Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

145_turbo_16V

Advanced Member
  • Content Count

    1,833
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Thanks
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Why do you not accept Sunni Islam?   
    in all sects there is khilaf. You realize that there are at least 4 madhahib in Sunni Islam and lots of sub-divisions within those?
  2. Completely Agree
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in I am leaving Shiaism   
    If one of the brothers here is going to leave Shiism and revert back to Sunnism, my advice is to find another ism. Sunnism is defective, the first "election" was defective and everything went downhill from there. Even the rather liberal Mufti "Abu Layth" has described this election as flawed but as he puts it, the best solution to the situation at that time. Best? Best amongst the worst, maybe. So even some sunnis agree that this election was not really Islamic, just a politically expedient move.
     This is also what one Sunni scholar said in the forum at Al-Mahdi Center in Birmingham. You can watch the video on youtube. In his view Sayyidina Ali was the rightful 1st khalifah but he was denied that right. So how can this Sunnism be correct? At best it's just as "defective as Shiism". Now if you have serious objections to Shiism based on cultural issues, then you should also have objections to this very serious flaws in Sunnism. Maybe find another better "ism" form of Islam because Sunnism isn't it.
    However I do agree with this brother about the ridiculous cultural practices in Shiism. Prostrating to zuljenah, etc is stupid and makes a mockery of this deen. I do not like cultural Shiism at all. I actually detest it.
  3. Thanks
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Muslim2010 in I am leaving Shiaism   
    If one of the brothers here is going to leave Shiism and revert back to Sunnism, my advice is to find another ism. Sunnism is defective, the first "election" was defective and everything went downhill from there. Even the rather liberal Mufti "Abu Layth" has described this election as flawed but as he puts it, the best solution to the situation at that time. Best? Best amongst the worst, maybe. So even some sunnis agree that this election was not really Islamic, just a politically expedient move.
     This is also what one Sunni scholar said in the forum at Al-Mahdi Center in Birmingham. You can watch the video on youtube. In his view Sayyidina Ali was the rightful 1st khalifah but he was denied that right. So how can this Sunnism be correct? At best it's just as "defective as Shiism". Now if you have serious objections to Shiism based on cultural issues, then you should also have objections to this very serious flaws in Sunnism. Maybe find another better "ism" form of Islam because Sunnism isn't it.
    However I do agree with this brother about the ridiculous cultural practices in Shiism. Prostrating to zuljenah, etc is stupid and makes a mockery of this deen. I do not like cultural Shiism at all. I actually detest it.
  4. Completely Agree
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from AmirioTheMuzzy in Why do you not accept Sunni Islam?   
    for me this is a very important hujjah. i was a Sunni. Sunnis can argue about The fact that there are no specifics, no ayah about 12 imam, but the Quran is very clear about the the descendants of Nabi Ibrahim (عليه السلام) being Imams. An Imam isn’t just loved but not followed. He has to be followed. Any madhab which rejects this meaning of the Ayah IMHO, cannot be followed.
  5. Completely Agree
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from AmirioTheMuzzy in I am leaving Shiaism   
    If one of the brothers here is going to leave Shiism and revert back to Sunnism, my advice is to find another ism. Sunnism is defective, the first "election" was defective and everything went downhill from there. Even the rather liberal Mufti "Abu Layth" has described this election as flawed but as he puts it, the best solution to the situation at that time. Best? Best amongst the worst, maybe. So even some sunnis agree that this election was not really Islamic, just a politically expedient move.
     This is also what one Sunni scholar said in the forum at Al-Mahdi Center in Birmingham. You can watch the video on youtube. In his view Sayyidina Ali was the rightful 1st khalifah but he was denied that right. So how can this Sunnism be correct? At best it's just as "defective as Shiism". Now if you have serious objections to Shiism based on cultural issues, then you should also have objections to this very serious flaws in Sunnism. Maybe find another better "ism" form of Islam because Sunnism isn't it.
    However I do agree with this brother about the ridiculous cultural practices in Shiism. Prostrating to zuljenah, etc is stupid and makes a mockery of this deen. I do not like cultural Shiism at all. I actually detest it.
  6. Completely Agree
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from OrthodoxTruth in Why do you not accept Sunni Islam?   
    for me this is a very important hujjah. i was a Sunni. Sunnis can argue about The fact that there are no specifics, no ayah about 12 imam, but the Quran is very clear about the the descendants of Nabi Ibrahim (عليه السلام) being Imams. An Imam isn’t just loved but not followed. He has to be followed. Any madhab which rejects this meaning of the Ayah IMHO, cannot be followed.
  7. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Smiles786 in Is it possible to marry a sunni man?   
    Did you check with your marja? I think it’s discouraged but the definitive fiqhi answer should come from them not from this forum.
  8. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Ron_Burgundy in Sunni/Shia Debate-Mohammed Hijab vs Sayyid Haamid   
    What was the point about Nahjul Balagha which MH brought forth which would "destroy" our arguments? He didn't state which khutba of Amir Al-Mu'minin it was. I would like to look it up.
    I mean the question which they keep on asking is pretty dumb. "Show me where in the Quran there are mention of 12 imams". "Why does Allah make it difficult for us, couldn't he just show it in the Quran about the 12 imams".
    Show me where in the Quran there are mention of 5 prayers. Seriously, why do these people to themselves.  Isn;t there a hadith which states:
    صـلـّوا كـمـا رأيـتـمـونـي أصـلـّي
    Then it's the same for Imamah. 
  9. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Abu Nur in I'd become Shia immediately if...   
    Salaam I'm not Sunni, I was Sunni (following Imam Shafie (Rahmatullah Alaih)). Imam Shafie as you all know was a lover of Ahlul-Bayt. I came to Shiachat in 1997 when Bro Asad from Canada was the admin.
  10. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from shia farm girl in celebrating birthdays of Prophets and Imams   
    Oh my god, handing out candy! That's bidaa! LOL! :rolleyes:
  11. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from Rightly Guided Benefactor in Calling Allah's (swt) Name in the Bathroom...   
    According to the AB Alim Network:

    QUESTION:

    This Question should be answered by Ayatullah Seestani and Marhum Ayatullah Gulpaygani's Masail.

    When one is wearing a necklace, bracelette or pin with Allah, our Prophet's (SAWS) name, or the name of an Imam on it, be it they are wearing it *OR* it be a Qur'anic Ayat in their wallet - are they permitted to go into the bathroom with it, or must it always be removed?

    Is the ruling different if the item is directly touching the skin?


    ANSWER:

    Salaamun 'Alaykum,

    We are allowed to go to the bathroom with pins etc. which have the names of Allah or Prophet or Imams provided this does not entail any disrespect to them. It is not wajib to remove them unless there is fear of disrespect.

    Allah knows best

    Liyakatali

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
  12. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from wrangler in Ribena and Lucozade are HARAM!   
    (salam)
    Sis,
    You are not allowed to knowlingly consume alcohol especially if it is from Brandy in a cake.
  13. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from alshemary in UMAR BEATS UP ABU HURAIRA   
    :lol:
  14. Like
    145_turbo_16V got a reaction from kayjay in Malay   
    SA,
    Saya tengok video ustadh Kamil dan Prof. Azmi debat di Bagan Serai kut, hujung tahun 2011. Pejabat Agama tu cuba nak perangkap diorang. Diorang nak Ustadh Kamil kata kalau tak percaya Imamat maka jatuh hukm kafir. Pasai apa la setengah2 ustadh sunnah kat Malaysia ni suka membuat fitnah. Hang tak suka Shiah to tak apa, tapi biaq la depa nak hidup.
    La ni hari2 saya dok tengok videp Sayyid Kamal Haydari. Selama ni saya tengok videp dia, fuuuh dahsyat sungguh dia ni. Di ni kalau debat dengan ustadh2 Malaysia, habih, hancur.
×
×
  • Create New...