Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


Advanced Member
  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Aragaia

  1. Amazing how little you think of him. Philosophy and religion don't go together. Try as you may. I wouldn't rely on people who hate him to tell you the truth of him.
  2. So what is your objection exactly? His criticism toward philosophy came from spirituality. Philosophy lacks spirituality on many ways. That doesn't mean a philosopher can't be spiritual, but it does mean that philosophy does not in itself lead to spirituality, not to mention religion. Or do you think that this above mentioned logic can be used to attain the highest form of religiousness?
  3. What do you mean by tabligh? this is what he means with the word logic 'The study of the principles of reasoning, especially of the structure of propositions as distinguished from their content and of method and validity in deductive reasoning.' Not this "a particular mode of reasoning viewed as valid or faulty"
  4. Who says he considered philosophy haram? He simply thought it won't lead to religious truth. He believed that logic is not the way to do it. You are confusing two different meanings for the word logic. Obviously he didn't mean the act of using one's reason.
  5. I don't know if you're refuting "man's weakness requires him a powerful being who could solve his issues, is itself prove that human always need assistance" or supporting it, but I verify for my part it is perfectly true and according to the basic theory of Islam. "Perpetually is the servant either the recipient of a blessing from Allaah, in which case he is need of gratitude; or he is the perpetrator of sin, in which case he is in need of repentance; he is always moving from one blessing to another and is always is in need of repentance." - Ibn Taymiyyah
  6. One means start of modern days salafi Islam? its a shame you never replied to my thread about.
  7. Just one club. Is it even open yet? You certainly haven't seen it. I don't think that's the reason. It's far fetched.
  8. I don't understand why someone after Mohammed (sallallahu alaihi wassallam)?
  9. Okay. That certainly doesn't count as proof though. Actually I read somewhere recently about how Allah only speaks to the Prophets. But I forget who said it.
  10. Faith and certainty are in different categories. They can't really be compared. Asitotle is probably referring to objective certainty (?) but faith is not objective.
  11. Yes. If only someone could say with their own words. Successor of Allah and messenger of Allah are two entirely different things.
  12. We don't notice it. The subconscious replaces pieces of memories. There is no way for you to be absolutely sure of it. But I mean in general when talking of such dream - any dreams.
  13. Who told you this? I don't mean a scholar but a scripture or a Prophet or a messenger.
  14. Why must the ruler of the Earth be infallible. This is shirk. No one is infallible but Allah.
  15. What if the most guided isn't infallible? Did anyone ever say that they're infallible? I mean Allah or Prophets or messengers, did they say that?
  16. Only Prophets can have such things. Not sure if they should be called dreams, more like visions? But no. That's just psychology. For instance you saw the dream 10 years ago. You may think you remember it well but the truth is in time our minds start replacing forgotten things with new ones and memories can easily become disfigured.
  17. Ridiculous. All the rulings I read from others have reasoning presented. Only your sources seem to say nothing of it.
  18. Phobia means something negative and excessive which passes beyond logic and the reasonable way of reacting and acting. It isnt something prescribed to you by Allah to punish homosexuals or to seek them out. In other words you could say, it's a waste of time.
  19. Means you're not artistic. You can still leave other people freedom to express themselves. Dancing, like any art, can express all the beauty there is in life. It is challenging, exciting, a fascinating, way to love life.
  20. What's the reason theres about 30ish active posters despite it popping up in search engines remarkably well?
  • Create New...