Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Al-Ghadeer

Basic Members
  • Content Count

    20
  • Joined

  • Last visited

1 Follower

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Shia Ithna-Ashari

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. i found this on the world wide web. should interest you http://bestofbukhari.wordpress.com/ I have a thread running on it http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?/topic/235017306-an-intersting-blog-on-sahih-bukhari/ Do make a contribution Thanks
  2. I am sure there would be many, but it seems that i cannot specifically find any. Please be kind enough to list a couple from the 'many'. And btw my question remains unanswered "when you mean refutation do you mean that the hadith is wrong/weak or otherwise ?" As for your question, how am i supposed to even know if he is sunni or not ? Try asking the author of that blog.
  3. Could you provide me links to any website providing refutations for the same . I tried searching and couldnt find any. And by the way when you mean refutation do you mean that the hadith is wrong/weak or otherwise ? Kindly clarify Much obliged
  4. Salamun Alaikum I found a really interesting blog on the internet about ahadith from the sahih bukhari. http://bestofbukhari.wordpress.com lets just say that this guy is indulging in some friendly fire ;) But he has raised some very valid points though. Definately worth giving a visit
  5. How difficult is it for you to understand ??? Hafsa = Wife of the prophet i.e step mother of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) Umar = Father of Hafsa i.e step maternal grandfather of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) J. Umm Kulthum = Daughter of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) this makes umar the step (maternal)great grandfather of J. umm kulthum which shows thay are mahram ARE YOU TRYING TO SAY THAT THE RIGHTLY GUIDED CALIPH UMAR MARRIED A MAHRAM. ( not difficult for you given you believe that Prophet Musa ran naked ( nauzobillah ) amongst his people )
  6. it is rather difficult to believe because Hafsa = Wife of the prophet i.e step mother of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) Umar = Father of Hafsa i.e step maternal grandfather of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) J. Umm Kulthum = Daughter of Bibi Fatimah (s.a) this makes umar the step (maternal)great grandfather of J. umm kulthum which shows thay are mahram this is the simple reason that makes it impossible for me to believe that this marriage could have happened
  7. 1. Pathetic Comeback 2. You suffer from partial blindness or you deliberately chose to not read in detail about PMDC ( with reference to you saying """ So the person is neither male nor female """ ) 3. Good point Kismet110
  8. Shows your lack of knowlwdge of biology. here, for your reference http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistent_Mullerian_duct_syndrome kindly enrich yourself with some knowledge of biology and then run to find cover
  9. Salamun Alaikum if i were to type the entire answer here it would become too long. please read this article series and then if you still have a doubt then please ask here. I shall always be present ( It is not the sunnah of our Imam (as) to run away ) 1. I had given you a reply in post #2 which has been discussed very much in detail and with reference to my very recent post ( regarding the translation of verse 5:55 ) it should be clear that Ali un WAliallah is the sunnah of Allah Himself PS. read the ayah at the end of post #2 2. Still if you have a problem kindly read everything;( part knowledge is dangerous, as has been proved by the parody of translation) the article on the link given below Ali Un Waliallah then still if you have a problem, do come up with genuine doubt's ( and please no frivolous doubts or statements. If you are seriously interested in asking and gaining its fine , else we are just wasting time here ) Ma' Salam Al-Ghadeer
  10. Salamun Alaikum I am really sorry for not replying for the last 3 days as i was very busy with other work. So u asked for a reference from Grammer so here we GO Firstly I am apalled by the level of knowledge of Arabic Grammer amongst brothers who use this forum. Please, learn atleast the basics before running around with arguments on arabic and arabic grammer. Since you have talked about grammer I am assuming that you have some knowledge about it. so understanding all that i type should not be a problem, If you cant kindly refer a guy having some knowledge of Grammer. Grammaticall analysing the disputed part of Verse 5:55 وَهُمْ رَاكِعُونَ 1} uses of وَ in arabic are two ( other than swear/oath ) ie. 'and' as well as 'while' 2} analysing رَاكِعُونَ Ques 1 . Is it Fail e Madi ? Ans . NO Ques 2 . Is it Fail e Mudhaare ? Ans . No. if you say yes where are the harf e Mudhaare ( alif , ta , ya, nun )?? Ques 3. Is it Fail e Amr ? Ans . No Ques 4 . Then what is it ? ans . It is neither of the above because it is not a verb like يُقِيمُونَ and يُؤْتُونَ which occur earlier in the sentence. It is showing the 'Condition of the Doer of the Action' ie Haalat e Faael. in this verse the Faael (doer of action ) is الَّذِينَ ( those who ). Hence and therefore when you translate the verse the letter وَ should be translated as while and not as and because here Bowing ( ruku ) is not a verb but rather it is a condition of the person ( faael ) who is performing the Fail ( قِيمُونَ and يُؤْتُونَ ), I hope the matter of While is solved therefore the verse 5:55 is translated as " Only Allah is your Vali and His Messenger and those who believe, those who keep up prayers and pay the poor-rate while they bow " and yes between the two الَّذِينَ there is no وَ so The Wali given in this ayat is only the one who fulfills both the condition simultaneously, Hence Wali is Only 1.Allah 2.The Holy Prophet (saw) 3.The one who beleives, establishes prayer, performs charity (zakat) while in Ruku AND NOT ALL THE BELEIVERS Regarding the Third Condition there are many Places where it has been mentioned that this ayah was revealed in the Honour of imam Ali (as) ( i am in the process of acuiring scans of various Ahle sunnah Tafseer books to prove my point and to guide my fellow Brothers (since you have doubted the refernces given earlier) ) So with All Due respect I conclude The Vali are only 1. Allah 2, Prophet Mohammed (saw) 3. Imam Ali (as) P.S if you want to argue on the meaning of vali kindly start a new thread
  11. Here is a scanned reference for "prayer is better than sleep is an innovation of Umar bin Khattab" Analyzing the sanad of the hadeeth you have quoted from sunan abi dawood ::: The Sanad contains al-Harith bin Ubaid al-Eyadi about whom Imam Dahabi said: 'Not strong' (Al-Kashif, v1 p303), Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal said: 'His narration is not reliable' (Tahdib al-Kamal, v5 p259), Imam Yahya bin Moin said: 'Weak' (Tahdib al-Kamal, v5 p260), Imam Abu Hatim said: 'Not strong' (Tahdib al-kamal, v5 p260), Imam Nisai said: 'Not strong' (Tahdib al-Kamal, v5 p260). Also the Sanad includes Muhammad bin Abdulmalik who has been declared unknown by ibn al-Qatan (Tahdib al-Tahdib, v9 p317), Mardini (Al-Jawhar al-Naqi, v1 p392), Shawkani (Nail al-Awtar, v2 p17) and Zailaei (Nasb al-Raya by Zailaei, v1 p363). I wonder how you called the hadeeth Sahih !!
  12. For More Over Ali un Waliallah Ponder over the following do get me hadith with references ( and scanned as brother had asked earlier ) that other sahaba have been called WaliAllah I have provided scanned references for Ali Waliallah. Pls do the same for the other sahaba
  13. If you accept that Ali is WaliAllah then we don't have an argument Congratulations still for your satisfaction over the verse 5:55 reference
  14. ok so here is as you wanted some of your books saying Ali un Waliallah
  15. Dont try misqouting IT is not my rule. It is the Rule of the Ahle-Sunnah [ YOUR RULE ] and regarding umar's bid'ah here's a Tradition Caliph Umar Ascended the pulpit and said: " O people! Three things were permitted during the time of the prophet (saw) but I abolish them and consider them Unlawful. I would Punish one who commits them. They are Performing mutah with woman, Mutah of hajj, and saying hayya alla khayril amal in the azan " Sharh e Tajweed similarly Umar Making changes to the Religion of Prophet Mohammed (saw) can be found in Isabah fi Marefatus Sahaba Vol2, pg 63 printed egypt Muwatta of Imam Malik Vol2, pg 30 printed egypt Tafsir Kabir vol3 pg195, printed egypt kanzul Ummal Vol3 Zaad al Maad vol1 pg 243 Sahih Tirmidhi Pg106 printed nawal kishor press ( imam tirmidhi called it 'Hasan' And 'Sahih' ) Fathul Bari Sharh sahih Bukari Vol9 pg138 Sahih Muslim vol1 pg45 printed delhi and many other books. So it Would be best that we not discuss the said personality and instead concentrate on the topic
×
×
  • Create New...