Jump to content
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!) ×
Guests can now reply in ALL forum topics (No registration required!)
In the Name of God بسم الله

Talut

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    551
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by Talut

  1. Salam, I just started fitness for a few months and want to know how to continue during Ramadan month. Are there a few things I should change in schedule, time and weight?
  2. The use of C-weapons only started after Hillary Clinton stated that Assad would use them and therefore intervention was inevitable. I hope people are clever enough to understand what this really meant.
  3. To accept a hadith even when it is against Quran, the aale Muhammad and reason to me it's a sort of shirk.
  4. Is this proven to be a Sunnah in Twelver islam? And I see no objection in saying "sadaq Allahu'l Ali' ul Azeem" nor in "sadaq Allahu'l'Azeem. Both are names of Allah so both can be said. No offense but I believe people nowadays make issues out of nothing without looking at what things truly mean.
  5. Salam, Is "Sadaqa Allahu 'l-Azeem" to be said after reciting Quran? If not, what do Twelvers say adter reciting Quran?
  6. I am not a text man and got tired from scrolling your reply let alone reading it. I like the more dynamic debates with logical reasoning. The textual debates with ahaadith and degrading etcetera is really not my field. Same counts when I have such debates with Sunni's. I am sceptical towards ahaadith anyway after I noticed that it many times was used as propaganada tool for political and ideological purposes. Maybe that's the reason why. There are however historical events which are conformed by both unanimously. The disputed events I judge by myself.
  7. Wallahi, this is the first reply after long time that actually does make sense. Jazak'Allahu khayran.
  8. Sunni's say exactly the same. Why should I believe you and not them?
  9. Was Malik ibn Nuweira an apostate? Were all those who did not accept the authority of Abu Bakr apostates?
  10. So you say he a.s. wasn't able to intervene and the other says that it had nothing to do with the Shia of Imam Ali a.s.?
  11. So the Ridda Wars had nothing to do with the Shia of Imam Ali a.s.? Well if not so then I ask the moderators to close this thread.
  12. What is authentic and what is not authentic is not objective and unbiased but based on ideology and sectarian view. In Islam, what is authentic to one doesn't have to be authentic to the other. That is why the divisions and disagreements are because of the diffirent ahaadith collections of the diffirent sects and not because of the Quran itself which is clear, unambiguous and one.
  13. Not everything which is atributed to the Prophet s,a,w,a,s, is his. And what is sahih to a Sunni doesn't have to be Sahih to a Sunni. Second of all. As an ex-christian I know where this belief in the Return of Christ comes from.
  14. Why didn't he a,s, stay on earth like Imam Mehdi a.s.?
  15. Yes they failed to kill him, they did not crucified him but why does that implicate that he did not die?
  16. So are you telling me that when people try to kill or crucify somebody and they do not succeed, he will not die?
  17. That belief is non-Quranic and only known from the Bible. Later on this belief crept into Islam in the form of ahaadith. Did you ever thought about the 72 or 73 sects Islam will split into? The Quran is protected so what is the only way left to create divisions?
  18. I know. There are Sunni ahaadith about that as well. What is interresting to me is the emphasis on three times in Sunni and Shia traditions. I believe this is an ancient Islamic rule that was known in the past as well: Now when Daniel knew that the writing was signed, he went into his house; and his windows being open in his chamber toward Jerusalem, he kneeled upon his knees three times a day, and prayed, and gave thanks before his God, as he did aforetime. Daniel 6:10
  19. Salam everyone, My question to the Twelvers is the following. If the Ridda Wars were a reaction of the Shia of Ali towards the reign of Abu Bakr then why didn't he a.s. helped his supporters and kept silent?
×
×
  • Create New...