mn05

Allahumma salli `ala muhammadin wa Ali muhammadin

"Kulayni has reported, so also Saduq, Mufid and Tusi, traditions from Imam Sadiq, which point to the law of vertical inheritance and the continuation of the Imamate till the day of resurrection. He said: “ The Imamate will not be in two brothers after Hassan and Hussain. But it will be in the off springs and off springs of off springs, and likewise to the day of resurrection.” Kulayni: Al- Kafi, Vol. 1. P. 286 and Mufid: Al- Irshad, P. 289 and Saduq: Ikmal al- Din, P. 414 and Tusi: Al: Al-Ghaybah’ P. 118" "Kulayni reported that a man once asked Abu Abdullah Saying:" “ If it happens that I don’t find the Imam to follow what should I do? “ He replied, Love whom you love and hate whom you hate, till Allah cause him to appear.” Kulayni: Al-Kafi, Vol. 1, P 342 The hadith about the 12 names of the Imams seem to be fabricated, otherwise there will be no confusion among the Shia sects. People should have followed that hadith if that hadith was authentic, and also it goes against history as well.

Yes brother I am unable to comprehend the hadith because our schalors are saying they (Sunnis) are Muslims but here it says that they are not Muslims?

So basically this hadith is fabricated then. "Allah will not accept the belief of anyone who does not accept the wilayah of Hazrat Ali (ع) and one who does not dissociate from his enemies." (Ref: Biharul Anwar - Vol. 26, Pg. 229, H. No 10)

Walakumsalaam brother. This also applies to us as well. It depends on Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) if Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) will accept our deeds or not. I can't say I'm going to heaven because I pray, fast and give money to the poor. It depends on Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) for accepting my good deeds. Inshallah Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) will accept our good deeds.

Salaam brother what certain Shia believes you don't believe in?

Salaam brother are you saying that the hadith is fabricated about Sunnis not accepting the wilayah of Hazrat Ali (ع)?

I know for sure agha Khamenei said its makruh. . http://english.Khamenei.ir/news/5715/122-religious-inquiries-on-Ramadan-and-fasting-answered-by-Imam

agha sayid Sistani said its makruh. This is what I heard.

Salaam why do some schalors say its makruh to fast on Ashura and some schalors say its haraam?

If he is one of those drawn nigh (to Allah), then happiness and bounty and a garden of bliss (shall be his). (56:88-89) …that is in the grave and Paradise of bliss, that is in the hereafter.” Salaamwalakum. I like to know the reference for this hedith. I know you said it's in al-Islam.org but I like to know the reference. What Shia hedith book can I find this hedith?

How many meaning does Rijs have?

The Uncleanness (Al-Rijs) حممد بن احلسن الصفار: عن حممد بن خالد الطيالسي، عن سيف بن عمرية، عن أيب بصري، عن أيب جعفر )عليه السًلم(، قال: »الرجس: هو الهك، و ال نهك يف ديننا أبدا«. Muhammad Bin Al-Hassan Al-Saffar, from Muhammad Bin Khalid Al-Taylasany, from Sayf Bin Umeyra, from Abu Baseer, Abu Ja’far asws has said: ‘The uncleanness (الرجس – (It is the doubt, and we asws do not doubt in our asws Religion, ever’ 27. بصائر الدرجات: 226 /13. The uncleanness is talking about doubt not infallibility.

No doubt the alhulbayat have the highest level of human perfection, but they are human beings and nothing else. They are the role model for humanity. I believe extremist teaching have penetrated into Shia Islam and we need to look at what our Imams instructs us on hadiths that don't match with the holy Qur'an. Imam al Ridha (عليه السلام) where he says: …You should not accept any hadith that is attributed to us if it is in conflict with the Qur'an because whatever we say is in harmony with the Qur'an and Sunnah of the Prophet (saww) as we only narrate from God and his messenger.” (Rijal Kashi) Imam Sadiq (عليه السلام) says: “Do not accept any narration except that which is in line with the Qur'an and Sunnah, or what you find in the narrations of the previous Imams (عليه السلام), because Mughira bin Sa‟eed, may curse of Allah be on him, inserted such narrations in the books of the companions of my father (Imam Baqir (as)) which he (عليه السلام) had never said…..” (Rijal Kashi)

I think nobody is infallible. Only Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) is infallible. Everybody else is fallible. In the Qur'an I see Prophets making mistakes like Adam (عليه السلام). Musa (عليه السلام). solaman (عليه السلام). Yunas (عليه السلام). and even our holy Prophet making mistakes. In the Qur'an Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) is correcting the holy Prophet in certain situations. Infalliability is the attribute of Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) and nothing is like Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى). I'm not sure maybe I'm wrong.