Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Celtic Twilight

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    125
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Ashvazdanghe in Why Do Christians Deny Allah   
    Hi , We just consider the Jew theology which based on Torah which existance  of it approved  in holy Quran but in other hand in Quran said that the Jew rabbis has sold their faith to worldly  matters also after loosing or hiding original Torah the rabbis has rewriten it based on orals so as in Quran has mentioned  , They were moving their tongue like they were saying word of God but they has mixed their false belief with remaining  parts  of original  Torah which also Imam Reza (عليه السلام) in his debate with most knowledgeable  Rabbi on his time based on some parts of Sefirot(s) for proving prophecy  of coming of prophet  Muhammad (pbu) from text of Sefirots which that part approved  by the Rabbi as original part of sayings of prophet  Musa/Muses  (عليه السلام) but in other hand we deny book of Zohar & Kabalah as satanic innovations in Judaism & as similar fashion current theology  of Christians  as innovation of Paul which he has mixed false beliefs & innovations  with remaining  part of Bible/Injeel but  because Christians  in contrast to Jews have followed  it sincerely  but with ignorance which also they didn't commit great sins like killing  of prophets & disobeying  God likewise Jews which by contrast  with pride & arrogance Jews & their enmity with real  belivers  , Christians  have been humble people  as has been mentioned in Quran which their humbleness  with real belivers has been a key factor for introducing  them as friends  of muslims.
  2. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Eddie Mecca in What do Shias think about the rap music industry?Do Shias think its a tool?   
    F-Bombs dropped...be forewarned...Fat Joe Thinks Gay Mafia Controls Hip-Hop
     
  3. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Eddie Mecca in Why Do Christians Deny Allah   
    This is unfair to Christians.  The Catholic Church clearly teaches that Muslims worship the same God as they do. They are the largest Christian group. A lot of the Eastern Orthodox consider Christians Islam to be the worst Christian heresy, which is an old Christian idea, which again means that they believe that Muslims worship the same God as they do. Also Islam is closer to Christianity than Rabbinic Judaism is so if a Christian is going to say that Muslims do not worship the same God if they are going to be rational than they have to say the same for Rabbinic Judaism. 
    However there are a lot of nutters on the internet who use Christianity as others on the internet use Islam as a mask for their personal hatreds, pride, etc, etc and of course contemporary politics and political manipulations also enter into things especially where North Americans are concerned. 
  4. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in Why Do Christians Deny Allah   
    This is unfair to Christians.  The Catholic Church clearly teaches that Muslims worship the same God as they do. They are the largest Christian group. A lot of the Eastern Orthodox consider Christians Islam to be the worst Christian heresy, which is an old Christian idea, which again means that they believe that Muslims worship the same God as they do. Also Islam is closer to Christianity than Rabbinic Judaism is so if a Christian is going to say that Muslims do not worship the same God if they are going to be rational than they have to say the same for Rabbinic Judaism. 
    However there are a lot of nutters on the internet who use Christianity as others on the internet use Islam as a mask for their personal hatreds, pride, etc, etc and of course contemporary politics and political manipulations also enter into things especially where North Americans are concerned. 
  5. Like
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Tabassum Iman in Does Allah has a plan?   
    As-salam alaykom,
    In my opinion. YES! You should marry this woman. Do not delay. Better to speak to her father ASAP. There is a perfect atmosphere for marriage and good relations between your families. Let her father know you want to marry her, in case another man is interested. Make sure they know you want to marry her. It is perfect for you to get this part of your life settled early, then you can focus on making your money and building your family.
  6. Like
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Zainuu in Shia genocide in Afghanistan   
    Again, comments in this thread remind me of this saying:
     
    Keyboard warriors over here were no where when Iran was struggling to bring an Islamic government of a jurist. Many of them even criticised. But now they need Iran to reach everywhere in the world like a superman to protect muslims and Shias.
  7. Completely Agree
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Zainuu in Shia genocide in Afghanistan   
    What you don't seem to know is that Taliban was created before that by US in Afghanistan. And Hillary Clinton's cables are a proof for that. 
    The support you are talking about was not even exactly a support. They just said that Americans are bombing Afghans without any intel. Civilians die and Taliban suffers nothing. So, Iran just supported them to attack the locations of Taliban and not empty spots. Iran never called US into Afghanistan. 
     
    I would just talk about those parts that I know and can confirm:
    Firstly, need to say that many of the assertions in this are incorrect:
    1. Support for Yemeni Ansarullah was always to the extent Yemenis wanted. They are a part of Axis. They use Iranian weapons many times. Though, they deny continued aide because Yemen was blocked from all sides and is fighting by itself.
    2. Qatifi shias. Well well, how many of us speak about them?????? A simple question. Oppression on Qatifi shias by Saudi Arabia was only known when raised by Iran. The martyr Sheikh Al Nimr himself was fully supported by Iran (he was pro WF). Yes, military aide was not there becuase military men were not there. And Shias in Qatif were never allowed to raise arms. They were not given this much space let alone getting supokrt from Iran. You are talking as if all these oppressed communities are living in some land of roses where Iran has to just order and the aide will be on the door-step. 
    3. Bahraini shias? My world. Again, today everyone talks about it but who brought these issues up? What is the ideaology that led the Bahraini shias to revolt and protest. The leader of there movement Sheikh Issa Qassem is completely pro-WF and has studied in Iran. They all fully support Iran and recieve the support they can actually recieve under strick situation. Bahraini regime is so brutal that they keep an eye on every shia and censor everything coming on media against themselves. Bahrainis are protesting non-violently from a long time. They don't have a resistance group. To recieve any military aide, they need to form a front to fight the govt. So, as they are protesting non-violently, there unheard voices are brought before the international community by Iran itself. 
    4. Now, let me talk about Kashmir. Kashmir is definitely a place which needs support from muslims. But again, I can't even talk about how much support they gather from Iran. Your talks about military aide are ridiculous because you don't seem to understand how Axis works. Indian Kashmiris have no military aide becuase there is no strong resistance movement here. You might ask to create one. Please try to understand. Palestinian resistance was never created by Iran. So, Kashmir cannot and should not wait for Iran to create a group for them. India's relations with Iran has gone bad in previous years just because of Kashmir issue. You know it well that Kashmir has been trapped in a very complex sitaution and the rules are much strict and difficult as compared to Palestine. It is not a 'cake walk' to funnel weapons and intel into a region. 
    Regarding Hazaras, I am with you. In fact, most of the shias you mentioned or muslims are barely mentioned by Shias. But you are singling out Iran and this shows your problem with Iran actually. It is us Shias all together who are responsible. In fact, oppression on Hazaras is muchore detailed. It was even there before revolution in Iran. So, may I ask: Why we are hearing this now only? Why only this is heard from some years back? Because we were busy our shia Sunni chats and in are narrow minded approach towards life. We were living in a small bubble andthis wasour world. Now, suddenly when Iranians revolted, we all became known to the world. To be fair, before Iran's revolution, many in the world were not even aware about Shia Islam.
    For Kashmir, Indian and Kashmiris should come ahead and raise an initiative. Same goes for every region. iran is not my bodyguard. They just started a revolutionary idea of protecting Islamic lands from Imperialist powers. They never said that they are our bodyguards. They just brought an awakening and a realisation and that's it. We have to fight our own war andwe have to solve our own problems. This is what Iran's revolution wa sand this is what they are trying to explain us. Hezbollah's secretary general did mention this in his speach that when the initial leaders of Hezbollah in 1982 went to Imam Khomeini asking for help and told thme the situation. Imam said, "Rely on Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) and resist. Inshallah, if you are confident abou the help of Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) then know one can stop you from victory." He even said that,"Don't even wait for us or any other country to help you."
    Iran has always stood for us and there might be a thousand reasons because of which they can't stand for everyone. But Iran is not our guardian or body guard. So, singling out Iran is extremely baseless. Point should be that the entire muslim world (specially shias) are suffering from oppression. So, why are we quiet. How many muslims from East to west, really care.
    Iran never asked support while fighting Saddam 8 years. Iran never asked support while fighting Shah. They were also oppressed at that time right? Same goes with South Lebanese Hezbollah. Do you even know how poor the south Lebanon region is? Do you knlw how oppressed they were? 
  8. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight reacted to warisshah2012 in Barelvi Sunnis   
    Okay I've just seen this and similar threads about Barelvis on this forum and since I am a "Barelvi" myself and from a strongly
    Barelvi family I'll try to be as honest and brief as I can about our beliefs and how/if they differ from Deobandis' beliefs and our views on the Shia. 
     
    1. Beliefs:
     
    We are basically Sunni Muslims who follow the Maturidi aqidah and are Hanafi in fiqh. In addition almost all Barelvis are also initiated into one of the major Sufi tariqahs especially the Qadiri, Chishti and Naqshbandi orders and we emphasise this aspect a lot more than the Deobandis. 
     
    In addition to the above basic mainstream Sunni aqidah which we share with Deobandis we also tend to emphasise the following doctrines about the Prophet Muhammad over which many Deobandis object:
     
    1. Prophet Muhammad is the first thing created by Allah - before Arsh, Kursi, Pen, Tablet or anything else.
    2. He (sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam) is created from the Noor of Allah.
    3. He is alive in his blessed grave and answers the salawat of his Ummah.
    4. He is hadhir and nadhir. This means that Allah has given him the ability to see everything happening in the Universe as if he was looking at it in the palm of his hand and also that he has been given the ability by Allah to travel wherever he likes whenever he likes even after death and that he has the ability -again given by Allah - to be in multiple places at once (if he so chooses). This doesn't mean he is omnipresent always -- only if and when he chooses.
    5. We believe that before he passed away he was given knowledge of the Unseen by Allah including knowledge of the Five Things which Deobandis believe no one but Allah can know. However this knowledge is NOT equal to the knowledge of Allah but rather only an infinitely tiny drop of Allah's Knowledge -- yet this drop is an infinite Ocean compared to the knowledge of all other created beings including the angels such as Gabriel.
    6. Though we belief his a human being (bashar) we believe that he is also a Noor and that this Noori aspect of his nature takes precedence over his other aspect. In other words he is outwardly human but inwardly of a noorani nature.
    7. He sal Allahu alayhi wa sallam was born as a Prophet and he knew about his prophecy from birth. At the age of 40 he was ordered to proclaim his Prophethood publically.
    8. He was absolutely sinless and infallible and could never make any mistake whether small or large in any matter. Everything he said was wahy.
    9. He is the Arch-Intercessor and will intercede [do Shafa'at] for his Ummah on the Day of Judgement so that not even a single Ummati will be left in Hell. 
    10. He has been granted power by Allah to help his Ummati whenever he likes even after passing on to the Next world.
    11. Belief in the awliya of Allah and in their being given the power to help their disciples both near and far. We also believe that the chief of Walayat or Wali Allah is Imam Ali and that all other saints get their sainthood from him.
    12. Belief in the Panjtan Paak as being pure and holy (but mahfuz from sin as opposed to masoom which is only for Prophets) and in their ability to help.  Especially we emphasise the purity and sanctity of Lady Fatima al Batool al Zahra who we believe was free from such things as menstruation such was her purity. Thus we celebrate milad and the urs days of many saints and visit their graves.
    13. From all the saints we have special emphasis (after the Panjtan) on Sayyidina Ghawth al Azam Shaykh Abd al Qadir al Jilani (ra).
     
     
    These beliefs about the Prophet are highly emphasised in our gatherings and you can say that the Prophet is the centre of our religion and Madina, rather than Makkah, is our centre of love!
     
    2. Identifyng Practises
     
    1. We celebrate mawlid, urs days of all Sufi saints, especially the monthly commemoration of the urs of Shaykh Abd al Qadir Jilani.
    2. Huge emphasis on durood on the Prophet and Salam. Especially after Friday prayers -jumah' - we stand up and send salawat and salam on the Prophet using poetry from the verses of Imam Ahmad Raza Khan.
    3. Kissing our thumbs and placing them on our eyes everytime we hear the blessed name of the Messenger of Allah.
    4. Saying Ya Rasool Allah /Ya Rasool Allah madad / Ya Ali madad/ Ya Hussain/Ya Shaykh Abd al Qadir Jilani etc. etc.
    5. Going to the mazaars of the Sufi saints as well as the Ahle Bayt.
    6. Constant naats in praise of the Prophet.
    7. Commemorating the martyrdom of Imam Hussain alayhisalam during the 10 days of Muharram with majalis, khatms, crying, nohas, manqabats,(but no beating ourselves and we don't dress in black). Most Barelvis also consider Yazid a kafir and send laanat on him along with laanat on Shimr and all those involved in the martyrdom of Imam e Aali Maqaam. (All Barelvis hate Yazid but some stay silent on whether he was a kafir or not.)
    8. Qawwalis in praise of Allah, Rasul, Ali, Panjtan Paak, Awliya Allah, Sufi saints and murshids (but notice that there is heated difference of opinion amongst our ulema on this -- some say that qawwalis with musical instruments are forbidden but others allow it.)Thus almost all the famous qawwals like Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Aziz Mian and the Sabri Brothers were all Barelvis
    9. Many Barelvis have a Sufi pir or murshid and all believe in the concept of one even if they don't have one.
     
    .In short you can say we are Sunnis who emphasise Sufism a lot. 
     
    3. Differences with Deobandis
     
    Though both groups are Maturidis and Hanafis and follow Sufi tariqahs the differences are mainly twofold. One is that according to Imam Ahmad Raza Khan, some of the Deobandi elders wrote statements in their books which he considered to be kufr and hence he issued a fatwa of kufr on 4 individuals. The Deobandis say these statements were out of context or misrepresented. The controversial issues involved were whether or not lying is included in Allah's Power (the Deobandis' said yes it is intrinsically possible but He would never do it whereas the Barelvis say it is intrinsically impossible for Allah), whether the description used to describe the Prophet's partial knowledge of the Unseen by some Deobandi elders was blasphemous or not and whether the knowledge of the Unseen of the Prophet is greater or that of Iblis  and if it is proven by nass. These then are the technical issues which led to fatwa wars between these two groups and sadly, mullahs on both sides have continued to fan the flames for a century!
    The second issue is that Deobandis consider a lot of the Barelvi practises listed above as being 'bida'h and shirk' whereas in turn we consider them to be Wahabis-lite in their attitudes as many of the Deobandi elders themselves practised these things.
     
    4. View on Shias.
     
    Imam Ahmad Raza Khan divided Shias into 3 main groups and gave a different verdict on each group and never made blanket takfir of Shias as a whole (unlike the Deobandis who do so.)
    1. The Ghulat Shias -- he declared them as kafirs and defined them as being those who believed Imam Ali to be Allah incarnate,  or those who believed that Gabriel made a mistake in wahy and came to the Prophet instead of Ali or those who say that the current Koran is not the real Koran or has been tampered with or that any non-Prophet can be greater than a Prophet etc.
    2. The Rafidis - he considered them to be heretics [mubtadi] but not kafirs unless their beliefs tipped into some of the beliefs in point 1.
    3. Tafdilis - those who consider Imam Ali as superior from all the Sahaba but respect the other Sahaba too. Such as the Zaydis. He considered these to be  Muslims who were slightly misled.
     
    Most Barelvis follow the same opinion above as Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Raza Khan on the Shias although most Barelvis are also pro-Ahlul Bayt when it comes to a reading of Islamic history and support the 12 Imams and believe they were in the right.
    Imam Ahmad Raza has written so much poetry in praise of the 12 Imams and especially Ali and Hussain that he has often be mistakenly accused of being a Shia by Salafis and some Deobandis as have his followers. 
     
    Generally on a day to day basis Barelvis have no problem with Shias and strongly condemn their killings etc. which occur in Pakistan etc.
     
    5. Politics.
    Barelvis ulema and mashaikh are generally a-political with some very few exceptions such as Mawlana Noorani and, lately, Tahir al Qadri.
     
    I hope this has helped.
  9. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight reacted to notme in What happens-   
    Read: 
    https://en.shafaqna.com/135284/journey-of-the-unseen-world/
    https://www.shiavault.com/books/barzakh-purgatory/chapters/5-reward-and-punishment-in-barzakh/
    https://www.imamreza.net/old/eng/imamreza.php?id=3339
    https://www.al-islam.org/barzakh-purgatory-ayatullah-sayyid-abdul-husayn-dastghaib-shirazi/barzakh
     
  10. Completely Agree
    Celtic Twilight reacted to realizm in Shia genocide in Afghanistan   
    Look at it from another perspective.
    Arabs inherited Palestine as a common cause, before Shia/Sunni strife came on the scene. So it is not unhealthy for Arabs to stand out for other Arabs. Also, please bear in kind that before 1948, there were several Shia families living in Palestine. 
     
    And apart form this, if you speak on a more global level, indeed on one side Shias do not give as much importance as they should to Hazaras suffering, but on the other side, you see Sunnis being relatively silent on atrocities committed on Sunnis, like Boko Haram, terror attacks in Kenya. Same happened in the 90s with Taliban or GIA in Algeria. 
    It's human nature, some causes are more focused on than others, and gain more sympathy. 
    It's not just us shias. 
  11. Completely Agree
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Mahdavist in Shia genocide in Afghanistan   
    Speaking about one doesn't exclude speaking about the other.
    The question shouldn't be 'why are people speaking about Palestine', rather it should be, why aren't we speaking about Afghanistan?
     
  12. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from HusseinAbbas in Any UK SCers voting in the General Election?   
    Tommy Robinson is not someone I would call Hard Right- what I would call him is a degenerate, basically rootless, dodgy business man quite open about his drug use who has a psychopathic or at least sociopathic vendetta against Islam and Muslims most likely because he desperately wanted to get inside the clothing of an Aisha or a Fatimah back in his school days and she with utmost rationality and justice was having none of it. One of his major gripes is that Muslimas stay with their Religious communities when it comes to things romantic (how anybody capable of thinking would have a problem with this is beyond me- but poor old Tommy or whatever his real name is not great on thinking stakes). Tommy is extremely "socially liberal".
    George Galloway and Dennis Skinner strongly supported Brexit- would you say that George Galloway has an aggressively anti-Muslim agenda?
    Look the traitors of Sinn Fein used basically the same arguments in the six counties here in Ireland still occupied by England to get people to vote for Brexit- the DUP and "themuns" are for Brexit therefore it must be good, without the protections of the EU, blah, blah, blah.
     
  13. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Haydar Husayn in Why are Muslims seemingly democrats?   
    The thing is though is it right to refer to people as homosexuals? I would say that there are no homosexuals as such but that there are homosexual acts and people who indulge in them. Also if you look at how things have worked out in the West the more tolerance of homosexuality the more we have seen people who are engaged in these acts act destructively in other ways as well towards both self and others (violence, drug abuse, alcoholism, suicide, self harm, even deliberately getting HIV for sexual thrills, etc). Although this might seem counter-intuitive I think a society showing tolerance towards homosexuality is actually not being charitable to people who feel drawn to these acts or engage in them.
    When you say including immigrants does that mean that support open borders?
  14. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Abdul-Hadi in does/can islamic socialism work   
    MKO are currently allied to the scumiest, utterly nasty faction of the US Ruling Class who are the most cruelly capitalistic people you can imagine. They are also the people who are most antagonistic towards the Islamic world. It could be argued that anyone who allies with such people is NEITHER a Muslim or a Socialist. 
    Ali Shariati is probably the most famous, at least in the West, example of an Islamic Socialist.  A lot of what I have read by him I agree with but some of this stuff I found silly. He did though die a martyr and he was important in the restoration of Iran to the Iranian people. 
    From what I have read the economy of Iran is pretty Socialistic, not quite Socialism, but close. 
  15. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in does/can islamic socialism work   
    MKO are currently allied to the scumiest, utterly nasty faction of the US Ruling Class who are the most cruelly capitalistic people you can imagine. They are also the people who are most antagonistic towards the Islamic world. It could be argued that anyone who allies with such people is NEITHER a Muslim or a Socialist. 
    Ali Shariati is probably the most famous, at least in the West, example of an Islamic Socialist.  A lot of what I have read by him I agree with but some of this stuff I found silly. He did though die a martyr and he was important in the restoration of Iran to the Iranian people. 
    From what I have read the economy of Iran is pretty Socialistic, not quite Socialism, but close. 
  16. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in does/can islamic socialism work   
    I don't think that they are a Third Positionist group, Third Positionists tend to greatly admire the Islamic Republic of Iran. MKO are extremely strange, and I think in many ways there own thing, from what I have been able to gather about them they are like Trotskyites in regard to their psychotic cult of personality. Since Saddam went they are massively now supported by the Neo-Con wing of the US ruling elite. Resentment against Imam Khomieni and their cults of personality seem to be their key defining features. 
  17. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Ashvazdanghe in does/can islamic socialism work   
    I don't think that they are a Third Positionist group, Third Positionists tend to greatly admire the Islamic Republic of Iran. MKO are extremely strange, and I think in many ways their own thing, from what I have been able to gather about them they are like Trotskyites in regard to their psychotic cult of personality. Since Saddam went they are massively now supported by the Neo-Con wing of the US ruling elite. Resentment against Imam Khomieni and their cults of personality seem to be their key defining features. 
  18. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from notme in does/can islamic socialism work   
    Socialism does not have to be secular. I think actually Socialism can only really work long term when it has Religion, or at least some form of ethical Monotheism, because of the ethical demands it makes on people to work for the common good. I think the idea of an economy based around the concept of social duty as opposed to private greed fits in with what could be called the Abrahamic tradition in many ways. There was a quite interesting Jewish mystic called Yehuda Ashlag who predicted the fall of the Soviet Union, which he admired in very many ways because of it's atheism. He also predicted the collapse of "Labour Zionism" in Palestine for the same reason- but actually "Labour Zionism" in Palestine collapsed because of intra-Jewish racism as well as racism against the indigenous Palestinians who survived the Nabkha and were granted a sort of citizenship.
    Talking about "Labour Zionism" what annoys me about a lot of Socialists is that they believe that if solve the economy than everything else will naturally get sorted which is very, very untrue. 
     
    American Christianity in general seems extremely un-Christian to those who fall victim to Capitalism. 
  19. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Northwest in does/can islamic socialism work   
    I don't think that they are a Third Positionist group, Third Positionists tend to greatly admire the Islamic Republic of Iran. MKO are extremely strange, and I think in many ways there own thing, from what I have been able to gather about them they are like Trotskyites in regard to their psychotic cult of personality. Since Saddam went they are massively now supported by the Neo-Con wing of the US ruling elite. Resentment against Imam Khomieni and their cults of personality seem to be their key defining features. 
  20. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Northwest in does/can islamic socialism work   
    MKO are currently allied to the scumiest, utterly nasty faction of the US Ruling Class who are the most cruelly capitalistic people you can imagine. They are also the people who are most antagonistic towards the Islamic world. It could be argued that anyone who allies with such people is NEITHER a Muslim or a Socialist. 
    Ali Shariati is probably the most famous, at least in the West, example of an Islamic Socialist.  A lot of what I have read by him I agree with but some of this stuff I found silly. He did though die a martyr and he was important in the restoration of Iran to the Iranian people. 
    From what I have read the economy of Iran is pretty Socialistic, not quite Socialism, but close. 
  21. Like
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Northwest in does/can islamic socialism work   
    Socialism does not have to be secular. I think actually Socialism can only really work long term when it has Religion, or at least some form of ethical Monotheism, because of the ethical demands it makes on people to work for the common good. I think the idea of an economy based around the concept of social duty as opposed to private greed fits in with what could be called the Abrahamic tradition in many ways. There was a quite interesting Jewish mystic called Yehuda Ashlag who predicted the fall of the Soviet Union, which he admired in very many ways because of it's atheism. He also predicted the collapse of "Labour Zionism" in Palestine for the same reason- but actually "Labour Zionism" in Palestine collapsed because of intra-Jewish racism as well as racism against the indigenous Palestinians who survived the Nabkha and were granted a sort of citizenship.
    Talking about "Labour Zionism" what annoys me about a lot of Socialists is that they believe that if solve the economy than everything else will naturally get sorted which is very, very untrue. 
     
    American Christianity in general seems extremely un-Christian to those who fall victim to Capitalism. 
  22. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight got a reaction from Northwest in does/can islamic socialism work   
    I don't think that they are a Third Positionist group, Third Positionists tend to greatly admire the Islamic Republic of Iran. MKO are extremely strange, and I think in many ways their own thing, from what I have been able to gather about them they are like Trotskyites in regard to their psychotic cult of personality. Since Saddam went they are massively now supported by the Neo-Con wing of the US ruling elite. Resentment against Imam Khomieni and their cults of personality seem to be their key defining features. 
  23. Sad
    Celtic Twilight reacted to notme in does/can islamic socialism work   
    On a local scale, socialist economy (ignoring the secularism) works within the framework of Islam. I converted to Islam long before I ever read about socialism, but I find much to admire in socialist ideology. I haven't read about Islamic socialism, but some day I'll get around to it. 
    Islam doesn't support or forbid any economic system, but it does obligate the community to care for the poor and infirm. in the United States that would be considered socialist or communist (though it's not).
  24. Thanks
    Celtic Twilight reacted to AmirioTheMuzzy in Imam Hassan's Number of Divorces   
    At the end of the day though, Sunnis actually believe that Musa (عليه السلام) punched the angel of death.

    https://muslimmatters.org/2016/08/12/the-curious-story-of-moses-and-the-angel-did-the-messenger-musa-peace-be-upon-him-really-punch-an-angel/
    https://www.reddit.com/r/MuslimsRespond/comments/c0zmoe/the_moses_slaps_angel_of_death_on_the_eye_hadith/
  25. Like
    Celtic Twilight reacted to Ashvazdanghe in Why 2 Messianic Figures?   
    Hi it's an idea that created by wise people to separate Abrahamic religions from each other that they use an army of crazy men to promote their plan however their crazy army are not just crazy Christians but also wahabists are following their footsteps under control of these wise men  that they inserted Dajjal as Islamic Antichrist to Sunni belief that also affected shia sources but real personality is cursed Sufyani that is a person from descendants of Abu Sufyan from Ummayid branch that will rise as a bloodthirsty Islamic leader but in reality he will have support of these crazy people & in shia prophecies said that he will have religion these crazy christians (Evangelism & etc) but shows him as a Muslim that plan of creating ISIS /Daesh was preparig everything for his rising & one of major reasons of attacking KSA to Yemen is stopping process of reappearance of  Imam Mahdi (aj) & protection of rising of cursed Sufyani in future that even MBS declared that he is enemy of Imam Mahdi (aj) & his viewpoint it's an Iranian thing & in other hand they are distracting minds of anti wahabi Sunnis that believe to Imam Mahdi (aj)  with Dajjal & prophecies that they must start a war between India & Pakistan to force coming of prophet Isa (عليه السلام) &  Imam Mahdi (aj)
     
     
×
×
  • Create New...