Advice To Read Jihad Al-nafs By Grand A Behjat

[raficsulejmanovic]

I was reading about Grand Ayatullah Muhammad Taqi Behjat Fumani when I stumbled this:

"His famous advice to youths is ‘to read and practise one hadith daily from the Chapter of Jihad al-nafs in Wasail al-Shi’a of Shaykh Hurr al-Amili."

I presume it is the same book as penned below.

I couldn't find in pdf online but I found most the chapters can be read here.

---

Combat With Self, ed. 2003

Author: Muhammad b. al-Hassan al-Hurr al-Amali

Publisher: ICAS Press, UK

ISBN 1 904063 14 4

[JHK]

1. Al Quran

2. Torah

3. Injil

4. Fascinating Discourses of Fourteen Infallibles

5. Nahjul Balagha

and then maybe Jihad al nafs.

[Ali_Hussain]

1. Al Quran

2. Torah

3. Injil

4. Fascinating Discourses of Fourteen Infallibles

5. Nahjul Balagha

and then maybe Jihad al nafs.

What you are saying is ridiculous, if you had read it, you would know it has more value (and is more authentic) than numbers 2-5

[JHK]

It is a copy paste of Quran. Allah warned about those who copy paste Quran.

Al-Quran Explicitly Commands to read Torah, Injil, and know Sunnah.

However most students never read Torah, Injil, and even Nahjul Balagha. It is shameful.

Do you claim your book is more important than What Allah Commands You To Read. Have you read Torah and Injil?

And is this what you teach your students? Are you misleading your students?

Inshallah Imam Mahdi will destroy your school if you don't think 2-5 are important. May Allah have mercy on you.

[Who_Am_I]

Jhk : 

The way you talk is so harsh. Dont you understand such books like combat with self are derived from Great Quran and Ahl e Bait a.s. such people like hur amili do not speak from their self  but from quran and ahl e bait. 

Surely people may read torah and injeel too. But dont do bad prayers it is not the school of thought of ahl e baite .