Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

Ahmad 313

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    106
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Shia

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Ahmad 313's Achievements

Newbie

Newbie (1/14)

1

Reputation

  1. I have told you already that Iran oes not fit the criteria of any of the narrations that you have posted. If you do think that pplease show me from where? Now your saying that the scholars will lead you to the Yamani(As). Do you have hadith to back up yourt claim? Show me one single narration saying that the scholars will lead you to the Yamani? Their agreements on things do not matter because Ahlul Bayt(aS) have not said that the scholars will be the one to lead you to this person. Al-Imam Al-Baqir "There is no banner better than that of the banner of Yamani, it is the banner of faith and dedication, because he calls to your possessor, so if the Yamani comes out, selling weapons to people or any Muslim becomes prohibited, and if the Yamani appears, stand up to him, because he's banner is the banner of faith, and its prohibited for any Muslim to turn away from him, and who ever turns away from him, then he's from the people of hell, because he calls to the truth and to the right path). Al-Ghaybah - Mohammad Ibn Ibrahim A' Noâmani p.264 ^^^^ Does that say anything about the scholars agreeing on his identity? Imam Al-Saadiq a.s says:"Becareful of Taqleed(copying scholars) for whoever copies someone in his religion has perished for Allah says in the Quran"They took their Rabbis and monks as Lords without Allah"By Allah they haven't prayed for them neither did they fast for them, but they made halal what is haram and made haram for what is halal, so they copied them in this manner, and so they worshipped them without even realizing. Sheikh Al-Kulayni Kafi v.1 p.53 ^^^will they lead you? Imam Hassan Al-Askari a.s he said to Abi Hashem Al-Ja'afari:"O Ibn Al-Jaafari O Aba Hashem, there will come a time to the people, their scholars are the most evil creation of Allah on the face of the earth, that is because they lean towards philosophy and aesceticism but they misguide our Shias and the ones who have our Wilaya, so if they reach a position they will not have enough of bribery,and if they betray that is because they worshipped God in fakery, by God they cut the routes for the true believers,and they call forth to the contribution of infidelity".Safeenat Al- Bihaar Wa Madinat Al-Hukm Wal-Athaar v.2 p.57 p.58 v.4 These scholars ^^^^ Prince of the believers a.s in Khutba mentions the ending days"The jurists"fuqaha" will lean towards lying and the scholars will lean towards misguidance" Ilzaam Al-Naaseb Ithbaat Al-Huja Al-Ga'eb v.2 p.195 Lets use our brain for this last one: From the Prophet of Allah pbuhap he says about the Ending days "The scholars of the ending days are the most evil scholars under the shade of the sky out of them came choas and to them it will return" Bihar Al-Shareef v.52 p.190 Do you think when the Yamani appears, who is a sign of the ending days that the scholars will actually lead you to him? Ali H: hold your tongue. you are no man to judge another here. leaders such as this coward ahmad can be judged as he claims to be a leader. iyatullahs dont have a problem with matham are they betraying imam hussain as? are they kafir? oh they must be because a brother on an internet forum says so. I see a big contradiction, and what postion are you in that your allowed to judge Ahmad? I dont have a problem with matam, Ahmad(as) does not have a problem with Matam. You misunderstood what I was trying to say. Maybe Malang will understand. Ill explain, I was trying to say people participate in elections which are Haram. because Imam Hussain(as) stood for the supremacy of Allah swt and not the people. Yet people go and cry for him. You get what I mean now?
  2. No you are not. A shia of Ali can never talk in a filthy like you, you are a disgrace. You do not love Hussain or Abbas. In Karbala they had a message that they proved. It was the Supremacy of Allah and not the people. Look at Yazid(la) he was respresenting the Supremacy of the people, while Imam Hussain(as) was representing the Supremacy of God. They proved that on earth it should only be the supremacy of God and not the people. You people in these days represent the supremacy of the people, you participate in elections, your scholars favour elections. Then when Muharram comes you go and hit your self for Hussain(as). Its a big contradiction. You are the one that is betraying Hussain(as), and going against his message. I really cant believe you would actually call your your self a shia, with the level of filth you talk. It just shows you dont even care if the message of Ahlul Bayt gets a bad name because of you. Your a selfish person, just like umar.
  3. I think we have a misunderstanding. I am specifically talking about photos, not actually him not showing him self. Again let me clear that we are talking about PHOTOS. Im really getting tired of it, that I have to answer everyone here, yet no one answers my simple question. HOW WILL ANY OF YOU KNOW WHO THE YAMANI IS? PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR METHOD IN RECOGNIZING HIM? Most of the hadiths that you have posted applied to Ahmad. He is the one with the black banner from the east. I dont see Iran fitting any of those categories at all. Oh man you need some serious help. You remind of umar b khattab. Thats exactly who you are, I can see both of your similarities. I want to know, show me anywhere in the Quran or Hadith where it gives you a chance to mock people? where are you learning this stupidness from? It just shows the manners that your parents have taught you which dont seem to be much. You call your self maula da malang, you sound more like iblees ka malang. Get a life, you seem like you sit at home all day and you take your anger out on this thread. You seem like that mohammed 2k8 idiot from youtube. Your an idiot, your questions are even stupider (1) why does the term mau mau affect MDM so much (2) why does P. Ease want a wall clock What type of stupid questions are these. What are you some refugee from Pakistan "Mau Mau" Is that what you talked in the streets over there. These questions are like those people who use to ask Imam Ali (as) how many hair were on their heads. History is honestly repeating it self. The people that believe in the unseen are starting to ask for material proof. HOW WILL YOU RECOGNIZE THE YAMANI? WHAT IS YOUR METHOD IF WE ARE SO WRONG? I ASKED YOU THIS ABOUT 3 TIMES, YOU HAVE ANSWERED ME. probably were thinking of insults, instead of spreading knowledge. Atleast bring a narration to prove your self. Salam, The language is the way how the imams speak. Im not sure if you have read some hadiths in depth, they actually go to explain things in a similar method. Let me tell you this type of stuff has to be said, we are all mature, well some of us are. So if we look at Ahlul Bayt(as), they have spoken a similar way. InshAllah you can explain a little more about whats wrong with it,,,maybe I misunderstood your question.
  4. Well, there is wisdom behind him(as) not taking a picture, that is he does not want people idolizing him, that shows his level of monotheism, that he does not want people to be worshiping him rather he wants them to worship The Creator. I dont find anything wrong with him not showing a picture, the reason which he has given are totally right, and do not contradict the Quran or Ahlul Bayt(as). Also, we have not seen our prophets or imams yet we still believe in them, what difference would it make if we see the picture or not. What I can tell you is that the people who have stayed with him for some amounts of times, have said that he fits all the descriptions of the Yamani(as). People who have seen him in visions have said the same. So inshAllah pray that you see him in a vision. Again there is proof that it is him, with many eyewitnesses who have been updating. And he does have specific ansar that he is still in contact with. How do you think he gets the emails, and messages, then answers them. They are through the rest of the ansars. Also he has published a sermon very recently with his same voice. Are you denying that visions are not a form of prophecy? Imam Mahdi(as) has told in a vision what the rank of Imam Ahmad Al Hassan is. The guy in the video does not fit the description of the Mahdi at all in any way. No signs resemble him at all! He has not come with the will of the prophetÕáì Çááå Úáíå æÂáå, and is not acting in the manners that the Ahlul Bayt(as) would act. Meaning that he does not fit the criteria. Something which has been neglected throughout history, which has not been looked at as much as it should is brought back by Imam Ahmad(as). Meaning that it is revived. This will has mentioned the Imams and Mahdis, the first of them being Ahmad. Imam Ahmad(as) has said that he is the one mentioned in the will. The one who will lead you to the 12th Imam(as). Who is the first believer in Imam al Mahdi(as). The will is just saying that there will be a person who is the first Mahdi, just like how the prophet has mentioned Imam Ali(as) as his successor in so many hadiths, and that was Ali(as) proof against the people of that time. He did not bring the actual paper, you understand whhat i mean? The will is a commandment, of who will be the hujjat after the prophet. Thats all, in this will you are commanded to follow Ahmad(as). How will you recognize this Ahmad? how will you recognize the Yamani? these are my questions for you, please answer them. Yes alot of Sayyids lineage leads back to the Imam(as), but not Imam Mahdi(as). Imam Ahmad (as) descends back to the 12th Imam(as). InshAllah if there are more questions please ask. Taken from AnsarAllah: Question 1: How can I believe, through the shortest way, that al sayyed Ahmad al Hassan is the messenger and the vicegerent of al imam al Mahdi (pbuh)? Zeinab al Mossawy, 16/Safar/1426 H Answer: In the name of Allah, the Compassionate, the Merciful, and all praises to Allah god of all worlds, The shortest way to believe in the unseen is the unseen, ask Allah after fasting for three days and begging by the right of Fatima (pbuh) daughter of Muhammad (pbuhahf) that you get to know the truth from Allah through visions or kashf (vision during wake) or by any prodigy of His (swt) kingdom’s unseen prodigies. Ahmad al Hassan
  5. Alhamdulilah those are some good questions. We take guidance from the unseen. Our religion is mostly based on the unseen, Imam Al Mahdi(as) in his occultation guides sincere individuals as well, yet he is unseen. This is what the faith of the believer is, believing in the unseen. When the Sufyani rises inshAllah you will start to see Ahmad(as). We have given you many reasons on why there are no photos, specifically that he does not want people to place another idol in their houses. He does not want people to idolize him. Im sure that is a very valid reason. We do know that he does exist because he is writing books, he is answering questions. Knowledge like this hasnt been seen since the time of the previous Imams(as). He has challenged many of the scholars to debate, they still do not accept. He is answering questions of people. This shows that he is still alive, and is in his 40's. The call has been on for about 12 years, which clearly shows that his age is not cut. All of the Ahlul Bayt(as) are from Yemen if we do look at narrations. Also there are no specific narrations saying the Yamani(as) will be from Yemen, rather he will be from the east. Now we know Yemen is clearly south from Medina. This should indicate to anyone that the Yamani will be from the east, reason for that is simple, the fact that Ahlul Bayt(as) have said so. Most of the shia in Yemen are Zaidi's, you think the most guided banner as mentioned in hadiths will be misguided? His qualification, what do you mean by that? I dont understand your question sorry. He is the Yamani(As) and is selected by Allah swt. He knows he is the great grandson of Imam Al Mahdi(as) because the Mahdi has told him so, and also his family tree goes back to the 12th Imam(as), which is verified by the other tribal members of the area in Basra. If you want to see it, Ill be glad to show you so. I dont understand what you mean by that, well the will existed before the other Imams(as) as well, yet it was before them. He has revived the will which he was mentioned in. I dont find anything wrong in that inshAllah, if you can explain me whats wrong with doing that it would be great.
  6. How can you say that. Imam Ahmad(as) has spoken against all the one who are participating in doing wrong. Thats what im trying to explain to you. That you are not reading his books thats why you form your opinion like that.
  7. Dont know where to start, there are so many post on different topics all over the place. People need to start going one by one inshAllah, so we can discuss this in a more civilized manner. MDM: understood. - the yamanai is the best of people - the yamani holds the will of the prophet - the yamani holds the weapon of the prophet ahmad gheeta is not the best of people ahmad gheeta does not hold the will of the prophet ahmad gheeta does not hold the weapon of the prophet. damn...all this time i have been blind. of COURSE when i see it that way, the yamani can ONLY be ahmad gheeta!!!!! What I would like know is What proof do you have that Ahmad(as) is not the best of people? He is the only one calling to the Supremacy of Allah swt. He is the only one that is taking a stand against the evil people of our time. Have you taken up the time to read his books? How do you know he does not holy the will of the prophetÕáì Çááå Úáíå æÂáå?
  8. You talk a lot yet you know very little, each post you make is proving what a failure you are in your own research. First of all your bringing narrations of Imam Jafar(as) where he predicted deviation. How can you make your own silly interpretation, I could go and say that he was talking about the people that do taqleed. You are not a infallible Mahhfzb, you are a miguided individual. Now you bring the hadith about two imams being on earth. You it is possible in both way once the 12th Imam(as) appears then he is the Imam of course, and after the 12th Imam(as) he takes leadership, what so hard to understand abou that. Does this contradict the hadith in anyway? Your now trying to say that the 12th Imam (as) will not have any successors/caliphs? are you gone nuts? And now your saying Imam Jafar(as) was crying for this, where did you get this from? Did some classical ulema say this or are you talking your own nonsense? Im very sure its you. No one would say anything that stupid. "And against the Sufyani from the people of the East,a successor of Al-Mahdi,and he shall defeat the Sufyani in Sham(syria)" Sharh Ahqaq AlHaq section 29 p.620 Prophet of Allah pbuhap said:"And then he mentioned a man and then he said, if you see him pledge allegiance to him for he is the Caliphate of the Mahdi"p.30 Besharat Al Islam" And then in Heera a mosque shall be built for him,500 doors,the caliphate of the Qa'em(riser)shall pray in it,because the mosque of Kufa will be constricted" Bihar AlAnwar v.52 p.474 Tahtheeb AlAhkaam v.3 p.245 Imam Jaafer a.s says:(companion of the matter finds a place in Basra) Haft Al Shareef p.175 Al-Imam Al-Baqir "There is no banner better than that of the banner of Yamani, it is the banner of faith and dedication, because he calls to your possessor, so if the Yamani comes out, selling weapons to people or any Muslim becomes prohibited, and if the Yamani appears, stand up to him, because he's banner is the banner of faith, and its prohibited for any Muslim to turn away from him, and who ever turns away from him, then he's from the people of hell, because he calls to the truth and to the right path). Al-Ghaybah - Mohammad Ibn Ibrahim A' Noâmani p. 264. Look for yourself, and now tell me that the Mahdi will not have a successor. Again you are not able to give a valid reason for the will being wrong. Which scholars have ever said this will is wrong in anyway? Are you making up stuff now. You seem like your not doing this for the sake of Ahlul Bayt, but to rather satisfy your self. You have said the the will is authentic according to its rijal, do you know what that means, that it is the word of Ahlul Bayt(as). So that would mean that you are not accepting their words, rather you are following your self, or your imaginary ulema that you are talking about. Even IF the ulema have said something wrong about it, it does not take away the fact that this will is from Ahlul Bayt(as). <<<this is a whole seperate debate, first bring your proof for those scholars who say its not authentic. You are twisting and turning hadiths just like Imam Sadiq(as) said that people would twist and turn them for their own benefits. You will get it man, come back to your senses. You have turned into a nutcase. Now about the modern day ulema. You think when the Mahdi(as) appears all the ulema right now will be waiting for him, your wrong. Prince of the believers a.s in Khutba mentions the ending days"The jurists"fuqaha" will lean towards lying and the scholars will lean towards misguidance" Ilzaam Al-Naaseb Ithbaat Al-Huja Al-Ga'eb v.2 p.195 From Mufathel Ibn Umar he said:I heard Abu Abdullah a.s saying:"If the riser(Qa'em) stands,he will start with the liars amongst the Shias,and so he then kills them" Ikhtyar Ma'rifat AlRijal AlToosi v.2 p.589, AlKashi p.253 ^^Now I can be like you and say that hadith is for you. Imam Al-Saadiq a.s says:"Becareful of Taqleed(copying scholars) for whoever copies someone in his religion has perished for Allah says in the Quran"They took their Rabbis and monks as Lords without Allah"By Allah they haven't prayed for them neither did they fast for them, but they made halal what is haram and made haram for what is halal, so they copied them in this manner, and so they worshipped them without even realizing. Sheikh Al-Kulayni Kafi v.1 p.53 Imam Al-Baaqer a.s "If the Qa'em emerges he shall aproach to Kufa and so then a few thousands will emerge out of it claiming that he has no son, with them are weapons, and they will say, return from where you came we do not need your help with sons of Fatima, and so he shall take to them the sword until he reaches the last one of them, and then he shall enter Kufa and will kill in there every misguided hypocrite, and will destroy their palaces,and will kill the fighters until Allah swt is pleased" Irshad Al-Mufeed v.2 p.384 Imam Hassan Al-Askari a.s he said to Abi Hashem Al-Ja'afari:"O Ibn Al-Jaafari O Aba Hashem, there will come a time to the people, their scholars are the most evil creation of Allah on the face of the earth, that is because they lean towards philosophy and aesceticism but they misguide our Shias and the ones who have our Wilaya, so if they reach a position they will not have enough of bribery,and if they betray that is because they worshipped God in fakery, by God they cut the routes for the true believers,and they call forth to the contribution of infidelity".Safeenat Al- Bihaar Wa Madinat Al-Hukm Wal-Athaar v.2 p.57 p.58 v.4 Prophet of Allah pbuh said:"O Ibn Mas'ood "Their scholars and jurists,are betrayers and sinners, they are the most evil creation of Allah and also their followers from the ones who come to them and take from them and love them and sits with them and asks from them,they are the most evil of the creation of Allah where he shall enter them hellfire "Mute,Def and blind, and shall not return"Makaram Al-Akhlaaq p.450-45 From the Prophet of Allah pbuhap he says about the Ending days "The scholars of the ending days are the most evil scholars under the shade of the sky out of them came choas and to them it will return" Bihar Al-Shareef v.52 p.190 "When Imam Al-Mahdi emerges he will not have any enemies except the scholars,if it wasn't for the sword, the scholars would have issued fatwas to kill him" Bayan Al-A'ema a.s v.3 p.99 Yome Al-Khalas p.279 Besharat Al Islam p.297 "His enemies are the scholars of Taqleed, they will be under his rulership in fear from his sword and his power,and for a want from what he has" Prince of the believer a.s "And he shall avenge from the Fatwa issuers(scholars)in religion from what they don't know about, so Woe unto them and who followed them,was religion missing so that they can erect it?Or was it bent so that they can straighten it? Or did the people ask for what opposes it and agreed to its opposition?Or did it force them to do righteousness so they sinned against it? Bayan Al-A'ema A.S V.3 P.298 Here you go for your modern day ulema. I hope you enjoy following them. I wonder what your response to this will be. Probably some more nonsense. From looking at your post and videos, it shows which side you are on.
  9. This is definitely comparable. The reason for that is that the Prophet was mentioned in a book. And in this situation we have a person Ahmad whose mentioned in a book as well. So why would that not be comparable?
  10. Was the Prophet sawa mentioned in the bible? If he was tell me wasnt that his proof against the Christians? Guess what it was already there before him. You havent answered my question that I had for you and MDM. MDM must answer himself, for the nonsense he has talked. Everything he said doesnt make sense.
  11. In the will of the Prophet Muhammed(sawa) it says that the first of the 12 Mahdis will be Ahmad. Now you tell me, is Imam Ali (as) Ahmad? Another thing that we need to comprehend is that the 12 Imams are Mahdi's too. The word Mahdi means rightly guided. It shows us that they are rightly guided are they not? So that hadith does not contradict this message at all. Also the narrations say AFTER the Imams will appear 12 Mahdis.
  12. @ MDM and Love of Islam How was the Prophet Muhammed (sawa) Prophesized by the prophets before him? Was it in a similar method or different? How will you know who the Yamani(as) is? Whats your method in figuring this out? Please answer my question and avoid going off topic. May Allah forgive us for our wrong doings, and give us patience. Imam Ahmad Al Hassan(as) has come with his family tree proving his lineage. He descends from the 12th Imam(as). His family tree is verified by the other tribal members in Basra Iraq. And that is the method on how to verify a family tree by asking the other tribal members about it, from that specific location. You just proved my point. Your asking for artifacts and what not then at the same time your saying it can be engineered. You are starting to not make any sense whatsoever. You are going to deny every single thing. We pray for the Ulema who were righteous, who were the working scholars. For example Khomeini(ra) etc. The non working scholars are the ones who we do not support in any way. Was not the Prophet Muhammed(sawa) mentioned in the scriptures, e.g. OT,NT. Yet people still denied him. Was Jesus(as) not mentioned in the scriptures, yet those same scholars who studied those scriptures denied him and tried to kill him? You are just like them in saying the will is nothing new it has been there for ages. There is a reason why our Prophet(sawa) wrote the will, there is a reason why Ahlul Bayt(as) have showed us the characteristics of individuals to come after them. The name Ahmad can be looked at as one of the reason. Just like how the Prophet(sawa) was prophesized in the other scriptures as Ahmad. Yet people like YOU denied him. So if we go along with your method in finding out who the first Mahdi will be, we would not believe in Ahmad. Your method is indeed a very big failure. Im sure you would be the same who denied our holy Prophet. Now answer my question that I addressed to you and Love of Islam above. Show me one single narration saying the Yamani will be from Yemen. In its original form. Since I have came to this website you have been talking out of your mouth not using your head. You have not pointed anyone to one single narration for any of your claims. Provide us with narrations for what you say. What are you talking about the actual will you acting like you know the writing of the Imams(as). Do you know there way of writing, if someone provides you with it will you believe? how will you know its them writing this? is this your method in know who the Mahdi is? Your saying the will of our Prophet(sawa) is not special? are you out of your mind? It just shows how twisted you are. Man i feel bad for you, May Allah help you. It is revelation, whatever Ahlul Bayt say is with the will of Allah swt. Im surprized that you even believe in the 12 Imams with your twisted ideology, were you born into shia islam? its just crazy. Your whole ideology is flawed and if you keep on rambling on, you will be exposed inshAllah. Now answer my question that I addressed to you and Love of Islam. Because I assure you, you will not have a valid answer for that. Probably some next weird theory of yours. Your an example of someone who has went away from the path of Ahlul Bayt(as). Laughing does not help your case at all. It is not proof of any sort. Please tell me did ghulam bring the will of the prophetÕáì Çááå Úáíå æÂáå?
  13. @ Malang You have actually proven your self to be an idiot. You calim to be the follower of Ahlul Bayt(as) but at the same time you fail to be even following their manners one bit. Again you are a malang, and you seem to be representing the ones in the streets of Pakistan. Maybe that who you learn your manners from.... So what will the actual will do for you? Do you know the writings of the Prophets and the Imams(as) that youll be able to recognize that it is them who wrote it? Its going to be the same thing as in the books but in just there writing that you apparently recognize for some reason. How is that proof, tell me if you see the actual "will" how will you know its the actual will? Honestly your starting to prove that you have a short attention span or something, in other words "your a little slow" So now, You look for the writings of the Imams? is that the proof your lookng for? Is that what you will base your faith on writings that you have never seen in your life? May Allah increase your thinking skills, and guide you to the light of Ahlul Bayt(as), and give you a glimpse of their manners.
  14. MAFHHZB: All sayyids from the lineage of Ahlulbayt we find today in the World are Yamani. So Ayatollah Sistani, a Kuffan, and a Seyyid, is also Yamani who is Dajjal for them. Ayatollah Khameni is Yamani although there is speculation that he could be Khorasani, i.e now he could be both Khorasani and Yamani combined. Prove to me that hes even sayyid.
  15. First of all you need to relax on the video promotion, im sure the whole world knows about it now. Its actually getting annoying. I think you need to understand that we have said already the "Imams" have a higher rank then the "Mahdis" but that does not take away the fact that they are Imams does it, even if they are lower in ranks. For example out of the 12 imams there were some with higher ranks then the others. I overall do not get your point in what your trying to say, you did not disprove anything. You have also called the will of the prophet(sawa) weak, at the same time your ready to analyze. Please answer the question in a more logical way. Also prove that the ulema have graded the will as weak, why are you ignoring the references which I have provided you with. All the classical ulema have not said what you are saying. You are putting lies on the ulema. Why? Who are you to grade something as weak, you honestly are starting to seem like some psychopath. The references are provided in the other page but just for you ill post them again. AlJame'a is the Golden chain from Toosi(Silsila Al Thahabya) to the book of Al-Bazoofri"Al-Hussain ibn Abaydallah Al-Gathaa'eri and Ahmad ibn Abdoon.And Istibsaar Sheikh Al-Toosi says"And what I have mentioned from Abi Abdullah Al-Hussain in Sufyan Al-Barzoofri Ahmad ibn Abdoon and Al-Hussein ibn Abaydallah reported me it. AlIstibsaar v.4 p.342 AlBazooferi(Sheikh that is Thiqa,from our companions)Khatemat Al Wasa'el p.177 Hur Al Ameli #1Ahmad in Abdulwahaad(Rijal AlToosi p.413-414 5988) "Everything he narrated is accepted" Amal Al-Amaal AlHur Al-Amili v.2 p.16-17 "And what he approved is reliable from what is corrected from the Sheikh" Mustadrakat Ilm Alhadeeth AlSheikh Ali AlNamazi AlShahroodi v.1 p.359-360 1157 "He is praised and his narrations are saheeh" Mujam Al-Rijal Alhadeeth Al-Sayed Al-Khoei v.2 p.152 655 "he is a Thiqa because he is a scholar from Najaashi" #2 AlHussein Ibn Abaydallah Al-Gada'eri Rijal Al-Najashi p.68-69 166 he says: "All his narrations are acceptable from his scholars" "he is our sholar May Allah be pleased with him" Rijal Al-Toosi p.425 6117 "We have heard of him and we have accepted all his narrations" Mujam Rijal AlHadeeth Sayed AlKhoei v.7 p.22-23 3940 "we cant refuse the mans' authenticity" "He is from the sides of Sheikh Al-Najaashy and all his scholars are reliable(Thuqaat) #3Abi Abdullah Al-Hussain ibn Ali ibn SufyanRijal Al-Najashi p.67-68 -162 "A scholar that is thiqa(reliable) a great friend of ours" Sheikh Toosi in Rijalaho p.423 6092 "He is valuable and his apellation is Aba Abdullah" Wathqa Alama Al-Hili Khalasat Al-Aqwaal p.115 "Sheikh that is Thiqa(reliable),a great friend of ours and valuable" #4Ali ibn Sinaan Al-Musali AlAdl Sheikh Al-Namaazi Al-Shahroodi in his book Mustadrakaat Ilm Al-Rijaal Al-Hadeeth 10071 "He is the correcter" "well respected narrations that assist its fineness and completeness" #5Ali ibn Hussein Rijal Al-Najaashi p.261-262 -684 he says "One of the grand scholars of his times,and the head of them in knowledge,and their jurist,and their Thiqa(reliable). Rijal Al-Toosi p.432 6191 he says: "Thiqa(reliable) he has many compilations we have mentioned them in the Fihrast" #6 Ahmad ibn Muhammad Al-Khaleel Sheikh Ali Al Numaazi Al-Shahroodi in his book Ilm Al-Rijaal AlHadeeth 1532 he says: "It assists that he is fine and complete" AlSudooq used his narration from Jaafer ibn Muhammad Al-Alawi Al-Areethi by Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Jaafer Al-Ahwaazi with hadeeth Fawaatem for Fathaa'el Al-Shia Book of Imaan p.122 v.68 p.76 Mustadrakat Ilm Al-Rijaal AlHadeeth v.1 p.434 AlGaiba p.103 from Ali ibn Sinaan AlMusili Al Adel from Ahmad ibn Muhammad AlKhaleel from Muhammad ibn Saaleh Al-Hamdaani narration on their names and their qualities from Muftathab Al-Athar in this chain of trasmission v.9 p.125 v.36 p.216 #7Jaafer ibn Ahmad AlMasri Sheikh Ali Al-Namaazi AlShahroodi Mustadrakaat Ilm Rijal Al-Hadeeth 2533 "He has a very respected narration v.2 p.143" Tareekh Al-Islam AlThahabi v.23 p.139 "Mirza Al-Noori says that when the(majority(Ahlulsunna))criticize the narrations that aid the Shia is a proof that the scholars are reliable" #8AlHassan ibn Ali Rijal Al-Najaashi p.66 155 "The speaker is thiqa reliable" Mustadrakaat Ilm Al-Rijaal Alhadeeth Sheikh Ali AlNamazi AlShahroudi v.3 p.156 44181 "the narrator is thiqa reliable" #9Ali ibn Sabaya(father of Hussein ibn Ali Al-Masri who is thiqa) ====================================================================================== Gaibat Al Toosi from Sheikh Al Toosi"The leader of the Shia sect"p.156-We have said already:"And what has lead to its authenticity,the Shia Imamya see it on the way of Tawaater(definite degree of surety)and the way it has been authentic is present in the books of the Imamya". And the Mirza AlNoori(AlTabrasi) in Najem AlThaaqeb 2/71 when he informed with proof about the offspring for Imam Al Mahdi a.s when he said:It is narrated from AlToosi with a reliable source from Imam Al Saadeq a.s about a report mentioning some of the wills of the Messenger of Allah pbuhap to Prince of the believers pbu him in the night of his death and in one of its mentioning says:"and when death comes to him let him hand it over to his son the first of the close ones" NOW IF YOU SAY ITS WEAK, YOU HAVE WENT AGAINST THE ULEMA!
×
×
  • Create New...