Hadi5

I mean Shia Twelver.yes we have Fatmids in Egypt.But we couldn't maintain it for long enough.

We know from history that shias never got chance or if got couldn't run government for pretty long time.Why Shias couldn't maintain and run their government for long time. Was it because Shias didn't give due importance and seriousness needed for it. Or for them running a government according to their view's isnot important .

That were we all failed. Unfortunately our love for World and wealth prevented us from what was our duty .Still it is good initiative if we will convince this and understand it's importance.

Definitely those who pay it ,might be giving it to desrved needy Syed. And Sahme Imam to mujtahid.And mujtahid will use it were it is needed. Do all of us pay khumus sincerely.Since we claim to be Imams and Allah.

Brother don't give quick judgements.How come if someone achieved piety is misguided.That too when one believes in Allah and Prophet saw and day of judgement. If he loves Ahlebayt as also. Allahs judgement and justice is more perfect.How come one achieving piety can be misguided. You are Just contradicting basic of Islam.

That is true. Brother all Prophet's , Holy books and Imams ultimate and only aim was to make people "Muttaqi". Muttaqi means able to avoid sins and transgression. Now how much and how early one acquires it ,is the basis on which hereafter lies. One born in religious and scholar family is expected to achieve early. Muslims are expected to achieve earlier than non Muslims. Shias are expected to achieve earlier than Sunni. It's were we have to introspect. Why Taqwa is is important.Because realisation of Tawheed depends on level of Taqwa.

Mr.Allah clearly said in Quran that those who struggle in me I will show them path. How much you and me or any Sunni has struggle in Allah. This the standard. I am a shia.I must recite,Quran delibrate over it and implement it. Saying of Holy Prophet saw and Ahlebayt as. Minimum thing that one is expected to do leave all sins .So sins are almost common in Shia and Sunni. It depends how much one struggled to achieve. Now Imam as Said whosoever didn't check daily his actions he is not ours. That means a Shia should fix a time and check his all actions of that day.If he has done sin

Brother it's not libral talk but fact. I have heared a great scholar from Qum talking it.Even he went it's not shia, suni, Christian etc label that matters.But it's only the level one acknowledged and realised Tawheed of Allah. So it's possible someone after reading quran just realize a little amount of Tawheed or achieve little proximity to Allah. Other person does contemplate on quran and achieve higher level. NowQuran, actions of Ahlebayt as and supplications of Imam all are inviting people to Tawheed and Love of Allah. It's now our duty how much we achieved from it. So

When Imam Hassan as handed over khalfa to Muawyiya. Ist condition he kept for Muawyiya was to run government according to Quran and Traditions of Holy Prophet saw. That gives what was importance of Islam government to IMAM Hassan. During Yazeed again the country was in peace but Imam didn't accepted unislamic practices of Yazeed. My nation is peaceful , but acohol is allowed, adultery is allowed, gay is allowed, gambling Hijab is banned so on. And I am happy with it But I have problem of Islamic government in muslim country. I have problem with Quranic laws to be impl

Brother what I have understood is Islam has different levels understanding. And there is place for ignorance .Be him Shia or sunni. Allah doesn't need labels weather we one Sunni or Shia by our definition. Ultimately it's struggle in the path of Allah it needs surrenderring and leaving everything to achieve the love of Allah.And this the teaching of Ahlebayt.Did we have achieved it or not. Whosoever achieved it is successful. I may again say it's not label of being Shia or sunni .

Thousands of Prophets came to establish law of Allah.And hundreds of Prophets got martyred. So do you mean because of threat to life and death we should not implement Quranic laws. Quran says those of who claim to be Muslims will be checked by fear of death, hungry and loss of wealth.

If there is threat to life then definitely one has to do Taqqia. But where I live, we do not much trouble in praying as we do in presence of Sunnis. And we some time pray in Sunni mosques.And Sunni too pray in Shia mosque. But yes it's not much prevelent. May be it's because that hatred ones used to be out of ignorance has decreased.

Now a lot Shia scholars don't believe Sunnis are kafir. Again who is kafir and momin only Allah knows.Its what scholars say today. That reality' is dependent on ones heart not on verbal decleration. Today nither khamnai nor sistani belives Sunnis to be kafir. Yes, if any one hates Imam Ali as that problematic and he is Nawasib.

Definition of Nawasib is hating Ali as. And not doing error in who is superior. I have seen Sunni scholars who definitely rank Ali higher than other khalifs. Now if any Sunni out of ignorance rank Abubaker more than Ali as should not taken otherwise.And he can't be considered Nawasib.

That has been already said.No one can say anyone kafir aslong one declears Tawheed of Allah ,Prophethood of Mohammed saww and Day of judgement. Now who really belives it Allah knows best'. It's this reality that will be checked. Suppose I have to love Allah most and fear Allah only. Do in reality I love Allah most and fear Allah only will be decided by Allah. Now Prophet saw and Imams teachings is to achieve this state were one loves Allah only and fears Allah only. Out come this love and fear is that one leaves sins and do zikr of Allah most time of day.