Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

John_313

Advanced Members
  • Content Count

    266
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by John_313

  1. @Mohammed72 Did Ibn Abbas (ra) commit shirk for recommending someone to say Ya Muhammad (sawa)?
  2. Ya Allah, when will these people try to use rationality. Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) answers the same argument you used in this video: Brother, what I don't understand from you is how can you not believe in Sahih Ahadeeth?
  3. @Yahya313 What's your religious education? I sincerely cannot believe what you just wrote, has come from a Shi'a. If you love good, then you should hate evil. If you praise good, then you should insult evil. It's not possible for someone to agree upon two contradictions. You have to enjoy good and forbid evil. What's your point for claiming that the Ahadeeth isn't Sahih? No, Sheikh Yasser Al Habib didn't teach it to me. What's missing in the chain, or how does it contradict the Holy Qur'an? The prophet (sawa) was sent to spread mercy and destroy tyranny, praise mercy and demonize tyranny. Haven't you read the Noble Qur'an? So then, why do you call me for demonizing the enemies (tyrants) of Ahlulbayt (as)? Surely those who disbelieve and die while they are disbelievers, these it is on whom is the curse of Allah and the angels and men all; (2:161) (As for) these, their reward is that upon them is the curse of Allah and the angels and of men, all together. (3:87) Surely those who conceal the clear proofs and the guidance that We revealed after We made it clear in the Book for men, these it is whom Allah shall curse, and those who curse shall curse them (too). (2:159) But whoever disputes with you in this matter after what has come to you of knowledge, then say: Come let us call our sons and your sons and our women and your women and our near people and your near people, then let us be earnest in prayer, and pray for the curse of Allah on the liars. (3:61)
  4. Brother, he's concerned because his Abu Bakar committed shirk lol. Run @Mohammed72 run, because you're running out of replies. I have a question, why do followers of people who doubted Islam (such as Omar) keep repeating the same Stone Age arguments which have been answered so many times? @Mansur Bakhtiari what do you think of this guy, using the Ya Ali argument lol.
  5. @Mohammed72 Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha) has asked the followers of Abu Bakar and other idol worshippers to have debate series. He (ha) has challenged your scholars again and again, however, they keep hiding. I have a question, are you willing to debate Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha) and defend your religion?
  6. @Mohammed72 Listen to this Hadeeth narrated in your sources portraying Abu Bakr as a Mushrik.
  7. Firstly, I'm not a Shirazi follower, Shirazi (ha) also believes in WF applied in Shura. Shirazis are not against what you said, again this shows your ignorance. Because there is no proof for Absolute Wilayatul Faqih, and Ayatollah Sayed Ali Sistani (ha) doesn't believe in Absolute Wilayatul Faqih either, are you going to respond the same way to Ayatollah Sayed Ali Sistani (ha) as well? Grand Ayatollah Khorasani (ha)? Ayatollah Sayed Khoei (ra)? And other scholars from Najaf? I advise you watch this video: Your complaining is not counted as a religious argument, our Imams (as) have forbidden uprising during the occultation of Imam Mahdi. Whether you will follow them is up to you, I have shown you Sahih Ahadeeth on PM. What other understanding does this Sahih Ahadeeth have? Please inform me, I'm interested on you knowledge. (READ CAREFULLY) our religion in not a revolutionary one, during oppression, we need to perform taqqiyah and wait for the awaited one. Your analogy is illogical and you have kept and still keep arguing through using assumptions. And finally, STOP CHANGING THE TOPIC!
  8. For most "Muslims", Abu Bakr was the first Khalif after the prophet (sawa). According to your logical fallacy, they're on Haqq. You say that nobody cares when you cannot deny the truth lol. CHALLENGE, if most of you believe that Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha) and Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) are exposed, "...bring you proof, if you are truthful... (Al Baqarah, 2:111)". You cannot base your beliefs on speculations, that's not what our prophet (sawa) and Imams (as) have teached.
  9. @Mohammed72 Your "arguments" are very weak and Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) and Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha) have answered you points so many times loool, and I was going to respond until I saw @Qa'im had refuted you. I'm an ex-follower of Omar and have become a Muslim (when I converted to Shi'a Islam), however even your Sahih Ahadeeth say that the Omar ibnul Khattab was not a Muslim: Allah says in the Holy Qur'an: "The believers are only those who believe in Allah and His Messenger then they doubt not..." (Al Hujarat 49:15) However in Al Tabaqat Al Kubra by Ibn Saad, it's narrated that Omar said: "I have never doubted (in Islam) as much as I did in the battle of Hudaibiyah." How can you still follow a person who has these incidents? If he doubted in the battle of Hudaibiyah, what confidence can you have to say that he didn't doubt after the prophet (sawa) died, or when he (Omar) became the second Tyrant? Why not follow the Ahlulbayt (as) who are purified (thus cannot doubt) by Allah in Surah 33:33? You are confident on following Omar who was fallible and sinned, but not Ahlulbayt (as) when they're infallible. Furthermore the prophet had insulted Aisha in your Sahih Ahadeeth, refer to Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith: 4.336 Narrated Abdullah: The Prophet stood up and delivered a sermon, and pointed to the house of Aisha, and said: “Fitna (trouble/sedition) is right here,” saying three times, “from where the side of the Satan’s head comes out.” As well as when according to your Sahih Ahadeeth he smiled and laughed when someone insulted Abu Bakr as narrated in Nathr Al Durr by Al Aabi, vol 1, pg 150. Therefore insulting Abu Bakr makes the prophet (sawa) happy lol. Here you have your Tyrants exposed. What caught my attention was when you @Mohammed72 said we (Shi'a) commit shirk (I seek refuge in Allah) when say Ya Ali Madad, watch this video:
  10. Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha) has answered this in his (ha) post on August 15, at 8:12 AM. Reference: his (ha) official Facebook page.
  11. May Allah lengthen the life of Sheikh Hassan Allahyari, and increase his knowledge, and increase his arguments, and strengthen his confidence!
  12. Why unfortunately, why would someone condemn Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) for no reason? What are the problematic things he says? Obeying the Prophet (sawa) in a accordance to his (sawa) narration in Al Kafi, is problematic? Seriously, (to all those who want to have a discussion) please be more specific on the points you're trying to make. If it's only because he used a mursal hadeeth in a statement, then it's very laughable you try to generalize a whole topic (and you're still not sticking on the topic I opened). Using a mursal hadeeth is not a good reason to lower the status of such personality, that we all know is fallible, but that's all you're coming up with throughout the whole discussion. For now the topic is whether they're Western agents or not.
  13. Ok, message me on PM tomorrow. Firstly, stop repeating things others have stated earlier. Secondly, I know the story and have seen the videos long ago. How come your speculation is so advanced that you think I'm that ignorant? How dare you accuse me of committing shirk? You are disobedient to our Imams (as) because they have forbidden Absolute Wilayatul Faqih, while you praise a personality who propagates such idea (and I'm ready to debate you on this topic as well, tomorrow on PM in sha Allah).
  14. I didn't follow Ayatollah Sayed Ali Sistani (ha), I had his picture on respect to him. When I firstly chose Shirazi (ha), I chose him because I was convinced he was the most knowledgeable scholar. For very good reasons. However that's still not part of the topic.
  15. Brother (in humanity), are you aware of how many volumes does Ayatollah Sayed Muhammad Shirazi's (ra) Al-Fiqh contain?
  16. They (Redha Shirazi (ra) and Sadiq Shirazi (ha)) studied with other scholars as well lol, how didn't you research that? Especially Ayatollah Sayed Sadiq Shirazi (ha), you can even find the list of (non-Shirazi) scholars he (ha) studied with in his (ha) official website. You seem very confused, it's ironic because the same scholar of the century disagreed with Absolute Wilayatul Faqih, therefore it's not true, is it? Why are there people still following Khamenei for that matter?
  17. Our Imams (as) have said that any act of thankfulness on the death of such individuals is acceptable. Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) cites evidence in his website, check out this link: http://alqatrah.net/en/an244 Again, you're changing the topic. Please try to improve your focusing and stick on one topic. Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha), has obeyed the holy prophet (sawa) because he (sawa) said: The Messenger of Allah (sawa) said: “When you find bid’ah (innovation) and doubt/suspicion after me, do baraa’ (disassociation) from them and increase in your insults (sabihim) to them, and oppose (them) and bring evidences against them so they may not become greedy in bringing fasad (corruption) to Islam. You must warn people against them and do not learn their bid’ah (innovation). Allah will write for you hasanaat (good deeds) for this, and will raise your darajaat (levels) in the next life” Al-Kafi, Volume 2, Chapter 159, hadeeth 4. What's there to doubt of his legitimacy, of being a scholar?
  18. I know Ayatollah Abu Qasim Khoei (ra) didn't agree with Ayatollah Muhammad Shirazi (ra) and said he was not a scholar, but so did Muhammad Shirazi (ra) complain about Khamenei the same way. Sorry I have changed my taqleed, so you don't get mixed up. Still, Sheikh Al Habib (ha) did not study under Sayed Muhammad Shirazi (ra) (whom Sistani followers can find an objection against), but under Mujtaba and Redha Shirazi (ra). Therefore he's qualified (so Sistani followers cannot have any objection). Please explain more on what's the point you're trying to make?
  19. It does when your channel is closed for more than 8 months, for financial reasons, this in regards to Sheikh Allahyari (ha). As per Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha), check out this link: http://alqatrah.net/en/ns109 Who are you tell people whom should they do taqleed to lol. Message me on PM and I will show you reasons why Grand Ayatollah Sayed Sadiq Shirazi (ha) is far more knowledgeable than Ayatollah Sayed Ali Sistani (ha) lol, since you called me to follow Sistani (ha). I think that the users should be more rational when responding rather than speculating and ridiculing. At the end, it effects you not me because you weren't answering any of my points. Thus Sheikh Al Habib (ha) and Sheikh Allahyari (ha) are not Western Agents because of the rational reasons I presented above. If they were Western Agents, why ask the audience for money when they can get it directly from the Western Governments that fund them (as you claim)?
  20. Just as I expected, you don't want to discuss because there is no response to my arguments. How? Through Western sponsored News Networks lol?
  21. For those who doubt Sheikh Yasser Al Habib's (ha) status as a scholar (Sheikh). Check out this post and have a read on Sheikh Yasser Al Habib's (ha) certificates from scholars (ha) higher than him. @repenter I'm still unconvinced. What year did Ayatollah Sayed Redha Shirazi (ra) move to Qom, and where did Sheikh Yasser Al Habib (ha) ever say that he studied with Ayatollah Sayed Redha Shirazi (ra) in Kuwait?
  22. Exposing deviation is rude (I seek refuge in Allah)... What's wrong with Sheikh Yasser Al Habib's (ha) and Sheikh Hassan Allahyari's (ha) moral perfection? The Messenger of Allah (sawa) said: “When you find bid’ah (innovation) and doubt/suspicion after me, do baraa’ (disassociation) from them and increase in your insults (sabihim) to them, and oppose (them) and bring evidences against them so they may not become greedy in bringing fasad (corruption) to Islam. You must warn people against them and do not learn their bid’ah (innovation). Allah will write for you hasanaat (good deeds) for this, and will raise your darajaat (levels) in the next life” Al-Kafi, Volume 2, Chapter 159, hadeeth 4.
  23. Al-Kafi vol 8, pg 310, Hadeeth number 483: Omar ibn Handhala says, al-Imam al-Sadiq ‘alaihissalam said, “There are five signs before the rise of the Hujja ‘alaihissalam, the heavenly call, Sufyani, the sinking of the earth, the murder of the pure soul and Yamani. I asked, may I be your ransom, If anyone from your House should make an uprise (khuruj: uprise or revolt to topple the government), should we make an uprise along with him? He said, No. If you are a Shi’a, then remember, it is prohibited until you hear the Saiha and that Yamani has appeared, to make an uprise. That is unless the MI6 and CIA had paid Omar ibn Handhala to narrate this hadeeth. Al-Kafi vol 8, pg 264 Hadeeth number: 382 Our master Syed al-Sajjideen ‘alaihissalam said, “By Allah, no one makes an uprise from us before the Rise of the Awaited One, salamullahi ‘alaih, except that he will be like a nestling (baby bird), who flew off his nest before its wings grew, and kids pick him and play with him. Ibid # 383: Says al-Imam al-Sadiq ‘alaihissalam, “O’ Sadir, stay at your home and be a rug of your house (as motionless and passive as a rug of your house). Don’t move and remain absolutely silent so long the earth and the sky are silent (sinking of the earth has not occurred and the heavenly call/saiha has not been heard). When you hear that Sufyani has risen, come to us, even if you have to walk. Al-Kafi vol 5, pg 22 Hadeeth Number 2: Says the Imam ‘alaihissalam, “Make pilgrimage to this House [the Ka’ba]. Does not each one of you like to be [safe] at his house, have his family prosper through his generosity, and wait for OUR RULE. If he should live to see Our Rule, he will be like the ones who were with the Rasool of Allah salla Allahu ‘alaihi wa Aalihi wassalam at the battle of Badr. If he should die, while waiting for Our Rule, he will be like the close companions of the Awaited One ‘alaihissalam who will be with him at his tent”… Al-ibid pg 23, Hadeeth number 3: Bashir al-Dahhan: I said to al-Imam as-Sadiq ‘alaihissalam, I saw you in my dream and I said to you in my dream, Fighting under the banner of someone other than the Infallible Imam, appointed by Allah, is haram like eating rotten dead animal, drinking blood, and pork. And you said in my dream, “It is indeed so”. Al-Imam al-Sadiq alaihissalam replied [in wakefulness], “It is indeed so, it is indeed so”. Praise be to Him, the most High, and may He curse (withdraw his mercy from) the ones who disobeyed our Imams (as) concerning this matter!
  24. It seems like we can't have a proper discussion [edit]. Ok, if the west is pro-Sheikh Habib (ha), why are they "exposing" him?
  25. Brother, are you aware of how many people have found the right path because of Sheikh Yasser Al Hanib (ha) and Sheikh Hassan Allahyari (ha)? I know many pious Shi'a who were full of doubt but have increased their faith because of our Sheikhs' preaching.
×
×
  • Create New...