Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله


Development Team
  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by Sirius_Bright

  1. You should probably read replies before jumping. This has already been answered. Help yourself.
  2. Brother @Ashvazdanghe already posted fatwa from some top muqallad. If taraweeh is considered haraam then there's no point in asking if it is allowed with 'Forada' niyyat. It's altogether haraam. Also, the fatwa of Sayed Ali Sistani you posted tells about regular prayers and in that too you only have to synchronize action with Sunni imaam otherwise it is as good as praying forada and alone. Unity is neither in usool e deen nor in furoo e deen to ve wajib on us. Why do we need to compromise our beliefs every time for unity. Why can't we just follow our own things and co-exist peacefully in society.
  3. Quote me if you're addressing my post. You don't have to try and extrapolate anything if you're usooli and do taqleed. To my knowledge, no maraja has given permission of taraweeh till date - makes it haram across shi'ism - plus we have ahadith of Aimma (ams) condemning taraweeh as a bid'ah. Tatbir has mixed fatwas. Some allow, it some don't - To each his own muqallad.
  4. Tatbir and other rituals do have fatwa from Mujtahideen, many of them allow it. On the other hand, I'm yet to see a mujtahid giving green signal to taraweeh. Tatbir has ambiguous narrations and one has to rely on his muqallid while taraweeh has straightforward condemnation.
  5. You people always look to deviate the topic to tatbir, don't you?
  6. Both are forbidden act, what difference does it make. You were not ready to go for taraweeh but you went only because of your host. Anyway, I don't want to discuss this. It was meant as a general statement and not to target anyone. I apologize if that hurt you in any way. General statement - Unity has caused us damaged big time.
  7. Taraweeh is bidah and promoting bid'ah is a sin. Shaitan did lot of worship than you and I could ever do but not obeying Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) for one Sajdah to Adam got him removed from Allah's mercy. Worship is not reciting Qur'an in supersonic speed but it is obeying Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) in good and evil.
  8. I don't see what different thing I told him than 'it is bidah' and 'Allah is most forgiving'. I'm actually giving him hope that even if you regret doing that particular sin, Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) will forgive Insha Allah.
  9. I don't recall any fatwa from Sayed Sistani recommending to join Sunnis in congregation for unity. You know the situation better but in no circumstances a sin is allowed except taqaiyah. You should have refused there. I would compare this to a very good Christian friend asking to take a sip of alcohol. Both are sin, both should be rejected, no matter your relations. Never a good idea to make creation happy against creator.
  10. If you're comparing rush in first 10 days of Muharram and the day of Arbaeen, Mahe Muharram has quite less people (but more than normal days).
  11. @ahlulbayt_72 Brother, please contact your muqallid or his wakil or atleast a knowledgeable scholar for your question.
  12. How would you do that for any xyz company?
  13. The cartoon in the video was denying Shias with Sahih Bukhari, Musnad, Tirmidhi... Aisha, Abu Hurairah, ibn Awf.
  14. Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى) knows your intentions and the regret. Ask him for forgiveness. He is Ghafoor. Insha Allah He will forgive you. Ilahi Ameen.
  15. Alaikas Salaam, Why would someone want to stand in bid'ah congregation?
  16. One thing is sure, Iran cannot be behind this attack.
  17. I did have real issues with the video and some brothers here illustrated it better than I could. It would really help if brother at IP do not commit those kind of mistakes in his every second video. One should not make videos if he's not capable of defending himself/shi'ism to the opposition and make us laughing stock especially if he's representing Hawze Ilmiyah (as he claims). Also, his obsession with unity, shirazis is astounding. He doesn't fail to mention them even if it's not relevant to the subject at hand. Talking about being brothers, I see how brotherly it is to compare wahabi takfiri cult with Shirazis.
  18. I can attest to the fact that these things happen all the time where Shias are treated (or atleast understood) worst than kuffar. If you're denying such things never happen in real world than either you're making excuses for your Sunni brothers or you live on mars. It's quite clear where all your Sunni brothers get their 'Shia kafir' Aqeedah from.. It's their scholars on the minbar and their books.
  19. Even lay people can point blunders in his videos and he calls himself seminary student. Also br. Tawheed needs to rein himself sometimes and admit his amateur content.
  20. That would be some other prayers. Salatal layl (or tahajjud) is 11 rakats and should be prayed until time of Namaze fajr. http://www.duas.org/tahajjud.htm
  21. Keep a piece of blank white paper between your phone and back cover. In case you are traveling or forget to take khaake shifa, this paper can be used for prostration.
  • Create New...