Sallamu Alaikum They cannot be termed as lies, nor did i claim they were lies. However, what we do know is that Imam Ibn Hajar, Suyuti and Ibn Kathir accepted all the hadith in Bukhari and Muslim as Sahih, regardless of whether they questioned some aspects of the hadith, the quotes never say they actually rejected it and nor did they weaken the hadith. Secondly, they go onto cite criticism of Imam Bukharis Tarikh. I have no idea how this book is even remotely linked to the topic. And LAstly regarding the narrators, then i have already pointed out that none of the Criticism reaches the level t