Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by salmany

  1. salamu `alaykum I pray you are well. On the website, look at the top right corner and you'll see a link "Endorse". This is not being endorsed because of King `Abd Allah but because the inheritors of the Prophet (Allah bless him and grant him peace) had a considerable role in formulating it. It is a very positive step towards ridding the "takfiri" attitude that is so prevalent amongst certain segments of the community. With prayers Wasalam salman
  2. salamu `alaykum I pray everyone is well and in the best of health. May Allah grant us all good in this life and the next. I would encourage all the members of this forum to endorse "The Amman Message" (www.ammanmessage.com), a three point message that stresses tolerance and the impermissibility of declaring any valid Muslim group as out of the fold of Islam. Just go to the website and see what it's about. To endorse it, click on "Endorse" on the top right corner of the website. It has been signed by a large number of Sunni, Shi`a (zaydi an ithna asheri), and Ibadi scholars and was released on
  3. Sallamu Alaikum Whole Sunni school sis. Imam Ahmad himself wrote in his Fadhail As sahaba: فضائل معاوية بن أبي سفيان رضى الله تعالى عنهما He uses the word "Huma" which is 3rd person dual, meaning "Them both" i.e Muawiya and Abu Sufyan, since they were both Sahaba. Dear sis i have told you this before, but there is no "official Deoband position." Why? Because Deoband is only a School where people come out of, some have one opinion and others have another. I have already clarified my position and the position i was taught before. You mean Amr (commonly known as) Bin Al Aas. فضائل عمرو بن ال
  4. Sallamu Alaikum al nasu `iyalun `ala abi hanifa fi al fiqh = people (scholars) are all the dependents of Abu Hanifa in fiqh. Dhahabi relates it in Tadhkirat Al huffaz in the chapter on Abu Hanifa. I had typed up a Biography of Imam Abu Hanifa Recently. Here are some Qutes from it: a. Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Hussain ibn Fatima Bint Prophet Muhammad: Abu Jafar Muhammad ibn Ali the great grandson of the Prophet Muhammad (Allah Bless him and grant him peace) said: How commendable are Abu Hanifas manners and how sublime is his skill in Fiqh! b. Imam Malik ibn Anas ibn Malik The founder of
  5. Sallamu Alaikum [edit] [Mods note : WARNING and SUSPENSION for praising Muawiya]
  6. Sallamu Alaikum I would le tmy 8 year old bro read that. Mind pointing out whats wrong? Or is this another diversion from the topic?
  7. Sallamu Alaikum They cannot be termed as lies, nor did i claim they were lies. However, what we do know is that Imam Ibn Hajar, Suyuti and Ibn Kathir accepted all the hadith in Bukhari and Muslim as Sahih, regardless of whether they questioned some aspects of the hadith, the quotes never say they actually rejected it and nor did they weaken the hadith. Secondly, they go onto cite criticism of Imam Bukharis Tarikh. I have no idea how this book is even remotely linked to the topic. And LAstly regarding the narrators, then i have already pointed out that none of the Criticism reaches the level t
  8. Sallamu Alaikum To many errors which i cannot go through. However, i will point out the opinion of the Ulema regarding the Sahihs. The above i believe is taken from a book called "Traditional Schoalrship And Modern Misuderstanding" by Abu Ammar ( ? ) which i read a while back. Anyway, Al Nawawi in his introduction to Sharh Sahih Muslim (1:20): -- innama yaftariqu al sahihan `an ghayrihima min al kutub fi kawni ma fihima sahihan la yahtaju ila al nazari fih. "The two Sahihs differ from all other books only in respect to the fact that what is in them is sahih and does not require investigation.
  9. Sallamu Alaikum No offense to you Akhi, but this is a ridiculous claim. I have the History of Tabari in Arabic, English aswell as Urdu, i have not seen any sort of "Abridged Shia versions" or "Insertions." Regardless to say, what many people dont get, and what i have stressed repeatedly on this board, is that Imam Tabaris history is an Annal which basically means he gathers many sources and many different narrations for certain events, some which are contradictory. He further provides the Sanad so these sources can be authenticated by the reader. Wallahu A'lam
  10. Yeah, that'll do loads of good showing that Islam doesn't discriminate against women. :rolleyes: I'll bet that came from an Abu Hurairah hadith. Sallam I can see i had made some erroneous claims, Praise be to Allah who increased my knowledge. As for the touching of the female, it is only touching of one who is not your Mahram. The word used in the verse: "Or if you touched women" is Lam and some of the Ulema have stated that Lam can refer to touching with ones hand. There are two more verses in the Qur'an using the form lamasa, which also means to touch; one of them is clearly a reference
  11. Sallamu Alaikum To the Brother inquiring about Sahih Muslim and others. Note that the hadith that you stated about Abu bakr being the Pillar and so forth is not found in any of the 6 Sahihs. Further, regarding Allahs leg they are metaphors. One cannot blame them for being present in hadith when they are present in the Quran.
  12. Sallam Infact Shaikh Saduq also mentioned 2 types of taqlids, One Halal and one Haram. Ill try to get the exact quote.
  13. Sallamu Alaikum Ali ibn Abi Talib ibn Abdul Muttalib ibn Hashim ibn Abd Manaf, Abul Hasan Qurashi Hashimi, Amir Al Muminin, the first male believer in Islam, the Prophet's standard-bearer in battle, the Door of the City of Knowledge, the most judicious of the Companions, and the "Possessor of a wise heart and enquiring tongue." The Prophet nicknamed him Abu Turab or Father of Dust. His mother was Fatima bint Asad, whom the Prophet called his own mother and at whose grave he made a remarkable intercession. He accepted Islam when he was eight, or nine, or fourteen, depending on the narrations, b
  14. Sallamu Alaikum Correct, another book of his is Riyadh Al Nadirah which contains an exhaustive documentation of the hadiths on the merits of our Liege Lord Ali.
  15. yea confused Imam Shafi`i in Kitab al Umm stipulated "there is no harm" incurred in (wilfully) leaving the hands hang by the sides in prayer if stillness is preserved, as the Sunna of folding the hands is for the purpose of preserving stillness inside prayer.
  16. :S Its usally 3 Rakah Fardh, and then the Pray 2 Rakah Sunnah.
  17. Sallam Thats Odd, the MAlikis usually pray with their hands down and it is perfectly acceptable.
  18. Sallamu Alaikum The discussion ends here. Until you learn to accept how ignorant you are of Sunni works i shall not discuss this issue with you and when you elarnt o speak with respect. He claims that so and so scholar said this, but when that same scholar lays down a principle then he reject it. He is ignorant of the Principles. Quoting Rijal books is easy, but knowing the Principles behind it is difficult. Br. Syed Farid, unfortunately, doesnot know the principles at all. As for Ibn Al Mubarak, suffice to say he is one of our Imams. I know you auoted a Sunni source, but what does that prove
  19. Sallamu Alaikum Very Rich coming from a man who does not the basics of Hadith science, yet has rambled on continuously. The case of Ibn Ishaq is similar to that of Al Waqidi. However, only those people would know the truth behind his acceptance who have indepth knwoledge of the science of Rijal. The only reason he was counted as weak by some was because (1) he would conceal the chain of narration sometimes and (2) He was suspected of being a Qadirite. In the above this is not the case. The best and most comprehensive summary of Ibn Ishaq is mentioned in Uyun Al Athar, which i doubt you have
  20. sallamu alaikum Ibn Al Jawzi (A hanbali) said in his Daf Shibah: ----- I have seen among the followers of our school some who held unsound discourses on doctrine. Three in particular have applied themselves to write books in which they distort the Hanbali madhhab.... They claimed: we do not construe the text according to the directives of the Arabic language. Thus they refuse to construe "hand" (yad) as meaning "favor" and "power"; or "coming forth" (maji') and "coming" (ityan) as "mercy" and "favor"; or "shin" (saq) as "tribulation." Instead they say: We construe them in their customary exter
  21. Sallamu Alaikum Abu Ja'far Tabari Muhib Al Tabari was another scholar. Imam Tabaris history is an Annal, meaning he put in his book what he could without authenticating it.
  22. Sallamu Alaikum Why does ignorance always prevail? Why is it when i provide sources and rebut others then you go aroun din circles passing your own opinions? I shall repeat: Further reports that the Prophet added it and the peopel actions: 1. From Said Al Musayyb: حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرٍ قَالَ أَنَا عَبْدَةُ عَنْ مُحَمَّدِ بْنِ إِسْحَاقَ عَنْ الزُّهْرِيِّ عَنْ سَعِيدِ بْنِ الْمُسَيِّبِ قَالَ { جَاءَ بِلَالٌ إلَى النَّبِيِّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يُؤْذِنُهُ بِالصَّلَاةِ فَقِيلَ لَهُ إنَّهُ نَائِمٌ فَصَرَخَ بِلَالٌ بِأَعْلَى صَوْتِهِ الصَّلَاةُ خَيْرٌ مِنْ النَّوْمِ فَأُدْخِلَتْ فِي
  23. sallamu Alaikum Akhi Noor leave him, hes a trouble maker who walks around with his head up high like hes a scholar. May Allah give us All guidance.
  • Create New...