Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

karbalah

Advanced Member
  • Content Count

    1,326
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by karbalah

  1. Great peace thanks I will post it to his face book I need info on Hareth because my cousin accuses our Imam Ali sa of killing a hostage that was innocent well learned and wise just to shut him up . I googled could not find much
  2. Salam alikum it's in Arabic so strong Arabic speakers please any feed back on Nadir bin Hareth here it is : النضر بن الحارث، قتيل الكلمة الحرة، نضر بن الحارث كان رجل مثقف من قريش وكان يحرج محمد في دعوته للناس ويناقشه بفضل اطلاعه على الاساطير وقصص الاقوام الاخرى ... وهو من أفسد على محمد ادعائه للنبوة في الفترة المكية حيث لم يؤمن برسالة محمد في مكة سوى سبعين شخصا طوال ١٤ عاماً من الدعوة ! وفي أحدى المناظرات سأل النضر محمد ثلاث اسئلة ليختبر نبوته، وكان على محمد ان يأتي في اليوم التالي لكي يجيب اسئلة النضر بن الحارث لكنه تأخر لأيام عديدة بحجّة ان احفاده (الحسن
  3. I am hoping anyone would have string background Information on him it seems like the cut off line of where my cousin came to the conclusion that Imam Ali sa just made a mistake by killing this guy because he was an innocent hostage .
  4. Salam alikum sorry for late replies but life and work been hectic but I have a question here is the post from my cousin لا فتى الا علي ..... ولا سيف الا ذو الفقار شعرٌ قدسي كنت أردده منذ الطفولة دون ان أغوص في فلسفته .. احيانا كنت اسأل ، ولماذا السيف والقتل ؟؟... فيأتي التبرير مباشرة ً من عقلي الملقّن ... القتال كان دفاعاً عن النفس... فكان يريحني هذا الجواب بعض الشيء... اما الان اسأل.. يا علي...... لماذا قطعت عنق النضر بن الحارث ... وهو أسير بين يديك يرجو الرحمة ... لقد قتل ذو الفقار الفكر والكلمة الحرة any one know who Hareth
  5. His wife suppers him she is Druze sect . Kids are babies still
  6. Your answeSurah imran 3:113-115 They are not [all] the same; among the People of the Scripture is a community standing [in obedience], reciting the verses of Allah during periods of the night and prostrating [in prayer]. They believe in Allah and the Last Day, and they enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong and hasten to good deeds. And those are among the righteous.And whatever good they do - never will it be removed from them. And Allah is Knowing of the righteous. The above is proof we don't villanize jews or christians/people of the book. As here, God directly explains the
  7. I have an issue with him not adding any references when he sprouts at racks like that ... my problem I an not knowledgeable in Islamic history.. i would argue with him about the Hajaj but I do not want to be like him I need references .
  8. I have an issue with him not adding any references when he sprouts at racks like that ... my problem I an not knowledgeable in Islamic history.. i would argue with him about the Hajaj but I do not want to be like him I need references .
  9. Copied كتاب نهج البلاغة . أن مؤلف الكتاب هو الشريف الرضي ( 969 - 1015م ) بينما الأمام علي ( 599م - 661 م) اي بين موت الكاتب وموت علي 400 سنة تقريباً. في المنهج العلمي للبحث يكون "السند" هو الوثائق الموجودة كتاب نهج البلاغة مكتوب من دون اي وثائق تثبت النص عن علي. لنقل الكلام يجب أن يتواجد الإسناد عن كذا عن كذا عن كذا علي قال كذا مثلاً. أو يكون الإسناد مكتوب عن كذا عن علي وتجده في كتاب قبل كتابة نهج البلاغة. وعلى كل ناقل أن يبين الإسناد المكتوب بالأسماء. الإدعاء المجرد لا يعجز عنه أحد. حتى النقل يدخل في قائمة التراهات أساساً إستناداً على تجربة عل
  10. Al Salam alikum because of the month of Ramadan I have not been very active . But to those who speak Arabic ayone saw anything like this attached? for everyone here he is Depcting Imam Ali similar to al Hajaj that or Imam fought and killed he is using this war as proof that there was injustice done , I am not very well versed in history but anyone with knowledge of that incident maybe can give me some input .
  11. You really opened my eyes to something here I have been in touch with a group of pious people that said same thing it was never in his heart to start with . I am copying your post with minor adjustment . Added that I think that being this far from Islam also leads you to Join the extremist on the other side ??
  12. Al Salam alikum in light of what happened here is a new post . I have been using your replies to add to his posts . but I am on the verge of giving up .
  13. Ramadan Mubarak everyone . New post came up today it's in Arabic : "وَعَلَى الَّذِينَ يُطِيقُونَهُ فِدْيَةٌ طَعَامُ مِسْكِينٍ فَمَنْ تَطَوَّعَ خَيْرًا فَهُوَ خَيْرٌ لَهُ وَأَنْ تَصُومُوا خَيْرٌ لَكُمْ إِنْ كُنْتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ "- البقرة ١٨٤. هذه الآية غير مفعول بها، اذ نسخت ( أبطلت) بآيات قرآنية اخرى.. الصوم في هذا العام حوالي ١٨ ساعة في معظم العالم ، وشهر حزيران هو شهر الامتحانات وتقرير المصير ، كثير من الصاءمين ، هم من طلاب المدارس والجامعات والذي يتقرر مصير مستقبلهم في هذا الشهر .. لا زال العالم الاسلامي بانتظار علماء شجعان ليعيدون تفعيل الآية المذكورة أعلاه .
  14. Married with three kids I think it's the new friends he has it's a cult .
  15. I bashed my head and had to take Advil for migraine he does jump around I did consider him here I will ask I doubt he will he seems to be a coward .
  16. I challenged him to give me sources , still waiting . I gave up , but it's good to be able to have strong arguments to post against him I will copy paste yours God bless
  17. Sorry I was away a bit I gave up on him but his mother called me crying for me to keep talking to him so with your help I will try !! Amazing refute God bless
  18. Al Salam alikum , I wanted to start a debate here , because I need the answers to be helpful and knowledgable , I have a cousin whom after 30 years of pious religious beliefs reverted to atheism . I debated some of his ranting on his Facebook page then gave up but this person's mother who is a relative called me and cried asking me to please keep talking to him . in my heart I feel it's a lost cause . But for her I promised to try . I am not very knowledgeable I do not have a strong data base . I need help so please unlike past posts do not ask me to spit in hi
  19. Thats just it ... I do not know how he could flip ...born and lived in south Lebanon ...I am thinking psychosis ....I am not even questing what he is writing as much as I am trying to push back at his grandoise delusions I need some back up strong debator in Arabic ... Not just info I can find it When it comes to translating the Koran I step away because I know each AYA had its own time term location and reason .... here is a post : القتال والجهاد في الاسلام ان فكرة الجهاد في سبيل الله فكرة خطيرة ، وقد استعملها محمد ليحرّض المسلمين على القتال ، فوعدهم بحور عين
  20. Lol ... I am having fun with him it's not really bothering me .. Look at my history here .. my problem is I am not historicaly in inclined in Arabic refutations. I am am holding my own very well in English in his abysmal sea of darkness it's good to جادلو بالتي هي أحسن To rattle ...and confuse o am not bothered so much as sad my friend that my cousin whom I knew to be religious attacked and debase Muslims now and his arguments are easily refuted .. If I know some decent Arabic words look I am using this forum to get some feedback I
  21. Know anyone that can help me get some answers in Arabic ???
×
×
  • Create New...