-
Posts
20,950 -
Joined
-
Days Won
240
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Blogs
Everything posted by Ashvazdanghe
-
can any of the shia brothers or sisters explain?
Ashvazdanghe replied to qasim2448's topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
Salam this weak narration has been discussed & refuted countless times which Ironically has been recycled again in recent days by other users . -
Salam all Zaydis don't believe to this which for example Houthis of Yemen who are Jarudiyah branch of Zaydism have similar opinion likewise Twelver Imamiyya which Imamiyya is general lable for all branches of Shias even 4 sunni school of thoughts are following one of 4 Sunni Imams so therefore they can be labeled as Imamiyya too although currently Imamiyya is equivalent to Shia but in later centuries it has been used for historical Alawis who believed to legitimacy of 4 sunni caliphs have been labeled as Imamiyya which has been mentioned by you but on the other hand current Imamiyya is Twelver Shiism which has been called as Rafidism in later centuries who only belive to legitimacy of Amir Almuminin Imam Ali (عليه السلام) & reject legitimacy of all 3 Sunni caliphs before & after him .
-
Hudud upon on insane person and suicide
Ashvazdanghe replied to PureExistence1's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam a legit insane maybe harms him/herself without intention of killing him/herself but on the other hand committing suicide is intentional killing of yourself by having sane mind ; so therefore the legit insane never commits suicide even he/her hurts him/herself seriously because He/She has no intention of killing of him/herself due to his/her insanity . Mental break down of a sane person for any reason or nay situation is not equivalent to insanity which even in case of suicided after mental break down due to any sever condition is forbidden by Islam which Islam has many solutions for facing with mental break down so therefore suicide for sane person due to mental break down is forbidden in all conditions which using survival rules likewise eating meat of pig for survival doesn't justify it which you have used forbidden Qiyas for justifying Suicide . It doesn't justify suicide which Allah won't forgive anyone who has committed suicide because such person has disappointed from Mercy of Allah which he has satanic mindset that Allah can't solve his/her problem so therefore he/She has committed Shirk by committing suicided . They have loosen their faith when they have committed suicide so therefore they will be judged as unbelievers & people who have committed Shirk . -
Salam your are comparing apples with oranges which you have misinterpreted any Fatwa about special condition & turning your innovation into a general Fatwa which This is about disobeying in general matters likewise house chores which has no relation to not doing intimacy which as usual you have misinterpreted anything based on your delusional innovation .
-
Salam this is another innovation by you which has no basis except your total ignorance from islamic rulings which you want to promot your innovations in name of Islam due to having problem in your family which Woman even can't ask for divorce if her husband doesn't pay her Nafaqah in similar fashion She can't refrain from intimacy although your innovation . Can a woman who hasn’t received her Nafaqah consider herself as divorced? If so, when does her waiting period of iddah commence? Can a woman who hasn’t received her Nafaqah for the past five months consider herself divorced? For example, because of having another family, if a father deserts his first family and doesn’t provide their sustenance and doesn’t care about them anymore, can the mother of such family consider herself divorced and if so, from when does her waiting period of iddah commence? From the day the father has deserted the family, or three months after the day the father has done so? In any case, if the husband doesn’t pay her the Nafaqah without any legally acceptable excuse, the Islamic authority can divorce her from her husband and she will have to observe the waiting period after the divorce has been executed. Fortunately, given the means of communication in today’s world, Muslim women can engage in solving their problems of this genre. https://www.islamquest.net/en/archive/fa635 It is in the interests of both women and men that nafaqah be the charge of men and women be the dependants of men. Because men are attracted to and fond of women, they desire to spend for them, and not only are they without resent, they are completely satisfied and feel good about themselves when they behave in this way. The financial dependence of women is not a drawback and it does not make them stipendiary servants; rather, it strengthens the backbone of marriage. Basically, in familial life, a man’s earnings belong to the family, they are utilized for acquiring necessities; therefore, financial independence or the lack thereof is not an issue. Here, it must be pointed out that the aim of Islam in making men responsible for nafaqah is not to thwart employment of women, make them consumers and ‘stay-at-homers’, and obstruct them from having jobs and responsibilities outside their homes. Instead, Islam intends that women not be forced to work and provide living expenses; however, with regard to her abilities, preferences, and facilities, and the mutual agreement of spouses, a wife can choose an acceptable job and perform her responsibilities outside her home, and thus have an independent income. Naturally, her income belongs to herself and she need not use it for family expenditures. A virtuous woman would, however, with purity of heart, like her husband, prefer to donate it to the family so that it would have a part in managing and improving familial life and increase serenity and love within the entire family. https://www.al-islam.org/introduction-rights-and-duties-women-islam-ibrahim-amini/nafaqah-financial-support-and-its This is another example your total misunderstanding from Islamic rulings which you misinterpret anything in favor of your own innovation by making a ruling for special condition into a general Fatwa for all times & all conditions based on your innovation
-
Salam there is no problem with cursing is his public name which his name doesn't protect him from wrath of Allah/Yeheweh/God because we curse his evil persona & his evil procedure which is in similar fashion of specific curse Yazid & cursed Muawiyah which cursing them by these names doesn't mean cursing other people even if a Shia has name of Yazid or even Muawiyah so then cursing doesn't apply to him which in shia history you can find some shias with name of Yazid or even Muawiyah who has been devout followers of Ahlulbayt (عليه السلام) which cursing cursed Umayyad's curse Yazid & cursed Muawiyah doesn't affect Shias with similar names to them .
-
No longer feeling regret fot some sins, what do I do
Ashvazdanghe replied to Botak's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam https://www.shiachat.com/forum/search/?&q=allah doesn't hold grudge&page=2&quick=1&search_and_or=or&sortby=relevancy -
Salam you can find your answers here thanks to @Borntowitnesstruth https://www.sistani.org/english/book/48/8232/ https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01236/#:~:text=Answer%3A If a person takes,food stuffs (wheat or bread thanks to
-
Salam related thread https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235086654-kurds-djinns/
-
Salam related thread https://www.shiachat.com/forum/topic/235086654-kurds-djinns/
-
Salam it has been refuted in following threads which it's a too weak narration also it's a false interpretation of the too weak hadith by anti shia people .
-
An objection to "Divine Simplicity":
Ashvazdanghe replied to Ibn Murtuz's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam related thread -
Why can't the sunni also believe in the 'divine simplicity'?
Ashvazdanghe replied to a topic in Shia/Sunni Dialogue
Salam related threads -
Salam , Lol this is just an imaginary story about "Rukhsati" which has no basis which this story just innovated by you to justify your innovation living without intimacy which your innovation has been refuted countless times but you have returned with a false story & accusation against imam Ali (عليه السلام) just for proving your innovation .
-
Are all duas answered? (Serious Question)
Ashvazdanghe replied to a topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam , yeah holds weight because we don't all consequences of requests in our Duas which maybe we desire something that looks good for us in our short sides understanding but Allah knows that it will leads to horrible consequences for us in case of fulfilling in our world but because we have had good intention for doing good deeds so therefore he will reward it in resurrection day free from it's horrible consequences ; in extent which you will regret that some of your prayers have been answered in this world which you will wish all of your prayers would be preserved until day f resurrection . https://tanzil.net/#trans/en.qarai/2:216 -
Why is Mahr/Dowry necessary For Mutah?
Ashvazdanghe replied to EiE's topic in Social/Family/Personal
Salam accusation just based on anti Shia propaganda which you are parroting any anti Shia rhetoric from anti Shia people which this is clearly a Wahabi accusation which doesn't see Mutah as a valid Islamic marriage but on the other hand anti Shia people likewise you verify innovation of Wahabis of marriage with intention of triple divorce at one session or Jihad of nikah by Daesh a good thing for making an excuse for making Muslim women into prostitutes based your anti Shia procedure. . -
Salam both of these aaccusations are just baseless accusation which have been spread by zionists against Shia Marjas ; which Imam Khomeini (رضي الله عنه) certainaly never made a deal with Israelis which the Iran–Contra affair has been a great mistake of Mr. Rafsanjani which some Isrealis have made contact with him as American authorities when america has tried to make a deal with Iran which when real zionist identity of them has been exposed so then Imam Khomeini (رضي الله عنه) has stopped it immediately . In similar fashion Shia leadership in Iraq has just taking a “wait-and-see” approach against cursed Saddam when his masters tried to remove him ; which non of Shia leaders have cooperated with America even some of them have supported Moqtda Sadr as leader of Mahdi's Army about violent resistance against Americans but in Shia leadership has been accused to cooperation with American by anti Shia propaganda which has been spread by radical Baa'this & Wahabis & Zionists by support of America .
-
Sayyed Abdul Malik Al-Houthi ,the Yamani?
Ashvazdanghe replied to mina's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam ,yeah . -
Breastfeeding to become mother of child?
Ashvazdanghe replied to a topic in General Islamic Discussion
Salam Mujtahidin and Shia taqlid authorities have presented 7 conditions and some 9 conditions, if they are met, the relationship of becoming Mahram and kinship between the mother who donates milk and the child who receives it is formed. In the meantime, several principles are common in the treatises of all these elders: 1) Feeding should be done directly under the mother's breast. 2) At least 15 times or 24 hours continuously. 3) Milk should be given to the baby without any utensils (spoon, cup, etc.). 1)In the mother's milk bank, the milk used to feed the baby is obtained by mixing the milk of 2 or 3 mothers. This work is customary all over the world; Since the protein level of different milks is different, in order to bring the final milk to a desirable and moderate level of protein richness, the milk of several mothers is mixed together and after pasteurization, it is given to babies. This incident, in our country, in addition to solving the scientific and qualitative aspect of the problem, has also helped to solve our religious concern in this field. 2) The pasteurized milk of the mother's milk bank is given to the baby through a device. In the neonatal unit and NICU, milk is generally given to the baby through the mouth and nose through an "oral-gastric" tube, and therefore breastfeeding is not direct. "Riza'" literally means breastfeeding. According to Shia jurisprudence and the opinion of all the scholars, breastfeeding causes "Mahram" if it has the following conditions: 1- The child should eat the milk of a alive woman 2- The baby sucks the milk from the breast (so if the milk is poured down the baby's throat or fed with a glass or other device, it will not cause breastfeeding and becoming Mahram. 3- The child should not vomit milk due to illness. 4-He should eat enough milk fifteen times or one day and night, so that it is said that meat has grown in his body from that milk. 5- The child has not reached the age of two years. 6- The child should not eat another food or another woman's milk within a day and night Since in the milk bank, the donated milk is not from the same person and feeding is not done directly from the breast, therefore there are no issues related to becoming Mahram and [having] foster brothers and sisters, and you can easily donate your milk and the recipients They can also feed donated pasteurized milk to their babies. According to the poll conducted by the Office of the Supreme Authority, it is safe to consume the milk provided by Shir Madaran (mother's milk) Bank. https://farsnews.ir/news/13980509001194/گفتوگو-با-مدیر-اولین-بانک-شیر-مادر-در-ایران https://crta.iums.ac.ir/بانک-شیر-مادران In order to solve this concern once and for all, we sent a letter to the Supreme Leader's office and appealed to him in this regard. The text of the letter was as follows: Today, many babies are born prematurely or with diseases that, despite the need to feed with mother's milk, do not have the possibility of having their own mother's milk. All over the world, to meet the needs of these children, centers called Mother's Milk Bank have been set up, which receive milk from donor mothers and prepare it for feeding these babies. The milk obtained from this milk bank is given to babies through a device. What is the ruling of His Highness in terms of confidentiality between donors and recipients of this milk? The letter was submitted to the Supreme Leader's office through Dr. Seyed Alireza Marandi, the head of the Iranian Neonatal Doctors Association, and he said in response to this appeal: "If the milk is not transferred directly from the breast to the baby's mouth, becoming Mahram does not take place." We have framed the text of this appeal and installed it in the location of Shir Madar Bank so that it can be seen by all families and is a source of reassurance for them. It is good to know that some time ago, when I was invited as a representative of the "Emro" region (Middle East) to the meeting related to the Mother's Milk Bank at the World Health Organization, the attendees asked about religious issues related to the issue of the milk bank in Iran, and I asked about the advanced rulings of Shia jurisprudence. I explained to them in this regard. It was very interesting for them that Shia jurisprudence is so up-to-date and they said that they will reflect this issue to other countries, including Islamic countries. Of course, it is necessary to add that the rulings of the beloved ones of the Sunnis in the field of riza' are different. https://farsnews.ir/news/13980509001194/گفتوگو-با-مدیر-اولین-بانک-شیر-مادر-در-ایران https://gahvare.net/articles/CmQMv/اصطلاحات-و-مفاهیم-بانک-شیر-مادر https://www.isna.ir/news/1402051106703/فعالیت-۱۱-بانک-شیر-مادر-در-ایران-نحوه-اهدای-شیر-مادران https://madarsho.com/article/mom-milk-banks -
Did Imam Ali gave his daughter in marriage to Umar
Ashvazdanghe replied to Solo_Ta72's topic in General Islamic Discussion
Did Umar Marry Imam Ali's Daughter? 1/3 - Enquiries About Shi'a Islam 40/47 https://www.al-islam.org/media/did-umar-marry-imam-alis-daughter-13-enquiries-about-shia-islam-4047 Did Umar Marry Imam Ali's Daughter? 2/3 - Enquiries About Shi'a Islam 41/47 https://www.al-islam.org/media/did-umar-marry-imam-alis-daughter-23-enquiries-about-shia-islam-4147 Did Umar Marry Imam Ali's Daughter? 3/3 - Enquiries About Shi'a Islam 42/47 https://www.al-islam.org/media/did-umar-marry-imam-alis-daughter-33-enquiries-about-shia-islam-4247 -
Salam everything is pure if you don't seen Najasah with naked eye also there is no trace of it likewise smell or color of it so therefore everything is pure which you must get rid off Whisper of Shaitan as Waswasah or OCD .
-
The matter about preserving morals although you can do it based on rulings about this matter .