Urgent Attention Of Admins

[Guest Mushu]

Admins need to look at the rules and regulations of this site.

We aren't allowed to request for Allahs (SWT) mercy to be removed from Abu Bakr, Uthman, and Umar, and yet you allow members of the site to openly slander the names of our beloved scholars.

People who have given and dedicated their entire lives to serve our beloved religion are insulted on a daily basis, whilst moderators hunt for people saying la'nah, giving them harsh and instant warnings.

The current state of things is disgusting and shameful.

This issue needs to be looked at.

Just now even, whilst I was in the chatroom, I had to endure certain members slandering the good names of Al-Shaheed Mohammed Baqir Al-Sadr, Syed Al-Khomeini, and also Syed Mohammed Al-Musawi.

I left the chatroom with disgust, and I do not intend to return there until the current state of affairs is rectified.

Edited August 30, 2011 by Mushu

[MissShiaMuslim]

+1

[Muhammed Ali]

I have said it in a recent thread; this forum is at it's lowest pont ever. The moderators are not fulfilling their duty.

[Ya Aba 3abdillah]

I had to endure certain members slandering the good names of Al-Shaheed Mohammed Baqir Al-Sadr

Who, and at what time?

[Guest Mushu]

Who, and at what time?

I dont wish to be a 'grass', or point at a particular individual, because that is not good akhlaq. I am merely raising my concerns about the forum as a whole.

If you still wish to know, please PM me akhi.

[yassameen]

with presence of mods sometimes even

[Guest Mushu]

with presence of mods sometimes even

Though to be fair, today only one mod was present, and she is usually an excellent mod, one of the best. I suspect she wasnt aware of what was happening.

[Ya Aba 3abdillah]

I dont wish to be a 'grass', or point at a particular individual, because that is not good akhlaq. I am merely raising my concerns about the forum as a whole.

If you still wish to know, please PM me akhi.

well i just read the logs. haidar al karrar has no idea what he's talking about when speaking about shariatmadari. as for shahid as-sadr, he said that they said things "laymen would say". he's ill educated, so it's to be expected from someone who shows little respect for such great men. but what do you expect of these people anyway.

[Guest Mushu]

well i just read the logs. haidar al karrar has no idea what he's talking about when speaking about shariatmadari. as for shahid as-sadr, he said that they said things "laymen would say". he's ill educated, so it's to be expected from someone who shows little respect for such great men. but what do you expect of these people anyway.

Thank you brother, but I also very much resent the slandering of the names of our other Ulema', such as Syed Mohammed Al-Musawi.

But Jazak'Ullah.

I would also like to request some action taken to prevent this sort of thing happening in the future, for example the introduction of some more, stricter chatmods.

Edited August 30, 2011 by Mushu

[Kamranistan]

I think generally on this website, scholary hating is integrated as part of discussion, without it there is no discussion.. Sad times

[Guest Mushu]

I think generally on this website, scholary hating is integrated as part of discussion, without it there is no discussion.. Sad times

Its fine to disagree with a scholar, and discuss them in a polite way, but to slander and insult?

In real life, I would have straight sparked someone who spoke like that. No lie.

[Kamranistan]

P.S. I pretty much agree with Mushu. So that's 2 to the cause!

[Shia_Debater]

Who, and at what time?

Brother its also happening on the forums, people debating or arguing and sending a few insults to each other whilst they are at it. I do not doubt that the admin team do a great job and it is hard to monitor the whole website but I even read in the rules people will get temporary bans if they keep on insulting and there are people who I have seen send insults in alot of there posts and I dont see any temporary bans.

Maybe get a few more admins or go through the general discussions threads once a day, that is the area where alot of heated arguements are and where insults happen the most.

[Kamranistan]

Brother its also happening on the forums, people debating or arguing and sending a few insults to each other whilst they are at it. I do not doubt that the admin team do a great job and it is hard to monitor the whole website but I even read in the rules people will get temporary bans if they keep on insulting and there are people who I have seen send insults in alot of there posts and I dont see any temporary bans.

Maybe get a few more admins or go through the general discussions threads once a day, that is the area where alot of heated arguements are and where insults happen the most.

Debater's right.

[Muhammed Ali]

I do not doubt that the admin team do a great job

I must say that they do very good job on other areas but the abusive and disrespectful language has to be stopped.

[Abu'l Khattab]

well i just read the logs. haidar al karrar has no idea what he's talking about when speaking about shariatmadari. as for shahid as-sadr, he said that they said things "laymen would say". he's ill educated, so it's to be expected from someone who shows little respect for such great men. but what do you expect of these people anyway.

Right right, all I said is that Muhammed Baqir al Sadr said (ra) after umars name? Is this true? If so, would a layman even say this?

[King]

get over yourselves, stop whining like a baby, no one needs this forum to turn into a police forum. Mashallah its at a highpoint these days, a lot of good discussions in the chatroom among the jokes here and there.

peace

[Guest Mushu]

get over yourselves, stop whining like a baby, no one needs this forum to turn into a police forum. Mashallah its at a highpoint these days, a lot of good discussions in the chatroom among the jokes here and there.

peace

NOTE TO ADMINS: This member spends his time trying to draw msn's from reluctant SC members. Furthermore, he spends hours TRYING to flirt with female SC members.

Check the logs, i'm not lying. I have no reason to.

[King]

NOTE TO ADMINS: This member spends his time trying to draw msn's from reluctant SC members. Furthermore, he spends hours TRYING to flirt with female SC members.

Check the logs, i'm not lying. I have no reason to.

BOHOOO go suck on a lemon, and if you want some msns HOLLA

spoil sport

[Abu'l Khattab]

Its fine to disagree with a scholar, and discuss them in a polite way, but to slander and insult?

In real life, I would have straight sparked someone who spoke like that. No lie.

You know what the islamic def. of slandering is?

[Blissful]

NOTE TO ADMINS: This member spends his time trying to draw msn's from reluctant SC members. Furthermore, he spends hours TRYING to flirt with female SC members.

Check the logs, i'm not lying. I have no reason to.

Some members post music links in the chatroom and on people's profiles all the time :)

[-Enlightened]

Just now even, whilst I was in the chatroom, I had to endure certain members slandering the good names of Al-Shaheed Mohammed Baqir Al-Sadr, Syed Al-Khomeini, and also Syed Mohammed Al-Musawi.

I don't think there was a Mod at that time ..but none of us would allow it if it happened

[Abu'l Khattab]

I dont wish to be a 'grass', or point at a particular individual, because that is not good akhlaq. I am merely raising my concerns about the forum as a whole.

If you still wish to know, please PM me akhi.

Lol gheebah much?

[Abu'l Khattab]

Its fine to disagree with a scholar, and discuss them in a polite way, but to slander and insult?

In real life, I would have straight sparked someone who spoke like that. No lie.

I'd like you to say that to some members of my tribe heh:

[Ya Aba 3abdillah]

Points have been noted and issues will be addressed inshAllah.

[Abbas.]

Salams Dear Members

While the issues raised by you will be addressed and dealt with by SC team, there are a couple of points that need to be conveyed to all members just so that you understand our perspective and that we are all on the same page.

Firstly, the responsibility of ensuring that forum rules are not broken does not entirely rest on SC team. We'd like to encourage all senior or serious members to contribute in this regard and make use of the "report" feature. If you see any thread, post or profile breaking forum rules, please inform us by reporting it. If you find any member misbehaving in the chatroom, please report him/her and feel free to 'printscreen' and share it with admins. If you can't be bothered doing that, atleast save some general info such as the date/time of chat and the username. We can then access chat logs to see if the member actually broke our rules.

Secondly, the issue of disrespect/slander towards esteemed scholars has to be dealt with carefully. This is a grey and a sensitive area and at times, we have to differentiate between a slander and a criticism. Please note that while our principles/rules do not allow disrespect towards our esteemed marjas, we also have to allow criticism (constructive) in honor of free speech. So at times, if certain critics on the forum are being tolerated, it is not because we have lost our ways. Rather, it is the teachings of our great marjas - tolerance and patience - that we give equal opportunity to everyone. Having said that, we will obviously not let any member get away with insulting/abusive comments against our marjas/scholars. So kindly report a member who is guilty of (repeatedly) insulting our scholars. And if you feel that the team is not taking appropriate actions of your reports, please contact one of the mods/admins and submit your complaint.

Thankyou

Regards

I