Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله
Sign in to follow this  
ShiaSoldier@2007

Nadeem Sarwar What Do You Think?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

I'm kinda 50/50. Some of his nawhas are extremely good like (Aa ay mere Hussain meree goad mein aja/Musafiran-e-Musibat/Qaidkhanay mein) but some are completely songlike (No it doesn't sound like a song because I've listened to that song - I never listen to music, it's just that the tune doesn't have any riqqat or dard in it) Ex: Amma achi amma mera kunba kahan hae/ jhula jhulaoon loree sunaoon aa mere asghar. Overall, I think he's okay. His bad nawhas balance out hid good ones.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
does anyone know how often does he go to shaam with a sangat for chelum? all the noha khawans i know of go every year but ive never heard of him leading a sangat there, or kerbala, or anywhere really

Nadeem Sarwar went to Syria in 2005 and 2006 on chehlum. A friend of mine went to Syria in 2005 and told me that NS was there too. My chachu went in 2006 and had an amazing time mashaALLAH(swt) with so many good nauhakhuans present.

Feamaannillah!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

personally i dont like the guy...mainly becaude his nohay are tuned on a humerous/joyful tune..and other top nohay khwaan have done that before aswell..but all of this guys nohay are tuned funny..and u cant give sarwar the credit for the Poetry..the poet is Rehan Azmi..nadeem just makes awful tunes..

i played one of his nohay in fromt of a sunni friend one time and he said let me lissen to it..after listening to it, he said "is it a song"...i said "no".. he said "it sounds like one...

this guy should just stop reading nohay coz it makes evry1 laff...and his videos are a disgrace to azadari..

Ya Ali Madad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Salaam

For quite a few years, I have been listening to comments made by people against Nadeem Sarwar. Well, How can people know the intentions that lie deep within the hearts of others?

Maybe Nadeem Sarwar's recitations are accepted by Bibi Zahra (S.A.) hereself! so, who are we to comment?!

I personally think that it is a good thing to appreciate that our children, who belong to the 21st century where Metal and Rock cultures have flourished their roots, are turning towards Azadari through these nawhas. I personally have seen young children craving and demanding MP3 players and Ipods just for the sake of listening to nawhas!

Agreed!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
personally i dont like the guy...mainly becaude his nohay are tuned on a humerous/joyful tune..and other top nohay khwaan have done that before aswell..but all of this guys nohay are tuned funny..and u cant give sarwar the credit for the Poetry..the poet is Rehan Azmi..nadeem just makes awful tunes..

i played one of his nohay in fromt of a sunni friend one time and he said let me lissen to it..after listening to it, he said "is it a song"...i said "no".. he said "it sounds like one...

this guy should just stop reading nohay coz it makes evry1 laff...and his videos are a disgrace to azadari..

Ya Ali Madad

(salam)

MashaALLAH(swt), Rehan Azmi writes hundreds of kalamz every year. He cant write everything on his own. Basically what happens is that the nauhakhuwans go to him and tell him the concept and he turns it into poetry. Rehan Azmi is an amazing poet! But the nauhakhwuans MUST be given credit for the "CONEPTS".

Nauha--->funny??how come?? :huh:

Feamaannillah!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
is nadeem sarwar the nauha reciter and writer makrooh.

I heard once he tried getting a band with guitars and stuff to say nauhas but was booted off and insulted.

(salam)

earlier 90's were the best nauhas i have ever heard, but now sorry to say he cant able to creat the environment of sorrow in his nauhas, most of the people love his style, speed, way of presenting or creativity, but the basic meaning of nauha is to creat sadness..

well i also heard some nauhas similar to the way of Songs which is absolutely haram...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Salaam

For quite a few years, I have been listening to comments made by people against Nadeem Sarwar. Well, How can people know the intentions that lie deep within the hearts of others?

Maybe Nadeem Sarwar's recitations are accepted by Bibi Zahra (S.A.) hereself! so, who are we to comment?!

I personally think that it is a good thing to appreciate that our children, who belong to the 21st century where Metal and Rock cultures have flourished their roots, are turning towards Azadari through these nawhas. I personally have seen young children craving and demanding MP3 players and Ipods just for the sake of listening to nawhas!

for your first para if you belive Bibi Zehra s.a permitted him for nauha, then mazallah bibi zehra allowed him to recite nauha which include the tune of songs, he is submitting something bad towards Bibi Zehra, i cant explain this illteracy i feel insult if i say anything bad for Bibi just to explain you..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

he's a DRAMA, heard the way he puts his fake crying into his studio nohay...i dont dislike him as a person, i just dont like any of the tunes to the nohay he reads..

and rehan azmi dosent get any kind of CONCEPT from any nohay khwan...i've just met rehan azmi and he tell me how each nohaykhwan requests for a noha on a certain topic and he writes it..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
he's a DRAMA, heard the way he puts his fake crying into his studio nohay...i dont dislike him as a person, i just dont like any of the tunes to the nohay he reads..

and rehan azmi dosent get any kind of CONCEPT from any nohay khwan...i've just met rehan azmi and he tell me how each nohaykhwan requests for a noha on a certain topic and he writes it..

I think he sounds better than others who DONT show any change in their voices :dry: on a misra thats more sad than the other misras of a nauha. They recite the nauha as if they are just reading something without really feeling the "dard" in the kalam. Nadeem Sarwar's voice reflects the emotion of a particular misra. If a misra is "tableeghi", he recites it in an addressing sort of way and if its "sad", his voice is toned down.

"Concept".."Topic", I dont see a big difference in the two..but obviously the nauhakhuwans tell him what they want and he writes the poetry for them.

No hard feelings :blush:

Feamaannillah!

Edited by G.A

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(salam)

I have always loved this nauhas rite from the 90's.Infact when he came to india(mumbai) in 1991.He had recited nawhas in a mataam at our house n my Dad had gifted him many Nuwhas n marsiya books which he (dad) had brought from Hyderabad(india).

So in the next year(1992) Nadeem had recited the nauha"Garm rehti pe main girta hoon samaloon amma",which is taken from a hyderabadi marsiya.:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He, um gets weirder and scarier every year.

I think someone said.."tableegh for the kids" ?? I think not lol. The video for Buss Ya Hussain is hella scary =S I did like this years 'Haye Qasim' and 'Abbas BUlata Hai' though.

I think he has an amaaziinngg voice MashaAllah, but lets hope he uses it for reciting more dard-waley and better nauhas rather than song-like ones.

I would probably like him better then.

You guys, puhleez. I share the sentiment of not getting too music-y, but better Nadeem Sarwar than Britney spears.

Drums are allowed in azadari and are well used in Iraq. He also picks good nauhas to read. Garm reti is my favorite, its a hyderabadi nauha ;)

(salam)

I have always loved this nauhas rite from the 90's.Infact when he came to india(mumbai) in 1991.He had recited nawhas in a mataam at our house n my Dad had gifted him many Nuwhas n marsiya books which he (dad) had brought from Hyderabad(india).

So in the next year(1992) Nadeem had recited the nauha"Garm rehti pe main girta hoon samaloon amma",which is taken from a hyderabadi marsiya.:)

Yeah... and Rehan Azmi changed the words and messed up the tune.

Why can't they just recite the original Ali Javed Maqsood version? =S

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

Wish I could bribe Sipah-e-Sahaba ( A Wahabi Terrorist Org) to kill him.. he is such a big fitna... likewise Naqi the guy who runs Al-Zulfiqar group in Karachi... People like him are the fitnah with in the shia community

PEACE

lol here u are talking about getting a known shia killed, and ur calling HIM the fitna

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I personally dont listen to urdu latmiyats, but seeing this thread made check this reciter's latimayats. We ought to think positively about things. not negatively. look at everything positively (glass half full rather than half empty). There is nothing wrong with pop (not that i listen to it). The nawhas that the elders of the community listen to were once also considered pop when they were young. It depends on the intention of the singers and the intention of the listeners. does it ultimately bring them closer to ahlul bayt? if it doesnt bring us closer to ahlul bayt then we should not say it doesnt bring anyone closer to ahlul bayt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

well , I think my statement was pretty clear... I wont argue .. coz Jahalat ka koi ilaj nahi hai..and since when did that business man become a shia

PEACE

that is very true indeed. he takes �10,000 for 10 days in moharram from khojay in uk. i know the ppl personally. he's not an azadar. he used to be a singer in karachi for weddings. and now he's stuck in the middle of singling and reading nohay! he should just quit.

people who onli go to matamdari 10 days a year dont know anything about good or bad noha khwan.. i recommend that pl should step into the azadari regularly urself and then u will find out for urself... not just listening to his nohay in ur earphones for time-pass... be real.. this is musaib of moula hussain.. nothing is more important in our world.. NOTHING..

ALI ALI

Edited by bar_yazid_lanat

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nadeem Sarwar's noahs are getting more music like year by year. The videos are SCARY. This year, Abbas bulata hain and Hai Qasim were good though. His pre-2000 nohas were much better. After 2000 he killed it..

Some of his better earlier ones are

Aa dekh mere Ghazi ooncha hain Alam tera..

Na rakh ab chaadar bazuo pe tunie le daag chupa nahi Zahra ki jaa sharma nahi..

Tamam alam main aaj matam Hussain baykas ka ho raha hain..

Ay Shion jab peena pani bhool na jaana mujhe..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

salaam.

first i am absoluteley discusted that i find people back chatting filth about the great nadeem sarwar.

People find anything and i mean anything to not like a person.

If you dont like the way his nawhas are recited then thats fine just dont play it, DONT start saying bad stuff behind his back.

Whos next you lot going to cuss? Abuthar al halawiji , bassim al karbalei, mesum abbas?

Also theres different opinions on instruments. Abuthar for instance uses instruments in his latmiyas.

Also theres no set fixed way to recite a nawha, so again if you dont like it, dont play it.

where will it stop.

From an islamic website im shocked to see this fitnah topic.

Also some message i read from someone saying theyll go to the extent of wanting to kill him?

Astagfirullah.

disgracefull.

Ali

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

why is it that no people who actually DO (two handed) matam can stand his nohay? someone like king katri or hassan sadiq make u wanna go insane in matam, nadeem makes u want to start changing lightbulbs and doing bhangra

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I dont like his nauhas... and I think his popularity's gone to head.

Its like, when you need attention you do all these weird things with the hair and the videos.. and stuff.

I've met him once- and he was so nice back then. Lol, i realized how silly it is now.

We were all standing in a line waiting for him to sign our autograph book.

But hes all conceited and weird now...

He's like a Man Hananh Montana for kids now. I like his nohas from the 90's..

lol :lol:

I personally think that it is a good thing to appreciate that our children, who belong to the 21st century where Metal and Rock cultures have flourished their roots, are turning towards Azadari through these nawhas. I personally have seen young children craving and demanding MP3 players and Ipods just for the sake of listening to nawhas!

Oh, so basically you're saying that nauhas should be like modern rock music just so that youngsters listen to it??

What will be the difference then?

Aren't nauhas supposed to be mournful?

As for children looking up to Nadeem Sarwar as a rock star, well to me it is actually a great thing, because if they look up to Nadeem Sarwar, they will spend their spare time reciting Nohas, on the other hand if they start idolizing rock starts, they would do things which are generally associated with rock stars. (sex, drugs, alcohol and the list goes on)

And what is associated with Nadeem Sarwar? I thought over that and its definitely nothing very nice

(salam) ya ali madad

i dont like Studio nauhay end of

i mean the intentions annd the words may be beautiful, but the way they recorded with the sound effects really P1$$3$ me off :mad: lol...

Agreed.

why is it that no people who actually DO (two handed) matam can stand his nohay? someone like king katri or hassan sadiq make u wanna go insane in matam, nadeem makes u want to start changing lightbulbs and doing bhangra

Lol. yepp agreed... Its sad though, innit?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(bismillah)

(salam)

The problem lies in this very thread. A lot of people have created a fan club culture which destroys the entire purpose and credibility of the rememberance of the Imam (as) and his family/companions sacrifice. People seem to be more interested in the recitor than the content (just like people have favourite singers, you've now got favourite recitors). The way people talk about and compare the "tunes" and the "melody" is a complete embarassment to the concept of religious eulogies.

One who truly wishes to mourn the Imam (as) will do so, regardless of the voice of the recitor and the "tune" of what he is reciting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok im not going to talk [Edited Out] about him Some of theseguys hate his guts i mean hes nuetral for me sometimes good even..

some of you guys are talking about him like he's saddam hes a fellow shia for god sake give him some respect..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well Nadeem Sarwar is my most favourite nauha khwan.He is so good.but i dnt understand that why some people doesnt like him??his nauhas are best.i dnt think that these are just like popular songs.His voice is so good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...