shia and Sunni Muslims. Can some assist? ?

It is very difficult to get a Hadith book that is unanimously agreed upon by both Shia and Sunni Muslims. This might be as a result of the differences in the methods adopted by each of the schools of thought in the acceptance and the authentication of Hadith.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In many years of reading i have never heard of a book of Traditions that is accepted by both Shia and Sunni.

And logic says that it doesn't depend on the book itself, but rather it depends on the chain of transmission of each individual Tradition.

I know that the Shia are very careful about the chain of transmission. But since most  Shia are not skilled enough to examine the chain of transmission. Instead they generally rely on the transmitters of Traditions that have historically been trusted - and these Traditions are collected in a lot of books of Shia Traditions that have been trusted over the years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Ozzy said:

Mustadrak alas Sahihain by Hakim Naisapuri

Kanzul Ummal by Ali Muttaqi

Yanabee al-Mawadda by Qandoozi Hanafi

* Although these are sunni books, it contains many merits of the Ahl Bait عليهم السلام

as salam alaykum my dear and respected friend. 

In regards to Qunduzi, I would not say that.

It is without a doubt that one of the most commonly used sources in the world of Sunni-Shia polemics is Al-Qunduzi Al-Hanafi’s Yanabee’ Al-Muwadda. This is not a surprise, since the book is attributed to a “Hanafi scholar” and contains narrations in which the Twelve Imams are appointed.

Sunnis correctly dismiss the book as unreliable. Not only is the author not known to the vast majority of Sunnis, but his time is too late, a whole millennium after the Golden Era of Hadith, for anyone to take him seriously.

However, dismissals like these were not accepted by Shias, who would insist that he was one of the greatest Hanafi scholars of all time, even though his Hanafi fiqh related works are virtually unknown to Shias.

yanabi0011In any case, after a little digging through his book, we were able to find irrefutable proof that Al-Qunduzi took part in some foul play when compiling his book. He betrayed the trust of his readers as we shall soon demonstrate in the screenshots below.

yanabi0001In one of the most important chapters of the book, Al-Qunduzi states that he provides his narrations from Ghayat Al Maram. For those that are not aware, Ghayat Al-Maram was authored by Hashim Al-Bahrani, an extreme Akhbari Shia scholar. Through Ghayat Al-Maram, he quotes many narrations from various sources, including Fara’id Al-Simtain, Al-Arba’een by Abi Nu’aym, and others.

 

yanabi0003yanabi0002One of the main sources that he also quotes from is Al-Manaqib by Al-Khawarizmi. He quotes around ten narrations from that one source. However, what we found peculiar is that the names of the teachers of Al-Khawarizmi were very familiar. Names like: Ahmad bin Mohammad bin Yahya Al-Attar, Mohammad bin Al-Hasan bin Al-Mutawakkil, and Al-Ja’afar bin Mohammad bin Masroor. These were the names of the teachers of the infamous Shia scholar Al-Saduq!

It was then that we decided to return to Ghayat Al-Maram itself, to find the source of the confusion.

ghayatghayat1It was no surprise to find the narration of Al-Khawarizmi. However, there was only one narration by him, instead of ten! Hashim Al-Bahrani refers to it as an Aami (Sunni) source too.

We could not find the other narrations that caught our interest in the same chapter. However, upon flipping over to the next chapter, which was exclusively for Shia reports, we found that Hashim Al-Bahrani was in fact quoting Al-Saduq.

It was due to the grace of Allah – subhanahu wa tala – that we were able to find the exact same narrations that Al-Qunduzi was quoting. However, he deceived his readers by replacing the title and author of the book that he was quoting from, in order for Sunnis to accept his narrations. He repeats this offense with several narrations. Each time he replaced the name of Ibn Babawaih Al-Saduq with Al-Manaqib, alluding to Al-Khawarizmi.

ghayat2ghayat3In conclusion, Al-Qunduzi was an deceiver. He is not reliable and his book should not been trusted as a source for hadith narrations. May Allah – subhanahu wa ta’ala – punish him and whoever spreads falsehood in this life and in the hereafter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, Abu_Rumaysah said:

as salam alaykum my dear and respected friend. 

In regards to Qunduzi, I would not say that.

It would be nice if you expressed yourself in your own words, rather than copy and pasting from other websites.

Let me quote from one of your favourite websites:

Quote

3- It is not allowed for a Shia to quote a large paragraph from a Shia propaganda website and expect people to refute it even though he made no effort in writing or researching it. A Shia can only link to such articles.

Shouldn't this work both ways?

Edited by Haydar Husayn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...