Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


Advanced Member
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About haidermpr

  • Rank
    Level 2 Member

Profile Information

  • Religion

Previous Fields

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

1,604 profile views
  1. Brother Salam, slight correction: It was not Ibn Ziyad instead his father Ziyad was appointed by Imam Ali (عليه السلام) and later on Ziyad joined Muawiya and his son Ubaidullah Ibn ZIyad sided with yazid
  2. Ruling 2794. A Muslim inherits from a disbeliever (kāfir) but a disbeliever does not inherit from a deceased Muslim, even if he is the deceased’s father or son. If we go according to this ruling of Syed Sistani that means it is not for us to find whether money is halal or haram instead we are free to use inheritance.
  3. Ohh Really brother!!!! What was his role in all early battles starting from Uhud, Khandaq and Khaybar?? How many wars he had won against enemies leading the army on the battlefield??? Provide historical source rather providing your thoughts as you asked to discuss rationally. As far as openly declaring Islam is concerned many had already done before him like Ali Ibn AbuTalib, Abuzar Ghiffari, Hamza Ibn Abdul Muttalib. Thanks
  4. Not Yazid but Muawiya initiated the massacre of Karbala by mentioning the name of few important figures of Madina to be contained by Yazid if he wanted to rule. Yazid followed his father advice and sent letter to his governor of Madina Walid ibn Utbah to either take allegiance or kill Imam Hussain (عليه السلام). All those people who were named by Muawiya left Madina and stayed in Makkah like Abdullah ibn Zubair and Abdullah Ibn Umar. It was only Imam Hussain (عليه السلام) who not only refused to pay allegiance but stood up against his tyrannical rule too. So Yazid was very much involved in mas
  5. No, Imam (عليه السلام) were never silent, they continuously taught true Islamic teachings to people but Ummah was not ready to listen them. The Ummah even didn't listen Imam Ali (عليه السلام) though on numerous occasions Prophet (saww) introduced him as his Wasi (successor) in very clear terms. Prophet (saww) ask Ummah to follow Qur'an and Ahlebait (عليه السلام) but Ummah believed only in Qur'an and left Ahlebait (عليه السلام). In Court of first caliph, daughter of Prophet Fatima Zahra (sa) presented all proofs from Qur'an regarding her inheritance but was rejected based on fabricated had
  6. Just get us name of 12 guided caliphs from Sunni Books.. how hard it is for opposite faction to prove 12 guided caliphs.. All Sunni stops at Imam Hasan (عليه السلام) as rightly guided caliph. If We accept these 5 caliphs according to Sunni traditions and accept Imam Mehdi (عليه السلام) as last guided one, where are rest 6 guided caliphs? How Sunni and their books are going to convince us about these forgotten 6 caliphs???
  7. How beautifully AmeriKKKan Zionist propaganda used to work among the Muslim? Zionist really know the methods to dupe the masses of this Ummah. AmeriKKKan had planned the destruction of Iraq, Syria, Iran, Libya etc long before the imposed war on Syria. According to General Wesley Clark speech in 2007, he recounted his discussion with Under Secretary Wolfowtiz in 1991 regarding Operation Desert Storm. He quoted Wolfowitz, “one thing that we learned is that we can use our military in the Middle East and the Soviets won’t stop us, and we got about 5 or 10 years to clean up those old Soviet c
  8. Brewing doesn't always means making making alcohol Yeast do fermentation of sugar. Brewing can be done using yeast and stop fermentation at particular time to get carbonated drinks with few percentage of alcohol that do not intoxicate people. Choice is yours to use it or not..
  9. Brother @Abu Hadi Thanks for compilation and sharing these beautiful narrations with all of us. In reality, it doesn't matter whether we become billionaire or not. Important thing is that we will be closer to Allah by following such traditions. Worldly gains are side effects that culminate from following such important traditions of Ahlebait (عليه السلام).
  10. It is completely prohibited to eat scaleless fish according to Jafari doctrine.. Kindly go through link https://www.Sistani.org/english/qa/search/641/
  11. thanks for all the information and old pics..
  12. With the quote of very verse, kindly provide me logical answer to above raised questions by me..... Imamah is not first thing in Deen instead it is Oneness of Allah and his presence when there was nothing.. So kindly provide logical answer for his presence????? Then Allah sent Prophet/messengers to propagate Deen.. why he stopped at 124000? what is logical answer to that??? There was time difference between different Prophet/messengers, why Allah didn't send messengers continuously.. There are communities and nations where may be 1 or 2 messengers came throughout history of th
  13. Brother with all due respect, I don't have logical answers to 12 numbers of Imam ordered by Prophet (saww) and hence can't answer that... But it looks that you are too much in intellectual debates and believe that everything can be proved through logic/intellect/reasoning etc I have great doubt about such thinking... Kindly prove me logically that there is Allah.. It is open challenge to everyone who think that he can prove Allah using his/her intellect..Intellect doesn't have answers of all the realities. Kindly prove logic behind 124000 messengers/Prophets selected by All
  14. We already replied on this that you need to read sermon of Shiqshiqya and I think @Ashvazdanghe provided link and sermon in his comment Maula Ali (عليه السلام) never permitted AbuBakr or anyone else to put on garment of Caliphate...
  15. People raising questions regarding Imamah and this definite 12 numbers of Imam (عليه السلام) should go through book Peshawar nights. It was discussion between Shia scholar Syed Mohammed Musavi and scholars of Sunni. He visited India and was persuaded for debate in Peshawar with fellow Sunni scholars on varied topics including Imamah and discussion continued for 10 nights where Syed Musavi replied the queries on different Ulema from other sects. I am attaching link of this book that is compilation of discussion between Syed and other scholars-- Kindly go through below link and you people m
  • Create New...