Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Abu Nur

Moderators
  • Posts

    8,622
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    23

Abu Nur last won the day on October 21

Abu Nur had the most liked content!

About Abu Nur

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Shia Islam

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

37,667 profile views
  1. Great video as usual. But I disagree with him when he brought about Shia Islam and how they use the esoteric meaning to support the immaculate of imam. Any religion that base their proof ( or their fundamental principles) only by esoteric meaning is weak religion. But esoteric meaning do exist and can not be deny in Quran and only most knowledgeable people can grasp it. But the rest Masha'allah may God bless him for this knowledge and may God also bless you brother for all this time bringing us wonderful understanding on Quran and showing how these Christians essential belief is based on weak proof.
  2. Off topic but one interesting thing about how we can know prophet Ishmael is the one who was choosed to be sacrificed is that by his character mentioned in Quran, where God said that he was the patience one. It is something that is very honorable title who tolerate all kind of tests. The Prophet Muhammad (saws) and his Ahlulbayt (عليه السلام) surely are the manifestation of patience and prayer.
  3. If they reject it after they understand it is the truth then they become kafirs. If they accept it after understanding as truth they will be believers. If they don't accept it because they do not recognize the truth they are muslim and God will judge them in day of judgement and will not be in the state of those who recognize the truth and accept it. So yes, it is that serious that you take it very lightly. As have been seen by your post, you belittle the religion of Islam. This is because you really have no understanding of it at all.
  4. Yes, it is part of the belief of Shia Muslims, because of the event of Ghadir, where the Prophet stated that whomever I'm the master, Ali is his master. This is itself an indication of succession in leadership and guidance (not prophethood and messenger hood), because Ali (عليه السلام) became the master of all the believers at that day after Prophet. It is even interesting that Imam Ali (عليه السلام) in authentic Sunni narration in one of his sermon bears witness to this event when some people started to doubt his khilafa. Insha'Allah I try to find it when I have more time.
  5. It is not valid at all. Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) have promised that he will send a prophet like musa who will bring new book and new ummah. Does it make any sense that God will leave that new ummah without a divine leader where he supported bani isreal with divine leaders after musa? Read Quran how many times God gave succession and protecting of his religion but then He stopped it with our Prophet? If you ask the family of the prophet and their followers they will say that God gave succession of Muhammad (saws) to Imam Ali (عليه السلام). Of course his opponents will say different. The reason why there is two groups tells you that there is something about the succession that some disagree and other agree and others don't care. This same happened with God choosing talut as king and majority did not accept it.
  6. You just said while ago that the one who does not follow the prophet is kafir and now you are saying that Qur'an is sufficient enough? If Qur'an is sufficient enough then there is no need for Hadiths. If there is no need for hadiths, then there is no need for the Prophet Words to be obeyed, and if we do not obey the Prophet we go against the Holy Qur'an. Contradiction. If we only have access to Qur'an then God will judge based by it. But it does not work when you have both of them access with you and you decide to reject one and accept one. Umar did the same mistake, saying: “The Prophet is seriously ill and you have the Quran; so the Book of Allah is enough for us.” What Umar did is that he disobeyed the Qur'an command itself by not following the Prophet instruction.
  7. They inteprate it as to take care of the prophet family, for they do not believe that it is meant to follow them and obey them. It will also contradict with their belief system that prophet did not leave successor. There have always been two different ways who disagree with each other, and only one of them is with the truth. This is part of test of Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى).
  8. Good, we agree. Shaytan became kafir for disobeying God and still he have faith for God. You have been here very unclear of what your stance is. Reading by your previous posts it make people think that you think hadiths have less importance in our belief or that Quran is enough for us. It is not enough, because part of the obedience is prophet words so we need Hadiths also. And they are no less important. I don't care what hadiths you accept, but it is essential to believe in them.
  9. How extent it's need to be to be called a follower of the Imam Ali (عليه السلام)?
  10. Don't make something important to sound like less important. Disobeying God and Prophet Muhammad (saws) and rejecting their sayings is Kufur. So Hadiths are very important and part of the Obedience of God and Prophet. I clearly distinguish that God words are Qur'an and the rest are the Prophet, and we can not reject the Prophet words either because of the Obeying is wajib. Imagine if the person have only access to Hadiths only. Then his belief will be judged based on the knowledge of Hadiths and his faith. But most of the case is that we have access to both of them and we need to follow both of them.
  11. If they were following him, they would focus on him, his narrations, his family and his companions. But rather they do not so.
  12. Quran is God words, so what is the words of our Prophet so we can learn to what exactly we need to obey. They are exactly the hadiths. It means there are such an essential laws and beliefs uttered by the prophet that we must believe in it or else we become kafir and these words are not found in Quran.
  13. No, his action is based on His intention, If He intended not to speak, He does not cease to be Communicator, or The One Who Talk to His slave.
  14. Kalimatullah in the manner of Jesus was that God Created Jesus directly by the Word BE! The same way with Adam. Your interpretation is not acceptable by Qur'an either, so yes you are here describing what Christians believe.
  15. The proof is logical following by what God have taught us about Himself. In this issue God says that He Is the First and Eternal, this itself tells that to be the first, It must be that He was Only Him alone without creation in existence and nothingness expect God. This itself tell that it is impossible that God have always created. Being Creator does not mean that He need to act as Creator (there is no need, but He wills whatever He wills with His Intention). Nor when He act first time to create the creations follows that He became a Creator (Astagfurullah).
×
×
  • Create New...