Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

skaswani

Advanced Members
  • Content Count

    87
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About skaswani

  • Rank
    Level 1 Member
  • Birthday 07/07/1981

Profile Information

  • Location
    Karachi

Previous Fields

  • Gender
    Male

Recent Profile Visitors

732 profile views
  1. Salam, Indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who do not use reason. (Qur'an al-Anfal 8:22) I think its my right as well as duty to ask question and seek the answers with logic, isnt it? My Logical question is, If the most Important function of Imam is "to Guide as he is called her Hadi" then how much possible that 1400 years people were blessed that they could meet/see/ask their concerns/get Prophet & Imams glimpse and we are not! How much effective it is to seek Hadayat from a hidden Imam where we are not in contact and we cannot ask any question but have to refer our questions to Ayatullahs/Maraja/Mufti/Alims and how much we can assure that the ruling given by those learnt persons is equivalent to the Prophets & Imams & its from the infallible hadayat How much effective is it that new problems on which the Ayatullahs/Maraja/Mufti/Alims does Ijtihad and ensure that there will be Zero error and the Ijtihad would be as good as that we have seek the guidance from the Prophet or Imams. Hope considering the above mention Aayat, now my questions can be entertained with logical answers Jazak Allah
  2. we are here looking for logical responses not by hadiths. If possible kindly share your logical responses Thanks
  3. Thanks for updating your self, however so far non has really replied my logical questions.
  4. 1- Sorry?? The Aga Khan doesnt have no progeny?? he has 3 sons 2- Furthermore, Ismaili Imams also claimed that their Imamat will continue till Qayamat, & Imams will always be "Hazir Imams" not "Gayab Imams" , , and that can also be taken as a litmus case to prove / disprove Ismaili Imamat 3- Not only Ismailis have customized their faith, if that was the case, I believe then All Muslims would have no difference at all , is that so?? 4- Ismaili Imamat is about to collapse?? how come?? 5- Word Imam does mentioned in Qur'an 12 times, it is also mentioned Imams singular as well as plural , so what does it provide? .. I kindly read my above mentioned 3 questions and if possible try to reply them logically,, I'll be thankful. my some logical questions if u can reply logically thanks
  5. Seems good point, but here is my two relevant questions, 1-Jesus 12 disciples also include Juda?? the one who ditched him?? or let me know if I am wrong? 2- Other/Above mentioned Prophet even had 12 disciples or Imams (with or after them) but I believe Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم) was very different in position & nature, by nature he was the last Nabi and after him no Prophet will come, so question is how is it possible that Imamat limit/ended on just 12 Imams 3- Imams basic function is to give Hadayat & be the proof of Allah (his Hujjat) & His Authority on Earth , Unity of Command, etc If Imams are Hadaya, then how can we be left on Ulimas and Ayatullahs for Hadayat If Imams are Proof of Allah (Hujjat) then why we can't see them and see the Proof of Allah If Imams are Authority, then how come we can accept authority of any Ulima / Ayatullahs If Imams are Unity of Command, then how come we can look upon others for this function. Hope I may get logical replies on the above mentioned questions.
  6. Salam I would like to see more logical replies on this topic, please comment if you have any logical reason on this topic. Thanks
  7. Agreed! That what salafies/wahabais says, but do you care?? .. same you are saying about Ismailis that we are not muslims  In short they call you kafir and you call us, what is the different b/w u and them? I gave u online reference, u did not comment on that for Ismailis Prophet, Imams ans GOD saying are our doctorine, don’t know abt you, as far as I know in Shia Islam Imam hold the Absloute authorty Is that not what Allah mention in Quran abt Shafaat?? Forgivness has been given to choosen one?? Ayat e Kusar?? What is that?? Didn’t Ali a.s said “I am the divider of Heaven and Hell” So, you mean to say that Salat your salat is same as sunnies salat?? No difference?? Comon yar, whom u fooling to?? Jamat Khana is not just a prayer hall but it has lots of different institution where Ismailis discuss their problems and slove them. It’s the same question with sunnies ask shia that “ where is the Quran of Ali a,s?? “ this is a complied quran of our khalifa whom u call sinners if u don’t have eman on them then how come you have eman on quran?? See.. just a base less argument, if we don’t accept quran then how we are following the Idea of Imamat?? Please make sence Don’t God mention in quran that God talks you in “Tamseel” aayat Noor Still You did not not comment on Amma message!
  8. salam, intresting! majority?? dont majority think shia as Jews?? or the extendend version of Jews?? just for the record, if you know something about Jordon's Amman Messaage conferences it has been declared and accepted by sunies that they accept Jafaries inthe fold of Islam! and for your kind info Ismailis are Jafaries, inaddition to that Shia and Sunni Top Ulima and Ayatullahas have accepted Ismailis as part of Islam :) link attached for your kind review and reference : http://ammanmessage.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=57&Itemid=42 and if u check from the site who were the uilmas and ayatullaha , i think if ismailis are really kafir or murtad or what ever.. i think 1st thing u need to do reject your TOp Ulima and let me paste the ulima namees for your reference too 11.Grand Ayatollah Al-Sayyid Ali Khamenei 12.Grand Ayatollah Al-Sayyid Ali Al-Sistani 13.Grand Ayatollah Al-Sayyid Muhammad Said Al-Hakim, Noble Najaf 14.Grand Ayatollah Shaykh Ishaq Al-Fayad, Noble Najaf 15.Grand Ayatollah Shaykh Bashir Al-Najan, Noble Najaf 16.Grand Ayatollah Al-Sayyid Shaykh Hassan Ismail Al-Sadr 17.Grand Ayatollah Al-Sayyid Fadil Lankarani 18.Grand Ayatollah Shaykh Muhammad Ali Al-Taskhiri, General Secretary, Forum for Proximity of the Islamic Schools of Jurisprudence, Iran 19.Al-Sayyid Muhammad Husayn FadlAllah 20.The Imam Al-Khoei Benevolent Foundation, United Kingdom reference : http://ammanmessage.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=82&Itemid=60 those were only shia ulima link state all sunni ulima too Yes, Aga Khan is 49th Imam of Ismaili Muslims and we take his as Shia take their Imams, he has the authority to interprate Quran! .. not to change Quran! it need to be understood that the way shia offer salat is hell different then sunnies, infact every sect has his own way of performaing salat! can you show me ONE AGGREAD UPON TEXT of Salat for my reference which is shared by all muslims ?? in my limited Knowledge i believe NO! then why are u confusing people on this issue?? if u have right to pray as u like, why can't we?? with due respect to u, who r u in authority to judge us Ismailies recite ginans, what is it?? its prasing of Allah, his Prophet and Imams and Ahale bait , wht objection you have.. what is Naat?? is that not a form of prasing Prophets?? and what is Manqabad?? is that not form of praying Imams and Ahaley Bait?? for your kind info our Salat/Dua is in Arabic, and the Ginans are not part of Dua! please confirm before communicating your knowledge to others! i wonder that have u every read quran or not! It is not taqwa that you turn your faces toward East or West, but it is taqwa to believe in Allah and the Last Day, and the Angels, and the Book and the Messengers, to spend of your substance out of love for Him, for your kin, for orphans, for the needy, for the wayfarer, for those who ask, and for the ransom of slaves; to be steadfast in prayer and practice regular charity; to fulfill the contracts you have made; to be firm and patient, in pain and adversity. Those are the truthful and those are the righteous [2:177] it has been forbidden by all Imams including Current Imam, if an Ismaili or Muslim Drink That doesnot mean that Quran Allows this, muslims rapes , muslims kills , muslims gamble what muslims dont do .. do u allow a jew to say since muslims do all this His Prophet/Quran / Allah give muslims permission?? pls be muture! is this some thing new? read Sufi Books, for them Heaven and Hell are metaphorical in meaning! and Quran also mention that "it has Zahir Means as well as Batin" i remmber one event that : once Imam Jaffar a,s was with his sahabi , a person came and stated an ayat of Quran, Imam a,s gave him one interpratation, when he left, another person came with same aayat, Imam a.s gave his another interpratation, a sahabi was next to Imam asked that you have interprated 1 Quranic aayat with different ways ........." Interpratation of Quran is on Imam, we are lucky that we have un broken chain of Imamat since Imam Ali a.s, and your imam is in gayabat please this question now should be directed to above mentioned ulima as their knowleddge and reading will be more then you and me:) Admin : id this allowed on this forum to bash others faith like this?? Regards
  9. Ismaili take Salat as Faraz/ Wajib as Muslims do, yes We combine as Shia do and its also allowed, our act of performing Salat is different and correct me if i am wrong shia act of prayers differ from sunnies am i wrong?? alchole, gambling are prohibited, and if someone (any Ismaili) use it its his fault or his problem, Imam and Prophets can only Guide! just guide! regards,
  10. Salam Dear Admin, i am unable to search even after longin please do some thing in this regard Thanks
×
×
  • Create New...