In the Name of God بسم الله
Search the Community
Showing results for tags 'lobster'.
Salam, I am curious if there is any Marja that permits the eating of Lobster and Crab. Maraja that classify Lobster and Crab as Makhrooh are mentionable as well. I know Ayatollah Sistani and Khamenai say Lobster and Crab is haram. I am looking for Maraja that say otherwise.
Salam alykom I posted a question on yahoo answers earlier this week asking non-muslims if they think whether eating omnivore animals like pigs is morally right or not. One response I got was from one person asking the difference between eating fish and pigs if they are both considered omnivores? He claimed that fish are not only omnivores but as well and will eat anything including dead human flesh. Now I am aware that not everything in the sea is halal, and that in order for a fish to be considered halal, it must have scales. However even those that do have scales end up eating worms if you feed them and of course worms are considered najis. So how are we permitted to eat fish if their food is impure? Any ideas on how I can reply to him. Here is a link to the question. http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AtMKHwiVec3.y4xKbNs8DkLty6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20130202205536AAC1f73 Below is what the guy responded. "When I was a lad, my daddy used to take me fishing. I was asked to take a nasty, slimy earthworm, impale it on a hook and use it to catch a fish. Fish are omnivores, and will eat other fish (cannibalism) and vermin like worms and insects. Some will even eat dead things, including dead human bodies. Fish can carry parasitic tapeworms that can infect people... In my mind, I cannot get over those things and nothing in the world can make me eat fish. So, as a Muslim, do you feel the same way I do towards fish?" fi aman illah
Recently Browsing 0 members
- No registered users viewing this page.