With whom sacrifice of Ismail a.s was ransomed?

**Aabiss_Shakari** · August 14, 2009

(salam)

(bismillah)

ÑóÈøö åóÈú áöí ãöäó ÇáÕøóÇáöÍöíäó {100}

ÝóÈóÔøóÑúäóÇåõ ÈöÛõáóÇãò Íóáöíãò {101}

ÝóáóãøóÇ ÈóáóÛó ãóÚóåõ ÇáÓøóÚúíó ÞóÇáó íóÇ Èõäóíøó Åöäøöí ÃóÑóì Ýöí ÇáúãóäóÇãö Ãóäøöí ÃóÐúÈóÍõßó ÝóÇäÙõÑú ãóÇÐóÇ ÊóÑóì ÞóÇáó íóÇ ÃóÈóÊö ÇÝúÚóáú ãóÇ ÊõÄúãóÑõ ÓóÊóÌöÏõäöí Åöä ÔóÇÁ Çááøóåõ ãöäó ÇáÕøóÇÈöÑöíäó {102}

ÝóáóãøóÇ ÃóÓúáóãóÇ æóÊóáøóåõ áöáúÌóÈöíäö {103}

æóäóÇÏóíúäóÇåõ Ãóäú íóÇ ÅöÈúÑóÇåöíãõ {104}

ÞóÏú ÕóÏøóÞúÊó ÇáÑøõÄúíóÇ ÅöäøóÇ ßóÐóáößó äóÌúÒöí ÇáúãõÍúÓöäöíäó {105}

Åöäøó åóÐóÇ áóåõæó ÇáúÈóáóÇÁ ÇáúãõÈöíäõ {106}

æóÝóÏóíúäóÇåõ ÈöÐöÈúÍò ÚóÙöíãò {107}

My Lord! grant me of the doers of good deeds. [surah Saf'aat Ayat 100]

So We gave him the good news of a boy, possessing forbearance. [surah Saf'aat Ayat 101]

And when he attained to working with him, he said: O my son! surely I have seen in a dream that I should sacrifice you; consider then what you see. He said: O my father! do what you are commanded; if Allah please, you will find me of the patient ones.[surah Saf'aat Ayat 102]

So when they both submitted and he threw him down upon his forehead, [surah Saf'aat Ayat 103]

And We called out to him saying: O Ibrahim! [surah Saf'aat Ayat 104]

You have indeed shown the truth of the vision; surely thus do We reward the doers of good: [surah Saf'aat Ayat 105]

Most surely this is a manifest trial. [surah Saf'aat Ayat 106]

And We ransomed him with a Feat sacrifice. [surah Saf'aat Ayat 107]

Any Sunni can tell me that with which sacrifice Allah almighty ransomed the sacrifice of Ismail (as)?

There are many allegation on Shia muslims that they exaggerate the virtues and merits of Ahlul bait (as) and they are exaggerators and this exaggeration have led them astray. So dear Sunni brothers present your tafseer of "Zibhul Azeem" and let me compare it with Shia interpretation of it, so that i can find the truth.

Awaiting_for_the12th · August 15, 2009

Imam Hussain(as)

**Aabiss_Shakari** · August 15, 2009

^^ Yes brother. But i want to know Sunni view of it. They call it exaggeration.

moot ko yaad kero · August 15, 2009

salam bro aabiss and nice topic

i don't think so any suuni or nasbi will reply you on this topic,

i did not found any sunni alim like Ahmed raza khan (kanzul iman) writes any thing about the ayat 107 or any nasbi alim like ibn kaseer in his tafseer writes any thing about the ayat 107

they only discuss other ayat and explain the tafeer of other ayats but not 107.

both alims discuss the matter either he was ismail a.s or eshaq a.s and only writes the whole incident

when, who, why, ibrahim a.s take his son, but when the matter of ayat 107 came. they kept slint and move forward without writtin any thing.

**Aabiss_Shakari** · August 15, 2009

Çÿ ãیÑÿ ÑÈ! ãÌªÿ Çی˜ ÕÇáÍ (áš˜Ç) ÚØÇ ˜Ñ 100

101. Ó Àã äÿ ÇÓÿ Çی˜ áš˜ÿ Íáã æÇáÿ ˜ی ÎæÔÎÈÑی Ïی

102. ªÑ ÌÈ æÀ ÇÓ ˜ÿ ÀãÑÇÀ áäÿ ªÑäÿ áÇ ˜ÀÇ Çÿ ÈیŠÿ! Èÿ Ô˜ ãیŸ ÎæÇÈ ãیŸ Ïی˜ªÊÇ ÀæŸ ˜À ãیŸ ÊÌªÿ ÐÈÍ ˜Ñ ˜Ñ ÑÀÇ ÀæŸ Ó Ïی˜ª ÊیÑی ˜یÇ ÑÇÆÿÀÿ ˜ÀÇ Çÿ ÇÈÇ! Ìæ Í˜ã Â ˜æ ÀæÇ Àÿ ˜Ñ ÏیÌیÆÿ Â ãÌªÿ ÇäÔÇÇááå ÕÈÑ ˜Ñäÿ æÇáæŸ ãیŸ ÇÆیŸ ÿ

103. Ó ÌÈ ÏæäæŸ äÿ ÞÈæá ˜Ñ áیÇ ÇæÑ ÇÓ äÿ یÔÇäی ˜ÿ Èá Çá ÏیÇ

104. ÇæÑ Àã äÿ ÇÓÿ ˜ÇÑÇ ˜À Çÿ ÇÈÑÇªیã!

105. Êæ äÿ ÎæÇÈ ÓÇ ˜Ñ Ï˜ªÇیÇ Èÿ Ô˜ Àã ÇÓی ØÑÍ Àã ÇÓی ØÑÍ äی˜æ ˜ÇÑæŸ ˜æ ÈÏáÀ ÏیÇ ˜ÑÊÿ ÀیŸ