Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Me sunni

Advanced Members
  • Content Count

    99
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Me sunni

  • Rank
    Level 1 Member

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Muslim

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male
  1. I didnt read all the posts, but don't you think that Syria should be controlled by the law of Allah awj? And as far as oppression goes, do you not think the people of Iran are oppressed by their government? Do you not think that even the Iranian government are corrupt? I have an Iranian working for me, he has been here in australia for 2 years & has told me many horrific stories of corruption, manipulation, murder, rape, prostitution etc committed in public by the leaders. The saddest part of his story is he has left Islam, I have spoken to him on many occasions in regards to practicing & getting back to his roots, the problem is he is so emotionally damaged by the effects of the corruption is Iran that he needs time to get over it.. Yes I do understand that no situation should lead you astray and tried to explain to him that the government in Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Egypt etc should have no affect on our beliefs as Muslims. And he was a Shia, may Allah awj guide him back, ameen.
  2. Thank you so much for your reply. May Allah awj reward you for your patience & efforts, ameen.
  3. Inshallah I will pray for you at Fajr, my next prayer. Thanks for the links, will watch. I'm starting to feel more & more comfortable around here as more misconceptions are cleared up. Jazakallahu khair.
  4. That was playing on my mind for a while, things that seem crazy are not so crazy when someone answers your questions... Thanks Rasul.
  5. @preethics. May Allah awj reward you for your efforts & patience with my limited knowledge. I read all your posts and it now makes sense in regards to hidden knowledge. A couple more questions, I hope you don't mind? - You mentioned killing of prophets, is this fact or just an example? Never heard this before? - where exactly does it mention the 12 imams in the Quran? - I know nothing about the lives or who Abu Bakr, umar, Uthman where so don't take anything I say in regards to them as defensive. Is there any videos on a Shia view of these men? - I know that imam Ali was the first boy to accept Islam & grew up in prophet saws house which is more than I know about the other 3 mentioned, is there any videos on imam Ali from a Shia perspective? Again thank you so much for your time, patience & efforts with me.
  6. Why is cursing a part of any religion? If I am a true believer wouldn't it be smart of me to leave it in gods hands? We are all going to be judged and no one will escape judgement so what's the point behind cursing? Please explain as this is a real issue I have with Shiism. So far in Sunni Islam I have seen no cursing of anyone, so far?
  7. Thanks Jaysro. I was born to communist parents who had no religion. I was brought up in Australia where most are catholic. I learned about Catholicism and really didn't like it at all. The fact things were not logical like the trinity etc... So looked into other religions & Islam was the only one that was logical & in Australia we have massive Muslim communities, but very little Shias. So learned from friends & local lectures at Sunni mosques. Coming from Catholism I have a real fear of invoking others like they have saints etc, worship Jesus as though his god etc...
  8. So me posting a video from YouTube & kindly asking questions is an attempt to defame Shiism? I have said in many posts that I know nothing about Shiism. I knew nothing about Islam 2 years ago & I'm sure I asked some stupid questions & upset many people with them, BUT when you don't know something how do you know what to ask & what not to ask? How do you know how to approach a person live or on the net? You don't! Soil I have upset anyone in anyway please forgive me as I don't have an agenda to defame anyone..
  9. If answering a question with another question is your idea of a good answer then I agree, BUT when I don't answer your question, get defensive & ask the same questions I asked you with arrogance then NO that's not helping me, you or the person who thought they were really smart by doing so...... Really non productive! Maybe because I have the name me Sunni people around here instantly get defensive. Does it not occur to anyone that I am here seeking knowledge? I know absolutely nothing about Shiism, how could I live my life not knowing if I really know the truth?
  10. The fact of the matter is the Quran we read today is written by Uthman, like it or not it's the oldest surviving copy of the Quran. I never claimed anyone to be better or closer to the prophet saws, but if Imam Ali was here to preserve the Quran where is his copy? Yes there is no doubt he lived & died by the Quran, but many people memorized the Quran which is great (may Allah reward them), but this doesn't help me or you in anyway what so ever.. I'm not doubting that imam Ali wrote a Quran, but if it was the perfect Quran Allah awj most certainly would have preserved it. Allah awj has destroyed the originals of many other religious books for the simple fact that they where over written by the Quran, if imam Ali's Quran was perfect it would be with us today. There is no doubt in my mind that Ali had alot of knowledge & the fact that he could tell us when each Surat was revealed & wether or not it was day/night etc... But as far as hidden knowledge? I really don't think so, at the end of the day he WAS not a prophet of Allah awj and merely a man like you & I. Again, I'm not saying who wrote the first Quran, but the oldest copy we have today is uthmans copy. Knowing the unknown like when you will die etc is nothing like the guessing game of predicting weather, knowing when you will die due to illness etc, they are merely just calculated guesses. As for imams knowing when they will die, that just doesn't make sense, Allah awj has many attributes man cannot have. Why would Allah awj give man the ability to know when he will die? This would defeat the purpose of being here for a test, why not just send the imams straight to heaven & you say they are here to preserve Allahs religion. So please tell me exactly what they have done to make Islam better for me today? There is many ways to take that statement about peace & ahlul bayt. I don't know if the Shia believe that prophet Mohamad saws had sons? If you do tell me why you think they died? Point taken on the as. But I have the feeling you guys take the above mentioned peace upon ahlul bayt a bit too serious? Do you guys invoke others to ask of Allah awj?
  11. Please prove to me that Shiism was at the time of the prophet saws? And that Shiism started from Imam Ali? Are you serious??
  12. Brother I think you need to take some chill pills :) Why so paranoid? I put this video to see if it was true & what you Shia think about it. I didn't come here for a battle, merely to see if it was true, if I go around believing everything I hear without verifying it where would I be now? As for the authenticity of the sahaba I really don't know what your trying to say, I simply see that there was a prophet saws who conveyed a message which I beleieve to be true. Wether or not you like the sahaba, if Allah awj wanted imam Ali to be his successor IT WOULD HAVE happened. What your implying is that the creator of the worlds, heavens & everything in between couldn't control who was to succeed prophet Mohamad saws. Maybe I don't know enough about Islam to comment, but to me I don't really care right now.... And giving me attitude instead of manners will keep me thinking this way... Please remember there are people like myself all over the world who know very little about Islam & come to different sources to learn.. The link doesn't work, please post it so I can open it.
  13. @pueethics. You can see barelymuslims user name. Maybe try a bit of manners & patience with him. Without good manners, patience & character There literally wouldn't be any Muslims today... If you can prove the story of the blind man wasn't the prophet saws then PLEASE do. No need to get defensive & start speaking badly of the Sunnis, please bear in mind you Shia use the term a.s which is used for prophets of Allah awj on your imams who were just men like you & I weren't they?? If your imams protect the message why are we reading a copy of uthmans Quran & not one of your imams copies? Did they even make copies of the Quran? Religion has been altered from what I see & the Shia do pretty much the same things as what the Christians have done from what I have seen.. In saying this I have seen very little, but hopefully I will learn on this forum inshallah. Knowing the unseen means knowing the unseen, you can not water it down & say they know certain things, they either know the unseen or they don't! Do they know when the hour will arrive? Answer this one question for me & from Past reactions to the question I'm 100% sure you WILL not answer the question! Was there any Shia at the time of prophet Mohamad saws?
  14. Ok so maybe prophets don't make mistakes (even though the story of the blind man says other). What about non prophets or normal men like Ali ra? Did he make mistakes? Does he know the un-seen? Please understand I have came from another religion who worship men, prophets etc... So try & keep this in mind and answer clearly please.
×
×
  • Create New...