Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
redman 123

Imam Ali And Slave-girls

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

(salam)

There are multiple reports that he did get married when he was with fatimah

one of them when they went to a battle.

Not enough study is been put to the timing of his marriages

Imam Ali is reported in Tabaqat Ibn Sa3d (Sunnie Historian) to have 33 children 19 females and 14 males He is also known to have had 25 Wives. 9 of them we know their names and from number 10 to 25 we don’t know their names for some unknown reason!!!!

There are conflicting reports so do not quote everything I paste here but this is one of the famous reports about the names of his wives:

Imam Ali’s Wives and children:

1) Fatima Alzahraa

(Hasan, Husain, Muhsen, Zainab alkubra, Um kulthoom alkubra, Zainab alsughra)

2) Emamah bint Aby al-3ass

(mohamd alawsat)

3) Khawla bint jafaar alhanafiah

(Mohamad Alakbar)

4) Fatima Bint Hizam alkilaabyah or Ummulbaneen

(Abbas, Abdullah, Uthman, Jaffar)

5) Laila Altamymyah

(Ubaidullah, Abu bakr, Mohamad alasghar)

6) Um habib Altaghlubyah

(Umar alatraf , Ruqayah alkubra)

7) Asmaa Bin Umais al Khath3amyah

(Yahya, Aown)

8) Um Sa3eed Bint Orwah

(Ummulhasan, Ramlah alkubra, Um kalthoom)

9) Mahyat bint Emree Alqais Alkalbyah

(Small daughter that died early)

10) Wife 10

(Mohamad Alasghar)

11) Wife 11

(Umar alasghar)

12) Wife 12

(Zainab alSughra)

13) Wife 13

(Um kalthoom Alsughra)

14) Wife 14

(Nafeesa)

15) Wife 15

(Ruqayah alsughra)

16) Wife 16

(Um Hani)

17) Wife 17

(Fatima)

18) Wife 18

(ummulkiram)

19) Wife 19

(Um jafar, Jumanah)

20) Wife 20

(Um Salamah)

21) Wife 21

(Maymoonah)

22) Wife 22

(Khadeejah)

23) Wife 23

(Emamah)

24) Wife 24

(Ramlah alSughra)

25) Wife 25

(Umme Abeeha)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it is narrated by buraydah aslami that during the return from yemen imam Ali took a slave girl from the share of booty of the prophet , buraydah was angry and reported it to Rasoolallah at which Rasoolallah became enraged and said something like " whatever belongs to me belongs to ali" buraydah was so moved that he never complained about Ali again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it is narrated by buraydah aslami that during the return from yemen imam Ali took a slave girl from the share of booty of the prophet , buraydah was angry and reported it to Rasoolallah at which Rasoolallah became enraged and said something like " whatever belongs to me belongs to ali" buraydah was so moved that he never complained about Ali again.

this relates to whom ever i (pbuh) am a friend of ali(as) is his friend also

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

There are multiple reports that he did get married when he was with fatimah

one of them when they went to a battle.

Not enough study is been put to the timing of his marriages

Imam Ali is reported in Tabaqat Ibn Sa3d (Sunnie Historian) to have 33 children 19 females and 14 males He is also known to have had 25 Wives. 9 of them we know their names and from number 10 to 25 we don’t know their names for some unknown reason!!!!

There are conflicting reports so do not quote everything I paste here but this is one of the famous reports about the names of his wives:

Imam Ali’s Wives and children:

1) Fatima Alzahraa

(Hasan, Husain, Muhsen, Zainab alkubra, Um kulthoom alkubra, Zainab alsughra)

2) Emamah bint Aby al-3ass

(mohamd alawsat)

3) Khawla bint jafaar alhanafiah

(Mohamad Alakbar)

4) Fatima Bint Hizam alkilaabyah or Ummulbaneen

(Abbas, Abdullah, Uthman, Jaffar)

5) Laila Altamymyah

(Ubaidullah, Abu bakr, Mohamad alasghar)

6) Um habib Altaghlubyah

(Umar alatraf , Ruqayah alkubra)

7) Asmaa Bin Umais al Khath3amyah

(Yahya, Aown)

8) Um Sa3eed Bint Orwah

(Ummulhasan, Ramlah alkubra, Um kalthoom)

9) Mahyat bint Emree Alqais Alkalbyah

(Small daughter that died early)

10) Wife 10

(Mohamad Alasghar)

11) Wife 11

(Umar alasghar)

12) Wife 12

(Zainab alSughra)

13) Wife 13

(Um kalthoom Alsughra)

14) Wife 14

(Nafeesa)

15) Wife 15

(Ruqayah alsughra)

16) Wife 16

(Um Hani)

17) Wife 17

(Fatima)

18) Wife 18

(ummulkiram)

19) Wife 19

(Um jafar, Jumanah)

20) Wife 20

(Um Salamah)

21) Wife 21

(Maymoonah)

22) Wife 22

(Khadeejah)

23) Wife 23

(Emamah)

24) Wife 24

(Ramlah alSughra)

25) Wife 25

(Umme Abeeha)

You need to corroborate the above through Shia works relying on authentic narrations from the 11 Aimmah succeeding Ameer ul Momineen. They would certainly know how many wives he had and how many children he had from each wife.

If you cannot do that, please do post such things on public boards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

There are multiple reports that he did get married when he was with fatimah

one of them when they went to a battle.

Not enough study is been put to the timing of his marriages

Imam Ali is reported in Tabaqat Ibn Sa3d (Sunnie Historian) to have 33 children 19 females and 14 males He is also known to have had 25 Wives. 9 of them we know their names and from number 10 to 25 we don’t know their names for some unknown reason!!!!

There are conflicting reports so do not quote everything I paste here but this is one of the famous reports about the names of his wives:

Imam Ali’s Wives and children:

1) Fatima Alzahraa

(Hasan, Husain, Muhsen, Zainab alkubra, Um kulthoom alkubra, Zainab alsughra)

2) Emamah bint Aby al-3ass

(mohamd alawsat)

3) Khawla bint jafaar alhanafiah

(Mohamad Alakbar)

4) Fatima Bint Hizam alkilaabyah or Ummulbaneen

(Abbas, Abdullah, Uthman, Jaffar)

5) Laila Altamymyah

(Ubaidullah, Abu bakr, Mohamad alasghar)

6) Um habib Altaghlubyah

(Umar alatraf , Ruqayah alkubra)

7) Asmaa Bin Umais al Khath3amyah

(Yahya, Aown)

8) Um Sa3eed Bint Orwah

(Ummulhasan, Ramlah alkubra, Um kalthoom)

9) Mahyat bint Emree Alqais Alkalbyah

(Small daughter that died early)

10) Wife 10

(Mohamad Alasghar)

11) Wife 11

(Umar alasghar)

12) Wife 12

(Zainab alSughra)

13) Wife 13

(Um kalthoom Alsughra)

14) Wife 14

(Nafeesa)

15) Wife 15

(Ruqayah alsughra)

16) Wife 16

(Um Hani)

17) Wife 17

(Fatima)

18) Wife 18

(ummulkiram)

19) Wife 19

(Um jafar, Jumanah)

20) Wife 20

(Um Salamah)

21) Wife 21

(Maymoonah)

22) Wife 22

(Khadeejah)

23) Wife 23

(Emamah)

24) Wife 24

(Ramlah alSughra)

25) Wife 25

(Umme Abeeha)

According to sheikh al Mufid in Kitab Al-Irshad...Imam Ali Had 27 children...the wives thing is not specific...but he mentions 6 wives by name.....hmmMMMMMM I'd take shiekh mufid to be more reliable anyways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(bismillah)

(salam)

^^any evidence Imam Ali never had any slave-girls while married to Bibi Fatima

What you're looking for is evidence that he had them, rather than didn't. You cannot look for evidence of something that never was. When you search for evidence, you're searching for something that existed or that took place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Imam Ali is reported in Tabaqat Ibn Sa3d (Sunni historian) to have 33 children 19 females and 14 males. He is also known to have had 25 Wives, 9 of them we know their names and from number 10 to 25 we don’t know their names for some unknown reason!!!!

There are conflicting reports so do not quote everything I paste here but this is one of the famous reports about the names of his wives:

Imam Ali’s Wives and children:

1) Fatima Alzahraa

(Hasan, Husain, Muhsen, Zainab alkubra, Um kulthoom alkubra, Zainab alsughra)

2) Emamah bint Aby al-3ass

(mohamd alawsat)

3) Khawla bint jafaar alhanafiah

(Mohamad Alakbar)

4) Fatima Bint Hizam alkilaabyah or Ummulbaneen

(Abbas, Abdullah, Uthman, Jaffar)

5) Laila Altamymyah

(Ubaidullah, Abu bakr, Mohamad alasghar)

6) Um habib Altaghlubyah

(Umar alatraf , Ruqayah alkubra)

7) Asmaa Bin Umais al Khath3amyah

(Yahya, Aown)

8) Um Sa3eed Bint Orwah

(Ummulhasan, Ramlah alkubra, Um kalthoom)

9) Mahyat bint Emree Alqais Alkalbyah

(Small daughter that died early)

10) Wife 10

(Mohamad Alasghar)

11) Wife 11

(Umar alasghar)

12) Wife 12

(Zainab alSughra)

13) Wife 13

(Um kalthoom Alsughra)

14) Wife 14

(Nafeesa)

15) Wife 15

(Ruqayah alsughra)

16) Wife 16

(Um Hani)

17) Wife 17

(Fatima)

18) Wife 18

(ummulkiram)

19) Wife 19

(Um jafar, Jumanah)

20) Wife 20

(Um Salamah)

21) Wife 21

(Maymoonah)

22) Wife 22

(Khadeejah)

23) Wife 23

(Emamah)

24) Wife 24

(Ramlah alSughra)

25) Wife 25

(Umme Abeeha)

Very untrue.

Sheikh Mufeed's Kitab Al-Irshad lists a total of 27 children and not more than a total of 9 wives at different times. But no slave girls during the time of Lady Fatima Zahra or after.

for some unknown reason

The reason is not that it is simply not true.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rasool said" some people will give their blood for Ali whilst others will cry for the blood of Ali." these people who cry for blood of Ali , their descendants are still around i think this settles this matter Ya Ali madad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
(salam)

There are multiple reports that he did get married when he was with fatimah

one of them when they went to a battle.

Not enough study is been put to the timing of his marriages

Imam Ali is reported in Tabaqat Ibn Sa3d (Sunnie Historian) to have 33 children 19 females and 14 males He is also known to have had 25 Wives. 9 of them we know their names and from number 10 to 25 we don’t know their names for some unknown reason!!!!

There are conflicting reports so do not quote everything I paste here but this is one of the famous reports about the names of his wives:

Imam Ali’s Wives and children:

1) Fatima Alzahraa

(Hasan, Husain, Muhsen, Zainab alkubra, Um kulthoom alkubra, Zainab alsughra)

2) Emamah bint Aby al-3ass

(mohamd alawsat)

3) Khawla bint jafaar alhanafiah

(Mohamad Alakbar)

4) Fatima Bint Hizam alkilaabyah or Ummulbaneen

(Abbas, Abdullah, Uthman, Jaffar)

5) Laila Altamymyah

(Ubaidullah, Abu bakr, Mohamad alasghar)

6) Um habib Altaghlubyah

(Umar alatraf , Ruqayah alkubra)

7) Asmaa Bin Umais al Khath3amyah

(Yahya, Aown)

8) Um Sa3eed Bint Orwah

(Ummulhasan, Ramlah alkubra, Um kalthoom)

9) Mahyat bint Emree Alqais Alkalbyah

(Small daughter that died early)

10) Wife 10

(Mohamad Alasghar)

11) Wife 11

(Umar alasghar)

12) Wife 12

(Zainab alSughra)

13) Wife 13

(Um kalthoom Alsughra)

14) Wife 14

(Nafeesa)

15) Wife 15

(Ruqayah alsughra)

16) Wife 16

(Um Hani)

17) Wife 17

(Fatima)

18) Wife 18

(ummulkiram)

19) Wife 19

(Um jafar, Jumanah)

20) Wife 20

(Um Salamah)

21) Wife 21

(Maymoonah)

22) Wife 22

(Khadeejah)

23) Wife 23

(Emamah)

24) Wife 24

(Ramlah alSughra)

25) Wife 25

(Umme Abeeha)

Is this from Kitab Al-Irshad?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Very untrue.

Sheikh Mufeed's Kitab Al-Irshad lists a total of 27 children and not more than a total of 9 wives at different times. But no slave girls during the time of Lady Fatima Zahra or after.

The reason is not that it is simply not true.

Perhaps Kitab Al-Irashad is one of the most reliable on this subject.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You know, I think a lot of ppl make ths things up jst to slander holy figures. All I know is Bibi Fatima was his soulmate and hsi true love.

Why would it be slanderous if he had any other wives or slave girls when he was with Fatima(sa) when its in accordance to Islam and Quranic laws.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×