Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


Advanced Members
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by hardtoforget

  1. he didnt pray with every1 theres pictures......
  2. Why your bringing fake sunni hadiths as arguement against Momins???
  3. Thatz cuz its not allowed in the forums - you can go 2 sunni forums to do that...
  4. Can you check if there is a problem in it after Mufadal? Bihar al-'Anwar, volume 3, page 57, chapter (bab) 4, tradition (riwayah) no. 29
  5. he didnt say fabrication....he only said maybe not true so like Sunni silence is closer to what he says unlike what som of his followers think without reading....
  6. Actually they say kafirs not bidatis so theyr even worse than u think. Even more laughble :DDDDD I dont think so thats fair. We say the same thing that they are wrong and wer right bcuz theyr bunch of nasbis.
  7. 5 is right number not 3. u have to know quran does not have say everything bcuz where it says the name of Ali AS? It is proofed from hadiths that its 5 and ur allowed to make it 3. wer not aga khani kafirs.......
  8. can u show the dual form inside of quran? yes/no? cuz this is a nasibi logic flaw so don't lie on quran like this. This you said: Please show where in quran you read aynain unless u made it up in stupid joke/mockery. Even the nasibis own scholars never made such a big lie to the quran. if u dont know what ur saying than u shud better just not say it bcuz ppl can use u and ppl like u to mock Imams AS and our believes... this is ther mujasimi religion. They like to say theyr not mujassim so theyll say "clocks have hands too" and etc. but really any1 can see bcuz clock is still a machine so its still jism with parts to it. Or they say "hand of time" but time is also something so they have nowhere to run.
  9. depends, if u think mufadal is a liar than its fake and if u think hes true than its true.
  10. actually if u know anything about their religion than u will learn they are all same in the end. Wahabis are even sometimes more tolerent than some of the sufis and deobundis.
  11. what kind of ppl use youtube? 12 year olds and stupids usually. What kind of ppl use an encyclopedia. so its okay we have wikipedia :)
  12. u shudnt make up things against quran and Allah
  13. I heard from a nasbi scholars book/article that bismillah ir rahma ir raheem is not in all of them or theres differences in where it happens in some of them like here.
  14. why does living mean u also are perciever? What if ur born w/out nose, ears, mouth, feeling or eyes...than u cant be perciever but ur living.
  15. theres disgreement on mufazal ibn umar if hes thaqa or liar.
  16. what makes u different than frm the sonnis who pick and chose what they want from Imams AS if u are (hypothticly ) willing to do the same...
  17. o wow i didnt kno that. so balagh for us is just 9 yr old than???
  18. than u wud leave imami tashyu and have ur lots cast w/ deniers of muta, raja and all other things w/ ejma from tawtur............ wats wrong on his point? Can sum1 we say is liar in fqih be sadoq in aqedat than?
  19. sum ppl said that it was aisha others said it was the jews poison others said we dont know (natral)
  20. U sound like a nasbi. We dont say it as PART of the azan bcuz when we say it we do it with niyaah that its something extra and thats halal They do not. scholars can just look and decide if its real or fake by seeing with ther hearts and quran
  21. but prophet was in his lap. U wna sya he missed a salat too...
  22. 1 Its said that since prophet knew the ghaybat than they AS also knew about things about certain ppl/events. So for example they can give special insight on who not to trust and stuff like that. also many things that prophet knew (so religion is full) he didnt say out loud like bcuz of munafiqs so the imams AS give that. even if they didnt give ny new info prophet said there will be 12 Imams AS after him so... 2 sum1 else will prbly give the reason but its enuf if the Prophet allows u something or says no to u about something. Even if u dont like something prophet allows u still cant forbid it cuz thats a shirk. muta belief is mu[Edited Out]ar even if sum1 doesnt wna do it. 3 most scholars dont allow zanjir zani. And even if they do than there are examples even from time of prophet that some ppl did some very similar things. heres an example from ur own religion's books: (sum sunni also put a refutation link against it but its a very shollow one cuz its said that this is hasan (authntic)).
  23. in ur dreams maybe. if u take out bismillah like Nasbis or if you put bismillah than meaning changes from "I start in God's name" to .... nothing.... .......
  24. So Saduq cites narrations he doesnt agree to in work of aqeedat? The arguement is that the Imam AS actions shows the man can marry with a non seyed. the 1st is basis for ruling than what imams AS did and ther families did shows it doesnt applies to men. Brother said thers no authentic prooves that females of Imams AS families merried to men who arent seyed. theres other narrations which also shows that this kind of marriage is not liked as well.....
  • Create New...