Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


Veteran Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

Everything posted by power

  1. Using profanity language is prohibited, discussing historical discourse is not. Now can you articulate concisely this comment of yours; Because it has become source hatred amongst Muslims that has damaged the Islam.
  2. How about you addressing my question first?
  3. It is evidently obvious you have doubts. But anyway for a believer primary source will always have precedent than any secondary source.
  4. Are you implying Shias are to blame for the damage? Because of are stance against the companions?
  5. Not entirely sure what point you are making now, however, you made a claim saying: Shias are unable to prove the validity of this claim historically... the only proof they have is hadith and interpretation of Quran verses. Then you said: what i mean outside of Islamic books... for example if i wanted to learn world history in genreral, i'm not going to pick up Quran and Hadith books... Conclusion to your asserted claim is: With the absent of independent source the claim is not valid. But now it appears you are doing a U Turn i think.
  6. Tell me honestly, Would Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) forgive those who have brought about innovation into Islam?
  7. Again you are admitting to my points, that the companions were not sincere in their taqwa.
  8. Thanks for your admissions.There was some issues. proves my point.
  9. Sadly you dont see the bigger issue, after the demise of Rasulillah ((صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم)) Islam has taken many different forms, because of the companions. Hence all the bloodshed that is going on.
  10. If i wanted to learn about the Prophets and previous Prophets, i wont pick up a science book, Quran and hadith would be the primary source.
  11. Concealment is don in a manner that nobody knows, otherwise is defies it purpose if its don openly. The truth alway has consequences, regardless how you voice it. Rasulillah ((صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم)) went to many battles because of the truth. Imams (عليه السلام) were martyred because they were Haq. Those who were sincere in their imaan will be rewarded by Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى). The question is was the majority of the companions sincere in their imaan? If you forensically study history of the companions, then sadly your perspective of the companions is unsound to put it mildly. History is a testimony that doesn't favour your biased view.
  12. Every Imams (عليه السلام) lived in a period were their lives was in danger. They could not openly curse the companions hence they were doing dissimulation.
  13. This is an extract from Nahjul Balagha : During his silence, he indeed started cooperating with the first 2 Caliphs as consultant and did his best to decrease the damage as much as possible. If he had not done so, Islam would have been destroyed completely. Imam Ali said: "I tolerated those periods as if there was a thorn in my eye and a sharp bone stuck in my throat."(1) Islam was very young at that time (only 23 years old!) and division among Muslims could have totally removed Islam from the surface of the earth. So he kept silent. Even though Imam Ali (عليه السلام) cooperated with companions, the above sermon from Imam Ali (عليه السلام) clearly shows he had endured immense pain in silence.
  14. That one incident has no consequences in the eyes of Allah and her father?
  15. I believe saturday night will be the last night and sunday will be the last day.
  16. Bibi Fatima (sa) cried for six months on her father's grave complaining of injustices that her family had endured. For me personally that speaks volumes about the so- called so and so!
  17. There is error in your reasoning, history hadiths does not favour your unsound reasoning.
  18. Differentiating between truth and falsehood in history of Islam is so important, regardless of what sect you belong to.
  19. So my understanding is correct, as for rest of your post i have no problem thanks.
  20. That's what i'm saying.
  21. My understanding was the holy Quran lays down the foundation (The fundamentals) And the Imams (عليه السلام) where to protect the foundation from deviation.
  • Create New...