-
Content Count
1,265 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
1
Ali bin Hussein last won the day on July 19 2019
Ali bin Hussein had the most liked content!
About Ali bin Hussein
-
Rank
Level 4 Member
Contact Methods
-
Facebook
Warrila
-
Website URL
https://zaidiportal.com
Profile Information
-
Location
Internet
-
Religion
Shia Islam
-
Mood
Content
-
Favorite Subjects
Sports
Previous Fields
-
Gender
Male
Recent Profile Visitors
-
Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
Ali bin Hussein replied to The Green Knight's topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
Who exaggerates more ? Sunni or Shia ? -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
-
Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
Ali bin Hussein replied to The Green Knight's topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
This is a very strange thread. @El Cid is correct it's obvious an army is needed to win wars. -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
-
Eddie Mecca reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Eddie Mecca reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ansar Shiat Ali reacted to a post in a topic: Is praying Tarawih an innovation?
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: Is praying Tarawih an innovation?
-
Is praying Tarawih an innovation?
Ali bin Hussein replied to Nightclaw's topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
Interestingly Malik ibn Anas always prayed in his house -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Was Buraq as horse ?
-
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Was Buraq as horse ?
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ashvazdanghe reacted to a post in a topic: Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
-
Eddie Mecca reacted to a post in a topic: Was Buraq as horse ?
-
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
I agree with this as the real difference. But not necessarily to the exclusion if other sahaba. As in Zaidi Imams have used hadith from sahaba and wives including Aisha (and not just to debate Sunni). Ok I don't want to derail this thread. So.ill stop there. -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Forgiveness for black magic
-
Forgiveness for black magic
Ali bin Hussein replied to musa shakr's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Agree with the above post. In Islam you just need to ask Allah directly for forgiveness. It's one of the beauties of our faith no other intersession is a requirement. -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Start a podcast?
-
Just start it. Don't think to much. I kept thinking about starting a website. Then one day I just stopped thinking about the plan. And started working on the site. Just do a single podcast. And go from there.
-
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: Start a podcast?
-
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: A Sunni friend of mine asked me a question and I don't have the knowledge to answer it
-
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
1) I'm going in what you said. When you stated there are more Ahlulbayt in Sunni. By that I assumed you meant the you have more Syed scholars within Sunni 2) I wanted to keep the example simple in trying to highlight you don't have a specific concept of following Ahlulbayt. I understand use of akhl and Maliki being the madhab of the people of madiba. But we will become a topic that is too big for us. 3) Explicit appointment of Imam Ali is different to Sunni. Once tthat is established you move to differentiating between Shia. 4) I cant give a better answer than that. -
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
We all agree follow Ahlulbayt So why should you follow Zaidi Ahlulbayt Well I claim Zaidi aqeeda can be prooven through Qur'an and mutawatir. The article of aqeeda that Sunni can't accept is Succession of Imam Ali So if I am right we are left with very general Shia. Now you look at all the groups of Shia and see where the aqeeda differs. And for me I cant accept those points that go beyond Zaidi aqeeda. (Like Sunni feel about Shia and mutazila.) So for me Zaidi aqeeda is perfect so I can't follow any other Ahlulbayt who differ from my aqeeda. Within Zai -
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
1) Majority is not really a good argument as its dependant on who is in power. And those that are in line with said power will end up having more numbers. Eg many Zaidi Imams revolted and were killed. Or the fact that majority Shia were once zaidi (idrisid empire) 2) I did mean ijma within a madhab I was trying to convey how Zaidi rulings work in relation to hadith. 3) Yes but for example if you add a invovation and then go as far as say its aqeeda you can't ignorecit. Eg a Sunni scholar is Ahlulbayt but then insists that beleif in return of Dhul qarnain is aqeeda and tha -
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
I think this is worth discussing. For arguments sake lets say we should follow Ahlulbayt . Ahlubayt are not inffalible you would agree. (Exception being Ali Hassan and Hussain for Zaidi) So firstly you would agree we should follow those of knowledge (scholars) Therefore it becomes dependant on a criteria of inclusion. As in if you are Ahlulbayt and say you become Ismali Or are Sunni Ahlulbayt but have not studied deen. Etc it's pointless including it as part of Ahlulbayt scholarly opinion. It would make sense those who are Ahlulbayt and knowledgeable would have a soun -
Ali bin Hussein reacted to a post in a topic: “The city of knowledge” hadith
-
Belgium is my pick.
-
“The city of knowledge” hadith
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ibn Al-Shahid's topic in General Islamic Discussion
This is the whole issue we are discussing. I stated that Sunni do not see Imam Ali as an alternative or possiblity for caliph ahead of Abu bakar. You then stated several possibilities Including Ali. And then refferanced his knowledge. It looks like we are going in circles. I believe my initial point stands. Regardless of nas or merit you don't accept Imam Ali as a viable alternative (and its just lip service when you say you do). This merry go round conversation is my evidence. You can disagree I'll let the 3rd observer judge for themselves. -
Proving Jesus (as) was not God
Ali bin Hussein replied to Ya_isa (as)'s topic in Christianity/Judaism Dialogue
1) I understand it is difficult topic. I've tried to understand your point of view. 2) Of all the explanation you gave this is the most difficult for me to even try and see your pint of view.- 144 replies
-
- jesus
- christianity
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Currently Doubting faith please help
Ali bin Hussein replied to hadi_syed's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Speak to a Shia scholar. Some of your issues should not effect your faith. 1) This is not a wajibat or sunnna. It has no bearing on being a Shia. 2) if she did or didn't has no bearing on being a Shia 3) What Khalid did or didn't do has no bearing on being a Shia. You are Shi because you believe in Ahlulbayt and the succesion of Imam Ali. Focus on these things There is a site called al-islam.org. Which has many books. Start with ones that address the fundamentals of religion. -
Umar the Brave the Warrior the Champion
Ali bin Hussein replied to The Green Knight's topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
I can't say about individual battle feats etc. But all the early Muslims were brave. That's a fact. You don't do what they did without courage. And generally the culture was one of a mark of a man is battle capability. If you were a coward you would get little respect. Imam Ali was the very best warrior of culture built on warfare. Let's not cut off our nose to spite our face.