Which Marja To Follow?

[Guest silasun]

Salaam

Can anybody provide a link from the scholars of qom which shows their list of marjas of equal knowledge? I think it is jamiat al modaraseen.

Is ayat. Vahid khorasani among these equally alam marjas?

Ws

[Ethics]

Choosing which is knowledgeable in matters of taqlid isnt based on majority or which scholars say who is better but based on ones own research and understanding on which mujtahid is fully equipped.

[Against oneself]

avoid sherazi, moderassi, qazvini, rohani, gholpayghani, saeed al-hakim, khorosani. these are all tatbir supporters. choose seestani, makarem shirazi, nouri hamadani, kamal haydari, khamenei, zanjani, these are pious ones.

[kamyar]

Is ayat. Vahid khorasani among these equally alam marjas?

Ws

 

و علیک السلام

 

Yes, he is:

 

http://www.jameehmodarresin.org/index.php/2014-01-23-07-32-22/599-495

 

http://islamquest.org/en/archive/question/fa1820

[repenter-gone4awhile]

avoid sherazi, moderassi, qazvini, rohani, gholpayghani, saeed al-hakim, khorosani. these are all tatbir supporters. choose seestani, makarem shirazi, nouri hamadani, kamal haydari, khamenei, zanjani, these are pious ones.

 

You can't just discard marjas like that bro..........

[Gwalch]

avoid sherazi, moderassi, qazvini, rohani, gholpayghani, saeed al-hakim, khorosani. these are all tatbir supporters. choose seestani, makarem shirazi, nouri hamadani, kamal haydari, khamenei, zanjani, these are pious ones.

Sheikh Wahid Khorasani, Sayed Rohani, Sheikh Safi Golpaygani, Sayed Mohammad Saeed al Hakim are first grade maraji' according to the Hawza seminaries of Qom and Najaf along with Sayed Sistani and Sayed Musa Zanjani. If you're going to discredit every scholar that condones Tatbir, then say farewell to Shi'ism.

[Gwalch]

From my experience, those usually referred to as the most learned are Sayed Sistani, Sheikh Wahid Khorasani, Sayed Mohamad Sa'eed al Hakim, Sayed Sadeq Rohani. Sheikh Wahid is an excellent choice, being a quintessence of Fiqh and Usul, without mentioning his expertise in rational fields and 'Aqeeda, have all made him the current head of the seminary in Qom.

[Noorelhussain]

avoid sherazi, moderassi, qazvini, rohani, gholpayghani, saeed al-hakim, khorosani. these are all tatbir supporters. choose seestani, makarem shirazi, nouri hamadani, kamal haydari, khamenei, zanjani, these are pious ones.

 

So he shouldn't follow the following marja just because they allow tatbir? Interesting.

[Against oneself]

allow tatbir??!!! they encourage it! in public and on babies!!! yes u have spoken the truth. dont do taqleed on them! some of these do takfer on the pious ones. takferis dont deserve taqleed. sham shame

[Ethics]

dont be silly your reasoning is childish and irrational. No marja encourages tatbir on babies, that is a false accusation. Do not speak in plurality, lumping all the marja together when you dont have evidence for all. You are speaking in whims. Your identity on this forum is bringing up fitna amongst Shias with stupid topics or when you get your own feelings hurt. Your lucky the mods dont ban your account again.

Edited August 2, 2015 by Ethics

[Against oneself]

oh my friend. why no read urself? he says mustahab to tatbir on babies http://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235019366-sayid-shirazi-fatwa-on-tatbir-on-children/?p=2656359

friend read like u like it http://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235031682-mahdi-moderassi-calls-irfan-ulama-mushrikdont pretned now these guys dont do takfer