Ya Allah Madad

Brother, thats why its word of Allah swt. As a general rule important events/concepts are atleast mentioned twice in Quran. So that in case at one place if we understand incorrectly then the other place should correct and explain us. And thats why Quran also dont need any tafsir to explain its basic rules and concepts except only in some rare cases.

Firstly, this is not like your copy paste stuff. I have just shared the relevant part not the entire sermons. My own comments are also included with many questions. But again you are able to answer any one properly. Secondly, its not hypocrisy. I clearly said in one of my previous post that many sermons are authentic and many are not. Here I am just showing the reality of the book you claim to follow and love to read. If you consider the overall contents of this book then most part of it do not support twelver shiism in general, in fact refute it badly. My post is just a teaser of it.

This is all you have to say in response to my post where I showed the side of nahjul balagha which badly refutes false shia beliefs. Its not only about proofs of ghadir from nahjul balagha but about how Imam Ali a.s understood from this event. Its very shocking to know that there is no any sermon on ghadir in the entire book of 200+ sermons. And this shows that how much there is difference between beliefs of shias and beliefs of Imam Ali a.s.

There is a big difference between saying he should have became the caliph or he had the more right to caliphate and saying he was divinely appointed by Prophet saww himself in front of all at ghadir. To believe one you have to reject the other. What you believe now after reading my long post? And what Imam Ali a.s had believed for himself?

Exactly ego issues. They all believe truth is only with us. Thats why they dont even listen/read to others stuff properly. And whenever they listen/read they listen only in order to refute them. This is not at all a waseela. But I dont understand how people can fall in this tactic of iblees. While there are hundreds of clear verses on this issue of not invoke others than Allah in the form of dua. Word wasela has been used only twice in Quran. But sadly people doing this are giving only importance to 5:35 and are totaly ignoring the other place 17:57. Those whom they invoke seek

So it means Ahlulbayt also used to recieve revelations from Allah swt on their own apart from the inherited knowledge from Prophet saww. Because the inherited knowledge is not only limited to ahlebayt. The job of the prophet is to deliver the message to everyone. Hadith books of ahlul sunnah are full of such knowledge which is directly narrated from prophet saww. Read book Dalail Nabuwah of Imam Bayhaqi which contains thousands of prophecies from prophet saww as narrated by thousands of different companions. Source of the knowledge which was revealed to prophet saww is not only limited to

Same to you brother. It was you who started this blame game, and I just answered your copy paste via a simple link. The sunni scholars have also insulted the imams from the progeny of the prophet saww. Anything on above question except copy paste. Before pointing out on others first have a look at your own actions.

Assalam o Alaikum brother, I saw your following post in another thread where you have emphasized on using our own mind. So brother why not you are doing the same in this matter. Just look at the following verses (forget about what tafsir say) and use your brain. And tell em are'nt both are similar. Infact 48:2 is more clear in meaning than 33:33. Therefore if 33:33 proves infallibility then why not 48:2. Either both or none of them. Moreover 33:33 is just a part of verse unlike 48:2 and is continuation of verses from 29-34.

Well said. Epic line. Content is important not the title or who is saying this. Same is the problem with many sunnis like brelvi sufis who also do not accept the truth about tawassul and istighasah since its coming from salafis. This reminds me of following verse. Rum 31-32 [Adhere to it], turning in repentance to Him, and fear Him and establish prayer and do not be of those who associate others with Allah [Or] of those who have divided their religion and become sects, every faction rejoicing in what it has.

Such defense is because many ghullat beliefs are now part of fundamental belifs of shias. Like asking Imams for help, infallibility, divine messages, additon in adhan etc. Shia Allama Mamqani wrote in Tanqihul Maqal (Volume 1, Page 334): قال المامقاني في تنقيح المقال ج1 ص334 : قد نبهنا غير مرة على أن رمي القدماء سيما القميين منهم ، الرجل بالغلو لا يعتنى به ، لإن الاعتقاد بجملة مما هو الآن من ضروريات المذهب ، كان معدوداً عندهم من الغلو ، ألا ترى عدهم نفي السهو عن النبي صلى الله عليه وآله والأئمة عليهم السلام غلواً ، مع أن من لم ينفي السهو عنهم اليوم لا يعد مؤمناً ، ولقد أجاد الفاضل ال

Brother those who are writing letters to Imam are praying and asking him directly, not to Allah. Then he will pray to Allah directly for you. You pray to him then he will pray to Allah for you. This also shows they believe Imam in living under that well thats why they are putting letters to it, hpoing that they will reach to our Imam. Read only books from Al-islam.org. Brother is it not like saying follow al-islam.org blindly and dont read books from other websites. WHY? Is everything that al-islam.org says is true and correct? And whatever others say are wrong?

Its very easy to verify such things, you just need to do a little research without being biased. 1. Its persian Isfahan since the same hadith gives a hint i.e they will be weraing persian shawls. And we know that Isfahan in famous in wolrd for its artwork like shawls, rugs, wall art etc. Isfahan golden era started during the shia safavid danysty. More on Isfahan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isfahan 2. This is how jews feel at city of Isfahan http://edition.cnn.com/2015/03/11/middleeast/iran-jews-esfahan/index.html 3. Hadith is from sahih muslim, so it should be authentic.

Imam Ali Reza a.s have big objection. Source: Bihar-ul-Anwar vol-25/343. http://dlia.ir/kotob/arabic/531/beharo_al_anvar_025/index.html Prayer of Imam Ali reza a.s Bismillah ir-Rahman ir-Rahim. O Allah, verily, i disassociate myself before you from the strength and power. There is no strength and power except with you. O Allah, verily, i seek refuge in you and disaasociate myself before you from those who claim for us what is not true for us. O Allah, verily i disassociate myself before you from those who say regarding us what we have not said about ourselves. O Allah, to you

You are right brother. Such things have ruined the shia image all over the world. Whether someone like it or not and whether someone practise it or not, this is how the world sees shias in general. And if you search shia muslims on google you will find this https://www.google.com/search?q=shia+muslim&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwic45XBxODUAhUDT48KHdlaAXAQ_AUIBigB&biw=1366&bih=632#tbm=isch&q=shia+muslims Many shia scholars are also responsible for this. They are the backbone of such people who practise and defend such beliefs

This is called online waseela. No need to personally go to shrine and to spent hundreds of dollars just call and talk to Imam on hotline for you needs. Such practises are disgust for shias. But unfortunately many tv channels are involved in this and are providing this service to people all over the world. Brother following video is of Karbala satelite channel, who is also doing the same. In fact much better than what you shared. Watch this, how dangerous this waseela concept has become.