Ttp's Justification For Murdering Children

[Inquisitor]

I came across this article and if it is truly how they think, it is disgusting, does not make sense at all:

 

The Islamic terrorist outfit that carried out the bloodiest school massacre in world history Wednesday defended its action as being in line with what Prophet Mohammed, who Muslims believe was the last messenger of God, did with his enemies 1400 years ago. “At the time of the Bannu Qurayza massacre, Prophet Mohammed ordered only those children be killed whose pubic hairs have appeared,” said Umar Khurasani, spokesperson for the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan. Bannu Qurayza was a Jewish tribe that lived in present day Medina. Islamic history texts confirm 800 men and boysand one woman of the Qurayza tribe were beheaded. "Killing of children and women is according to the teachings of Prophet Mohammed; those who are objecting should study Sahih al-Bukhari," Khurasani said. Khurasani insisted the TTP followed what he called sunnat, or actions of Prophet Mohammed during wars.. He said those who are saying the Peshawar attack was un-Islamic should read Sahih al-Bukhari 5th Volume, Hadith. No. 138. Bukhari is considered to be one of the most authentic books on what Prophet Mohammed said and did during his lifetime. The TTP statement coincided with the television interview of Maulana Abdul Aziz, chief cleric at the Lal Mosque in Islamabad, who flatly refused to condemn the Peshawar attack during a television talk. But he did acknowledge the jihadists were prepared by Islamabad for jihad in Kashmir.

 

Read the entire article here:

http://www.examiner.com/article/ttp-says-peshawar-attack-exactly-line-with-what-prophet-muhammed-did-taught

 

-------

 

I tried to search volume 5 of Bukhari's Saheeh, however could not find the hadith the article speaks of. I however found it in Sunan Abu Dawood here:

 

http://www.usc.edu/org/cmje/religious-texts/hadith/abudawud/038-sat.php

 

See hadith #4390.

 

This is the Islam that TTP wants to preach and are proud of. Bravo! I'm sure the holy Prophet is really pleased that you have kept his sunnah alive. Sick.

[Mohammadi_follower]

No it's not true only adult men were beheaded not children , and this woman was killed because she killed a muslim.

Now ifyou read the bible you can find a lot of stories like that where Josue of Moses or King David killed a lot of people Young or old .

[Syed Fraz Hussain Naqvi]

No it's not true only adult men were beheaded not children , and this woman was killed because she killed a muslim.

Now ifyou read the bible you can find a lot of stories like that where Josue of Moses or King David killed a lot of people Young or old .

 My dear...Verily it is written in Sahih Bukhari....and now many of us would come to know that Shias are right in their point of view that many of Ahadees are self-made...It points at the authenticity of Bukhari....It is the reason why terrorists are feeling proud in their activities...If those who were guilty whud hav been punished 1400 yrs ago then we have not been tended to witness the present circumstances...Thanks

[Jahangiram]

Yes and im sure the TTP went through a thorough examination of each individual student to test whether he had pubic hair growing around his private parts. Guns blazing and all.

 

And they discerned whose an innocent muslim or not. 

 

All the above shows why TTP is a dying breed, nothing could be worse for them than having the afghan Taliban condemning you for killing innocents.

Edited December 18, 2014 by Jahangiram

[iCambrian]

Has anyone actually read the hadith referenced? 

[The Green Knight]

Bukhari and other books from Muawiya's hadith factories are a heap of rubbish. We've been saying that all along and that remains so. No matter who reads them and how. Fanatics deriving their codes from them are poison for the society. This poison is why our ummah is in the state it is today.

[iCambrian]

I wonder...are many sunni scholars discrediting the hadith? Or Interpreting it differently? I wonder what their response is to this

[FeudalKingdom]

I wonder...are many sunni scholars discrediting the hadith? Or Interpreting it differently? I wonder what their response is to this

The decision to slay all men from Bani Qurayza was that of Hazrat Sa‘d bin Mu‘adh [RA], and was in accordance with the Jewish law as stated in Deuteronomy 20:10-14. The law was a punishment for those who broke treaties.

Therefore, it cannot be used as an excuse to attack Muslim children.

[Spicen]

Y

The decision to slay all men from Bani Qurayza was that of Hazrat Sa‘d bin Mu‘adh [RA], and was in accordance with the Jewish law as stated in Deuteronomy 20:10-14. The law was a punishment for those who broke treaties.

Therefore, it cannot be used as an excuse to attack Muslim children.

Theres a verse in OT where Moses supposedly kills all men in a village and enslaves the women and children. In Samuel G-d commands the king of Jews Saulkill children amd infants.

Besides hadiths are not infallible.

[baqar]

No it's not true only adult men were beheaded not children , and this woman was killed because she killed a muslim.

 

Dr. Barakat Ahmed has written a book clled "Muhammad and the Jews" in which he says that the Bani Qurayza story contains a lot of lies.

 

Islamic history says all the Bani Qurayza Jews were killed.

 

But common sense also tells me that all the 500 or 800 Jews  could not possibly have been at fault. 

 

The story is plainly false.

 

Dr. Barakat Ahmed is not a Shia but I think his argument makes a lot of sense.

 

Theres a verse in OT where Moses supposedly kills all men in a village and enslaves the women and children. 

 

Just like Sahih Bukhari & Muslim, the OT contains a lot of garbage. 

[PeaceLoving]

 

 “At the time of the Bannu Qurayza massacre, Prophet Mohammed ordered only those children be killed whose pubic hairs have appeared,” 

 

The Bani Quraiza story is, like many others, one of the BIG LIES  of Islamic history.