Brother of Ayatollah Sistani

[celestial]

Salam,

Does anybody here know about Sayed Sistani's brother?

All i can find on the internet is these pictures;

Someone says that he is killed by Iranian regime. Is this true?

Edited March 28, 2016 by celestial

[Hameedeh]

The Twitter page where you found those images is an abomination. Obscene and disgusting lies. It is a hoax and full of profanity. 

[allsayyidsareahlulbayt!]

asa,

no irani government doesn't go around killing ulama. the whole type of stories was based off the incident of the burial of ayatollah shirazi, the government did not want him buried in his house, they had him buried in rawdah, to prevent a point of fitnah.

[celestial]

35 minutes ago, hameedeh said:

The Twitter page where you found those images is an abomination. Obscene and disgusting lies. It is a hoax and full of profanity. 

Links are changed with imgur...

Okay, so can you give us information and truth about events?

28 minutes ago, allsayyidsareahlulbayt! said:

asa,

no irani government doesn't go around killing ulama. the whole type of stories was based off the incident of the burial of ayatollah shirazi, the government did not want him buried in his house, they had him buried in rawdah, to prevent a point of fitnah.

What fitnah? Can you elaborate please?

Edited March 28, 2016 by celestial

[Hameedeh]

19 minutes ago, celestial said:

Okay, so can you give us information and truth about events?

It is a matter of disinformation. People who are anti-Iran, anti-Islam or anti-Shia make complaints against the government of Iran. Any ayatullah or famous person who dies becomes an excuse to blame the government, by making wild claims about being murdered.

Ask Ayatullah Sistani HA if the Iranian government murdered his brother. I would believe what he says.  

[celestial]

3 minutes ago, hameedeh said:

It is a matter of disinformation. People who are anti-Iran, anti-Islam or anti-Shia make complaints against the government of Iran. Any ayatullah or famous person who dies becomes an excuse to blame the government, by making wild claims about being murdered.

Ask Ayatullah Sistani HA if the Iranian government murdered his brother. I would believe what he says.  

I doubt he will answer about that, if his brother is really murdered.

Reason is simple, millions are following him and he can't say anything he wants.

Probably there are millions unaware of this. Imagine people hear this from the mouth of Sistani, now that could be a huge fitnah and uproar...

[Ali_Hussain]

I google his name in Arabic, there are stories of his death, but there isn't much other than that, nothing about Iran.

I checked on youtube as well, nothing either.

[DigitalUmmah]

4 hours ago, celestial said:

Someone says that he is killed by Iranian regime. Is this true?

lol wut

[celestial]

Found some new pics.

 

He extremely looks similar to Sayed Sistani.

I'm really interested in knowing about him...

Edited March 28, 2016 by celestial

[LabaikYaHussein]

Every time an ayatollah gets murdered people always blame iran like what lol 

[celestial]

24 minutes ago, LabaikYaHussein said:

Every time an ayatollah gets murdered people always blame iran like what lol 

Why an Ayatollah gets murdered? Especially in an Islamic regime?

Edited March 28, 2016 by celestial

[LabaikYaHussein]

31 minutes ago, celestial said:

Why an Ayatollah gets murdered? Especially in an Islamic regime?

Allah(swt) knows best right could be anyone could be paid hitman from zionist regime the brits and keep in mind that people causing mischief on the lands are liable to become killed im not saying that this man was a mischief maker God forbid me for saying such a thing and will never say that unless there is solid proof but we cant point fingers on the one nation who is the back bone of the shia world 

[celestial]

11 hours ago, LabaikYaHussein said:

Allah(swt) knows best right could be anyone could be paid hitman from zionist regime the brits and keep in mind that people causing mischief on the lands are liable to become killed im not saying that this man was a mischief maker God forbid me for saying such a thing and will never say that unless there is solid proof but we cant point fingers on the one nation who is the back bone of the shia world 

If a zionist hitman murdered Ayatollah, then why doesn't Iran declare it to the world? Why don't we know it? That would be a good propaganda for Iran, why don't they do this?

It's the opposite, it's like the information about him is sealed. That's more like a behavior of the guilty.

[Don'tMakeAس]

6 hours ago, celestial said:

If a zionist hitman murdered Ayatollah, then why doesn't Iran declare it to the world? Why don't we know it? That would be a good propaganda for Iran, why don't they do this?

It's the opposite, it's like the information about him is sealed. That's more like a behavior of the guilty.

The irony 

If you make a claim of someone being murdered by someone else, you have to back it up with evidence. You can't just say "Iran is behaving like it's guilty because there's no proof on the Internet that Iran murdered him."

[celestial]

9 minutes ago, Patience101 said:

The irony 

If you make a claim of someone being murdered by someone else, you have to back it up with evidence. You can't just say "Iran is behaving like it's guilty because there's no proof on the Internet that Iran murdered him."

If you know the story, please share with us.

I didn't make any claim, i only asked questions. There are people on the topic implying that he may be murdered by zionists. Read carefully.

[Don'tMakeAس]

31 minutes ago, celestial said:

If you know the story, please share with us.

I didn't make any claim, i only asked questions. There are people on the topic implying that he may be murdered by zionists. Read carefully.

You did in fact make the claim that if Iran (?) doesn't release information about him, it's 'more like a behavior of the guilty.'

What relation does Iran have with Ayatullah Sistani's unnamed mystically-appearing-on-Twitter brother?

[celestial]

3 minutes ago, Patience101 said:

You did in fact make the claim that if Iran (?) doesn't release information about him, it's 'more like a behavior of the guilty.'

What relation does Iran have with Ayatullah Sistani's unnamed mystically-appearing-on-Twitter brother?

It's not mystically appering, it's just i came across recently. As you can see there are various pictures of Him on the internet, not just the twitter.

[allsayyidsareahlulbayt!]

asa,

the shirazian camp would have  used his grave as a rallying point againist the waliyat-ul-faqih of the muslims.

[celestial]

We are all speculating here...

I wish someone with knowledge would shed a light upon this.

[Ali_Hussain]

Actually, it is discussed here: http://www.yahosein.net/vb/showthread.php?t=215906

I can't see much evidence for either side, the source of the story is Allah Yari.

Basically he is saying that the brother was against WF, so sayed Khamene'i had him poisoned, this is according to the students of Mahmud Sistani.

[repenter-gone4awhile]

I trust a drugged senile George Bush before i trust anything Allah Yari says about anything. Brother Mufeed who isn't here "officially" anymore knows this guy personally, the guy is a nutjob.......

[Hameedeh]

On 3/28/2016 at 0:30 PM, celestial said:

millions are following him and he can't say anything he wants.

Ayatullah Sistani HA is not my marja, but I love and admire him. I would never believe that such a religious and pious man, who has spent his entire life in the service of Islam, could lie about anything or hide the truth. Ask Ayatullah Sistani HA how did his brother die, if he was murdered.  

[celestial]

4 hours ago, hameedeh said:

Ayatullah Sistani HA is not my marja, but I love and admire him. I would never believe that such a religious and pious man, who has spent his entire life in the service of Islam, could lie about anything or hide the truth. Ask Ayatullah Sistani HA how did his brother die, if he was murdered.  

This is not hiding the truth, are we lying when we do taqiyya for example?

Why doesn't Sistani go around and curse the 3 caliphs openly? It's pretty much understandable if he doesn't talk about the issues which could be schismatic. He is known as a quietist in the world.