Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

VoidVortex

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    472
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    VoidVortex reacted to Abu Nur in My Experience in a Chinese Government Concentration Camp   
    https://youtu.be/qTE8SJFQ8iU
  2. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Essentials123 in Not getting married due to mental health issues   
    First, know that Allah loves you
    Second for the depression try a few things:
    1. Diet:
    Diet can have a pretty big impact. I just checked a vid and many people in the comments are attesting to keto helping a loved one's autism. 
    Try out the keto diet where you intake 80 to 90 percent fat, and the other 10 or 20 percent carbs and protein.(don't worry about consuming so much fat, contrary to myths, eating fat in itself doesn't make you fat)
    The diet could consist of foods, such as:
    • Fatty meat
    • Coconut oil ( or you could get mct oil which is even better)
    • Eggs ( good quality eggs are one of the best foods out there)
    • Fatty fish ( I would supplement omega 3, its very important)
    Also you can have salads too and any other meat you want
    You would also want to add electrolytes( magnesium, potassium, salt), B vitamins
    Also have at least 5000 iu of vitamin D a day, vit D is very important for the body.
    cut out the sugar in your diet and cut out veggie oils
    Also supplement on probiotics for the gut, most serotonin is produced in the gut
    By God's permission this diet may reduce the symptoms of the depression and autism, try implement it slowly and see if it helps. For the keto part, there will be something called a keto flu, as your body is not used to it so when you feel symptoms if you switch to keto you need to intake electrolytes to a high enough amount. This includes salt, a few thousand miligrams of potassium and 400 mg of magnesium a day. You can get potassium from losalt, those salt brands that replace sodium with potassium and you can get it from green veggies but those veggies differ in how much they have. Salt is extremely important in tackling keto flu.
    I'm sorry for overwhelming you, but these were dietary points I think you could try to help
    Exercise:
    Exercise is extremely important for mental health, exercise daily even if it's just walking.
  3. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Silas in I'm on the verge of leaving Islam. Please help   
    Inshaalah you'll benefit a lot from this:
    You need God's Love more than you think - YouTube
  4. Like
    VoidVortex reacted to Yusuf71 in My son thought Farsi was difficult, so I showed him this   
    I speak a bit of Gaelic and I´m currently learning Farsi.  I am surprised how many Farsi (or perhaps Arabic) words are in Gaelic like khaleej (gulf) or Is MIse Yusuf (my name is yusuf).
    Farsi grammar is actually very easy, the problem with Gaelic is that it doesnt look like how it sounds. It never had a written history until much later, it was only oral and has so many dialects that trying to find a standard is a problem. 
    Theres a little bit of info on Irish Gaelic (Scottish Gaelic´s cousin) and its relationship with Arabic  here https://www.albawaba.com/slideshow/arab-irish-connection-nobody-told-you-about-818170
  5. Like
    VoidVortex reacted to Abu Nur in A study of matn criticism amongst the Imamiyyah   
    The Qur'an gives an humble viewpoint about the Prophets (عليه السلام) that at the same time they are depending and needy of God (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) mercy the same how we are too. Among of them they were poor because of the humbleness and how giving they were. Among of them are those who God show His miracles as proof to people not that the prophets themselves cares about the miracles. Among them are messengers who give glad tidings and word from Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) to people to guide them.
    There are clear verses that show what Imams and Prophets are, but it does not mean that they are attributed the greatest attributes just because God choosed them, but rather they are limited with the attributes as how much God will give them to help them and others in their journey of guidance and knowing God. By logic and analysis we can form a picture of how much we can know about them such that we don't give them an less picture about them. They know more than us but we don't ask how much because it will lead us out of boundary.
    It has been demonstrated by Ghulat that how far out of boundary we really can go. 
    Example:
    Two companions enter upon Imam al-Sadiq and inform him that:
    Mufadhal b. Umar says that you are the ones who allot the Rizq of the slaves.
    The Imam replied:
    By Allah – None allots our Rizq except Allah. I was in need of food for my family once, so my heart became constrained, and I became ponderous over what I was going to do, until their (i.e. my family members’) strength drained (i.e. due to hunger), only then did my soul get pleased (i.e. my Dua for Rizq was answered). May Allah curse him and disassociate from him.
    They both said to him: Do you curse him and disassociate from him? He said: Yes, so you two also curse him and disassociate from him, may Allah and his messenger disassociate from him15
    - The same way how we seek rizk by Dua the same way The Imams (عليه السلام) also do.
  6. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Eddie Mecca in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    wilayat al faqih and wilayat takwiniyyah are not really related. Being wali al faqih doesn't give you the esoteric wilayah of the Imam. Imam Khomeini and Khamenei do not have such a power. Its far fetched for a lot of people to even claim Imam Zaman has such a power, let alone fallibles. As for Imam Zaman, he may have such a power, he may not, I don't know. 
  7. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Eddie Mecca in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    I wrote something for this, but @Ashvazdangheanswered the question way better than I could. I will also add he was a revolutionary in fiqh too.
    let's take this question and answer by Sayed Sistani for example:
    Sayed Sistani explains the hadith in a different way than what the hadith appears to be saying. He's not rejecting the hadith but adding nuance to it. 
    This view is a recent view, and jurisprudents of the past actually only allowed seeing a woman once, with or without lust. Jurisprudents today have started issuing views different to the jurisprudents of the past. This is because hadiths have nuances, and they cannot just be read and applied. They have to be analysed very deeply and understood in the correct context, otherwise are our jurisprudents today sinning by ruling music to be lawful in certain circumstances despite some pretty explicit texts banning even certain instruments? 
    Anyways, its not a matter that if I see an apparent conflict between Quran and hadith and the beliefs of a scholar I will adhere to the beliefs of a scholar, although we actually do this in taqlid, but its the case that I will consider a scholar's view as long as they provide evidences for it, and highlight why X hadith can be interpreted in Y way. For Sayed Khomeini's view on wilayat takwinniyah, whilst I acknowledge his view, I actually don't accept or reject his view. I do say however that his view could be argued for and against, but for now I don't reject it nor do I accept. As I increase in knowledge maybe my view will change, or it won't. If a scholar intends to argue for something, they need to bring evidences for it. Imam Khomeini actually brought hadiths from al-kafi to justify his view in those chapters I posted, hadiths I didn't know existed and not what I expected to be in al-kafi. Of course he can't argue for his view on this fully in that book, because it wasn't suitable to explain fully why he believed in his version of wilayat takwiyniyyah, he might have had to write an entire book for that or more(which might exist I'm not sure), certainly something which can't fit into a chapter.
     
  8. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Eddie Mecca in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    I will say though that Imam Khomeini can be wrong about this, and his arguments can be responded too. He may be right or he may be wrong. It is however important to see that we have a portion of scholars that believe in wilayah takwiyyiniyah to this extent. Ayatollah Khomeini was heavyweight scholar, even in fiqh he was extremely strong, let alone his specialisation in other subjects. It makes his perspectives of the religion certainly worthy of consideration.
    certainly not. Those scholars are using Quran and Hadith to derive their conclusions in the first place. 
    Let's take the rulings on music for example. It was essentially consensus that musical instruments were haram because the hadiths clearly stated it was haram. 
    But, recently the rulings on this have changed. Sayed Sistani himself views it permissible as long as certain conditions are fulfilled. Did Sayed Sistani suddenly imagine Quran and hadith to not be strong proof. Certainly not. This is because hadith on this subject can be re-interpreted to be seen in the light of prohibiting it when it is suitable for entertainment or sinful gatherings. 
    In a similar manner, Sayed Khomeini does not consider wilayah takwiyyiniyah the tafweedh prohibited in hadith, just like Shaykh as-Saduq and Shaykh al-Mufid differed on ghuluw. They didn't magically disregard sources, but their interpretation differed. 
  9. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from PureExistence1 in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    The theories are just an attempt to understand Quran and hadith at a much higher level. God isn't going to spoon feed us, a lot of higher teachings are in the Quran but unfortunately they have been neglected because we didn't have the capacity to understand. There's a reason its a common trend that the Imams forbade those who knew more about their status from disclosing their secrets, its because people couldn't handle it. Some were rightly accused of ghuluw and some were falsely accused of ghuluw. At the very least we can agree that secrets did exist and a very small minority had access to some of these secrets. 
    For example if you read risalah al wilayah by Allamah Tabatabai its full of Quran and ahadith. Allamah wasn't just a philosopher or mystic, but he was also a mufassir, so he would never think to go against Quran in his worldview and he believed his worldview was in line with the Quran, even if to some his worldview seems to be against Quran. Anyways scholars like Ayatollah Hasanzadeh have proved a lot of things that may have not been conventionally accepted like immateriality of the soul for which he provided 20 proofs . To be honest, the best way to see their views is to read his books.
    Anyways I think at least the second video you will like to watch. The ulama abrar p2 video, because it talks about ghuluw and mufawidha and because this discussion especially happens here at shiachat frequently it would be great if you watched it when you have time and gave your thoughts.
    (2) 07 - Ramadhan 1443 | Dr. Faroukh Sekaleshfar | What Exactly Ulamaa Abrar Theory Entailed? (p2) - YouTube
    I would also say watch part 3 if you have time but part 2 is more important.   
  10. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from TechySkills in Ayatullah Mohsen Kadivar's view on Hijab: it is not obligatory   
    What do you define as a real religious Ayatollah? Why does liberality define a person's religiosity? What's the proof being conservative makes one a better mujtahid than being non-conservative?
    I'm not saying this to defend or oppose anyone. Just this statement in general is what I'm asking about
  11. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Ayatullah Mohsen Kadivar's view on Hijab: it is not obligatory   
    To be fair, we impose the spiritual and moral aspects of fiqh rulings onto fiqh. 
    for example, take the rulings of purity of non muslims, some impose the idea that they are inherently najis because of their kufr. 
    But recently there has been a shift in fiqh and non muslims (non ahlul kitabi) will be ruled as tahir most likely in the future. Some maraja have ruled them tahir and others have changed it from impure to impure with obligatory precaution.
    Those spiritual dimensions that we imposed turned out to be false. 
    We can extrapolate spiritual and moral aspects from fiqh, but we can't invalidate fiqh because of our own conceptions of spirituality and morality, at least that seems to be the case in my view.
    I just wanted to comment on this since its a good point to comment on.
  12. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    The theories are just an attempt to understand Quran and hadith at a much higher level. God isn't going to spoon feed us, a lot of higher teachings are in the Quran but unfortunately they have been neglected because we didn't have the capacity to understand. There's a reason its a common trend that the Imams forbade those who knew more about their status from disclosing their secrets, its because people couldn't handle it. Some were rightly accused of ghuluw and some were falsely accused of ghuluw. At the very least we can agree that secrets did exist and a very small minority had access to some of these secrets. 
    For example if you read risalah al wilayah by Allamah Tabatabai its full of Quran and ahadith. Allamah wasn't just a philosopher or mystic, but he was also a mufassir, so he would never think to go against Quran in his worldview and he believed his worldview was in line with the Quran, even if to some his worldview seems to be against Quran. Anyways scholars like Ayatollah Hasanzadeh have proved a lot of things that may have not been conventionally accepted like immateriality of the soul for which he provided 20 proofs . To be honest, the best way to see their views is to read his books.
    Anyways I think at least the second video you will like to watch. The ulama abrar p2 video, because it talks about ghuluw and mufawidha and because this discussion especially happens here at shiachat frequently it would be great if you watched it when you have time and gave your thoughts.
    (2) 07 - Ramadhan 1443 | Dr. Faroukh Sekaleshfar | What Exactly Ulamaa Abrar Theory Entailed? (p2) - YouTube
    I would also say watch part 3 if you have time but part 2 is more important.   
  13. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Thoughts 2023   
    How do you manage to not burn out working for that much a week?
  14. My Prayers
    VoidVortex reacted to notme in Thoughts 2023   
    Working 16+ hours a day 7 days a week is too much anyway. Maybe after the school year ends I'll just do nothing. And by do nothing, I mean only work a normal number of hours per week, not all of the normal waking ones, and most of the ones that normally are for sleeping.
    My associate is running an environmental protection non-profit, and I'd like to be able to put some time into that. 
    It'll be fine, but for now I'm still sad and angry.
  15. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Mahsa Amini, 22-year old Iranian, dies after morality police arrest   
    even if this is the case, invading an entire country because of the actions of terrorists is nonsensical. There's no justification for it. It took them 10 years to find Bin Laden and another 10 to pull out. During this time, the military industrial complex was booming from the war that American taxpayer money was funding. 
    Afghanistan is one of the many examples of the US government bowing down to its military industrial complex and corporations instead of its people. Eisenhower didn't warn the people of the military industrial complex for nothing!
    A waste of 20 years. A waste of many lives. A waste of trillions. 
  16. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Poem: A Looming Angel   
    Usually they say a parent is being kind or hits their children out of love. Maybe the angel's harshness causes one to grow, but if the angel used love instead of fear, the person might grow far quicker : ).
    The question is, how do you see your lord. Is the angel reflecting how you see your lord
  17. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    in the sense that obeying him is like obeying the Prophet etc. 
    For example it is narrated that our deeds are witnessed by the 12th Imam every monday and thursday. Does it mean that wali al faqih has this ability. Nothing suggests that, and if someone wishes to prove this they can bring their proof.
  18. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Mediterranean Alawite in Mahsa Amini, 22-year old Iranian, dies after morality police arrest   
    even if this is the case, invading an entire country because of the actions of terrorists is nonsensical. There's no justification for it. It took them 10 years to find Bin Laden and another 10 to pull out. During this time, the military industrial complex was booming from the war that American taxpayer money was funding. 
    Afghanistan is one of the many examples of the US government bowing down to its military industrial complex and corporations instead of its people. Eisenhower didn't warn the people of the military industrial complex for nothing!
    A waste of 20 years. A waste of many lives. A waste of trillions. 
  19. My Prayers
    VoidVortex reacted to notme in Thoughts 2023   
    Well.... because of the incident with the substitute last week, my boss told me they will not be renewing my contract.  They would rather have no teacher at all next year than have me.  
    I guess there were consequences, just like I told the kids.  
    I haven't decided whether to go somewhere else or do something else.  I love the kids but have really grown to dislike the administrators.  
  20. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Muslim2010 in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    wilayat al faqih and wilayat takwiniyyah are not really related. Being wali al faqih doesn't give you the esoteric wilayah of the Imam. Imam Khomeini and Khamenei do not have such a power. Its far fetched for a lot of people to even claim Imam Zaman has such a power, let alone fallibles. As for Imam Zaman, he may have such a power, he may not, I don't know. 
  21. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from GEU_40 in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    @Abu_Zahra
    Al-Saduq's boundaries of ghuluw are rejected by the majority of scholars, its better to use the contemporary mainstream view of the boundaries of ghuluw and tafweedh.
    Do you reject that human beings can teleport and have extraordinary powers like reading minds. Some of our great scholars had such abilites. Or is it purely the idea of tafweedh(that Allah delegated affairs) that you reject.
  22. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in A study of matn criticism amongst the Imamiyyah   
    first, stop saying he has a famine of knowledge, attack the ideas rather than the individual, you are presupposing with certainty that the view you are advocating is correct, whereas it may not be. He was a very knowledgable man, but he didn't believe in X concept and that's ok, that doesn't mean he has a famine of knowledge. Insan kamil is a term introduced by Ibn Arabi anyways, it has certain connotations that come along with it, connotations that many will reject, and it does not mean a person has a famine of knowledge if they reject Ibn Arabi or Mulla Sadra's ideas. 
  23. Like
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Wilayat At-Takwiniyah and the Quran   
    wilayat al faqih and wilayat takwiniyyah are not really related. Being wali al faqih doesn't give you the esoteric wilayah of the Imam. Imam Khomeini and Khamenei do not have such a power. Its far fetched for a lot of people to even claim Imam Zaman has such a power, let alone fallibles. As for Imam Zaman, he may have such a power, he may not, I don't know. 
  24. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Hameedeh in My darling, my android   
    it certainly would not count as having a soul. The soul or heart is a very very great thing, which does not exist in the material world. Its impossible for human beings to give a soul to something. 
  25. Completely Agree
    VoidVortex got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in My darling, my android   
    it certainly would not count as having a soul. The soul or heart is a very very great thing, which does not exist in the material world. Its impossible for human beings to give a soul to something. 
×
×
  • Create New...