Panzerwaffe

afghanistan should have been a soviet republic only way to civilize them russians did so much for afghans in 10 yrs and ungrateful mujahideen wrecked it all

Wasalam So essentially the Sunni hadith masters have to rely on history and rijal works So their opinion is based on 2nd hand information and cannot be considered reliable ?

How did the hadith masters pass judgmental of the reliability of narrators if they did not investigate their biographical information themself. ?Most of Masters lived in a time which was several decades after the earliest narrators were alive So how did they get their biographical information on them? they must have relied on some historical sources or biographical data compiled by earlier historians. So the Judgment of even the best masters is essentially dependent on this biographical data and historical resources

Question should be why do Sunni still respect aisha after she fought against a legitimate righteous caliph

I will be very interested in this too please share more information what did he say about abu ayub ?

When in your timeline does shiaism becomes majority sect ? Interesting thread

no we destroyed ralph naders and bernie's careers by a resounding majority we in america hate all revolution, we HATE socialism while not understanding what it means and while demanding all its benefits the problem is the "educated" middle class which sees imaginary social evils and lives in a self righteous bubble and does not know how the world works wealthy will always be evil but whose votes keep them in power ? I really wish we can rehabilitate the image of socialism in america, putting the "social" in SS checks many of us love to receive

there is hope ! Thanks for saying this

true to an extent but accumulation of any sort is not justified as long as there are poor in such huge numbers in this world, so there is some injustice that is occurring by which we accumulate wealth whether we know it or not

shia on this forum are mostly the more intellectual lot and even amongst them < 10 percent are interested in this history they represent a drop in the bucket of the total shias so don't act like all 12er shias are like some GD intellectuals because they observe muharram in indopak it is more common to find names like qumbar , kumail , thaqlain than miqdad or salman and I'm not saying that 12er scholars have neglected this subject, they have not but few read their books or reference them in majalis

that is the incentive for many to have kids , but even in worst case no one is actually starving unlike other countries .You can get 3 to 4 diagnosis once u see a doctor , talk to a social worker and MOST people walk out with some benefits [esp if you are not a white male , sad truth from 14 yr experience. We never talk about the silent war on the single white male in USA] religious perspective no absolutely not but muslims should also not pay tax to a non muslim govt logically or historically, [yes i know "scholars" change their opinion on it based on whichever way the wind blows]

99 percent of "religious" muslims Ive met have read exactly ZERO religious books

ASA give the polish a break dude , they are amazing hardworking people and i see a lot of polish men and women here in chicago not one complains about these things back home I'm sorry I'm not aware too much of whats going on there , just want to say Hi to you btw i love your location stasiland , sounds very umm utopian

needs are subjective these days honestly for someone who lives in america we technically don't need any money food stamps are pretty generous, section 8 is decent in most places and at thrift stores i can find better clothes than my wardrobe AND Medicaid is amazing ! i would hoard money for peace of mind essentially, for the "what ifs"

i prefer someone who has a good job, cooking and cleaning is so OVERRATED and I'm a minimalist so I can feed and clean myself with kids yes both partners can take turns, i love taking care of kids too