Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'isnad rijal', ' al kafi' or ' hadith sciences'.

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • Religion Forums
    • General Islamic Discussion
    • Shia/Sunni Dialogue
    • Christianity/Judaism Dialogue
    • Atheism/Other Religions
    • Minor Islamic Sects
    • Jurisprudence/Laws
  • Other Forums
    • Politics/Current Events
    • Social/Family/Personal
    • Science/Health/Economics
    • Education/Careers
    • Travel/Local Community
    • Off-Topic
    • Poetry and Art
  • Language Specific
    • Arabic / العَرَبِية
    • Farsi / فارسی
    • Urdu / اُردُو‎
    • Other languages [French / français, Spanish / español, Chinese / 汉语, Hindi / हिन्दी, etc.. ]
  • Site Support
    • Site Support/Feedback
    • Site FAQs
  • Gender Specific Forums
    • Brothers Forum
    • Sisters Forum
  • The Hadith Club's Topics
  • Food Club's Topics
  • Sports Club's Topics
  • Reverts to Islam's Topics
  • Travel Club's Topics
  • Mental Health/Psych Club's Topics
  • Arts, Crafts, DIY Club's Topics
  • The Premier League Club's Topics
  • Quit Smoking's Topics
  • Quit Smoking's Ramadan 2020 : Quit smoking!
  • Horses and Horse Riding's Topics
  • Sunni and Shia Collaboratian Club's Topics
  • THE CLUB OF CLUB's Topics
  • Islamic Sciences's Theology
  • Memorisation of Quran's Topics
  • Muslim Farmers and Homesteaders's Azadeh
  • Poetry Club's Topics
  • ShiaChat Youth Club's Topics

Calendars

  • Community Calendar
  • ShiaChat Youth Club's Events

Blogs

  • ShiaChat.com Blog
  • Insiyah Abidi
  • Misam Ali
  • Contemporania
  • Volcano Republic
  • Reflections
  • Al Moqawemat
  • Just Another Muslim Blogger
  • Amir Al-Mu'minin
  • Imamology
  • The Adventures of Wavey Bear
  • Religion
  • Think Positive
  • Reflections
  • A Whole Heart of Hollow
  • Blogging at ShiaChat
  • Shian e Ali's Blog
  • From the cradle to the grave - knowledge blog
  • repenters Beast mode 90kg - 100kg journey
  • My journey into a "White hat" Hacking career
  • The Sun Will Rise From The West
  • Muslim Coloring Book
  • Qom
  • ANSAR-AL-MAHDI (AFS)
  • My Feelings and Emotions About Myself
  • Unity, the New iPhone and Other Suppressed Issues
  • Mohamed Shivji
  • The People's Democratic Republic of Khafanestan
  • Crossing the Rubicon
  • My Conversion Story; from Roman Catholic - to Agnostic - to Islam Shia
  • Inspire
  • With Divine Assistance You Can Confront a Pharoah, Even Empty Handed
  • Banu Musa
  • Erik Cartman Podcast
  • My Quora Digest
  • Transcriber's Blog
  • ZIKR-E-MEHBOOB
  • A Marginalia to Mu'jam
  • Random Thoughts of ShiaMan14
  • Notepad
  • Pensées
  • Reflections
  • Historia
  • Test
  • Memorable Day, 28May2017
  • xyz
  • Alone with God | وحيدا مع الله
  • Procrastination Contemplations
  • From Earth to Heaven
  • The secret of self is hid
  • A Passing of Time
  • Pearls of Wisdom
  • The Muslim Theist
  • Stories for Sakina
  • Fatima
  • Toons
  • Saqi
  • The Messenger of Allah ﷺ
  • The Truth
  • A fellow traveller
  • Imam Mahdi ATFS
  • Self-Love, Islam & The Law Of Attraction
  • Basra unrest Iranian Conuslate Set Fire
  • spoken words/poetry/ deep thinking
  • Guide of marriage notes: Constantly updating
  • Zaidia the middle path.
  • The life of a Shia Muslim in the west.
  • Poems for the Ahlul Bayt
  • The Shuaybi Blog
  • Twelver Corpus
  • Manajat of the Sinners
  • Khudi
  • Chasing Islam
  • Bayaan e Muntazir
  • Deen In Practice
  • The Seas of Lights
  • Salafi/Athari - What does it mean?
  • The Luminous Clearing - Part 2
  • Shaan e Zahra
  • Book blog
  • Never thought I would see days like these
  • Yusuf's Blog
  • What’s in a Name?
  • Meedy
  • False Hopes
  • Contemporania - AI enhanced
  • Qur'an Semantic Field Analysis
  • Such as life
  • Regarding Iran. For the Record.
  • The Science of Signs
  • Lost Soul
  • Philosophy Club's Philosophy Club Journal
  • Quranic Studies's Quranic Studies Best Articles
  • Spoken Word's Blog
  • ShiaChat Youth Club's Blog

Find results in...

Find results that contain...


Date Created

  • Start

    End


Last Updated

  • Start

    End


Filter by number of...

Joined

  • Start

    End


Group


Facebook


Website URL


Yahoo


Skype


Location


Religion


Mood


Favorite Subjects

Found 1 result

  1. Salam alaykum. I want to open a thread about a question I have thought about for a long time, and I want to ask it in a fair way. We agree that the Sunna of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) is binding. Allah says: whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, leave it (59:7). And He says the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) explains to the people what was sent down to them (16:44). So the question is not if we follow the Sunna. The question is how we know that a report really comes from him (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). Our way is easy to explain. A report needs a connected chain up to the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), and every man in it must be known as truthful and precise. Ibn Sirin (رضي الله عنه) said that when the fitna came, people started to say: name us your men. Ibn al Mubarak (رضي الله عنه) said the isnad is part of the religion, and without it everybody would say what he wants. Both is in the introduction of Sahih Muslim. And the main question is truthfulness. Al Dhahabi (رضي الله عنه) writes about Aban ibn Taghlib, a strong Shia, that he is truthful, so we take his truthfulness and his bid'a is on him. He says if we rejected such narrators, a big part of the Prophetic reports would be lost (Mizan al I'tidal 1/5). Now your side. In your books the chains usually stop at an Imam, mostly al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) or Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه). I know your answer: the word of the Imam is like the word of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم), because of the report "my hadith is the hadith of my father" (al Kafi, Kitab Fadl al Ilm). But in the same chapter of al Kafi there is a report that Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: when you narrate a hadith, give it back to the one who told it to you. And in Sahih Muslim 1218, Jafar al Sadiq (رضي الله عنه) narrates from his father al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) that they went to Jabir ibn Abdullah (رضي الله عنه) and asked him about the Hajj of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم). So the Imams themselves named their source. So my first question: If the word of the Imam is enough without a chain, why does al Kafi itself tell us to name the one we heard a hadith from, and why did al Baqir (رضي الله عنه) name Jabir (رضي الله عنه) as his source? And how do you know that a report really reached al Kulayni from the Imam? I will come to your rijal in the next posts, but I would like to hear your answer to this first.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...