Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by jang

  1. what responses ? just talk ? it is clear that kulayni is against the Taqlid of a mujtahid.
  2. (salam) Shaheed Mohsin Naqvi pai Allah (swt) parr hore rehmat ho. A very nice dua.. Mohsin sahib bhee Mujtahid ki Taqleed kai sakht khilaaf thay aur Ali Yan Wali Allah Tashahud mai Wajib ki neeyat sai parthay thay.
  3. (salam) Kya Mujtahid ki taqleed Wajib hai...aap khud he parr lai Shaykh Yaqoob Kulaini ki Zabani : Page 1: Page 2 : Page 3 : Page 4 : Page 5 : aap khud faislah karay ? agar Shaykh Yaqoob kulayni mujtahid ki taqleed kai khilaaf hai to kya un sai barah aalim koi hai ? (salam)
  4. (salam) She's back and now its i the urdu section... why are you distorting the information baqir nisar has written ? r u aware it is a sin ... anyway here are the question you did not answer in the general discussion and did a quick runner, which is a habit or you. we want answers for them .... Would you say ------- YES or NO Secondly you said and i said so would you take you words back or want to shy away from the claim that you have made. Thirdly : do you have any other similarities between Baqir Sahab and Akhbaris except Taqleed ? if taqleed is the only thing Akhbari'ism is based on : than you will have to call all the sufis and saints an Akhbari as this list includes names like Lal Shahbaz Qalandar, Shah Abdul Latif Bhitai, Baba Bullay Shah, Ghulam Farid shah and the list goes on and on - and the list would also include names like Shaikh Yaqoob Al Qulainy, Allama Majlisi etc etc. would you call all of them AKHBARI ? Fourthly you said " don't see who is saying, but see what has been said - it is regarding a matter in which one has already brought "Authentic Proofs" (i.e. Authentic Ahadith) in order to proof his claim. " May i ask you how have you reached this conclusion ? there is no such thing mentioned in the tradition for sure : Well My dear sister - you have made some sweeping claims now you have to defend what you said in a proper way without shying away from questions. if you you continue to ignore the questions you would be doing a dis service to yourself and all your effort of writing so many pages would go waste. I have just asked four simple things without even reading the whole " BOOK " that you have written and you cannot even answer these - if i go through the whole thing i dont know hoew many more discripancies i would find in your " BOOK " I would start reading it after you satisfy me with your answers. baagh kar kaha jao ghee.... :!!!:
  5. (salam) molvi shabi-ul-hasan is definitelty against Azadari, their is no doubt about it, he openly has created so many problems in the mosque... he has no tameez at all, you should hear his majalis, first of all no-one can understand what he is saying in the first place, he has openly spoken against Maatemi's and called them Kafir, Mushrak, etc .. he does not speak infront of Dr Shabih-ul-Hasan Rizvi as he knows that he is the enemy of all mokassers and has read many majalis on them for instance he spoke openly against jan ali kazmi, infront of his face. brother abbas does not know anything about him, its better to keep quiet.
  6. it is vital that we stick to Imam Ali's (as) explanation then any others.
  7. (salam) Imam Ali (as) said "We are Alims and our Shia's our students". How is it possible to look at a person be ibadat where one says one thing is halaal the other says its haraam ? Ibadat is pure and has no deficiencies. think about it.
  8. that site is a joke and zainabiyah's arguments have been flawed, on this forum.
  9. a fantastic chapter on maatem of zanjeer in english... even the so called shia's should read it who r against it.
  10. a fantastic article on Azadari has been launched by the AA team .. all malangs should read it carefully and tell others... it covers maatem, zanjeer, Alam Paak etc ect Azadari
  11. what funny replies im getting .. brother djibril, a long reply but no answer to my question ... who is right from Agha sistani or Agha Khoi ? is a peacock halaal or haraam ? according to you they have read well, and no almost everything in shariyah. forget talking about space yet, these people are having difficulty on a Peacock ?
  12. sorry did not understand the last reply. :squeez:
  13. i would appreciate people's views on this :rolleyes:
  14. (salam) brother you have not understood anything yet i am afraid, you give only views but what about evidence to back it up. did the 4 wakils ever ask people to do their taqleed ? did they publish their tawzee ? did they call themselves wali-al-amar ? the real followers of the Imam's (as) followed the narration of the Imam's (as) not people's own opinions. their is a great difference. you need to understand the difference between a Narrator and a mujtahid .... the Imam's (as) selected certain personalities to narrate their hadees, not for people to start passing their own judgements on things. again giving ayat without tafseer of it ? justice is only upholded with our Imam (as) . bro instead of presenting theories, please present proof from Quran and hadees. Allah (SWT) has never allowed any non-masoom to change or to give their opinions. this is the very argument we present forward against sunnies, that we only obey those who Allah chooses, the same applies to shia's aswell. You tell me who to follow ? who is right ? Agha Sistani has made Halaal something that Prophet Muhammed (SAW) made Haraam. Who shall we believe ? A mujtahid or Imam's (as) ....
  15. (salam) you will never believe ...even Agha Khoi has said taqlid is not proven from the Quran and hadees... at least belive in him ? was he not a marjah for you ?
  16. (salam) after so much evidence from Quran, hadees, from Agha Khoi's words, sister zainabiyah still not believing. maybe it's not right for you to gain truth, which Allah (SWT) has destined.
  17. (salam) brother when you read namaz behind someone, you infact are reading for Allah but you position yourself behind a fallible person. the same way is with Taqlid, Taqlid is for imam's (as) only and you may refer to someone for guidance but that person does not give his own opinion's of things but instead gives you a narration of masomeen (as). He does not need people to do his Taqlid, or publish a Tawzee. This is what Shaykh Kulaini did , as many people came to him aswell, and he offered the hadees of Imam's (as) and did not give his own opinions or publish his own tawzee or call himself wali-al-amar, or ayatollah. brother if you cant read Urdu, never mind, please print the sheets and take it to someone who does and ask him or her translate it for you. or wait for a few weeks, i will try to get it translated. please read the moqaddama carefully.
  18. (salam) so its proven that Shaykh kulaynee is against Taqlid of anyone xcept masomeen (as) :o
  19. Read this sister Zainabiya, a gift from a brother : Lets see sister if you can answer about these 200 Fatwa's ... :P Dont ever mess with a True Malang :D
  20. (salam) I am here to inform all brothers and sisters about a new book being Launched, this week, written by Syed Baqir Nisar Zaidi Sahib called Kashful Tazaad. This book has been written to requests and reponses made by Momineen that Mujtahids have only minor differences and that Mujtahids only give fatwa in accordance with the Holy Quran and the Ahadees. But Baqir Sahib has challenged that concept and has presented over 200 fatwa's where their is major ikhtelaaf between Mujtahids, where one is saying its halaal for something and the other making it haraam etc etc. He also has written quite a number of Fatwa's which are incontradiction with the sayings of our Holy Imam's (as). The following are the Mujtahids under the scope : Agha Syed Ru-hullah Khomeini Agha Syed Ali Hussaini Sistani Agha Syed Ali Khamenei Agha Syed Abul-Qasim Khoie Agha Fazil Lankarani Agha Dr Sadiq Tehrani. It has been written in Urdu, but those people who do not understand Urdu, their is still a simple way you can gain benefit from the book too. You just need to approach someone who knows Urdu, at least the understanding of numbers, so that you may take the masslah or rule numbers from the book and check them in those Tawzee's which are in Arabic or in English. Tohfah Yaa Ali Madad
  21. Yaa Ali Madad I urge all brothers and sisters to read and save the following Moqaddama of Usul-al-Kafi where Shaykh Yaqoob Kulayni has clearly written that Taqlid is only of Masumeen (as). Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Please note that this Moqadama has been deliberately not been translated in the Urdu translation of Usul-e-Kafi. Yaa Ali Madad
  22. (salam) Here is what brother Abdul Hakeem wrote about the views of Agha Khoi. What do you say now sister Zainabiyah, even Agha Khoi is admitting that it is only believed on rational grounds, but we follow Sharah of Aima (as).
  23. (salam) all furu's are dependant on Man... if man reads salat, then it becomes a salat, if man fast, then it becomes a fast etc ect all aqaid r not dependant on Man, Tawheed is tawheed even if no-one beleives it. that is the reason why Aqeedah has to be correct 110%. remember also Imam's (as) are in Usul therefore supersedes all forms of Furu. thats why Imam Ali (as) says "Ana Salatil Momin" , I am the salat of a Momin and Imam Hussayn (as) proved who Hussain (as) was in the Salat of greatest worshiper of All (Prophet). i hope this helps
  24. which ones brother ? have u read al-kafi yourself ...have you read kitab-al-aqal, chap' 17-19.. if no please read them. Shaykh kolainei was totally against Taqled of any non-masom :P
  • Create New...