Jump to content
In the Name of God بسم الله

Hasan50

Advanced Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    25

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Profile Information

  • Religion
    Islam

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Hasan50's Achievements

Newbie

Newbie (1/14)

8

Reputation

  1. Hasan50
    Here is the latest update from Shaykh Asrar: https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1814722468815940&id=1582270502061139
  2.    Wisdom007 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  3.    Wisdom007 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  4.    Wisdom007 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  5. Hasan50
    I am sure Shaykh Asrat has many references for his claim reafy for the debate. But here the Ibn Abbas radiyAllahu anhuma issue has been discussed:
  6. Hasan50
    So is Shaykh Asrar correct about Twelvers and the following: Aqil Ibn Abi Talib, Muhammad Ibn Hanafiya and Zaid Ibn Ali? there is a narration in nahjul balagha where Hazrat Ali radiyAllahu anhu condemns both Ibn Abbas and Aqil Ibn Abi Talib.
  7. Hasan50
    This is the problem you see. That so many Shia are whipped into a frenzy and made to cry over this. This story of the door and burning the house is usef to convert people to Shia. So it is a major claim. It is also a eason for Shia to curse Abu Bakr and Umar radiyAllahu anhuma. Therefore it is important it be scrutinised. As for the threat narration it is a khabar e wahid and can be rejected due to the mutawatir reports that Hazrat Ali radiyAllahu anhu hot on well with the Shaykhayn. Mutawatir is not dismissed due to a one report where the narrator got the wording wrong.
  8. Hasan50
    A quick reply to the poisoning point: kosher meat is permitted for Muslims and Jewish slaughter is halal. I don't know what Shia say about this. this poisoning theory reconfirms my whole understanding that Shia thought is built on conspiracy theoris and they use khabr e ahaf in sunni works to substantiate their conspiracy theories. if Hazrat Fatimas alyhasalams house was burnt and she was struck by a door and had a miscarriage why would she go three days later after the Prophet passed away to ask for fadak? the whole thing dont make sense. then you hace ridiculous claims in works like ihtijaj e Tabrasi. If you guys want I can show you those silly passages. the whole khutba of Fatima is a forgery.
  9.    Wisdom007 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  10. Hasan50
    How could you love Abdullah Ibn Abbas when he was very close to Amir Muawiya and would keep good ties with him? in Nahj ulBalagha Hazrat Ali condemns Abdullah Ibn Abbas and Aquil Ibn Abi Talib. In Kafi Muhammad Ibn Hanafiyya rejects the Imamat of Zayn alAbidin and declares hinself Iamm. Sh Asrar is correct and you guys do not know your own sources.
  11. Hasan50
    The guy on here in earler posts was saying to you stay out of this and he was threatening with malangs. That same person was calling Sh Asrar names due to the propaganda of Sayed Ali. Now all the drama is over we hope that the shaykhs deal with this alone with no laymen involved.
  12. Hasan50
    going back to the debate. The guy who was calling sh Asrar a fasiq and liar has now apologised for all the lies he spread. He is the individual who spread many false rumours. Sh Abu Zaynnab has ordered him to apologise. Have a look on FB: https://m.facebook.com/1582270502061139/photos/a.1583562981931891.1073741829.1582270502061139/1807914442830076/?type=3 This guy Sayed Ali from Slough has embarassed genuine shia
  13.    Zamestaneh reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  14. Hasan50
    The narration of Hazrat Umar radiyAllahu anhu is khabr e wahid and therefore dismissed. Both Shia and Sunnis agree factts are in agreement that aqeeda is built on mutawatir. Therefore any hadith which is khabr e ahad which contradicts mutawatir we reject it. it is mutawatir That Hazrat Ali and Umar radiyAllahu anhuma got on. So we rject the one narration which contradicts this. if alKafi is the most authentic how many hadith of its 16000 narrations are authentic?
  15. Hasan50
    as a non Shia I feel the religion is built on a conspiracy. This is why I feel conspiracy theorists gravitate to shiism like Abdullah Hashem and others. i dont by yasir habibs bogus narrative that the wife of the prophet poisoned him and he passed away. or that Hazrat Fatima had a miscarriage due to Umar being violent. These are all fairytales and conspiracy theories from forgeries like the famous forged khutba e fatima. if nahjul balagha is so authentic why does it have no chains of narration and it was written over three hundred years after Jaazrat Ali!
  16. Hasan50
    Yasir Habib and Allahyaari are a joke. Numerous Shia have exposed them.
  17. Hasan50
    Why are you threatening him with malaangs? What will they do? I am going to inbox the brother Sh Asrars contact details very soon.
  18. Hasan50
    I think responsible Shias need to contact Shaykh Asrar and reach out to him.
  19.    Hasan50 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  20.    Hasan50 reacted to a post in a topic: Challenge To Debate Sheikh Asrar Rashid Accepted.
  21. Hasan50
    I like the answers on evolution at the end here off his mind
  22. Hasan50
    No he does not. He mentions Hume and others who refuted the design argument and he says Paley's examples are outdated but his core argument id valid. He definitley is not reading off a script in any of the videos.
×
×
  • Create New...